<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
دین ماسिक عطيا

Doctrine of the Atonement

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

We are on the last week of the doctrine of the atonement, which is chapter 27 this morning. And then next week, October 7th, I plan to go on to the doctrine of the resurrection of Christ, and then October 14th, two topics that aren't really talked about very much, but they're really important. Following on Christ's resurrection, he has ascension into heaven, and he's sitting at the right hand of the Father. And what does that mean in terms of application to our life? So we'll talk about those two on the 14th, and then another topic, October 21st, that isn't often talked about in one package, but the three offices in the Old Testament that Christ fulfilled, the Office of Prophet, Priest, and King. We'll go on and talk about that, and then October 28th will begin, at least, an overview of the work of the Holy Spirit. That would be chapter 30 in the systematic theology book, and then November 4th, a guest teacher. So that's where we're going. Well, here's where we are. Do you have an outline now? On the back page of your outline, we're on number six. Oh, back page, parentheses six. Why this sort of death? Does anybody need an outline? Hold up your hand. Everybody has one. Thank you, Garth, and Sandy. Okay, we had talked about the atonement and the nature of the atonement, various parts of Christ's sufferings, and understanding the death of Christ, the penalty was inflicted by the Father, and it made complete payment for us. We talked about, last week, Christ's death as a penal substitution. He bore a penalty in our place. He died as our substitute. Now, the question that comes up at this point, to some degree, why this sort of death? That is, why didn't Jesus die by, you know, a soldier just striking with a sword, and he would die, or some other kind of quick death rather than one that was so agonizing and was so prolonged. I don't think the Bible explicitly addresses that question, but I am going to suggest something, and that is, I think that it may be that Christ's death was so hard, and they're involved so much suffering, so that we could see how destructive sin is. That is, so that we could see in a stark, shocking portrayal the effects of sin taken to its ultimate conclusion in a human life. Let me explain what I mean. God created us to be like him, to be in his image, to reflect his character, and in many ways we do that, but, and that's the essence of those characteristics, in ways in which we reflect God's character, and we like him, those show the image of God, and they show what full through a beautiful, wonderful humanity was to be like. But many aspects of that humanity were taken away, and the crucifixion in a way was an extensive dehumanizing of the person of Jesus Christ. So, for instance, God created us to have life, but crucifixion led to death. It's a destruction of life that was essence, of the essence of what it means to be human. Another example, God breathed into Adam's nostrils, the breath of life, and he became a living soul, so to be able to breathe is essential to humanity. But as I explained, I think now three weeks ago, this horrible death by crucifixion, by being suspended, spending the criminals' weight on his arms, it made it increasingly difficult to breathe and was essentially a very slow, painful death by suffocation. And so, it was a prolonged demonstration of a removal of the ability to breathe, which is the ability to sustain life. And so, it was a prolonged removal of life, showing us really the consequences of sin that it just drains life from us, ultimately. God created us to have honor as his stewards over creation, and his representatives over creation, as the pinnacle of his creation, but crucifixion was holding someone up to shame. It was thought to be shameful. Roman citizens could not be crucified. It was only those who were not Roman citizens on whom the Roman Empire allowed crucifixion to be inflicted. And it was being held up to public shame and disrepute. And sin does that. Sin brings shame, ultimately, not honor. Another part of humanity with which God created us is that we would have rich and wonderful interpersonal relationships and fellowship with each other. But Jesus was all alone. All his disciples deserted him and fled. It says in the Bible. And so, isn't that also a picture of what sin does? It leads to isolation and loneliness. And people who are trapped in sin end up cutting off more and more relationships, and being more and more alone. God created us to be in fellowship with him. But here Jesus cried out, my God, my God, why have you forsaken me? The fellowship, the beautiful fellowship that he had known with the father from eternity, was temporarily disrupted, so that there was a dehumanizing factor of loss of fellowship with God. And sin does that, doesn't it? It alienates us from God. Crucifixion was a loss of mobility, the ability to move, to walk around, or to move one's arms or feet. And in a way, and God created us that way, so we have the freedom to move and to have control over our own bodies. But sin doesn't lead to bondage and imprisonment and loss of freedom. So, starkly, horribly pictured in the loss of freedom, also complete loss of freedom even to move, that Jesus experienced on the cross. God created us to have independence to be able to feed ourselves and care for ourselves. And that was denied in the cross, so that that's a picture, I think, of sin leading to a loss of ordinary human abilities, a loss of independence, and sin leads in that direction. God created us to be free from pain, having bodies that were healthy and strong. But Jesus on the cross was filled with pain, and I think that reminds us that sin doesn't lead to joy. Sin leads to suffering and pain, and we're seeing a portrayal of the consequences of it. God created us to be innocent, created Adam and Eve, and the garden to be innocent, but the cross is a picture of condemnation, being condemned to death, and sin leads to condemnation. God created us to have strength, as well as health, strength in our bodies. But on the cross, Jesus experienced physical weakness, the loss of that physical strength with which God created us, and isn't that what sin does? You think of someone in bondage to drug addiction or to alcoholism, or many other kinds of sin, eventually just leads to physical deterioration too, all sorts, and sin leads to weakness. And God created us to be beautiful or handsome or attractive in the way He created us, but Isaiah 53 talks about the fact that He had no beauty that we should desire Him, and His face was marred and distorted by the punishment. And isn't that a picture that sin leads to a loss of beauty or attractiveness or desirableness in life, and sin is ugly, and its beauty is a lie, it has no beauty ultimately. And so there was a picture of the consequence of sin, and Jesus, and even His clothing was taken away, He lost all His possessions, but doesn't sin ultimately lead to a loss of all things. And God created us to be in His favor and to have His pleasure and His joy and delight in us, but sin leads to an experience of God's wrath, and that's what Jesus experienced on a cross. So why did Jesus suffer this sort of death? Perhaps because it was, in many aspects, taking away of essential qualities of what it is to be truly human in the excellence with which God created us, and it was portrayed in such a stark way drawn out over time so that that would be so firmly etched in our minds, this is what sin will do. And here Jesus is taking that penalty for us. So that, through His suffering, we could be freed from those things and obtain the glory of the excellence with which God has created us, and we brought back to full possession of life and breath and honor and relationship and fellowship with God and mobility and independence. And freedom from pain and innocence and strength and attractiveness and possessions and the favor of God, we could ultimately gain all of those because Jesus took the consequences of sin for us.

I just, that's all I wanted to say about that, but it's kind of does this seem right to you. It's not in the book, it's sort of something I was reflecting on afterward, but it seems right to me. It was kind of prompted by something Darryl said in a sermon, maybe last Easter or something about the consequences of sin, and I began reflecting. Do you want to talk about that at all, or seem right to you? If they were godly priests, as they would take that precious, blameless, faultless lamb and take that knife to its little throat and cut it and the blood spewed out. And that they knew the horror of sin, and because in their hands that precious little lamb or animal would die because of their sins and the sins of Israel and the smell and the flies and the grossness of the blood and the blood all over the priest and all over his linen and his feet and as the blood would run down those troughs, I think it's, it's, Jesus is the lamb and being slain like that for us, it's believers. We look to the cross and it is an amazing thing. So sometimes we look at those Old Testament sacrifice, why did God command that? All these animals being killed and all this blood and everything. But it's to help us see this is how bad sin is. This is how horrible it is. Of course it should be revolting or something in that. I mean, we appreciate the greatness of what Jesus did for us through it. And you know, the bad priests, I think, you know how they say that sometimes sociopathic killers, they begin killing dogs or cats when they're younger, you know, without any feeling. And I just think, I bet you some of those nasty priests that really didn't trust God, didn't fear God. I bet they almost delighted. They're feeling the horribleness of it. If you, as in first John, I think it is, if you agree with God that something is a sin and you repent, at this point, could you expect there not to be punishment, but maybe correction? I guess I'm looking for hope in me. A little bit of complex question. When Christians sin, we don't come under eternal condemnation. There's no loss of heaven or consequence of going to hell or anything. And we pray for forgiveness. Oftentimes God just restores His favor to us. But there are times when, and John Paul mentioned it in the sermon this morning, there are times when God does discipline us for our good. But it's always out of His favor as a loving parent to do us good. And never to do us permanent harm. So Hebrews 12, before the moment, all discipline seems painful rather than pleasant. Later yields a peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who are trained by it. So it's a tremendous difference in what we do. And as, you know, we all are reminded by birthdays or surgeries or whatever we are growing older. And we live in a fallen world, and we will eventually, all of us, unless Jesus returns, will die. But even that is not punishment. That's because we live in a fallen world, and God has allowed us to follow in Jesus steps, even the path that He took, and through it, again, through it will bring blessing and bring us to great glory, ultimately, even though there are hardships in this life. Okay. Anything else on this? I don't want to take too long on it. But one more over here. Jerry is a guest here from Oregon. Sometimes when we're taking communion, one of the things I do in my own heart is contemplate the suffering of Christ on the cross and the dehumanization, call it a form of aversion therapy, if you like. But it brings me back to the reality of what my sin cost Christ. And the fact that when I sin, I am, again, re-addressing that issue and trying to commit myself to the idea, I don't want to do this anymore, because I don't want to, because when I reflect on what it costs Christ, I don't want to see that being mocked by my behavior. Thank you, Jerry. Good. I'm just thinking in the middle of these comments, I've heard sometimes people say, I don't like Christianity, I don't like this religion, I don't have this idea of this awfulness of Jesus dying and all the blood and the violence connected with it, and it just turns me off. And I think that those people don't understand that this is showing the consequence of sin. It's showing how awful sin is and it was necessary that this happened in order that the consequences of sin would be experienced by Jesus in our place. And it shows what we don't then have to experience in so many ways. Well, let's go on to the next point, D. There was still more to the atonement than paying the penalty for sin. And if I had left the lesson with just what we talked about the last two weeks about being a substitute for us bearing God's wrath in our place, paying the penalty for sin, someone could listen to that and say, well, wait, yeah, what you said is true, but you missed some parts of the atonement. There's more to it than that. And that's why I want to say, yes, there is more. That was the central part, I think. But there is more. And that is, we have multiple problems before we are forgiven. Number one, we deserve to die. Number two, we deserve to bear God's wrath. Number three, we're separated from God. Number four, we're in bondage to sin. Number five, we place powerful enemies, Satan and his demons. And in a way, the atonement was an answer to all of those aspects of our problem, not just number two, that we deserve to bear God's wrath or one and two, but also these others. So there are different words in the New Testament that talk about the atonement meeting these needs in different ways. We deserve to die. Well, there was a sacrifice to bear the penalty of death in our place. Greek were often in the New Testament, Thucia, a sacrifice. Number two, we deserve to bear God's wrath. And we talked about that at some length. There's propitiation. He'll ask Darion, that is, Jesus bore God's wrath in our place. Number three, we are separated from God. I don't think we really talked about that yet in any degree, but in order for a separation to be healed, we need reconciliation. So if you're alienated from someone, you need to be reconciled to the person. Well, we were separated from God, cut off because of our sin. And the atonement is viewed as reconciliation. So second Corinthians 5, 18 to 19 talks about the atonement in this way. I didn't put those verses up there, but I'll just read them. Second Corinthians 5, 18 to 19. All this is from God who, through Christ, reconciled us to Himself and gave us the ministry of reconciliation. That is God was reconciling the world to Himself, not counting their trespasses against them and entrusting to us the message of reconciliation. Therefore, we are ambassadors for Christ. God making us appeal through us. We implore you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God. And so the verbs katalaso, apocatalaso are used to talk about the atonement as reconciliation. That's also important to remember. And then we are in bondage to sin, and we need redemption to redeem us or buy us out of bondage, the nouns lutron or anti-lutron, the verb lutrao, to ransom from sin and the kingdom of Satan. So the son of man came to give his life as a ransom for many, or Titus 214, Titus 214, who gave Himself to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for Himself for people for His own possession, who are zealous for good works. And so there is redemption or ransom. And then number five, we face powerful enemies, but Christ triumphed over Satan and demons on the cross. And that's another aspect of the atonement. So He disarmed Colossians 215, He disarmed the principalities and powers and made a public example of them or put them to open shame by triumphant over them in Him that is in Christ on the cross. And so there are just other aspects of the atonement so that we get a full picture, and we could spend more time on all of those, but actually I'm going to go on now. My application of this, and trying to draw application more frequently in the class, application is we shouldn't neglect any of these aspects of the atonement, and we certainly shouldn't deny any of them. So, okay, Jesus paid us sacrifice, gave up His life. Wow, we are free from death, that is from eternal death, and so even our physical death is going to lead us into fullness of life. Well, you may be thankful for that. Propitiation. Well, we're never going to face God's wrath. My goodness, what a blessing. We face perhaps the discipline of a loving father, but we never face the wrath of an infinitely holy God is going to say, I'm going to punish you eternally for that sin, because that's all taken care of. So we don't face that anymore. It's tremendous blessing, tremendous relief, free from the vague fear that the many people in the world feel that they'll be under God's wrath forever, and they will, unless they trust in Christ. Reconciliation. Well, if that's true, if the atonement brought us reconciliation, well then we have fellowship with God. We can spend time with Him in prayer. We can read His Word and He speaks to us. We can worship Him and know that He hears our worship and He delights in it. That's reconciliation, tremendous application from that. And we have fellowship with each other as believers. And that's a great blessing, rather than being alienated and separated and cut off from other people, we have fellowshiped together with each other. And redemption. We're free from bondage to sin and bondage to Satan. And we've talked about this somewhat in the past. We'll talk about it more in the future. Because of what Christ has done, we can be progressively more and more free from sin in our lives, more and more leading lives of holiness. We can talk about that this morning as well. And we can be free from Satan triumphant over us, or getting victory over us, though we face attacks from Him, we have promises by which we can triumph. And so victory, we have power to triumph over Satan and demons as well. So that's the richness of the atonement and various applications. Now I want to go on and say, they're in history. There have been some incorrect views of the atonement. Well, you think through 2000 years of the church, you might get some strange views are taught. And there were some strange views taught, some early in the history of the church and some at other times. One is the ransom to Satan theory, where you see language of ransom in the Bible, this teacher in the early church named origin, who was in many, in many ways, very, very good, but it wasn't perfect. And he had some mistakes. And here he said, well, it's a ransom, must have been a ransom that God paid to Satan, to free people from bondage to Satan. It's a strange idea. It's not taught in the New Testament. Satan didn't have any hold over us, any payment that was due to him. The ransom was to free us from the bondage to sin. And the payment was that Jesus made the payment to guard himself in terms of the payment to earn our freedom. And so that's just a bad idea. And I don't know if anybody else has held it in the history of the church, but it just gets mentioned as one mistake. Number two, the moral influence theory. Number two, three and four are substitute ideas for propitiation. Number two, three, remember I talked about last week, Joel Green, Judith Gundary-Vole, Steve Chalk in England, these people under five C above on this page who are denying the doctrine of penal substitution, denying the doctrine that Jesus bore the wrath of God against our sin. Well, then people say, well, then how do they understand the atonement? What's the point of Jesus' death? And in history there have been these alternative theories and they take some combination of them and use them in substitute for holding to propitiation. And some of them have some truth to them, but they're partial truth. So here's one, the moral influence theory. The moral influence theory is that the atonement shows how much God loves us and that that moral influence will lead us to love God and return. In other words, don't think about any payment for sin. Jesus came and God sent him to live in this world where there's a lot of suffering and sin and he suffered and that demonstrates that God loves us so don't you love him in return? No payment for sin. Well, there's a little truth in that in that it does show God's love, but it's not the whole truth and it's taking an aspect of it, a partial truth and trying to make it a whole truth. What it denies is it denies the objective character of the atonement. What I mean by that is something really happened. God put the wrath and punishment that was due to our sin on Christ and he accepted that payment. Something happened in the transaction between God the Son and God the Father when Christ died on the cross. It's an objective reality. It's not just how it does good for us later. It's that something really happened in history in the history of the universe and the history of how God relates to the universe. It was an objective reality and it was accomplished. This moral influence you says, oh, the only point was to show us God cares for the world so that denies the objective character of the atonement. Another view that's an incorrect view if it's the only view that's held is the view called Christ, it's called the example theory of the atonement, but I call it the Christ as example theory because then it gets you to understand the meaning of it. This Christ death gives us an example of how to trust God and live for others, just like other heroic people have suffered for others in the past. See, and it just it shows you that if you are a righteous person, you will have persecution in this world and just look at Jesus and follow his example. Well, there's some truth in that. He did leave us an example that we should follow in his steps. So there's partial truth there. But again, if you say the only reason Jesus came was to show us how to face suffering and trust in God, if you say that's all it was an example for us, you denied the objective character of the atonement. You denied that something actually happened that a payment was made for our sin. And so you've got a partial truth and made it into the whole truth. Another theory is the governmental theory of the atonement. And this is a little bit harder to grasp. If you say to someone who holds this, why did Jesus come and die? Well, it shows that there was something wrong with the world. God's laws had been broken and somebody had to pay some kind of penalty showing the seriousness of sin. And so you should and so that should shock us and say help us to say, oh sin is bad. We shouldn't go there. It's sort of like the teacher who has 30 students in the class and doesn't know who did something bad in the class, broke the window. And nobody will tell. So the teacher says, all right, Sally, I'm going to punish you and then Sally has to go stand in the corner for an hour or something. Sally might not have done it, but just shows the teachers really upset. It's making an example out of somebody to show that something went wrong. And so God just shows Jesus and made him an example to show that the governor of the universe had been tempered with. And so somebody had to suffer. And in fact, God sent his own son to do that. That's the governmental theory. Again, there's a little sliver of truth here. There's a partial truth. I mean, when Jesus came and suffered, it does show that something's wrong with the moral behavior of the universe. But once again, it denies the objective character of the atonement. It denies the central truth of it that Jesus bore the wrath of God against our sin. And so it just says, oh, well, Jesus came to suffer to show us something's wrong. Well, that's missing the main point. That's missing the bearing of God's wrath and the penalty for us. So those are incorrect views of the atonement if they are held as the only views. And the first one, of course, is completely incorrect. All right. Still with me? I got one more thing to do here. Two more things. Two more things. One is did Christ descend into hell. Why do I even bring this up? Because in churches throughout the world that use the apostles' creed and Catholic orthodox and Protestant churches do use the apostles' creed, you start reading in it and it says this. I believe in God the Father Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, and in Jesus Christ is only Son our Lord, who was conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified dead and buried. He descended into hell.

The third day he rose from the dead, he ascended into heaven and sit at the right hand of God the Father Almighty, from then he shall come to judge the quick and the dead. I believe in the Holy Spirit, the Holy Catholic Church, the Communion of Saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and the life everlasting. Amen. How many people have heard that phrase before? He descended into hell. 100% of you. Okay. So it is important that we talk about it because you say that and you say, whoa, what does that mean? He descended into hell. People wonder. Did Christ descend into hell? Well, first, if you look back at historical documents of where the apostles' creed came from, it's different from other creeds. The nice scene creed was written in one place at one time in Nicea, in 325 AD, revised in Constantinople in 381 AD and you can find the exact dates. The calcedonian creed was written in Calcedon outside of Istanbul in 451 AD. It was a certain place, a certain time, and people wrote it and they said, we agree, okay, let's all go home, it's done. But the apostles' creed wasn't that way. The apostles' creed was kind of like a snowball that gathers more and more snow to it as it rolls along and maybe some of you in Arizona don't know what a snowball is. But if you grew up in Wisconsin, you know, you can push this snowball and as it rolls, it gets more snow on it. So, the apostles creed, there were sort of some statements of what people believed and then some more were added and kind of got widely circulated and there were different revisions of it. And the phrase he descended into hell wasn't in any early copies. It's not found historically until one copy in 390 AD reported by a man named Rufinus and then it doesn't occur in any other versions of this apostles creed until 650 AD. So, does that go back to the apostles? 390 AD, well, that's 300 years or more after the last apostle died, that isn't written by any apostle. And Rufinus, when he talks about it, he says, well, you know, these versions that had this didn't have the phrase buried. And so historians who look at this think it probably, first he was crucified, dad he descended into the grave on the third day he rose again from the dead because the Hebrew word shield and the Greek word, hey, these can both mean hell or the grave or the state of death they can have multiple meanings. And so I think, I think as I've looked into this historically, I think it came about first by a confusion. He was crucified, dad he descended into the grave the third day he rose from the dead. But then when people got crucified dead and buried, you get buried here and then keep he descended into hell, it makes people think it's something after he was buried, doesn't it? And so after that, then people made up all sorts of explanations that wouldn't contradict sound doctrine, but really aren't what you think when you say he descended into hell. Some people say it means he suffered the pains of death on the cross or the pains of hell on the cross. Well, theologically that's true, but when you put it after buried, it's kind of wondering. And other people have said, well, then there are some other theories that are questionable that he went and proclaimed to release to Old Testament saints so they could go to heaven. I'm not sure that the Bible teaches that. He went and proclaimed to sinful people that they'd never get out. That's a popular view today, but I don't think the Bible says that. So, oh, he went to hell and proclaimed to people they could have a second chance for salvation. They haven't believed first. I don't think the Bible teaches that. So you get all sorts of strange views as well. Where's the Bible support the idea that what happened when Jesus died? When he said father into your hands, I commit my spirit and he breathed his last. What happened? Well, there are some verses that people look at that could say that then Jesus's spirit went to the underworld or to hell. I don't think they prove it, but here are the verses. One is, Acts 227, you will not abandon my soul to Hades or let your Holy One see corruption. If you translate that as hell, then it would lead you to think that Jesus was in hell in some point. But I don't think we have to translate it that way. I think it probably just means you will not abandon my soul to the grave or to the state of being dead. Those are both legitimate meanings for the Greek word Hades that is used there. So that doesn't really convince me that Jesus descended into hell. Romans 10, 6 and 7, but the righteousness based on faith says, do not say in your heart who will ascend to heaven that is to bring Christ down or who will descend into the abyss that is to bring Christ up from the dead, but Christ is near you. And so does this say that Christ was in the abyss or in hell? No, read the verse. It says, do what is that word? Do not. Do not say this. Do not say, oh, you've got to travel up to heaven so that we could be near Christ. Don't say, oh, you've got to go to the abyss to be near Christ. Those are both wrong. He's near you. So I don't want to build a doctrine on a statement that the Bible says, don't say it. You with me? Okay. So I don't, I don't, I don't think that's a convincing verse. What about Ephesians 4.8? Okay. Therefore, it says when he ascended on high, he let a host of captives and he gave gifts to men in saying he ascended what does it mean to the, he had also descended into the lower regions, the earth, King James Virgin, New King James, New American standard and early printings of the English standard version. I'm sorry to say put into the lower parts of the earth. But even if you translate it this way, I think the of is just a genitive of opposition as we would say, the city of Phoenix. That means the city which is Phoenix, right? The city of Phoenix. And so I think this means the lower parts of the earth, that is the lower parts, that is the, the lower, the lower earthly region. I think it means Jesus came from heaven to the earth. So he descended into the lower regions, that is the earth. So I think it's a genitive of opposition. So strongly to most people think that's what it means that, that this is the common translation today, he had also descended into the lower regions, common, the earth. That's a very legitimate translation of the Greek genitive case which is there. So I think it means the lower parts that is the earth. So I don't think that means that Jesus descended into hell. What about 1 Peter 3? 1 Peter 3? For Christ also suffered for sins, the righteous, for the unrighteous, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit in which he went and proclaimed to the spirits in prison. Does that mean that after Jesus died, he went and preached to people in hell. He went and proclaimed or preached to the spirits in prison because they formerly did not obey when God's patients waited in the days of Noah while the ark was being prepared in which a few of that is 8 persons were brought safely through water. Now first thing I want to say about this passage is it is much disputed. But I have a little bit more to say about it. Let's read it again. He went and preached to the spirits in prison or proclaimed because and there's a technical question of Greek grammar having to do with how a participle modifies a verb. But it's very legitimate to translate this. He preached the spirits in prison when they formerly did not obey. I think that's the best translation. I've argued for that extensively in writing but not everybody agrees with it yet. So we just wait for the arguments to be persuasive. But anyway, think about this. Read it this way. He went and preached or proclaimed to the spirits in prison when they formerly did not obey when God's patients waited in the days of Noah while the ark was being prepared. My answer to this is I think it means that Christ was preaching through Noah at the time of the flood. Let's see, I published a commentary on the first Peter in the Tindale New Testament commentary series and I have a long appendix on that. I think what Peter means here and it fits the context is that just as Noah was faithful in bearing witness to God and preaching to the people around him in a sinful generation before the flood came, so Peter says, you are suffering and your neighbors are opposing you but you need to be faithful witnesses to because God saved Noah and he'll save you. Another reason for I think that is that this proclaimed or preached this verb, Karrusso, is picked up by the corresponding noun in second Peter 2, 5 where it says Noah is a preacher of righteousness. Karrusso is the corresponding noun so there's a parallel in Peter's thinking. He says Noah is a preacher of righteousness. And then did Peter think that Christ was preaching through the Old Testament prophets? Oh yes, Peter says in chapter 1, the prophets who prophesied about the grace that was to be yours, searched and inquired about this salvation, they inquired what person or time was indicated by the spirit of Christ within them when they were proclaiming the sufferings of Christ and the subsequent glories. Peter talks about the spirit of Christ preaching through the Old Testament prophets already so he could have the idea that the spirit of Christ was preaching through Noah. It would be very consistent with his thinking and he calls Noah a preacher of righteousness. So and especially if we translate it when I think it means Christ preached or proclaimed to the spirits in prison when they formally did not obey. That's when he preached, it was in the days when the ark was being built, Noah was preaching and Christ was preaching through him. Well, I think that's what it means but I have to admit it's disputed and evangelical interpreters have disputed but it certainly does so what does that mean? Jesus died in the flesh, he was alive in the spirit and then and then Peter says you know what in the spiritual realm long time ago, Jesus was already active in the world preaching through Noah. Okay, that's my solution. Well, what about this one last verse in terms of a descent into hell? For this is why the gospel is preached even to those who are dead that those that those judged in the flesh the way people are they might live in the spirit the way God does. Here's one other verse where people say oh wait a minute Jesus went to hell and preached to people a gospel so they could repent. I don't think it means that. I think it means the gospel was preached earlier to those who are now dead when it was preached they were alive. That is why the gospel was preached 10 or 15 years ago or 20 years ago to those who are now dead so that they could live in the spirit so they could come to faith. So I don't think that means that Jesus went to hell either and I think there's some reason to think Jesus did not descend into hell. Luke 223, he said to the thief on the cross today you will be with me in paradise. Paradise and San Corinthians and Revelation is two other uses it means heaven in the New Testament that Greek word paradise sauce. Today you will be with me in heaven in the presence of God. Jesus is saying to the thief he's not going to he's not saying you'll be with me in hell. Jesus went into the presence of God his spirit did or John 19.30 when Jesus had received the sour wine he said it is finished and he bowed his head and gave up his spirit his suffering was finished. There's no more going to hell to suffer anymore it was finished on the cross and then Luke 2346 when Jesus was dying he called out with a loud voice father into your hands I commit my spirit. That I think implies that he expected that God the father in heaven would receive his spirit so the same thing happened to Jesus when he died that happens to us when we die. Our bodies are laid in the earth but our spirits go into heaven to be with God and that happened to Jesus and Stephen when he was died and say Lord Jesus received my spirit I think he's echoing what Jesus said on the cross same idea. So my conclusion regarding the apostles creed is I don't believe that Christ descended into hell and so when I'm in a church where the reciting the apostles creed I say it like this. It was crucified dead and buried on the third day he rose from the dead I just don't say the words he descended into hell because I don't believe him. What I believe is when Jesus died his body remained on the earth and was buried but his spirit returned to the presence of God in heaven until Easter Sunday morning. When his spirit came back joined to his body and he was raised in new life. Application. Even famous ancient creeds do not equal scripture and people say it's been around so long and my response is even an old mistake is still a mistake. Number two Christ suffering ended on the cross he didn't descend into hell after that. Suffering was done it is finished and number three there's no second chance for salvation he didn't go to hell and offer a second chance for salvation to people in hell. Okay now here's where we are we're at 1057. I didn't get to the last part the extent of the atonement. It is a really controversial topic. I'm not going to omit it I'm going to take that topic for the first 10 maybe 15 minutes of class next week before I go on to the resurrection. And I didn't give you any chance to interact on the descendent of hell so next week come back we'll do that too. You're dismissed.