<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
दान महिनावार दान

Doctrine of the Atonement

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

Last week we were on this outline on the atonement and if you brought it from last week good if you didn't I we didn't do it anymore this morning did we got because we've been on this for three weeks now and so you'll just have to look on with a neighbor if you didn't if you're new and this is just be the first few minutes here. I'm at the end of the outline from last week on the atonement and right at the end we got to this question did Christ descend into hell because in the Apostles Creed it says he was born of the Virgin Mary suffered under Pontius Pilate was crucified dead and buried he descended into hell the third day he rose from the dead and I went through some historical background saying that phrase wasn't in there in the early versions of the Apostles Creed. It wasn't in there until 390 AD the first instance where somebody mentions that it was there 390 is a long time after the Apostles had died I think John the last Apostle died between 90 and 100 AD so 90 to 390 that's 300 years after the Apostles the first time that phrase appeared and then after 390 it didn't appear again until 650 AD which is a very very long time and it probably first meant he descended into the grave. Because the first version that had it didn't have the phrase was buried but it kind of accumulated in the history of the church and so then people made up different explanations for it my my own understanding was that I don't think it I don't think as it is in the Creed now that it's wise or helpful or useful because I don't think after Jesus died that he descended into hell. In fact oh we talked about that okay probably first many descended into the grave possible biblical support we looked at those and tried to give an answer to those my and then on the other side though I won't go through those verses but on the other side we looked at these verses that indicated I think that Jesus when he died his spirit went right into the presence of the Father he didn't didn't go to hell because he said to the thief on the cross today he will be with me in paradise and that Greek word for paradise it's used in second Corinthians it's used in Revelation but it means the presence of God in heaven it's another word for heaven basically. And John 1931 Jesus received the sour wine he said it is finished I think that means his suffering was finished he didn't have to go to hell to suffer anymore or be separated from God anymore. And he said Luke 2346 father into your hands I commit my spirit so I think he meant that he was going to the Father into the presence of the Father when he died just as Stephen in imitation of Jesus said in Acts 759 Lord Jesus received my spirit and of course Stephen when he died he went right to heaven. So my conclusion was I don't think Jesus descended into hell I don't say it as part of the Apostles Creed I think when Jesus died his body remained on earth as ours does when we die. But his spirit went right into the presence of the Father as ours will when we die and he's the pattern for us and then on Easter Sunday morning his spirit returned to his body and he was raised from the dead. So even famous ancient creeds don't equal scripture so an old mistake is still a mistake and Christ sufferings ended on the cross praise God for that that that means that his work of paying the penalty for our sins was completed. And I think this is also a reminder there isn't a second chance for salvation after death that the Bible talks about and some people would say Christ descended into hell to give a second chance for salvation but I don't think there are verses that support that no. The reason I went over that again for the last three or four minutes is to say I got to the end and the time was up and I said oh let's sing a hymn really quickly and I didn't have any chance for any questions and I said I would come back to this and give you an opportunity to interact on it if you wish. So Trent is there way to get some of that light out of my eyes thanks okay John who was it you John yes. I notice that the word again seems to come and go and I can remember saying the Apostles Creed for a long time where we said and he rose again from the dead oh and I'm wondering why is it an again did he do it before or is that just one of those words in there that. So you rose from the dead there it's there it's a rose from the dead yeah I said for many years and he rose again from the dead he has to have it. I think I'm not absolutely sure but I think it's just two different ways of English translation of either a Greek or Latin early copy. And I don't think anyone ever wanted to mean this was the second time he rose from the dead rose again from the dead I think it just means he rose from the dead I so probably again was dropped out because people just thought well what do you mean by again and.

So I don't know where rose again came from which but I think it's just a different translation I don't think it's any difference in meaning and intended good good okay what else anything else and Ed. For our sake for our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin and as in becoming sin. He becomes repugnant to God the father and I think following from that the idea that he was separated the Trinity was split for whatever moment because of that leaving the possibility that we're discussing. Yeah well I agree he made him to be no sin so that we might become the righteous of God in him it means that God put on Jesus somehow we don't understand the guilt liability for punishment that we deserve and so he thought of him as sin and so therefore he poured out his wrath on him and there was a separation from the favor of God the father in some way. But I think it happened on the cross not after he died. Okay because that's where that's where this and then when he says it is finished then I think it is finished so you want to come back on that. Yeah he also is reported to have said my God my God why have you forsaken me and I think I had to do with this verse I agree completely and but that was on the cross to you know and then it was over. So good yet it raised another question that I really didn't talk about that's a really hard question and that is what is the relationship among the members of the Trinity. We're at the point where Jesus is bearing our sins and dies. I'm going to just give you a quick summary of where I would fall down where I'd fall on this in terms of my understanding. I think that was we've gone over the Trinity in class a number of weeks ago I think that God is one being but within that one being there are three persons but each person. But the being of each person is equal to the being of the whole of God and how how one God can be one being in three persons I don't know it's unlike anything we know. I don't think there was any disruption in the being of God but there are personal interactions among the members of the Trinity so the Father sends the Son into the world. Father and Son send the Holy Spirit the Father says that Jesus baptism this is my beloved son with whom I'm well pleased. Well if the Father can talk about being pleased with the Son then I think it is possible that the divine nature of the Father also expressed his wrath toward the person of Christ God and man together. And that would mean also toward the divine being of Christ but there's nothing in the Bible that gives me too much help about that. It's just analogy from saying you're my beloved son with whom I'm well pleased or Jesus in John 17 talking about the love with which the Father loved him from the foundation of the world or glorify me in your presence John 1724 with the glory I had with you before the world was made. So there was interpersonal interaction of various sorts and I think that allows for the displeasure of the Father not that the Son had done anything wrong but he voluntarily took on himself the guilt for our sins. I don't know if that helps that I don't think the divine nature of the Son died or anything like that couldn't be regarded ceased to be God. Okay, wow. So I opened up to questions I realized there are hard questions that I didn't address or were the father and the spirit on the cross with Christ. I think the father I mean there was a just there are different so the father is not the son and the son is not the spirit even though they're one being their different persons so that on the cross was Jesus human and divine nature together. The father was I think putting the punishment for sin on the son so the father himself wasn't bearing that only the son was bearing that punishment. And the Holy Spirit the only verse I know about the Holy Spirit's work at that point is in Hebrews 8 or 9 I think it says through the eternal spirit he offered himself up to God so I think there was a helping enabling work of the Holy Spirit. But again the Holy Spirit didn't bear the penalty for our sin the father didn't bear the penalty for our sin just the son. Is that no the divine nature of Christ I think did bear the penalty but I'm way out beyond where I have any verses to talk about it. It's just I that I that I know about but it's from this client it's from thinking that if Jesus human nature alone bore the penalty he could have maybe endured the penalty for one person sin but for all the millions of people who would be saved I think he had to be God in order to bear that be able to bear that as well. Interesting isn't it that though I mean both your question adds question are questions that we wonder about and the Bible just decides not to give us very much information. So it's best for me to see like like Darrell does a step away from the Bible away from the pulpit and said don't have a verse here but this looks like what happened. You know it's one of those things that we get to heaven we're going to say oh wow that's amazing so yeah okay add again. The other part that is related to he who knew no sin became sin or we have is that by that God became just and the justify. So it's really interwoven together and yeah I mean wait it's complicated we want you to give us lots of things. No but it is the way in which God's love could could provide salvation for us and God's justice could be satisfied so that sin would be punished at the same time and God alone provided that solution and that is the wonderful amazing thing. It is not simple is not smile God loves you and he cares you know he forgives everybody it's there's a little bit of truth in that but but this is real it is a complex and profound truth of what the Bible says. Okay anything else Joyce or Joyce says she hates to expose her ignorance I just exposed my ignorance in the last two questions. So where were the believers of the Old Testament before Christ died okay I think okay in heaven okay but people disagree on that so I first gave you what I think they were in heaven with God. And then I can say there are other views and there is a view especially among some Lutheran writers that Jesus went to the realm where the Old Testament saints were and proclaimed release to them. It wouldn't really be hell but kind of a holding area I've forgotten the technical term and then let them have full access into God's presence in heaven because his redemption was done. It's hard because there isn't much in the Old Testament that talks about this but I would look at I would look at verses like Psalm 23 where David says surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life and I will dwell in the house of the Lord forever. It expects to be in God's presence forever and of course Enic was taken because God took him took him up into heaven Elijah was taken up by a chariot of fire into heaven and I think that probably was designed to teach people that yes God did take believers to himself at the time of the Old Testament. When Jesus comes to the New Testament and disputes with these Jewish leaders who didn't believe in the resurrection he said well I mean he quoted the Old Testament where God said I am the God of Abraham and Isaac and Jacob he's not the God of the dead but the living. So I think he's saying that they are living right now in the presence of God by saying he's not the God of the dead but the living he's God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob implying that Abraham Isaac and Jacob are living there. And that parable of the rich man and Lazarus again that's in the gospels but it's still before Jesus's death. He's in Abraham's bosom which is pictured as a place of comfort and joy I think in the presence of God so but people disagree on that there's not a unit because there isn't a lot in the Old Testament I'm probably missing some verses in the Old Testament but there are some things like that so yeah Mike. So somewhere in the New Testament I can't wish I could quote where I thought the believers prior to Christ were Christ resurrection were asleep I'm not sure the term they use and I don't know where they read that and then when he was resurrected they were as well. Do you remember anything about that or two or three passages when Jesus went to heal Lazarus he said he's not that he's sleeping. And Paul says those who are well even in 1 Corinthians 15 if there is no resurrection then those who are fall asleep in Christ have perished I think that's 1 Corinthians 15 but I think it's just an image of dying but I don't think it means that they are not conscious. Because let me see why do I think that there was a teaching called soul sleep and I think 7th Adventist hold to it that when when Christians even die we just sleep there's no conscious until Jesus comes back but John Calvin and the reformers argued against that and said no we go right into the presence of God Paul wants to depart and be with Christ that's far better and blessed are the dead who die in the Lord from henceforth and there's a lot of New Testament passage about going right into God's presence and so by analogy we would say okay if that's what happened to New Testament believers probably Old Testament believers too I'm struggling because I'm not sure what you aren't sure what verse and I'm not sure what verse so yeah I think they went right into the presence of God in their spirits but without bodies. Okay Jesus at the moment transfiguration see Moses and Elijah see this is before Jesus death Moses and Elijah appear with him there looks like they're they're still living and conscious and awake and alive so best I can do okay one more in Matthew it says that the saints were when Jesus died the two were open and the same. Who had fallen asleep came out of their toms I'm thinking maybe like sorry I'm thinking maybe like if God has a different perception of time like we will and maybe we will it would be like no time between we die and go to heaven but time like time for God maybe maybe is different I don't know yeah well I mean if people are not conscious when they die of course be like having an operation and so that's the thought and people who argue for that say that I don't think that's true because of today you will be with me in paradise I mean that's really a promise of being in fellowship with Jesus to where he says to the thief on the cross and Paul says not my desire is to depart and be unconscious in Philippians one but he says my desire is to depart and be with Christ for that's far better it sure is strong language I think for personally being in fellowship with the light how should we interpret like scripture like Matthew in Matthew oh the saints coming out of the toms yeah okay Matthew 2752 when Jesus died the toms also were opened and many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised and coming out of the toms after his resurrection they went into the holy city and appeared to many strange verse here's what I think it means and what's your name I didn't get your name Marty Marty okay I think it means that a few people in around Jerusalem who had been dead that they got new resurrection bodies right after Jesus was raised as coming out of the toms after his resurrection and they appeared to people and they were kind of evidence hey this is what's going to happen to everybody but no we don't hear anything more about them so I think since it says they came out of the toms after his resurrection I think they didn't just come back to life I think they had new resurrection bodies that were made perfect and so since they're not around anymore today I think probably when Jesus ascended God took them up into heaven it is interesting in the early history of the church there's no comment on that verse in the first you know in the first period after so it's just there but I think it is God saying hey you want to know what a sample of this is going to be like here's some extra additional proof John Piper has a little book called I can't remember it's a little poem for Christmas where he makes up a story about now one of the some of the people raised were the innkeeper who had gotten put no the innkeeper's wife and childhood had been killed by the Roman soldiers when he went to put all here and went to put all the kids to death it's really it's called the innkeeper I think okay I think what we'll go on now is this to the next material and we are here I wanted to take that time just because I didn't want to just talk and talk and talk and talk and give you no time for feedback on it so thanks for bearing with me on that and and contributing good questions we are now on the extent of the atonement first the question is whose sins were paid for when Jesus died everybody in the whole world and curled clean people won't be saved or just people that God knew would believe okay I do not enjoy talking about this topic very much because in 30 years of teaching theology to college students and seminary students I find that this topic raises lots more questions than it solves for a lot of people not for everybody and it's a point where people argue a lot and then it's another one of these topics where there's I'm not sure if there are any specific verses that really solve the problem for us so we're reasoning from one group of verses or another so I thought oh maybe I could skip this but then I thought no I haven't run away from hard questions in this class and so I won't run away from this one either but I'm going to say at the outset I'll give you my conclusion but really really good friends of mine disagree with me on this I think I may be the only person that Phoenix seminary who holds the view I hold but I'm not sure we haven't talked about it very much and some people think it's really really important because it kind of divides true Calvinists from not true Calvinists or truly reform from not truly reform people I'll just give you an overview there having said that I think there is some possibility for wonderful application on this too because it has to do with some of the teaching of scripture but I'm going to end up saying okay we talked about it but I don't want to spend forever talking about it all right but should I go on can I go on okay first and there I don't know if some of you have heard of this or not there's this acronym tulip tulip T-U-L-I-P told a gravity unconditional election limited atonement irresistible grace perseverance of the saints and that's sort of called the five points of Calvinism and this is L the third one limited atonement that is that Jesus' death actually paid for the sins of those who would believe not of everybody okay so that's where we are now the reformed view has some scripture passages to support it Christ death paid for the sins of all who would be saved for all time and that's that's the view that I am I'm going to end up holding just fair disclosure here with some qualifications it's called particular redemption or limited atonement Christ died for particular people for Garth for Sandy for Mark for Andrea for seat for individuals not just everybody okay and John 1011 I'm the good shepherd the good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep not for everybody the sheep Romans a 32 he did not spare his own son but gave him up for us all hall writing to believers gave him up for us all or Ephesians 525 husbands love your wives as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her not for everybody but for the church so that you say well that sounds pretty good okay but then there are other passages on the other side that's what makes it a hard question scripture passages used to report the non reformed view general redemption or unlimited atonement Christ death paid for everyone sins even for those who would never believe in him that is people in hell their sins are already paid for but they're not saved why because the payment wasn't applied to them and verses that are used to support that would be John 129 behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world or John 651 I'm the living bread that came down from heaven if anyone eats of this bread he will live forever and the bread that I will give for the life of the world is my flesh or first John 22 this one's quite strong he is the propitiation that's the sacrifice that bears God's wrath he is the propitiation for our sins and not for ours only but for the sins of the whole world Romans 1415 if your brother is grieved by what you eat you're no longer walking in love by what you eat do not destroy the one for whom Christ died well destroy what does that mean so they'll never come to the faith in here the one for whom Christ died or second Peter 21 false teachers even denying the master who bought them doesn't it sound like Jesus paid for their sins even though they weren't saved so there are verses on both sides now here's what I want to say some points of agreement people on both sides agree that not all will be saved now people who hold to unlimited tomen they don't say that everybody's going to be saved in the whole world even Hitler or even Pharaoh or even really evil people so everybody agrees on that there are some people that are not saved sadly and then number two everybody agrees we can rightly make a free offer of the gospel to every single human being because we don't know who will believe in the gospel so if I have my friend Sam I just made up the name Sam right now and Sam's not a Christian I say Sam if you trust in Christ you will be saved no qualifications no hesitation that's the gospel offer whoever believes in him will not perish but have everlasting light so that's a truthful offer well how you say how can you say that how can you say Sam if you believe in Christ you will be saved maybe Jesus didn't pay for his sins see that's a wrong reasoning because if he believes then God would have known that ahead of time and Jesus would have paid for his sins so there's no such thing as a person who says I want to believe I want to believe please Jesus accept me and she said no sorry you weren't counted okay there's no such thing as that Jesus says he comes to me I will not cast out so we can make a true offer because we don't know who will believe the gospel my personal conclusion is this but let me tell you this is based on kind of reasoning rather than on Bible verses exactly so I'm kind of over here again but my conclusion is I don't think that people in hell will suffer forever for sins that Christ has already paid the penalty for me kind of double jeopardy if Jesus already paid the penalty then how can these people suffer for those sins and the people my good friends on the other side will say well they paid the penalty because they didn't accept Jesus payment and my answer is it doesn't look to me when it talks when the Bible talks about hell it doesn't look to me like people are just suffering for the sin of not accepting Jesus they're suffering for the sins they committed all their sins and they're already paid for it how can they suffer for them so we kind of go back and forth but this is a logical deduction not a specific Bible verse I hold the reform view but I'm less confident about it than about other aspects of the atonement now that's just I'm just saying that honestly I'm just saying there might be some mystery here that we don't fully understand the benefits however and people who say oh this is an important doctor and they say well look the benefits are greater a sure thing the benefits are greater assurance of salvation and understanding that Jesus died with specific people in mind with you and me in mind that is he died thinking about me and thinking about Mike and thinking about Ev individuals in mind and there's something to say well if Jesus death really paid for my sins then my salvation is sure and God will see to it that that all of his purposes for me are accomplished and I can see the benefit of that he gives some assurance some points of clarification the question is what actually happen for whose sins did Christ offer payment and it got accept the payment too often the discussion on this topic has been confused by sentences that can mean different things like people say oh I believe Christ died for his people only well my answer is what is the word for mean that mean Christ died to make the gospel available for his people only that's not true he died to make the gospel available to everybody but if four means to actually pay the penalty for Christ died to actually pay the penalty for his people only then that seems right to me but you see if you just have that sentence that people are arguing over that sentence and they mean different things by four then they're never going to come to agreement because they got different definition of terms or Christ died for all people what does it mean does it mean Christ died to actually pay the penalty for all people and reluctant to say that doesn't mean that Christ died to make the gospel available for all people yes of course he did he died for all people that is to make the gospel freely available to everybody so there's a sense in which I'd agree with both those sentences and there's a sense in which I would disagree with both those sentences but if you ever get to a discussion about this it's good to interpret what people say in a sympathetic way not a hostile way do you is this what you mean by the word for and then try to clarify practical pastoral guidance if this becomes an issue for you both sides want to avoid implying that people will be saved whether they believe or not and I think just honestly that's true see here's what happens in the reform view they say Mike if you go out on people that Jesus died for everybody's sins they're immediately going to think I don't have to do anything my sins are all paid for I don't have to trust in Christ I'm saved see there's a people say well there's a logical deduction there if you say that everybody's sins are paid for then they won't even think they have to do anything and my answer is that no everybody wants to be true to what the Bible says you have to believe in order to be saved whoever believes in him will not be saved what will be will not be condemned we're not parish both sides want to affirm that all who sincerely come to Christ for salvation will be saved him who comes to me I will not cast out that's really important there has been a massive amount of conflict I guess is the only word for it in the Southern Baptist Convention 16 million member largest Protestant denomination the United States because there are some people in the Southern Baptist Convention who hold very strongly to this limited atonement view or particular redemption and then evangelism is really important in the Southern Baptist Convention so other people are saying well if you say Jesus didn't pay for the sins of everybody then I don't know if I can do evangelism and that's just misunderstanding I think but it's unfortunate everybody who comes seeking for salvation will be saved both sides agree the gospel offer is genuine and sincere whoever believes in him will have everlasting life that's true point D finally is it really that important to argue about this it's never an explicit topic of discussion scripture John the Apostle John the Apostle Peter the Apostle Paul Apostle James they placed almost no emphasis on this question do you think we should follow their example no I don't know if that made you all upset or made you happy or what but that's that's my take on this and I that's what's your name James James maybe it's because it was something that was so logically obvious that because we that Christ died for all who would believe that meant that no one who did not that he wouldn't pay the sins for those who wouldn't who never believed you know I don't think so because it's not logically obvious because there's this other thing that's logical that Jesus death was sufficient for the payment for everybody sins but it wasn't applied to everybody's well it's because the gospel offer was a free offer to all men but only those who are elective got those who it says all those who were appointed to believe in acts and she's saying you did not choose me but I chose you yeah it's it's a common theme that Christ that we were chosen before we chose Christ yeah and so and else because the double that double jeopardy makes it God if people in hell suffered or suffering for sins Christ or pay for yeah exactly it makes God unjustness and God's not so yeah therefore their sins could have been paid for yeah I just seems very reasonable to say that Christ died for particular people yeah it seems reasonable to me too but there are some very reasonable people to whom it doesn't seem reasonable so and I mean I mean really good friends of mine who are professors of theology who are strong Calvinist but they're what's called four point Calvinist rather than five point Calvinist okay and and so J.I. Packer is J.I. Packer has written a book on this called an introduction to John Owens the death of death and the death of Christ and that's a really strong defense of this John Piper holds strongly to this as he does to everything he's a good friend I just yeah and he holds it but now my friend Bruce where who teaches theology at Louisville at Southern Seminary in Louisville he's the upcoming president of the Evangelical Theological Society just a godly man he's a four point Calvinist he holds the limit to the he holds to unlimited at home and and some of my colleagues seminary college seminary colleagues at the seminary so anyway okay what do we got here yes your name Tom Tom yes in Romans 118 what do you make of when the gospel says that God made it plain to all mankind what was to be known about him I take that to be that God exists and he has moral standards that people have disobeyed but not that he made known to them how to be saved okay yeah good thanks okay anything else on this EG you probably have been around this question before where's here we go yeah I guess I'm not sure how to express this but one thought I have if the non-believer is not the person who does not accept Christ if suffering is eternal separation from God then it would not be necessary for Jesus to have died for their sins therefore he didn't yeah that's my answer ultimately but when I said that for the last 30 years people say oh what about this what about this what about this we just need to explain it more clearly I have no response okay Mike Mike Mike over here and then Sandy and then I think we'll go ahead thanks a lot sometimes I wonder whether we may do disservice to our theology if we contemplate sin and suffering as quantifiable or quantitative parameters and what I mean by that when we talk about those you know possibly being sent a hell to you know suffer or pay for their own atonement I think maybe that's a concept that really doesn't exist in scripture in other words the only provision that God has made is a perfect sacrifice and an alternative sacrifice in other words we we don't and we cannot atone for our own sin so there cannot be such a thing as a double jeopardy or double atonement or the related concept is those that are in hell are paying for their sins and eventually their sins are paid for and we don't believe in that so we need to perhaps move away from this quantitative covering and talk about a perfect covering and a perfect sacrifice that doesn't mean it's unlimited in the sense that it cover it will atone for everyone sin but nevertheless a not a quantitative suffering and a quantitative sacrifice but a perfect sacrifice by a perfect lamb is the critical thing that provides atonement I don't know if I'm explaining that right I think it's a quantitation versus an absolute yeah that's interesting and I'd like to think about that some more Mike you're saying get away from this how many people got paid for it just was a perfect sacrifice so leave it at that but my question I want to come back to this and maybe it's a question we can't answer what actually happened on the cross that is if I say the atonement was objective it really happened it isn't just something happens in me it's really Christ paying the penalty and gone father accepting the penalty there was a transaction between the father and the son there whereby sins were actually paid for well did Christ offer payment for everybody sin except the payment at that time that's where that's where the focus is and that's what makes it difficult for me now I'm feeling like I'd like to go on to the resurrection here pretty soon I said I see Sandy and then I got Andrea and then I have Bob I guess Bob's got the microphone Sandy would you just hold for one minute because Bob has the microphone it's hard to argue with him I'd like to read from Isaiah 53 all we are like sheep have gone astray we have turned everyone to his own way and the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of a Saul I guess I disagree so the us would be everybody and see the other people would say the us all is just the believers okay Sandy and then Andrea and then I'm not going to see anybody else at hand two old testament passages strike me as pertinent here in Deuteronomy 2929 where it says the secret things belong to the Lord our God our God but those things which are revealed among to us and to our children forever and the idea that the you know in order for us to do the law there was mosaic but for us the whole broad intention of God's will and let me just stop you there Sandy and say my instinct my hunch is there is a lot of Deuteronomy 2929 in this question it's the secret things that belongs to the Lord our God that there are mysteries here that are more complex than God has shown us now exactly and so and I might may have been trying to get at that to say he was nothing quantity you know that kind but we're saying well this might be a this might be a question that we just can't understand in this age right and then the other passage at least to me tells me what to do in these times of when I confront a quote-unquote secret thing a mystery that an aspect of mystery and that's Psalm 131 which I find very comforting it reads Lord my heart is not hotty nor my eyes lofty neither do I concern myself with great matters nor with things to profound for me surely I have calmed and quieted my soul like a Wayne child with his mother like a Wayne child is my soul within me oh oh my hope is in the Lord from this time forth never more so in other words my whole bottom mind point is the final analysis is we can trust the heart of God yeah yeah with all the things we don't understand we can trust the heart of God good thank you and Andrea Andrea whenever I hear about limited tonement it's I for children so I think of all the unborn and never made it and young you have a grasp the concept and just I think you've discussed this before but I was just curious on your opinion on that yeah I think that the children of believers who die in infancy are all saved of believers the the Bible doesn't tell us anything on children of non believers and so we trust God's love and his justice and we don't know because I don't want to say something where the Bible doesn't speak but for the children of believers there are all sorts of promises giving hope that God takes the children of believers to himself Noah and his children came into the ark Ray have wasn't her children but her whole family got rescued at the airport and there are these you will be saved on your household and whole households got saved in the book of Acts and the flipping jaylor and things like that and David when his son dies is if I will go to him he will not return to me I think David expects a reunion with his son and just let me say here two weeks ago or so John Piper who believed strongly in limited tonement his son and daughter in law had a baby that was at full term and died just like two weeks before it was supposed to be born and he spoke at the funeral about how he was just how he was just his assurance that Felicity their granddaughter came to heaven and was welcomed by John's father who had just died a few months earlier and I think there's truth in that okay okay now let's you know what I'm going to do this is different because I didn't get through a lot of material but it was good and what a wealth of Bible knowledge and understanding is in this class just from these questions that are thoughtful and reverent and remarkable so thank you for the discussion next week we go on to the doctrine of the resurrection so the schedule is going to be pumped back but that's okay we don't there's no syllabus there's no final exam we're all right oh you thought there's no so it's good that we end and sing some praise to the Lord for the wonderful redemption that he's bought for us so let's sing a man of sorrows what a name Lord Jesus Christ we give you thanks for this amazing teaching from your word that you who knew no sin became sin for us that you were willing to suffer the consequences and the results to which sin leads the suffering the betrayal the loneliness the shame the abandonment the pain the ebbing away of your life the mocking and enduring wave after wave of the unimaginable wrath of the heavenly father of your father the wrath that we deserved oh Lord Jesus oh Lord we give you thanks Lord as we've talked today there are there are things here we don't understand there are there are mysteries here beyond what you have told us in your word and we we do not in any way I mean to disrespect you or probe or insist on knowing things that you have not given us to know but Lord we we proband question and examine these things because we long to know more about you and the wonder of what you have done because we long to know you better because we long to know the the amazing depth of your work of atonement the Lord our hearts are content to leave these things now that we do not understand to leave them with you knowing that as your word says the secret things belong to the Lord our God with the things that are revealed belong to us and to our children forever and these things that are revealed Lord are so rich and so wonderful we stand before the father with no fear of condemnation we stand forgiven our sins forever paid for we have access into the holy of holies now because you are great high priest and you've gone before us and you've opened the way and you welcome us and so we come and we give you praise and thanksgiving and we worship you amen