<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
دین ماسिक عطيا

The Church, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Well, we have four classes to go, and we'll look again today at Calvin's Doctrine of the Church, and then on Thursday, sacraments and baptism, next week Tuesday, Lord's Supper, and then next week, Thursday, Civil Government. Now we'll take us through book four and complete our study of the Institutes. Today, I'm going to make out the exam that a few of you will be interested in. Those who are doing the exam rather than the paper. And I would suggest you just kind of use your syllabus as a guide, go through those the outlines again, and pay some attention, of course, to arrangement as well as content. Not only what Calvin says about some things, say, his teaching on repentance, or his practical description of the Christian life with the various subpoints under that, but where doctrines like that appear in the Institutes, we put a good bit of emphasis on Calvin's arrangement as well as his content. So mainly large discussion type questions, might be a few short answer types, but mostly give you a chance to write on some topic or some issue that Calvin deals with in the Institutes. Well, we were looking at nature of the church, and there are two big headings there, visible and invisible church. I think I've said all I need to say about Calvin's distinction there between visible and invisible, and so we come today to true and false church. Very important topic for Calvin, and for just about everybody in the 16th century as the church begins to divide, Catholic, Protestant, Lutheran, Reform, and so on, then the issue becomes very urgent, and that is what is the true church. And we'll move on later this morning to talk about the ministry, the officers of the church, the ministers of the church, and pastors and so on. And the prayer from Calvin this morning is a prayer particularly for pastors, and I'll pray this. We pray for faithful pastors in the words of John Calvin, let us pray. O faithful Father and Savior, we commend to thee in our prayers all whom thou hast appointed pastors over thy faithful, and to whose guidance thou hast committed ourselves, all whom thou hast been pleased to make the dispensers of thy Holy Gospel. That thou would guide them by thy Holy Spirit, and so make them honest and faithful ministers of thy glory, making it all their study and directing all their endeavors together together, all the desolate sheep which are still wandering astray, and bring them back to Jesus Christ, the chief shepherd, and prince of bishops, and that they may increase in righteousness and holiness every day. Amen. So we come to a true and false church, we need to first of all discuss Calvin's ideas about the marks of the church. How can you tell the true church? Calvin says true church will have two marks, and these are criteria of a true church. The face of the church comes forth and becomes visible to our eyes, so as we see these marks present in the face of the church comes forth and becomes visible to our eyes Calvin says. The first mark is the word of God, purely preached and heard. It's absolutely necessary for that to be true for a church to be there. Word of God must be preached, and Calvin qualifies that by, say, purely preached, which means the real word of God, correct teaching of the word of God, and he also adds the word heard. So it's not just the bare sermon, but it's proper true sermon, setting forth the true meaning of the scripture, and people listening to that. The heard, I think, the purpose of adding the word heard, their preaching of the word, pure preaching of the word, and hearing of the word, is probably Calvin's concern that preaching be in the vernacular. If sermons are in Latin and people don't know Latin, then they can't hear, doesn't do them any good. So sermons must be preached in the vernacular, as Calvin did in Geneva, he preached in French, not in Latin. He wrote in Latin and French, but he preached in French, so that people could not only hear him speak, but understand what he was saying. As we look at Calvin's life in Geneva, and the church in Geneva, we certainly see the importance of preaching. Preaching had fallen on bad times prior to the Reformation. We're not many sermons, and those sermons did not treat consecutively books of the Bible as Calvin liked to do in his preaching, so that people would be taught the Bible, whole books of the Bible, and in time the whole Bible. But sermons in connection with the Catholic NAS were often just short homilies related to some text in the liturgy for that day, but in Geneva it was quite different. There were three parish churches, Peter's were Calvin preached, and two others in and around the city of Geneva, and at its height there were 17 sermons a week in those three churches, so people heard a lot of sermons. In fact it said that practically every morning Calvin was in the pulpit telling people that they were sinners for whom Christ died, so they hear the gospel every day, and sometimes several times during a day. We have about 1,500 of Calvin's sermons that have been preserved, perhaps as many as 1,000 of those sermons have been lost. Unfortunately, beginning of the 19th century, perhaps even later, those sermons were being lost from the Library in Geneva, in fact at one time apparently a librarian not really realizing what he was doing was using Calvin's sermons as wrapping paper to send out books to people, thinking it was just scrap paper. A lot of Calvin's sermons were lost through that carelessness, but we have a good many of Calvin's sermons. Actually not all that many in English, we do have some, we have Calvin's sermons on the book of Ephesians in English, translated into English, some of his sermons on Job and some other passages to some other books too, but my no means do we have the complete corpus of Calvin's sermons. So Calvin's preaching available to us yet in English, I expect more and more of that will come as time goes on. Yes, dude. With Calvin preaching as much as he did, do we have a sense of what his sermons preparation looked like? The question is how did Calvin prepare, you know he's preaching and he's teaching consistently, preacher and a teacher, and his teaching, we know what that looks like because of his commentaries. And when you say look at Calvin's commentary, for instance on Ephesians, and then compare his sermons on Ephesians, there's some difference but there's not a huge difference, is preaching tends to be much like his teaching, but perhaps a little more personal, a little more application. But I don't know that we know exactly how Calvin prepared, he was studying all the time, studying scripture, and apparently had a marvelous mind because Calvin could teach and preach without notes and it sounds like he's reading manuscript and you read what he is producing. Students and friends took down his sermons by a kind of invented shorthand that they came up with and a team of them would take down his sermons and then compare what they had produced and sometimes showed it to Calvin sometimes did not. So we have his sermons, we have sermons on Deuteronomy that was those sermons were taken down by shorthand by these students. But Calvin was a student certainly and he was a man of remarkable mind and memory. So don't let that discourage you do the best you can and develop your own style and system but we can admire Calvin for the way he was able to preach so consistently for so long and produce such quality sermons. So the word of God purely preached and heard and then second mark of the church sacraments administered according to Christ institution will come to our study of the sacraments of the next two classes. Calvin reduces those from seven to two Roman Catholic church had by 16th century settled on the idea that there were seven sacraments. In fact that had been settled for several centuries by then. But Calvin does not agree with that and says there are two biblical sacraments. One is baptism and one is the word supper and these should be administered according to Christ institution. You might put it this way the question I said is I began where is the true church could be answered this way in the 16th century the Catholic church would say it's wherever the the bishop is churches where the bishop is where the priest is that's the church. Anabaptist some anabaptist in fact perhaps most of the anabaptists would put it this way the church is where godliness is where holiness is where Christian living is but Calvin's answer is that the church is where Christ is and Christ is present in the preaching of the word and in the administration of the sacraments. So where the word is purely preached heard in the sacraments administered according to Christ institution there he is present in his blessing and there is the church discipline is important for Calvin church discipline but it is not a third mark. The reform tradition Scotland Westminster Confession will add church discipline to preaching of the word and the administration of the sacraments as a third mark Calvin doesn't do that going to speculate in a moment as to why he doesn't do that. But if first of all say discipline is extremely important for Calvin and by church discipline when we think of that idea connection with the institutes we don't mean entirely cinchers or correction church discipline can have a more positive meaning which I think it should training helping instructing as well as correcting. All that's extremely important for Calvin it's indispensable in fact if the church is to maintain its true character if you had a church preaching a pure word of god and administering the sacraments correctly but had no discipline whatsoever Calvin said that church would soon disappear no longer be a church. So even though he doesn't have discipline as the third mark it certainly is important to him his favorite image or illustration of discipline is to compare it to sinews sinews of the body 4121 is one place where he uses that image. If the saving doctrine of Christ is like the soul of the church soul and body of the church we might say that is preaching of the word administration of the sacraments and we'll see that those two support each other. You don't have sacraments without word and word should lead to sacraments because both are saying the same thing both are preaching the gospel and supporting each other in the preaching of the gospel that's the body and soul of the church. But then Calvin says that church discipline is like the sinews that holds it together just like we need sinews to keep our bodies together so the church needs discipline in order to hold together. Calvin says all who desire to remove discipline or to hinder its restoration are surely contributing to the ultimate dissolution of the church 4121. So discipline has to be there for the church to be effective for the church to continue for the church to be ensured that the efficacy of the word in the sacraments will continue. But why not make it a third mark? Calvin doesn't say this in so many words but I think perhaps the answer is this in Calvin's thinking later reformed theology adds discipline. In fact I was reading Donald McLeod the Scottish theologian in book called Faith to Live by and Donald McLeod says that you could add a fourth mark which is compassion for the poor charity and he sees this in the development of Knox and Melville and the church in Scotland. And then a fifth mark which is worship which he sees at least hinted at in the Westminster Confession of Faith but Calvin two marks. And I think the reason that he does not include discipline as a third mark is that preaching of the word and the giving of the sacraments are sheer objective elements in which the grace of God. This is what makes the church the church God's grace is offered to us is poured out upon us in sheer objective manner and discipline is a kind of subjective response to that grace. In other words we learned we hear we obey we're corrected very essential for the church and without discipline the church would not long exist but there's a kind of difference there between the sheer objectivity of the two marks and our human response which is urgently important. The question is about that or thoughts on that. When was the church discipline became a third mark? Already in the 16th century because by the time we come to John Knox he has made church discipline a third mark and it certainly is present in the 17th century in the Westminster Confession of Faith. It's kind of a fine line there and Calvin you want to say there are two marks but discipline is so important very close to being a third mark but he doesn't quite elevate it to the same level where he wants to place the preaching of the word in the administration of the sacraments which as we'll see later are really two parts of the same thing and that is the offering of the good news. The gospel of God's grace to us. Okay as we look at discipline aims and steps we can go through this pretty quickly because this is well known but let me just mention these things. It has three aims in discipline and here he's thinking more of the corrective aspect of discipline. The first is that it preserves the honor of God. Church is God's Christ body and his honor is at stake and discipline must be exercised in order to preserve his honor. Secondly it protects the good from the wicked. We're easily led astray by bad conduct and bad examples and if the church is not dealing with wicked actions then that's going to contaminate others in the church and thirdly it leads hopefully the offender to repentance. Calvin's purpose in discipline is not just to punish. It's not really to punish at all. It's to correct. It's to cause the person to see the era of his or her way and repent and be restored to the full fellowship of the church. In this list typically Calvin begins with the honor and glory of God and ends up with the welfare and good of people. So you can see discipline serving both functions to glorify God and to help those in the church both by protecting some from the sins of others and also by bringing those who are guilty of specific sins to repentance. The steps, first private warning and Calvin is simply following a New Testament instruction here, private warning, public admonition that would be either before the entire church or with a group of elders meeting with the individual. And thirdly exclusion from communication, that is from Holy Communion. Most of the acts of church discipline in Geneva and plenty of this went on between the year 1557 and 1560. There were an average of at least 200 excommunications a year in the churches in the three churches in Geneva. We very seldom hear of an excommunication today, occasionally one of our churches someone is excommunicated but 200 excommunications a year shows the seriousness with which the leaders of the Geneva church. The church considered church discipline the extent of excommunication though was generally to be suspended from one communion and there were four quarterly communions in Geneva. So a person was excommunicated which meant that that person could not protect the communion for one time, sometimes two times, occasionally as many as four times but generally one time it did not mean the person could not come to church. In fact, the person was required to come to church because everybody else in Geneva was. So if you were excommunicated for something, it meant that on that one communion Sunday you were not allowed to protect on the Lord's Supper. It became quite an issue in Geneva because Calvin felt the church itself should have the ultimate responsibility of saying who could take the Lord's Supper and who cannot. But the civil leaders in Geneva felt that the state should have the last word in excommunication as was true in many other parts of Protestant Europe but Calvin insisted on the freedom of the church to decide this issue. And on one famous occasion when there was a man, one of the leaders of the church who had been excommunicated leaders of the state and excommunicated by the church but he insisted he was going to receive the Lord's Supper anyway. And Calvin wrote that if he did, that he, Calvin would stand in front of the table and physically prevent this man from taking Lord's Supper if it was necessary. Fortunately, the man did not show up. I'm not sure what would have happened if he had. Calvin was not that strong of a person and it could have been a disaster. But you can see Calvin's concern there at that. It's not the state but it's the church that decides this issue. A couple of questions. I've always heard of this mention between excommunication and borrowing some of the elements. Can you talk about that? And then the other question is, idea of borrowing some of the elements though they were pennant because evidently if you're just borrowing some of the elements for just one Sunday they'd have to be repented. They were unrepentant. It wouldn't be right to still look them back to the table the next Sunday. How is that appropriate to? Let me deal with those one by one. Excommunication. Say the first one again. The excommunication is a step beyond simply borrowing some of the elements. You might borrow some of the elements but they're still. Yes. Excommunication means you're out of fellowship with the church so that you cannot communicate which means receive Lord's Supper. And in Geneva that could be for one observance of Lord's Supper. Now in hardened cases where there's no repentance, then that excommunication can become more permanent. And the civil magistrates in Geneva then did become involved as to what punishment would be needed out to harden offenders. But generally in Geneva it was for a shorter time. And there would have to be repentance. There would be excommunication for one time and then the consistency would continue to meet with the individual if there was not repentance that suspension from the sacraments of the Lord's Supper would be continued for another time until there was repentance. Or until there was it was clear or at least seem clear to the consistency that there was a kind of final rejection and then punishment from the state would ensue. That was something that took place in the 16th century that we would not agree with of course that the state would then have the right to decide the ultimate penalty which could be to be barred from the city. And even more extreme cases. Yes, question. I was asking if this was the reason excommunication that Calvin got in Geneva for three years? It was Calvin's insistence on church discipline. I think the reason he was expelled and had to go to Strasbourg. There were a number of reasons there but the primary reason was his insistence on church discipline. Calvin said when he arrived in Geneva in 1536 there were sermons but that was all feral was there preaching sermons but there was no really organization of the church and no discipline. And Calvin felt that of course that was wrong and he moved to create a church system where there would be discipline. I think Calvin was right in doing that. He made him try to move too fast and alienated people unnecessarily rather than bringing them along slowly and carefully but that was the basic reason why he was expelled but then three years later the Geneva's realized that they needed something like what Calvin suggested. It was really not until 1555 that the concessory that would be like the the presbytery. The concessory attained the right to have its senates of excommunication recognized his final struggle between the councils and the concessory between state and church until 1555. And you might say Calvin finally won his long battle at that point. Okay, let's move on now to the next point here in the outline as long as the church retains its marks. We must not reject it even if it otherwise swarms with many faults. So Calvin says there are the two marks and then discipline is close but for reasons that already suggested not a third mark. But as long as the word is being preached and people are hearing it sacraments are being correctly administered that's a church. It's not a perfect church but it can be considered a true church even if it swarms with many faults. And when Calvin begins to describe what the faults are, tells us first of all there may be some fault in doctrine or sacrament for 112. So Calvin doesn't require a church to be perfect in its doctrinal teaching or perfect in its sacramental administration to be a true church. The fault in doctrine Calvin says has to be a non-essential matters. Could not have a church that had gone astray into some major heresy and that church was preaching that heresy. It could not be considered a true church but there may be, quote, some fault in non-essential matters. That's 412 and then Calvin begins to list what he thinks are necessary doctrines. God is one, I have to believe in the oneness of God that there is one God, Christ is God, our salvation rest in God's mercy and then you kind of hope he will go on and complete the list and he says and such like. So we don't have Calvin's authoritative list of what are the essential doctrines, certainly in the three that he lists. You get the doctrine of the unity of God, the oneness of God, the deity of Christ, salvation by grace we would say. But he doesn't say that's all he just says and such like so we were left to wonder what else should long in that list but Calvin says church may make some mistakes in some areas of its teaching but it has to be a non-essential area. Whatever that means, we know part of what it means from Calvin's words here but we don't know completely what it means at least at his point of view and it could still be a true church. What do we do then if we were in a church like that? We must try to correct what displeases us for one twelfth, this is all for one twelfth. We don't abandon the church, we work as hard as we can to correct what displeases us. So there may be some fault in doctrine or sacrament and there certainly may be and we would almost say will be imperfections of life that means people are not going to be living the way Christians ought to. We can't just say about a church where there is preaching of the word, pure preaching of the word, proper administration of the sacraments that I don't like this church because these people are too world like Julian. Can you understand or relate to that in relation to all of the press of the period and the nominations and also with enough of the churches going through right now? In terms of not leaving when it's not right? Well I think the answer from Calvin will be and I'll talk about this in a few minutes. Calvin did leave a church but now as he thinks about what is the true church? And he's thinking about the Protestant church, maybe even the reformed church but probably more likely the Protestant church. We'll see later that Calvin signed the Augsburg confession with its Lutheran statement of the Lord's Supper. So I think Calvin would not have said difference of opinion on the presence of Christ in the elements. It's not adequate for breaking fellowship with the church. So he does leave a church but I think he would say there, he does say there that the necessary doctrines were not being taught. God's salvation through the mercy of Christ alone was not being taught. So the Catholic church was not a church in which there was some fault in doctrine but major fault in doctrine. In fact Calvin says we left them in order to come to Christ with to not stay Catholics and be Christians. So that's a major issue. But I think this would apply more to our being in a church, getting unhappy with that church and then leaving it because some teaching doesn't please us. For some people aren't behaving the way they should in Calvin say no you can't do that. I mean we leave churches for even less significant things. We don't like the paint, the new color of the Sunday school building or something and people kind of wander about all the time. That's more of a modern phenomenon but I think it was a problem in Calvin's day two although people did not have the flexibility that they have today to change churches or change the nominations at the top of the hat. Calvin goes into this matter of imperfections of life. I'm not going to go through all these references that I've given there but just one or two Calvin says look at the church in current. There's a lot of problems in current and you read Paul's correspondence with that church and you find that all kinds of pretty major problems existed there. Yet Calvin said the church abides among them. Paul is still calling that a church is the church in current even though it's a church that has some major imperfections of life. And look at the church in Galatia. Some serious falling away in doctrine there. Paul says Calvin says Paul still recognizes churches among them. It's thinking of the whole province where there would be a number of churches, not just the one congregation but a number of churches in Galatia. So maybe some fault in doctrine, some imperfections of life. Calvin primarily here is opposing I think the anavabdist he calls them airy spirits, almost angelic kind of people that float above the earth and don't really live on this ground where we live. Because the anavabdist we're seeking for a perfect church, a pure church, church without sin and without an era. And Calvin is sure that they're never going to find it. He says in the creed, that is the apostles creed, forgiveness of sins follows the church. I believe in the Holy Spirit, the Holy Catholic church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins. So what Calvin makes of that is churches full of centers and we exist as a communion of saints, but we also exist as people who are centers that have to ask constantly for God's forgiveness and for the forgiveness of each other. Okay, let's come next to a comparison of the faults and the true church because Calvin becomes somewhat detailed here and sets forth two levels of false churches. Church can be a false church. True church is a church where the word is preached and the sacraments properly administered. But there are some churches where that's not true. So we call that a false church. But when Calvin comes to thinking of what is a false church, he wants to make a distinction here. And first he talks about churches that lack lawful form, the marks are missing, Christ is absent. But for Calvin, and this would be a description of the Roman Catholic church, which is a false church, but Calvin is not willing to go so far as to say that it cannot claim the name of church. It's a false church because it lacks the lawful form, but there are certain degrees here because you can go from false church lacking the lawful form to no church at all. And Calvin looks at the Roman Catholic church. It's somewhere between lacking lawful form and no church at all, but he's not willing to say there's no church at all. Catholics, of course, would say that of the Protestants that no church at all can't use the name church. In fact, the modern Catholic church, even in this ecumenical age in which we live still refuses to call a Protestant church, the church, because it's only one church. And that is the Catholic church. The two words they use for us are ecclesial fellowships. We have ecclesial fellowships, but the Catholics alone have the church. But as Calvin looked at the 16th century, he said the Catholic church lacks the lawful form, but he was not willing to go as far as saying that it was a false church. The marks were missing. Christ was absent, so Calvin separated from the Roman Catholic church, or as he put it, they have expelled us. He did not see himself so much as leaving the church as he saw himself being expelled from the church. He says it behooved us to withdraw from them that we might come to Christ. So pretty strong indictment there. Mark's are missing. Gospel is not being preached. Sacraments are not properly administered because the mass, for reasons that we'll see next week, I cannot be considered the true celebration of the Lord's Supper. So you have idolatry right in the heart of the church, the worship of the transubstantuated elements. And then Christ is absent. The presence of a pope symbolizes the real absence of the church's head, not the presence of the church's head. The pope is the head of the church. The presence of the pope takes the place of Christ. So it's no wonder that Calvin separated from the Roman Catholic church. He says apart from the Lord's word, there is not an agreement of believers, but a faction of wicked men. So if you don't have unity around the word, you don't have a church, you don't have a agreement of believers. You have a faction of wicked men. Calvin's treatment of his understanding of requirements of the true church that would be before verse 4 chapters, followed by arguments that the Roman Catholic church is not a true church. 4, 5 through 11, we're not reading all of that, but in 4, 5 through 11, Calvin argues in great detail that the papacy itself is directly contrary to church order. It gives biblical, historical, theological, and moral grounds. In some day, you may want to go through all of that, but we're not doing it for this class, but Calvin does set forth in great detail a reason why he considers the Roman Catholic church no longer a true church. This section demonstrates Calvin's considerable ability in church history. As we go through the institutes, we see Calvin using church history from time to time, but in these chapters, which we're not reading, he really delves into church history in a great deal of detail and shows skill they are for a 16th century scholar. He also shows his considerable ability in invective because Calvin's bolemic gets as strong in these chapters as anywhere, and sometimes certainly overdoes it in the words that he uses and the thoughts that he uses to denounce Roman Catholic church. But as strong as Calvin is in all of that, he insists that traces, the word he uses, traces 4, 2, 11 of the church still remain in Catholicism. He denies that the Catholic church is a true church, but he doesn't go so far as to say that there are no traces left. In fact, he says in 4, 2, 12, they are still churches to the extent that the Lord wonderfully preserves in them a remnant of his people. And Calvin argues that as long as they maintain baptism and other vestiges, they can be viewed as churches. Baptism is still there, practiced in the Catholic church in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. It's not clear what the other vestiges are, but Calvin does say something still there in the Catholic church, although he, one place describes it as a kind of trash heap or dung heap with just a little flicker of life or flicker of a flame. Still alive in the midst of all that's bad. Well, we come next to the doctrine of the church in terms of its order, church order, or the ministry of the church. And here Calvin says, scripture reveals an order of permanent validity. We have in the Bible, not only the doctrine of the church, but we have also the order of the ministry of the church. Calvin is different from Luther at this point. Luther did not spend much time thinking about or writing about a ecclesiastical organization, which to him depended almost entirely on circumstances, and he was willing to allow the state, the princes to control and to determine the outward structure of the church as long as ministers were free. We need to proclaim the gospel in the church. But for Calvin, the order of church government, as he says in 4-4-1, has been handed down to us from God's pure word. There is an order, and it's not open to us to create just any order or polity. We must obey the order that has been handed down from the word of God. But having made that point, Calvin also says that scripture gives us considerable freedom within the prescribed order of the word of God. It's Dr. McNeil puts it in our institutes in one of the footnotes that companies, 4-10-30, Calvin, sets forth a sensible freedom in secondary matters. God did not will in outward discipline and ceremonies to prescribe in detail what we ought to do. Calvin says, because he foresaw that this depended upon the state of the times, and he did not deem one form suitable for all ages. So he has not given, God has not given us a church polity in precise detail that can't be changed because times change, situations change, circumstances change, and it is necessary and permissible for us to change. What we do, how we see the church, and how the church is organized from time to time. Here is Calvin's commentary on 1 Corinthians 1440. The Lord allows us freedom in regard to outward rights in order that we may not think his worship is confined to those things. This freedom in outward rights, we can change, we can vary it, we can do it differently because his worship is not confined to the precise way in which we do these things. Then Calvin goes on to say, however, he has restricted the freedom in such a way that it is only from his word that we can make up our minds about what is right. So freedom, yes, but restricted freedom, we can't just do anything. We have the word that enables us to decide what is right. Sometimes we call this the regulative principle, you're familiar with that phrase, that we can only do those things which the Bible commands in our worship, we can only do those things which the Bible commands. I think we can use that expression for Calvin, but it seems to me that perhaps an even better way to think of it is a directive principle, scripture, directs more than it regulates. In other words, we have the scripture there which directs us as to how we should think about things. But then as Calvin says, God has restricted the freedom in such a way that it is only from his word that we can make up our minds about what is right. That's directive, not regulative. You see, regulative principle idea is an important one but it's a very difficult one to apply through church history and reform people that struggle with it all the way down to the present. It may be good for us to think of it more in terms of directive, but that's a matter we can probably spend a lot of time on. Calvin says that we can use our freedom, but love should be our guide. He wants to avoid rash, sudden, and unnecessary change for 10, 30. If we let love be our guide, all will be safe. That's a kind of a practical pastoral word and good word for you to remember as you go into a church and you want to change something. Maybe it needs to be changed, but let love be your guide. That means you don't do something suddenly abruptly and without preparing the people for it. You see, this is the older, more mature, more experienced Calvin talking now, not the young man that went to Geneva in his 20s and did try to change things pretty quickly and got expelled. And we're cautious now. Properly so I think. Calvin does talk about the importance of decorum, dignity, and propriety. I won't go through all of that, but this is another thing we have freedom, but we should use that freedom bounded by love. Whatever we do should be marked by decorum, dignity, and propriety. It's almost become a Presbyterian rule, hasn't it? We do things with dignity and decently and in order. And Calvin was concerned about all of this too. He says Paul sums up everything he has set forth concerning the external organization of the church with this statement. Seamliness should be preserved and disorder should be avoided. This statement shows that he was not willing to put people's consciences under obligation to the instructions he gave above as if they were binding for their own say, but only in so far as they make for seamliness and peace. So some things we do in the church, we do for those reasons, order, decorum, peace, propriety, not because those are absolute rules that cannot in any circumstance or situation be broken. And he ends up with importance of peace in the church. So we have a church order. It's given to us in the Scripture, has permanent validity. It's directive in that it shows us what we ought to do, but within the parameters of that church order, we have a great deal of freedom to move, to change things. We should all ways be guided by love, by decency, and by a sense of the importance of peace in the church. We'll begin talking about church offices and conclude this next time. The head of the church is Christ, 431. He alone should rule and reign in the church. So there's no Pope, Christ reigns in the church, Christ alone should reign in the church. Remember, the PCA was first being formed. We debated, we had our committees in different cities at first. So mission to the world was in Atlanta and mission to North America was in Montgomery and Christian education was somewhere else. We were fearful of a kind of church hierarchy. So we spread things out and then decided that that was not a good idea because these agencies had to work together. It would be better to have them placed close together. So we started talking about locating all the agencies in one place. That debate went on a few years. Atlanta was always a leading candidate. St. Louis seemed like for a while it could have been here that those offices would have been located because of seminary was here. But we talked about it a good bit. One general assembly, I think the one in which we voted to move our offices to Atlanta. People were talking about our headquarters being Atlanta and Dr. Morton Smith had about enough of that. So he stood up and reminded us that our headquarters are in heaven, he said. Not in Atlanta. And that's another way of saying what Calvin says here that we don't have an earthly head. We don't have earthly headquarters. Christ is head of the church. And Christ works through the ministry of men just as a workman uses the tool to do his work. Calvin says 431 or as a sort of delegated work. Christ who's working but is using people as a workman would use a tool is using us in a sort of delegated work. His commentary on Malachi 4.6, Calvin says God connects himself with his servants but he never resigns to them his own office. So we're connected. The ministry of the church is connected to God but we don't take over his office as the chief pastor of the church remains unviolated. Why does God do this? Calvin gives three reasons, that is why he uses human instruments. Why do we have pastors for people like us? Why does God do it that way? First his regard for us. It's all 431. It shows the significance of human beings that God takes some to serve as his ambassadors in the world to be interpreters of his secret will and to represent his person. The fact that God will reach down and call some, those of you in this class, some others, many others to be his servants, that shows his regard for the significance of human beings that he would choose to use such as we as his servants and ministers in this world. Secondly, it's an exercise in humility that helps all of us to be humble. We receive God's word from human beings just like us. In fact, Calvin says he may excel us in nothing, not be as smart as we are or as well placed in society as we are or a lot of other things we could say. But he's the preacher, he's the one that God has chosen to set forth his word and that fosters humility. We listen, expecting to hear and to learn God's word from a person that, humanly speaking, is below us in a lot of ways. And thirdly, it fosters mutual love. At that second point, you have to kind of apply that in your own thinking. There are some outstanding preachers that we would say, well, we can never reach that level of intelligence or ability to speak or anything else. But sometimes we hear people that are just other simple ordinary people and we might think, be tempted to think, well, who is that that he can be preaching and not listening and learning? I think there are occasions for us to experience humility there. And it fosters mutual love. The human ministry is the chief sinew by which believers are held together in one body because God has gained to work through human beings, not through angelic beings. And we're all alike in the church. We're all human beings. And the pastor to the youngest, smallest baby baptized in the church, there is that community. And it's the human ministry which is the chief sinew by which believers are held together in one body. We are dependent upon each other for the words, the very words that promise eternal life. And we can hardly be more closely bound up with one another than we are in the church. Now, those are Calvin's general comments about church offices. We'll have to look at the specific offices next time, Apostles, Evangelist, Prophets, which he says are temporary or extraordinary and then pastors, teachers, elders, and deacons which are permanent and ordinary. We'll also have a word about bishops and a connet on the role of women in the ministry of the church. Okay, that'll be all for today.