<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Dhuroni Dhuroni mujore

The Knowledge of God, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Good morning everybody, snowy morning and we are now at lesson three in our study of Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion. Lesson three knowledge of God, scripture. Before I come to the prayer that you just summarized briefly the first five chapters that we have looked at so far, those chapters and those chapters, Calvin tells us that God has not left himself without a witness. There's a two-fold witness that he is placed within every person. Stayar, it's instinctive, it's inarritable, that witness, that two-fold witness within every person bears witness to the fact that God exists, the census of any tantas, there is a God, a God of majesty who exists, and the second part of that two-fold witness within us is that we know that this God is a God of holiness and righteousness. The seed of religion is there, which expresses itself in natural law or in conscience and not only is God placed that two-fold witness within every person, but God has also placed before every person a two-fold witness. We see the greatness of God in the creation, whether we look up to the stars or down deep within ourselves, we see the marvels and wonders of what God has done in creation, and then as we survey the flow of history or the work of God's providence, that too is a dazzling theater. Calvin says in which we can see both the mercy and the judgment of God. That witness is there, it remains that it is ineffective, not because it lacks in power or in significance, but because of the blindness of our own hearts, because Adam's sin, and because we also are sinners, we constantly negate and confuse and reject the very clear witness that God has placed in us and before us in the world. That witness remains, but it serves now not to lead us to a true knowledge of God. It leads us to confusion and to superstition and to all kinds of errors, but it remains to hold us inexcusable. The witness is there, but it does not bear good fruit because of our sin. Therefore, Calvin says there is no pure and approved religion founded upon common understanding alone. That is through the natural revelation of God in creation. There is no true religion, and Calvin says, all excuse is cut off because the fault of dullness is within us. It was pretty bleak picture at the end of chapter 5 of book 1, but Calvin goes quickly to what he calls a special gift, and that is scripture. He's going to show us how through scripture we are able to recover the knowledge of God in creation that we would have seen through creation itself if Adam did not sin. Okay, that's a kind of quick review of the five books. We come to scripture and we come to a prayer from Calvin, related to scripture that we will use this morning as we study this topic. Let's pray. All mighty guide, thou showest thy glory for us to see not only in heaven and earth, but also in the law, the prophets and the gospel, and has so intimately revealed myself and I know the begotten Son that we cannot excuse ourselves out of ignorance. Grant that we may advance in this teaching, wherewith thou so kindly invite us to thyself, and may thus steadfastly cleave to thee that no errors of the world may lead us astray, but may stand firmly fixed in thy word, which cannot deceive us at last reaching heavenly blessedness, that we may enjoy thy glory, face to face, conform completely to thee in Christ Jesus our Lord. Amen. Calvin will now introduce the doctrine of scripture when and where it begins to function in his theology. You might say, well, Calvin has been quoting scripture all along, and that's true, but he's been using it incidentally and illustratively, I would say, because prior to this point, the knowledge of God that he's talking about is not the knowledge of God through scripture, but the knowledge of God that would have been available to us in the creation if Adam had not sinned, but that ways flows now. It's there to hold us inexcusable, but it does not give to any person a true understanding of who God is, and so scripture now is introduced in chapter 6 as a better means, Calvin calls it, another in better help, special gift, a more direct and certain mark. Those are all Calvin's words to describe the gift of scripture to us, to enable us to see what we cannot see because of our sin, but would have been able to see in nature if we had not sinned, but to see more than that. scripture does not enable us just to see what would have been available to us in the general revelation, but tells us that and tells us more. Calvin gives a very helpful and often referred to illustration here, and that is he compares scripture to spectacles, and let's use a little chart here. Here we have knowledge of God, the creator, here is us, and we can't gain access to this now because of our sin, so that knowledge is completely lost to us, but God in his mercy through the Holy Spirit gives to us the spectacles, Calvin's illustration, the spectacles, these are spectacles, eyeglasses, like some of us are wearing, Holy Spirit gives us such the Bible, the spectacles, and through those spectacles we are able to gain knowledge of God, the creator, this outer circle I used to represent the knowledge that would have been available to us in the natural revelation of God in creation, if Adam did not sin, but we gain not only that knowledge, but we gain even more knowledge of God the creator. For instance, that God is triune. The natural revelation would never have enabled us, even if Adam did not sin, to know that God was trinity, but the scripture teaches us that God is trinity and it teaches as many other things as well, so after renouncing the general revelation in nature, from the point of view of the unregenerate person, Calvin points the believer to it again as directed by scripture, so all those things that we talked about in the first five books, we know as believers, but we don't know all of that through our natural understanding, but because God has revealed it to us in His word, and that special revelation repeats first and then supplements the knowledge of God that would have been available to us in the general revelation, if Adam did not sin. Now, having come to scripture, we need to talk something about Calvin's doctrine of scripture. The scripture is introduced here. This is the primary place in the institutes where Calvin will discuss scripture, although in book three, chapter two, and in book four, chapter eight, you'll come to this topic again as you'll see in the outlined notes there. The Calvin doesn't develop a long treatise at this point on the authority of scripture or the inspiration of scripture or the nature of scripture. He does do something with those topics as you know from your reading for today, and we'll stop at this point and consider those points before we move further. Looking not only at what Calvin does here in book one, but at his general teaching throughout the institutes and elsewhere. These are the points I would like to make in connection with Calvin's doctrine of scripture. The Bible is the inspired word of God. The Bible is the word of God revealed in human language, and the Bible is confirmed to the believer by the inner witness of Holy Spirit. Those are the three important points. The third is very central to the section we read for today. The other two are there, but are fleshed out in other places in the institutes. First of all, the Bible is the inspired word of God. There are two persistent expressions that Calvin uses throughout his writings when he talks about the Bible. One is the mouth of God. Over and over again, Calvin will say something like scripture has flowed to us from the very mouth of God. That was in our section for today, 175. scripture has flowed to us from the very mouth of God. And you could search through the institutes and read his commentaries and you would find expression like that over and over again. The divine origin of the Bible. That's the first point here. I give a few places where you can find Calvin saying just what I said. The Bible comes from God. It's the words of God, the very words of God. The Bible is the speech of God. The Bible is God's speaking to us. Institutes 175, commentary on second Timothy 316 and many, many places. The second point I want to make concerning Calvin and his view of the Bible as the inspired word of God is that that word comes from God from the very mouth of God, but it is accommodated to us. That's an important word for Calvin. A convocation. The word of God is accommodated to us. In 113, 1, we see Calvin saying this as nurses commonly do with infants. God is want in a measure to list LISP in speaking to us. So he describes the Bible that way as a nurse or a mother or a father will, I think the way we could translate this best and understand it best is to say a nurse or a mother or a father will talk baby talk to an infant so that the child can understand. You all do that with your children. You have little children. You talk differently to those children then you talk to your classmates here. Talk baby talk. That's accommodation and that's what Calvin says the Bible is. It not only the Bible, the message of the Bible not only comes in the very mouth of God, but it comes from the mouth of God who is father and who in his love to us so that we can understand what he has to say, stoops to talk baby talk to us. Now people have used that in various ways. Some people have insisted that this means that Calvin is denying what we would call plenary verbal inspiration or in erency. After all if God is talking baby talk then can we assume that the text of the Bible is in eren. John T. McNeil the editor of our version of the institutes here not the translator but the editor in the person responsible for most of the footnotes makes that point in the introduction and in some of the footnotes that Calvin does not hold to an errant text. I'll say a little bit more about that in a minute but I want to get back to the baby talk idea. It seems to me and I've noted the other day and reading John Gerstner on Calvin that he makes exactly the same point that when God accommodates himself to us by using our language by talking baby talk by putting in the Bible things like stories and illustrations and parables and poems and things like that that's baby talk that that does not necessarily imply an errant text it is baby talk but it is God's baby talk and God's baby talk doesn't deceive it helps us to understand so I don't really see the linkage between a combination and errantcy seems to me that baby talk can be errant or in errant depending on the person who is doing the baby talking and when God lists or when God speaks baby talk to us God is perfectly capable of knowing how to do that in a way that puts forth truth pure truth and doesn't lead us astray and doesn't deceive us so it's a wonderful image I think of the Bible and Calvin will often often use it because you know we'll read in the Bible things about God having God walking God having hands arms and so on and that's a combination Calvin says we don't think that God actually walks on two feet but that helps us to understand that's God's coming down to our level and communicating to us in a way that we can understand and God does that because he is concerned about us he loves us somewhere I think it's in his commentary on Romans Calvin takes this idea of accommodation another step and he says if we love the people to whom we minister we will do the same thing we will accommodate our understanding to the level that they can appreciate it and receive it you see it's totally possible for a seminary student to go out and preach or teach in a way that nobody will have the slightest idea of what you're talking about unless you take the knowledge that you gain here and through the hard work of accommodation make that accessible to the level of the of the people to whom you minister doesn't mean they're not smart people but we learn our own vocabulary and we have our own way of saying things and our own terminology and unless we are able to express that in a way that others can grasp we'll fail in our communication so God accommodates and we should accommodate also Bible is the inspired word of guide comes from the mouth of God it is accommodated to our capacity and let me just make another point here our second point the Bible is the word of God revealed in human language Calvin is certainly aware of the fact that the Bible comes from the very mouth of God it is the words of God but Calvin knows too that it comes through human beings to reveal the human language Calvin himself is very very much aware of this as a student of humanism language he senses the different styles between the different biblical writers much more than I do he can speak about the style of Isaiah and the style of another Old Testament writer and compare those some better than others that doesn't affect his view of the Bible but one writer is a more eloquent writer than another another might be rather crude and direct and rough in his expression still the word of God that's what God wanted for that book and another Isaiah particularly is a writer of high eloquence and beauty so there are diverse styles in the Bible among Bible writers Calvin also deals not so much in the institutes but in his commentaries with problems and apparent discrepancies in the Bible so he's aware of the human element not only in diverse styles but in different ways in which the Bible and Bible writers seem to contradict themselves or not be precisely accurate and Calvin is always aware of these problems and he will spend considerable time in the commentaries dealing with him there's been a lot of discussion about this some people think that Calvin's treatment of discrepancies shows a kind of looseness in regard to his view of the inerrancy of the Bible in other words even though he says the Bible is from God it's the very words of God when he gets down to working with the text he finds problems and mistakes and has a kind of free use of these passages in which he denies what he has said about the inerrancy of the scripture or what he has implied about that in using the expression like the very word of God or Calvin can also use an expression like this the scriptures were dictated by God to these various Bible writers and that creates a little concern not only for people that would deny inerrancy but for people that would affirm it because it's seems to us to go too far but I think when Calvin uses the language of dictation this is Warfield's point he is not creating a theory of inspiration but he is stating that the product of the writing is as though it were dictated by God it's not that God is dictating every word and the human writer has no freedom to express himself in his own language or his own style but God is so superintending the process of inspiration that the product that is produced on the written page is as though God dictated those words this is how Warfield puts it it is not unfair to urge that this language of dictation is figurative and that what Calvin has in mind is not to insist that the mode of inspiration was dictation but that the result is as if it were by dictation that is the production of a pure word of God free from all human admixtures okay back to the problems that apparent discrepancies in the Bible I think a fair study of all of those have given a list of some of the more famous ones that Calvin deals with you can look those up in the commentaries if you are interested in following that through but it seems to me that in every case Calvin does attempt to harmonize to solve the problem and if he fails to do so he simply says I don't know what to do with this maybe somebody else does but he doesn't then draw the conclusion that one text or the other is an era he simply confesses the limits of his own understanding of how to deal with that particular problem and then quite often Calvin too will say well this comes this era this problem comes because of eras in the copies so I don't see Calvin ever admitting an era in the autographs

in the original writing of scripture he'll either say the era comes in the process of copying or he'll try to harmonize or he'll say I don't know what to do with it but that's a confession not of an errant tax but of a limited interpreter okay let me go through this next point with you because so much discussion has come down on this did Calvin view the Bible as an errant Calvin doesn't use the word in errant in fact that word is not commonly used for scripture until 19th century although one writer I think has successfully shown that some of the Westminster Divines used the word in errant for scripture so the word is in English older than the 19th century it goes back at least to the 17th century but the concept we believe goes back much further indeed back to the scripture itself but some Calvin scholars have adamantly rejected this point Findel is one of the writers that I referred to earlier in the syllabus in the first lecture for further study you can get his title there says in that book Calvin himself never affirmed literal inspiration on del uses the word literal here in the sense of in errant or plenary verbal literal inspiration and then on page 160 of his book on del says the authors of the books of the Bible wrote under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit they were nonetheless liable to introduce human eras into it upon points of detail which do not affect the doctrine talking about Calvin there Calvin thinks that the Holy Spirit inspired the writers but permitted these small eras of detail to come in that's Findel's view John T. McNeil the editor of our version of the institute's insists that Calvin was not concerned to assert verbal in errantcy you can see that it is introduction and notes his notes to section 488 of the institutes and in his other writings as well so McNeil agrees with Findel and then the most extensive argument along this line that Calvin was not an in errantist comes from Rogers and McKim in the book the authority and interpretation of the Bible have quite a long section pages 89 through 116 in which they are do that Calvin did not believe in and in errant text we have one writer to that list put a number four there Alistair McGrath English writer that early very highly respected by us Evan Jellicle Scholar teaches at Oxford and writes a book about every day or two

but so much I appreciate about McGrath but I'm afraid he's on the wrong side of this issue and this is his book Christian theology pages 180 through 181

the graph Alistair McGrath Christian theology pages 180 through 181 and this is what he said the reformers did not see the issue of inspiration as linked with the absolute historical reliability or factual in errantcy of the biblical truths Calvin's doctrine of accommodation implied that God revealed himself in forms tailored to the abilities of the communities which were to receive this revelation thus in the case of Genesis 1 Calvin suggests that a whole series of ideas such as the days of creation are simply accommodated ways of speaking a kind of divine baby talk the development of biblical infallibility or in errantcy within Protestantism can be traced to the United States in the middle of the 19th century he's talking about the Princeton theology there and Rodgers and Vittim argue that too that the idea of in errantcy is a Princeton invention been plenty of scholars who have countered that John Woodbridge a Trinity primarily and others that show that Princeton did not invent the doctrine of in errantcy it was not created by A.A. Hodge and P.V. Warfield in their book on inspiration but reaches back through church history so some scholars say no Calvin did not hold to an errantcy but there are others that say yes Calvin did hold to an errantcy V.V. Warfield in his Calvin's doctrine of the knowledge of God he says on page 162 of that section of his collected works scripture as given by God is free quote from all era it's Warfield John Murray wrote a little book called Calvin's doctrine of scripture

in which he says that Calvin's characteristic dictum is that scripture speaks with a veracity and authority equal to that of God speaking to us directly from heaven very words of God can it concern editor for some time of Christianity today and long time professor at Trinity seminary wrote in Calvin and holy scripture Calvin held to a rigidly orthodox verbal type of inspiration and Ed Dauy in a book that I referred to earlier in section lesson one of the syllabus the knowledge of God in the theology of Calvin says Calvin conceived the scriptures as literally dictated by God Dauy was one of my teachers at Princeton and Dauy did not like the doctrine of in errantcy very much opposed it felt it was destructive and harmful and a teaching of fundamentalism which he despite very much Dauy did like Calvin but Dauy's admission seems to me as all the more important because here you have a person opposed to the doctrine of inerrantcy who would very much like to have Calvin on his side but he admits that Calvin conceived the scriptures as literally dictated by God he does deal with that problem of dictation then and decides that Warfield has the best solution to that problem the quotation that I read to you from Warfield a few minutes ago Dauy says if Calvin betrays his position at all it is apparently assuming a priori that no errors can be allowed to reflect upon the inerrancy of the original documents now unfortunately in his second edition of his knowledge of God in the theology of Calvin Dauy retracts a bit his rather strong statements that appear in the first edition concerning Calvin's view of inerrantcy largely due to the influence of John T. McNeil Dauy worked with McNeil in producing the footnotes for the addition of the institutes that we're using okay any questions yes

Calvin did not hold a view of inerrancy what are their individual views on inerrancy are they all opposed to it or are they yes they would all all be opposed to it the graph certainly holds a very high view of scripture but would not use the word inerrancy thinks the word is unnecessary and confusing and problematic I did see an interview not longer ago with John Stott in which the question was asked what are the five books that it most influenced you in your life and the first book that he named was a revelation and inspiration by BB Warfield which pleased me very much that John Stott would take Warfield as being he says the best writer on the doctrine of scripture but that puts John Stott a bit out of step with general British evangelical thought which like FF Bruce and others which while holding to a high view of the inspiration of scripture would shy away from the the idea of inerrancy yes what Calvin does there see if I have a note on that that is in McNeil's introduction with a list of problems Calvin is frank to recognize that some passages do not admit of the claim of inerrancy on the verbal level yeah here it is his first Corinthians 2 9 Paul quotes Isaiah 64 4 no I has seen no ear has heard no mine has conceived what God has prepared for those who love him and this is what Calvin says about that two very great difficulties present themselves the first is that the words that are here quoted by Paul do not correspond with the words of the prophet if you look at Isaiah 64 4 it's not what it says so his Paul misquoting the second is that it seems as though Paul had perverted the prophet's declaration to a purpose quite far into his design second problem is Paul not only misquotes Isaiah but misuses Isaiah well pretty serious problem it would see what is Calvin's solution to this here it is where shall we find a sureer and more faithful interpreter than the spirit of God of this authoritative declaration which he himself dictated to Isaiah in the exposition which he furnished by the mouth of Paul and it's kind of a brilliant answer I think Calvin says the Holy Spirit inspired Isaiah and the Holy Spirit the same Holy Spirit inspired Paul and the Holy Spirit can comment on his own writings and Paul's comment then inspired by the Holy Spirit is an authoritative statement based on what appears to us a misquotation and a misuse of the statement as it appears in Isaiah 64 4 don't in a sense Calvin doesn't really solve the problem you know still looks like a misquotation on a misapplication but Calvin says the Holy Spirit you inspired Isaiah inspired Paul and we accept both as inspired scripture even though to our minds into our limited understandings there may still seem to be a problem the words of scripture cannot contradict one another because the Holy Spirit who dictated both of the passages cannot contradict himself

is that a solution or isn't it a solution well it's an assertion and you might say it's not a real solution but Calvin's confidence in the infallibility of the Bible overcomes his concerns about what appears to him to be an inconsistency okay thing out so far well early partway through what Calvin says about scripture here we have an inspired scripture holy spirit has given us this scripture which is inspired I would argue this I think Calvin does even in errant it's a perfect revelation but it's still not enough because well we believe that to be the word of God it's authority is there because it is the word of God but how does it become authoritative to us how do we come to know that it's the word of God how do we come to believe that it's the word of God you see we really have you might say two problems now because of sin we can't know God the creator we're back in this condition but God gives us the spectacles of scripture so that through the spectacles we can see what we cannot see that's his illustration you know I wear these spectacles and when I take them off I can see something I mean I know there are people out there but I don't recognize any of you and not sure how many are here and I have no idea what that thing is on the back wall back there because I don't see at distance very well at all I can read all day without my classes but even to see Julian here I've got to put him on so without the spectacles of scripture I look out at creation and I don't see anything I mean I see something but it's confused and it's it doesn't help me to know what's there but when I put these on and everything focuses and I see what's there so God has given us the scriptures so we can see we can see that the heavens declare the glory of God and the firmament showeth his hand you work I should have been able to see that without the Bible but because of my sin I cannot see that could be as Robert Frost said in one of his poems they haven't scared me they don't declare the glory of God but the vast expanse and emptiness of space frightens me well in a sense that's that witness still active in a non-regenerate heart holding him inexcusable because he does see that much but doesn't see more but you see the problem is not only do we need an objective cure which is the Bible but we need to know that the Bible is the word of God 171 hence the scriptures obtain full authority among believers only when men regard them as having sprung from heaven as if they are the living words of God were heard these are the words of God but they're going to have no force no impact in my life until I accept that until I believe that until I know that so the objective cure is the Bible but the authority of the Bible is a question now and Calvin says how do we know he will reject two ways and suggest a third way he would jacks the authority of the church there were people that would say certainly in Calvin's time well the Bible's the word of God because the church says it's the word of God and Calvin disputes that it's not the church that makes the Bible the word of God the church bears witness to the fact that it is the word of God but it's not the action of the church or the declaration of the church that gives the Bible its authority and he also rejects the idea that we can use rational proofs and we'll talk about how those rational proofs actually function in a few minutes but things like Old Testament prophecies are fulfilled in the New Testament we have all these diverse writers telling one message setting forth one message we have the majesty of the style of the Bible even though there are diverse styles but even the cruder styles of someone like Amos serves the purpose in setting forth the majestic word of God

and other arguments for the authority of the Bible Calvin says those play a part but they don't come first they have a role but they're not primary it's not the authority of the church it's not from the proofs so-called those persons act foolishly who wish to prove to infidels that scripture is the word of God we're not going to be able to get our evidence as in our arguments for the authority of scripture and take those out and read them off to somebody and prove thereby that the scripture is the word of God so the objective cure is there but there needs to be a subjective cure as well because with the even with the spectacles we can't see unless God enables us through his Holy Spirit to see now Calvin's illustration gets a little problematic here and he changes it two or three times here the illustration is more of a person who's blind not just a blurry eye at old man as he first describes him who can't see unless he has spectacles but spiritually I am blind and as a blind spiritually blind person I pick up the Bible I don't see anything you know see a book maybe I see a book to admire and to consider great literature or I might see a book that I think is full of arrows and nonsense but I don't see the word of God until the Holy Spirit works within my mind and heart the same Holy Spirit who gave the scripture and gave the spectacles works a miracle within the in terms of the illustration my blind eyes now can see in terms of the theology of what Calvin is talking about my regenerate heart now accepts the Bible as God's inspired authoritative word that's the subjective cure and here are the famous passages one seven two scripture exhibits fully as clear evidence of its own truth as white and black things do of their color or sweet and bitter things do of their taste how do we know that the Bible is the word of God we know the Bible is the word of God because it impresses us as the word just as when we taste something sweet we know it sweet taste something bitter we know it's bitter we read the Bible and we know it's the word of God one seven four the same spirit who has spoken through the mouths of the prophets must penetrate into our hearts to persuade us that they faithfully proclaim what had been divinely commanded here's the Holy Spirit speaking through the mouths of the prophets right here here's the Holy Spirit penetrating into our hearts same Holy Spirit we spoke through the mouths of the prophets penetrates into our hearts to persuade us that these books faithfully proclaim what had been divinely commanded and one seven five scripture is here's the important term self authenticated scripture is self authenticated it is sealed upon our hearts through the spirit it's one seven five the French translation of that passage done by Calvin self says that the scripture carries within itself its own credentials same idea self authenticated but a little more lively expression scripture carries within itself its own credentials so how do we know the Bible is the word of God well we know the Bible is the word of God because we know the Bible is the word of God it comes with its own credentials it authenticates itself and the spirit who gave it through the testimony of the spirit very witness to the truth of the Bible in our hearts it enables us to see and receive the Bible as the authoritative word of God to me that's although Calvin doesn't say it here that's regeneration that is part of regeneration so when God regenerates us gives us a new heart and a new spirit that enables us to embrace the Bible as the word of God now what about the proofs he goes on in chapter 8 to deal with what he calls sufficiently firm proofs which confirm in the Christian the testimony of the Holy Spirit now it's an important sentence the the proofs the what or feel calls the indicia the arguments for the authority of the Bible are sufficiently firm Calvin says there might be some debate among us as to how strong they really are that they make a point Calvin thinks they make a strong point but those arguments don't come first they follow they confirm in the Christian so they're not ways in which we can convince the unregenerate person of the authority of the Bible but they are ways that confirm us they interest us they encourage us to see that our faith is well placed Calvin calls them secondary age to our weakness nor if our faith was never fluctuating we wouldn't need secondary age but we're feeble people it's Christians and sometimes our faith so we'll see later in Calvin can become in battle and grows very weak and these secondary age then come to support us I won't go through the indicia but I've summarized them here and you've read through this the proofs from the Old Testament great antiquity of the Bible the miracles that took place fulfill prophecy the fact that the Bible has been preserved through all of these years in so many books of antiquity have been lost and then proves from the New Testament the heavenly character of the teaching the simplicity of its message the authority by which it sets forth that message and proves from church history testimony of the church to the scriptures and the testimony of the martyrs people that gave their lives in defense of and holding firmly to the word of the Bible as the word of God now let's come back to the matter of the function of these proofs and there are two ways to look at them I think only one way is fully accurate as reflecting Calvin's teaching that look at the two ways we've got Holy Spirit who brings conviction directly this is the word of God and we've got the proofs and we could see it like this the Holy Spirit takes those proofs and uses those proofs to produce conviction now that's the view Dr. Warfield Hill and very much wanted to find in Calvin the other way of seeing it like this take that arrow out the Holy Spirit produces conviction sweet things taste sweet the Bible the word of God and those proofs then follow conviction as secondary aids to our feebleness backing up and supporting what we have already learned directly through the witness of the Holy Spirit Warfield argued that the Holy Spirit allumans by means of the proofs but I think even Warfield recognizes that he's he's not really sure about this this is what he says Calvin speaks of the ineffectiveness of the indickia in producing sound faith in the unbeliever and of their value as corroborations to the believer and his language was would sometimes seem to suggest that therefore it were just as well not to employ them until after faith had formed itself under the testimony of the Holy Spirit of their part in forming faith under the operation of the testimony of the Spirit he does not appear explicitly to speak so think Warfield recognizes that even though he would very much like to see this as Calvin's program that Calvin doesn't explicitly say that in fact it seems to me that Calvin very much explicitly says this one of the few times I've ever disagreed with the New Warfield so note that

V.V. Warfield is a marvelous expositor of Calvin and of all the Widers on Calvin, ancient and modern I still think he is the best but at this point I believe he missed it the Holy Spirit allumans directly is Dauy says J.I. Packer says and the proofs are secondary aides to our feebleness okay the question is about that yes sir could you connect that with the current debate in politics on these oppositional versus classical politics well it has some some relation I think to that although that debate as you say is as modern form that we really can't impose on Calvin but certainly if you're going to use that language Calvin is a presuppositionist here not an evidentialist he says the arguments come later they can't come first think about this in terms of your own experience how did you come to believe the Bible was the word of God did somebody tell you that here's a prophecy in Isaiah that was fulfilled in Matthew hundreds of years later or did somebody tell you that the Bible was written by 40 I think 40 some writers over a period of centuries and yet as one message from beginning to end if somebody might say many people say not true there are a lot of different messages because we think still there's one basic message and all these different messages confirm and illustrate the one central message of the Bible but you can get a lot of debate as you well know of that

I suppose I came to believe the Bible was the word of God because my mother told me it was that sort of like the church but you know it was it was more than that the church can can bear witness other people can say this is the word of God but at some point I had to believe it for myself not just because my mother said it was the word of God and I don't remember the proofs even though I studied those and looked at those many times it's having any formative effect in producing a conviction in me that the Bible was the word of God in fact that came so early in my life I don't know how it came maybe just like Calvin said just like I learned as a child that sweet things were sweet I believe the Bible not to be authoritative because it bore witness to itself any reflections on that your experience Julia so would you say it was self authenticated in your experience

okay any other testimonies all right see where we where we are now there's just a little bit more in Calvin's treatment of scripture and I can comment on that briefly you read these sections as well once Calvin has brought together a word and spirit the first illustration back up there Calvin is very concerned to maintain the unity of the word and the spirit against a number of eras one would be the Catholic era of subordinating the scriptures to the church so he comes back to this and says that Catholics are wrong because they downplay the role of the spirit in illumination by subordinating the scriptures to the church he's already dealt with that and we'll deal with it again much later in the institutes in book four the work of the spirit in inspiration that's here and the work of the spirit in illumination that's here or both works of the spirit it's not enough just to say that we accept the Bible because the church says that it is the Bible we have within us the same Holy Spirit who gave the scripture now opening our eyes to see the truth of the scripture but the other era that Calvin is concerned about in particularly in this closing section chapter nine is the era from people he calls fanatics who elevate the spirit over the scriptures these would be people like the radicals of the Reformation people in Luther's camp like Carl's dot and Munster who taught that Revelation now comes directly from the Holy Spirit Luther and Carl's dot had a great debate on this topic that was when Luther said that Carl's dot had swallowed the Holy Spirit feathers and all with the illusion to the dove because of Carl's dot's insistence that it is the word of the Holy Spirit directly that is the word of God Calvin says these people are so enamored of the spirit that they saw little need for the written word so his concern here is to hold together the spirit and the word Calvin said and so these rascals this language is beginning to heat up a bit here and we'll continue to do so tear apart those things which the prophet joined together with an inviolable bond the Holy Spirit does not invent new and unheard of revelations but seals our minds with a very doctrine which is commended by the gospel Calvin says also says he is the author of scripture he cannot vary and differ from himself hence he must ever remain just as he wants revealed himself there so it's one Holy Spirit and there's one word of God and that Holy Spirit who is certainly active now in bringing illumination to us so that we can read and believe the Bible is speaking what he has already revealed through inspiration to the writers of the Bible they're not two messages an old message and a new message they're not two messages a written one and a a living one Bible is the living word of God and any attempt to put a wedge between the spirit and the Bible Calvin rejects as bound to fail all of Calvin's theology was carried out within these bounds the objectivity of God's revelation in holy scripture and the confirming illuminating witness of the Holy Spirit in the believer a unity and necessity of both the Bible and the Spirit the testimony of the Holy Spirit is necessary to believe the Bible and the word is the instrument by which the Lord dispenses the illumination of his spirit to believers so Holy Spirit is active teaching us leading us speaking to us but only through the truth of the Bible which is itself the word of God the word of the Holy Spirit or feel and some others have called Calvin the theologian of the Holy Spirit and people perhaps at first think that's a little far fetched because Calvin seems to be the theologian of the sovereignty of God or something else but as much to be said for that designation of Calvin as the theologian of the Holy Spirit even though it's not a huge section on the Holy Spirit in the institutes only the first chapter of book three the 1559 version that we're reading and that was put in for 1559 deals directly with the Holy Spirit all four books are about the Holy Spirit and there are many times since as today when we'll be talking about the Holy Spirit even though technically the teaching of the Spirit the work of the Spirit comes in book three the way in which we are united to Christ but the three books book one God the Creator book two God the Redeemer in Christ book three the way book four church all three are turnitarian in structure and not only is Christ and the Holy Spirit present in book one in creation but the Father and the Holy Spirit are present in book two in redemption and the whole Trinity is present in book three in the application of redemption to us and in book four the Christian community okay now we've got the scriptures so we can turn to the scriptures to see what those scriptures tell us about God the Creator we've got the scriptures our glasses are on the Holy Spirit is it work in our hearts and now we can look all the way here to see what we are told about God the Creator and that's our work for next week God is God God is Trinity God is one God is triune God is the creator of all things in God is the preserver of all things we'll learn that next week do you speak for a moment if

yes before there is a written word in Calvin in the Westminster Confession God was speaking in various ways to these people and there you might say the work of Revelation and illumination was together but God determined to put that revelation in written form at a certain point in history for us so that we could have the whole message of the Bible you still have the work of the Spirit in producing it and in illumination but those two are not simultaneously just now the Bible is there first and then I pick it up I'm illuminated by the Spirit so God was always speaking but in diverse ways and at sundry times according to the Westminster Confession okay thank you