<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tuku Tuku Masina

Saving Work of Christ, V

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We continue our study of Christ saving work. I'll just mention some of these features on page 122. Christ saved in His offices of Prophet Priest and King. All three of those are given in Hebrews 1. His saving work involves the states of humiliation and exaltation as we said under the person of Christ. Let me jump down to number 10 and instead of just saying His death is particular, let me present both sides of the matter in this excursus on the extent of the atonement. Millward Ericsson in his Christian theology, see in the bottom there, pages 825 to 835, very fairly sets forth arguments for both unlimited and limited atonement. He even uses fair terminology. Particular atonement is better than limited atonement. Particular or definite, definite. Limited sounds like something lacking in the work of Christ. Ericsson in Christian theology, Millward Ericsson is a Baptist theologian, calls himself a moderate Calvinist, that's a very fair description. He's a model of fairness and I, on controversial issues, I like to use him just for that reason. In these pages, he sets forth arguments for particular atonement there in your notes there at the bottom of 122 and then arguments for universal atonement and he concludes correctly that most of the arguments aren't very good. It's remarkable. He says those who argue for the Calvinist position of particular or definite or limited atonement turn to those passages where it says Christ died for His sheep, John 10, for His church Ephesians 5 and they thereby assume He didn't die for the goats or for those who aren't part of the church. I'm going to set forth the arguments and then come back and critique some of them. Other times this particular atonement, this limitation of the intention and efficacy of the cross is deduced from other doctrines. In John 17, Jesus says, I don't pray for the world but only for my people. Therefore, since his prayer is part of his priestly work, then his priestly work on the cross must be particular as well. It is inferred from the very nature of the atonement, Ericsson says. He is right. These are the ways Calvinists have argued. The atonement itself, by its very nature, involves a full payment for sin. This type of argument is used. Therefore, it must be efficacious and thereby particular or limited otherwise. Everybody would be saved and that's not true. It has historically been linked with election. Ericsson goes so far as to say, it's always or usually has been the case. If somebody teaches a Augustinian view of election, that election is based not upon foreseen human response, but upon God's own unconditional grace, then that has often been linked with a limited atonement view. Actually, he made a mistake on that argument, but let me go through these. Ericsson shows correctly that it is not enough to prove Calvinism to show these passages where it says Jesus died for his church, for his sheep and the like. You have to show that he didn't die for the others because Ericsson says doesn't it make sense in a context in which Jesus is talking about his church or his sheep, that he would say Jesus died for them? He's exactly right. It doesn't prove that he only died for them. You'd need some exclusion within the passage to make it a good argument. The mere fact that he says he died for his people, you will call his name Jesus, the angel told Joseph because he will save his people from their sins. It proves particular atonement, not necessarily so. Ericsson is correct, it doesn't necessarily prove it. It is deduced from other doctrines. This is kind of a second order proof I said earlier tonight. It's not wrong to do deduction, but we need to distinguish biblical data and basing things upon that and then making deductions from other biblical data. So this is not illegitimate and it could be used as supporting evidence, you with me, but it's not sufficient in itself. If I only had argument based upon deduction, I wouldn't hold that belief as firmly as I would where I had primary biblical evidence. Understand? And in fact, I would say, are we even, I'd even ask the question, are we supposed to make this deduction? Or is theology going beyond the Bible and asking questions of it at the Bible doesn't even answer? It is inferred from the nature of the atonement. Well, a much stronger argument would be where the Bible itself presents the atonement as effective and therefore limited or particular. That would be more powerful than this inference. This is another example of two. It's a deduction. Can you show biblically that the nature of the atonement demands effectiveness than you're showing something. But if you're merely arguing theoretically, it may impress those who already believe it, but it may not persuade those who for other reasons of inference and deduction have reached the other conclusion. It has been linked historically with election. No, Ericsson is a wonderful Christian man and especially adept at modern philosophy and theology areas that I am not strong in and which I rely on which and on which I rely upon him. I rely upon him for those areas. You're with me. My PhD is in historical theology. I think perhaps he isn't. He uses secondary sources somewhere somewhere he got misled. It is not true that these things have always been linked. So it's not a good argument for Calvinism in any case. If I'm right, even Calvin, who taught unconditional election, that's for sure didn't teach particular atonement. That is it was a later development. His successor visa taught it but not Calvin himself. It seems to be an issue he didn't even address. I'm not saying he denied it. He just didn't seem to even think about it. At least I can't find it in the institutes of the Christian religion. Well, Ericsson cancels out most of those arguments and I would say or he says they're some are bad and some are weak. I have to agree. But he is a very fair man who presents arguments for his own position and criticizes them soundly too. Arguments for universal atonement or unlimited atonement. The world and all passages Christ died for all Christ died for the world. A very common argument that is used. I'll summarize them now John 3.16 for example, for God's love the world. And I'll come back and criticize them in a moment as well. A couple places the Bible says some for whom Christ died will perish. Ericsson points to passages in Romans and first Corinthians, Romans 14, 15 and first Corinthians 8, 11 are passages that teach, that warn about somebody not stumbling a brother because you'll destroy the one for whom Christ died. Language similar to that. The gospel is to be universally proclaimed. How can we proclaim the gospel to everyone if Christ only died for all? This is an argument from deduction. And it has greater or lesser weight depending upon a number of factors. A limited atonement. Conor Dix, God's love for the world. This is closely related to three. It's sort of another deduction. Although one could point to passages that say God loves the world and say that's incompatible with particular or limited atonement. Ericsson critiques these as well. Even as the passages that say Christ died for us, people have to be evaluated in context. So do the world and all passages and Ericsson admits in most of them. The context is the world not only the Jews but Gentiles as well. That type of a thing. In general, these are not talking about each and every last individual. He admits that he does end up with a few passages that incline him in this direction and I'll get those on the table quickly. Some for whom Christ died will perish. The Romans and 1 Corinthians passages that I looked at that I mentioned to you. He admits are not very persuasive. They could be for example the being destroyed or whatever could mean physical death, which is spoken of in scripture as a judgment in 1 Corinthians 11 for example and not necessarily perishing eternally. So these are not enough to base. They might count as some evidence but they're not enough to base a view of they don't prove universal atonement. Likewise, the gospel is to be universally proclaimed. Well, George Whitfield believed that and limited atonement contradicts God's love for the world. Some of the greatest evangelists in history didn't think so. So these two have some weight even as the last couple of the second and third particular arguments had some weight to by it means by virtue of deduction. But in themselves, they wouldn't really sway the jury in Ericsson's estimation. I'm summarizing you ought to read his stuff. If you're really interested in this in the end, Ericsson appeals to four passages. One is first Timothy for ten. These passages appear to him conclusively to teach that Christ died to save every human being. So I want to be real fair to him. He has very well summarized the arguments on both sides. For example, I can't accuse him of holding back or ignoring the best Calvinist arguments. No, he hasn't done it. He's saying, am I admitting that there hasn't been good argumentation on either side? Yeah, that's exactly what I'm admitting. I think it is the case. First Timothy for ten, he says, is a verse that just cannot be ignored. I think he could have said that better, but I agree with him. It shouldn't be ignored. We put our hope in the living God who is the savior of all men, and especially of those who believe. He says, look at that. There's two different realms of salvation. There is a sense that Jesus is the savior of all men, bigger circle, and there's a sense, a subset of that that he's the savior of those who believe. Ericsson says this is conclusive. Well, again, I have great respect for him, but I disagree with him. He misunderstands. In the pastoral letters, the word savior does not always refer to Jesus. If my study is right, when it does refer to Jesus, it uses his name, and just an undifferentiated state reference to savior refers to God, the Father, not the Son. Let's just take a couple of little examples. You can trace the rest of them out yourself. In first Timothy, one, one, Paul and apostle of Christ Jesus by the command of God, our savior. Is that mean Jesus? It does not finish the verse. End of Christ Jesus, our hope. Understand? God, our savior means the Father. If you work through these references consistently, when the word savior, now granted, usually in the Bible, when it says savior, it means Jesus. I'm saying we need to be very sensitive to the way the pastoral's work. They used the word savior to refer to Jesus sometimes, and to refer to the Father sometimes. And we can determine which is which, because of the way they do it when they refer to Jesus. That was about as clear as mud. What I'm trying to say is, when Paul in the pastoral, first and second Timothy in Titus refers to Jesus, he uses his name, for example, second Timothy 110, the appearing of our savior Christ Jesus. He does it because the bare word savior refers to the Father and not to the Son. So here's what I'm saying. First Timothy, 410 is a problem for Calvinism, but it doesn't even pertain to the atonement. It is not talking about the Son of God. Calvinism in the larger Calvinist or minion debates would have to account for some sense in which God, the Father is the savior of all men, and in a distinct sense, a subset of that in which he's savior of the world. But it doesn't even talk about the Son of God and his atonement. So it's irrelevant to the matter of particular atonement. Understand? Understand what I'm saying? It doesn't speak of Jesus, so it doesn't speak of the cross. It is a problem for Calvinism in a greater way, in a larger concern, but is not even relevant. For Millward Ericsson or anybody else to prove unlimited atonement, they've got to have an atonement passage. It's got to speak of Jesus cross. Yes, I would. I would say God, in this case the Father, is the savior of all men in that in the book of Acts. He commands people everywhere to repent. I would say it this way. He's the only savior of humanity, and he actually saves those who believe in him. So I think I could handle it, but I'm not even interested in doing it right now. I want to stay on the problem. I'm on the defensive now. I'm not giving you my arguments for particular atonement. I hope I have time to do it tonight. I'm giving you Ericsson's best shot, and I'm trying to answer him. My response to his first passage of the four, he basis his doctrine on in the end is that it's irrelevant to this matter. It is a good passage, as a matter of fact, since Ericsson is a four point Calvinist, this is as much a problem for him as it is for me, a five point Calvinist, because it's a problem for the rest of his system. But it's not a problem for this part of my system, and it doesn't count for points for this part of his system because it doesn't speak of the Son of God and his cross. First John 2.2 is better because it does speak of the cross. First John 2.2, if anybody does sin, speaking of believers, verse 1, we have one who speaks to the Father in our defense, Jesus Christ, the righteous one. He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins and not for ours only. He is the propitiation, as a matter of fact, is the word for our sins, not for ours only, but also for the sins of the whole world. Surely this is a reference to Jesus. Yes, I admit it. Surely it's a reference to Jesus atonement. Yes, it's propitiation, no question. Surely it says he died for the sins of the whole world. I admit it. Well, then case is closed, right? It's unlimited atonement. Not so fast. We don't want to make an assumption here. I can view the whole world in two different ways. I can speak of the whole world in a distributive sense. You know what I'm going to say? We love these terms. They keep us employed in the theological profession, or you can also view the whole world in a collective sense. That used it as a turn on my pupil's gray matter, as much as when I say, we could view the world as all people without exception. In other words, each and every last individual in the world, understand distributive, counting them one at a time. Each and every last, we could view it however collectively to mean all, it's another use of all, but all without distinction. Not only red people, but white people, and black people, and yellow people, and brown people, and any other kind of people you have, and not only people that speak Chinese, but people that speak Spanish and French with me. Now, it is curious to me that there's one other use in first John of almost the exact same expression. The word order is slightly different as first John to two. I am going to understand it. I admit this is a better argument than his first one, and his argument has some weight, but I do think I can answer it. You may not agree with me, but I would take it as a reference to all without distinction. Not necessarily to all without exception, although it's possible. I'll compare it to first John 519, which certainly does not mean all without exception. We know that we are the children of God, and that the whole world is under the control of the evil one. That doesn't mean every last individual. There the whole world is sort of like Jesus Prayer in John 17. I don't pray for the world. I pray for the people you've given me. It almost means the unbelievers, or something like that. It certainly doesn't mean each and every last individual. It means collectively those who are against Christ and outside of Christ. So granted the sample is too small. These are the only two places I can find in first John anyway. I think in John's writings where this exact expression is used, and I also don't want to fool anybody. The word order is slightly different, but that's just John's style anyway. He almost always varies his word order. I admit Ericsson's argument has some weight. I wouldn't regard it as proving his case, however. Another one is Isaiah 53. He thinks this really is the cat's meow, as my mother used to say. My mother's still alive, by the way, I didn't sound like it. I know what I just said. Ericsson says, look, the people who are sinning and those for whom a tomen is made are coextensive. We all like sheep have gone astray. That means everybody. That means each and every last individual. We all like sheep have gone astray. Each of us has turned to his own way. That leaves no exceptions. And the Lord has laid on him, Jesus, the iniquity of us all. The remedy is coextensive with the need. He argues. I think he's being insensitive to the historical context of Isaiah 53. All is not all human beings, but all Israelites. Yes, there is a universalizing reference within the context. 52, 15, for example, he will sprinkle many nations. But in his context, 53, 6 is followed by, for example, my people, verse 8. He was cut off from the land of the living, for the transgression of my people, he was stricken. So I don't think it is a proof for universal atonement. It is a proof for Israelite atonement that the Messiah died for his people. There is a hint within the context, 52, 15, which is part of 53, if you will, it's a unit that he dies for the Gentiles too. That's brought to fuller light in the New Testament. But I don't.