<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bagi Bagi Bulanan

Calvinism in Nineteenth-Century America

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We were at lecture 30, faith and learning, Calvinism in 19th century America. There was an organization called the Evangelical Alliance, which was founded in London in 1846. And in 1873, it met in New York City. It was an organization to bring together Christians from different traditions and denominations to promote a proper ecumenical regard for different parts of the body of Christ. When the Alliance met in New York City in 1873, Charles Hodge was one of the delegates. Professor at Princeton Seminary, Hodge was in that year already 76 years old. And he had been teaching at Princeton for 51 years. He was asked to lead in prayer at the opening of the Alliance. One person who was there described Hodge as the most impressive personality of the meeting. Here's a picture of him drawn when he was about the age that he was when he attended the Evangelical Alliance in 1873. He was a picture the subserver said of strength lying in repose with a face both radiant and serene. He carried a gold-headed, ebony walking chain, and he leaned on it as he spoke with his many friends and as he rose to offer the opening prayer at the meeting of the Alliance. It's part of that prayer that I'm going to use now as we begin to study in this lecture Calvinism in 19th century America. Let us pray. Come Holy Spirit, come. Descend in all thy plenitude of grace. Come as the Spirit of reverence and love. We confess thee before men. We avow our faith that God is and that he is the creator, preserver, and governor of the world. We acknowledge that the God of Abraham and Isaac can of Jacob is our God. We confess Christ as God manifests in the flesh and is our only and all sufficient Savior who for us sinners died upon the cross to reconcile us unto God and to make expiation for the sins of men and who, having died for our offenses, has risen again for our justification. We acknowledge him as now seated at the right hand of the majesty on high, all power in heaven and on earth, having been committed to his hands. Thanks be to God, thanks be to God that he has put on us unworthy as we are, the honor to make this confession and to bear this testimony to God into his son. O God, look down from heaven upon us, shed a broad in our hearts the Holy Spirit, that we may be truly one in Christ Jesus, to the Father, Son and Holy Ghost, be glory, now and evermore, amen. As we think of Calvinism in 19th century America, I want to talk first of all about the New England theology, the students of Jonathan Edwards and his followers, of course, continued to teach the Calvinism that Edwards had taught in his time. As they did so, they also attempted to, as they said, improve it. Fortunately, those improvements were not real improvements, and what we have happening in New England after the time of Edwards is not a continuation of the strong edwards, the untheology of Jonathan Edwards, but a kind of watering down of some of the Calvinistic emphasis of Edwards. Joseph Bellamy and Samuel Hopkins and even Jonathan Edwards Jr., Timothy Dwight, are all described as being theologians of the new divinity, some of those names that I just read, there is a greater departure from the Calvinism of Edwards than in others, but in all of those names, there is some adjustment to the Calvinism, the reform theology that Jonathan Edwards taught. So, it's so powerfully in his time, and from the new divinity is just another step to what is called the new haven theology of Nathaniel Taylor, so in the hundred years between the death of Edwards and the death of Taylor, Jonathan Edwards is Calvinism largely disappear among his New England followers. In fact, Taylor's theology comes very close to the kind of pelagianism that Edwards had attempted to answer during his own lifetime. One of the histories of the New England theology after Edwards is called from piety to moralism, the passing of the New England theology by Joseph Heritunian, and he shows in that book piety versus moralism, the passing of the New England theology is the history of this period by Joseph Heritunian in which he shows how the high Calvinism, the piety of Jonathan Edwards, declined into a kind of moralistic theology in Edwards' theological descendants. Heritunian wrote this human depravity and regeneration by the Spirit of God were reconciled with free moral agency and moralized and confused beyond recognition. Such Calvinism was not very objectionable, but it was also not Calvinism. While that was taking place in New England, while one of the New England Puritan sinners was slipping away from Orthodox Calvinism, that is Yale and the Edwardian tradition, the other important New England Puritan center, Harvard College, was rapidly moving away from Christian theism to Unitarianism. Harvard in 1805 appointed a Unitarian to its chair of theology, which was an indication that the old Calvinism would certainly no longer be taught at Harvard as it had been in the early years of the school's existence. The New England Puritan era was founded in Massachusetts in 1809 as another place for New England trenditarians to study because of the loss of Harvard to Unitarianism. And for some years and over was an important center of New England congregational Calvinism, but gradually through the 19th century and over too was influenced by accommodating thought and by the end of the century had moved away from its Calvinist roots. And so as we look at the New England theology in the 19th century and that very brief sketch of it, there's much to disappoint us that the place where there had been so much good, so much life and great reform theology taught and preached for generations was largely lost to the reform faith. Another very important center of 19th century Calvinist theology was the small town in Pennsylvania, Versusburg, which was the location of a seminary of the German reform church. And the Versusburg theology became a second center for theology in America on the reform side of things. While New England was being influenced by American culture and by modern thought, Versusburg was attempting to return to the creeds of the reformation and post-reformation period and to the teaching of the reformers. There were two teachers at this little seminary in Pennsylvania who are well known and want to mention each of these briefly, John Nevin and Philip Schaff. John Nevin was an American trained at Princeton seminary, an old school presbyterian who began to teach at the German reform school. He was a theologian and Philip Schaff was born in Switzerland and came from that country to teach at Versusburg. Later, Schaff became professor at Union Seminary in New York City and became a presbyterian, he is primarily known as a historian. Nevin criticized as the doctrine of American Calvinism that he felt had been watered down by the Puritan revivalist subjectivism. He was not someone who supported the revivals, really of the first great awakening or the second great awakening. He felt that revivalism was a decline from true Calvinism and urged a churchly Calvinism with an emphasis on the sacraments, the ministry, the catechetical instruction, liturgy as over against the decision-based revivalism of his time. One of Nevin's important books criticizing the revivalist movement was the book The Anxious Bench, which indeed I think did provide a correction to revival-centered Christianity. I find myself really torn between Nevin's critique of the revival and appreciation for the revival. Somewhere between Nevin's critique which needs to be listened to and the revival itself, there is the important place for renewal and revival in the American church, but some of the excesses and problems that developed in revivalist theology, Nevin certainly points out with clarity and with force. Another book by John Nevin was the mystical presence in which he attempted to recover something of Calvin's on emphasis on the Lord's Supper as over against an American understanding of the Lord's Supper, which seemed to Nevin to follow much more closely the memorialism of Zwingli and not the real spiritual mystical presence of Calvin. John Nevin was an important theologian, but his influence was diluted in the American Evangelical church and certainly in the Calvinist church by a kind of electronian distaste for the doctrine of the divine decrees and Nevin's own pilgrimage closer and closer to the Roman Catholic church in the latter part of his life. Philip Schaff became the preeminent church historian in the 19th century and in some ways the father of American church history is eight volumes. History of the Christian church is still valuable and important for anyone studying church history. He edited the creeds of chrysanthem and the nice scene and post nice scene fathers just in saying those three words about Schaff, he can immediately see how important he is for us even today as we attempt to study the history of the church. Schaff's own historical theory, his understanding of church history was marked by a theory of development, what one writer has called somewhat romantic, progressing dialectical development. Schaff felt that church history was constantly correcting itself as different movements would arise to correct the mistakes or the over or under infacies of other movements and then eventually there would be a kind of evangelical Catholicism that would bring all the churches together in the highest expression of Christian truth. Schaff promoted that led him to advocate a revision of the Westminster confession of faith in order to accommodate other Christian traditions more clearly in changing something of the Calvinist tradition. He supported that revision of Westminster against the Princeton theologians and against his own colleague William Shed. So we have the New England theology, we have the Mercesburg theology, I think the most significant of the schools of reform, Calvinist theological thought in America in the 19th century was certainly the Princeton school and the Princeton theology. Princeton's history can be traced back to the law college in the Chamonix, Pennsylvania, that school of the first grade awakening of William Tennant senior, where so many of the preachers of the first grade awakening were trained. Out of that law college came the College of New Jersey founded in 1746 and eventually the seminary founded in 1812 with its motto, piety of the heart and solid learning. The first faculty of the seminary was Archival Alexander who came from the church in Philadelphia, originally Alexander was from Virginia and been president of Hampton Sydney College and also pastor in Virginia, pastor in Philadelphia and then the first professor at Princeton seminary. The second year he was joined by Samuel Miller who had been serving as pastor of a Presbyterian Church in New York City and several years later, 1820, these two were joined by one of the early Princeton seminary graduates Charles Hodge who then made up with Alexander and Miller the first faculty. Let me summarize the Princeton theology in five points. First it was certainly a place of reform theology. The textbook at Princeton was Francis Turreton's Institutes. It was still in Latin, the students read and practically memorized 20 or 30 or 40 pages of Turreton in Latin in order to recite those theological ideas to their teacher Charles Hodge. Eventually the Princeton students were rescued from the Latin of Turreton by Hodges on three volume systematic theology in English although there's still quite a bit of Latin and other languages in the footnotes and in various references that Hodges makes in his three volume systematic theology. Much of what Hodge does in his systematic theology is to bring up to date the ideas and teachings of Francis Turreton. Hodge you know is famous for having said more than once that a new idea never originated at Princeton. Some people like to quote that and say just like we thought I think new going on there just old-fashioned theology and it's very much what Hodge and the Princetonians wanted to advocate. Hodge may have overstated the case that there was never a new idea at Princeton, sure that he did but it was his conscious desire and Princeton's purpose to pass on what it had received from the reform tradition unaltered and unchanged and I think largely succeeded in doing that. The historic Christian reform orthodoxy in the 19th century was not New England or Versusburg but the Presbyterian seminary at Princeton in New Jersey. One of the emphases of Princeton as the century wore on was the inspiration of Scripture. Inspiration and in errantcy of Scripture a Hodge and BB Warfield wrote together a article or one of the journals published then in a book a little book called Inspiration in the year 1881. The Princetonians argued I think quite rightly that in errantcy was not a new idea despite some modern historians and theologians who attempt to say that Princeton invented the doctrine of in errantcy, they believed that they were going back to the Westminster Confession, to the Reformers, to Augustine, to the Bible itself, to set forth the Bible's own view of itself as inspired by God, plenary, verbal, inspiration which to them was in errantcy of Scripture and that has become one of the hallmarks of the Princeton theology of the 19th century. Another emphasis of Princeton often overlooked but important is piety and the Christian life. When Andrew Hafecker wrote piety in the Princeton theologians in 1981, I think it was hard for him to get people to take him seriously at first. Princeton was known as a place of high orthodoxy and Protestant scholasticism but a place of devotional life and love for God and constant search for a deeper walk with the Lord. I did not sound like Princeton to the minds of many people until Hafecker brought out this book and revealed what was true all along. This was not only a theological seminary where important work was being done on great teachings and doctrines of the Bible but a place where people were endeavoring to walk with the Lord and love him and serve him. Certainly every seminary student should read the religious life of seminary students and spiritual culture in the theological seminary. Those articles by Warfield actually addresses that he gave at Princeton or noted in the syllabus so that you can find them and read them. I urge you to do that. There are wonderful messages of what it means to be a seminary student and how to preserve and increase our spiritual life in the midst of all our academic work. Another emphasis at Princeton was evangelism and missions. Princetonians were by no means opposed to revivals. They were opposed to the type of revivals that they saw taking place under Finney or reasons that we've already looked at. Archival Alexander was sometimes referred to as the prince of Methodist preachers. He was not a Methodist at all. He was a Calvinist and a Presbyterian but he was so zealous to preach in revivals that people almost thought that he was a Methodist in his zeal to get the gospel out. His son, J.W. Alexander, preached that everyone will be saved who yields to the moving of the spirit takes God at his word and makes the universal offer his own particular salvation. In reward, teacher reading those words from J.W. Alexander claimed that such a statement represented the theology of Taylor and the theology of New England but it was not the theology of Princeton but it was the theology of Princeton. And J.W. Alexander and others did preach this kind of gospel as they offered salvation to the center and urged sinners to receive it. The Princeton Student Society of Inquiry on Missions was one of the most active and important centers of missionary study and missionary zeal in the first half of the 19th century. Really, before the mission boards became active in recruiting missionaries and training them was the student society at Princeton and other seminaries and colleges that carried on the work of sustaining and strengthening the missionary movement in 19th century America. And then a fifth point about the Princeton theology and informed interaction with culture. The Princetonians certainly emphasized the importance of the Christian world in life view. The Princeton journals from the biblical repertoire in 1825 through the Princeton theological review which ended in 1929 or over 100 years these journals were the leading voice for Calvinism in America. It was also at Princeton in 1898 that the stone lectures that year were given by Abraham Kuiper, the great Dutch Calvinist and theologian, the political leader who was quite soon to become the prime minister of the Netherlands. If you've been to a covenant college in the chapel of Covenant College in a window, they are actually in beautiful color there at the college. There is the Princeton window and it shows Dr. Warfield welcoming Abraham Kuiper as his briefcase and his notes that is the book we now call Calvinism is stone lectures in 1898 just 100 years ago. February of 1998 there was the anniversary lecture series at Princeton religion pluralism and public life Abraham Kuiper's legacy for the 21st century Abraham Kuiper's stone lectures the 100th anniversary February 25th through 28th 1998 will eventually see the papers that were given at that conference published by it's interesting to think that 100 years after these lectures another set of lectures are given to commemorate the importance of Abraham Kuiper and the stone lectures of 1898. We'll talk about Abraham Kuiper later when we come to 19th century developments in the church in the Netherlands but his Princeton stone lectures are certainly part of the history of Princeton and point to the importance of the Christian worldview which Kuiper so wonderfully epitomized in his lectures as part of the Princeton seminary heritage. Well that's all I'm going to say about Princeton if you want to know more about it a lot more about it I can recommend some books but we'll have to move on to other topics now. Not only were there these centers of Calvinism in the North New England declining away from the teaching of Jonathan Edwards Mercisberg recovering some important emphasis in Calvinism but also struggling with some of the problems reflected in Nevin's own spiritual pilgrimage Princeton holding true to the faith and the teaching of the reformers throughout that whole century and centers of Presbyterian and Calvinist thought in the South. The two centers in the South for reform theological thinking are two seminaries Union Seminary in Virginia and Columbia Seminary in South Carolina. Union Seminary in Virginia began in 1824 at Hampton Sydney College eventually moved to Richmond but for early part of its history at Hampton Sydney. The most famous theologian connected with Union was Robert Lewis Dabney. His latest 1860 Princeton attempted to bring Dabney to its faculty but Robert Lewis Dabney preferred to stay in Virginia partly because he saw the war clouds on the horizon and wanted to be in the South when the Civil War began. And actually Dabney as you probably know served as an officer under Stonewall Jackson. After the Civil War first thought of going to Brazil you really wanted to get away from the North and Brazil was a long way away but he went to Texas instead and there he helped to found Austin theological Seminary and encouraged the growth of the Presbyterian Church in Texas. Columbia Seminary in South Carolina found it in 1829 had a number of outstanding theologians including James Henry Thornwall who lived to be only 50 years old but left his mark on Southern Presbyterianism. And John Latia Gerardo the man that we talked about last time who was pastor of the black Presbyterian Church in Charleston South Carolina who then later after the Civil War went to the Seminary in Columbia and taught there for the rest of his life. There's not really much difference between Union and Princeton and Columbia. Columbia perhaps is a bit more Calvinistic in the sense of going back to the teaching of the institutes. Princeton had its theology more from Taroton which of course would be one step removed from Calvin and the institutes. As Princeton Seminary produced a series of important journals of theological thought so did the Southern Presbyterian Church in the Southern Presbyterian Review. One of the interesting things particularly about the Princeton journals but also the Southern Presbyterian Review as well is that these journals included articles about almost everything, not strictly theology alone, but recent inventions in science, recent discoveries and explorations and geography, music, art, literature, culture. Theology Bible, Bible criticism and I think to scan through those 19th century journals shows something of the breadth of interest and the Christian world in life view that marked these old Presbyterians. Well was there no other source and center for reform thought in America in the 19th century. There was one other but it was rapidly losing its reform heritage and I need to say a word about the Baptist before we end this lecture. Despite a persistent strain of Armenianism within Baptist life is always there, the general Baptist, that means general atonement Baptist, always there. Despite that strain until sometime in the 19th century or perhaps even in the early 20th century but it certainly begins in the 19th century, most Baptist adhered to the doctrines of grace as set forth in Pauline, Augustinian and reform theology. Those doctrines were transmitted through the enormously influential Philadelphia confession which in large measure is word for word the Westminster confession of the Baptist inherited from their English forebears, the doctrines of grace as taught in the Westminster confession. You can see that type of theology illustrated in the syllabus from the covenant and articles of faith of the first Baptist church in Atlanta, Georgia adopted at the organization of that church on January 1st 1848, certainly a reformed and Calvinistic statement of faith, part of which I have quoted in the syllabus. But a gradual change came over Baptist life in the 19th century until as Thomas Neville's put sit until the majesty of a sovereign God was swallowed up by the dignity of a partially fallen man. And the doctrines of grace were largely eclipsed among Baptist, as Neville's also expresses it, this theology vanished like a puff of smoke in a strong wind in 19th century America. I think the loss of Calvinism in the Baptist church was due largely to three things. One would be Campbellism, the Armenian and anti-confessional restoration church movement on the frontier which the Baptist had to struggle with and deal with and were influenced by. Secondly, landmarkism, there was the landmark movement, particularly in the southern Baptist church, in which you have a kind of exclusive Baptist theology, no fellowship with other Christians requiring immersion, even to transfer members from other Baptist churches, no table communion of the Lord's sufferer. And an idea that Baptist maintained their own pure succession throughout church history, not mixed up with the Roman Catholic church and even the Protestant churches. That exclusivism tended to isolate Baptist and moved them away from fellowship with other evangelicals and with Calvinists. Some of the landmark Baptist were strong Calvinists and remains though, but many of them lost their Calvinism during this kind of hyper Baptist movement within the southern Baptist church. And then the third reason that the doctrines of Calvinism declined among the Baptist was because of a very hyper Calvinist movement within the Baptist church itself. Churches that are called primitive Baptist or sometimes hard shale Baptist arose in which there was a virulent anti-missionary attitude and anti evangelistic attitude, kind of hyper Calvinism that says sinners can't repent and should not be asked to do so. That's not Calvinism, of course, but it became hard for Baptist then to separate that sort of teaching from true Calvinism of Charles Virgin and the London confession and the Philadelphia confession. Today it is encouraging to note that there's a kind of revival of reform thinking among southern Baptist and other Baptist, very disturbing to some Baptist and other Baptist are rejoicing that these doctrines which really are part of Baptist history, this confessional heritage is being restored again in Baptist thought. Well, that's a brief overview of the 19th century in terms of Calvinism. It's not a great century for Calvinism because it certainly is declining in influence and power in American life and in the American church. But some places were holding firm Princeton, Columbia at Union and other individuals and churches here and there throughout America to carry the doctrine of the reform faith through the century and into the 20th century. Seeing that we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us run with perseverance, the race that is set before us. Do what you like to talk about in the next six minutes. Yes. The question is where are the three Presbyterian seminaries that I talked about, where are they today, theologically. Princeton is very eclectic sort of place today. You get just about everybody they are from one end of the theological spectrum to the other. But I must say that it's more encouraging to hear about Princeton now that it was when I was there 10 years ago. Or a little more than that. But one thing the president of Princeton, Dr. Gillespie is something of I suppose we would describe him as a moderate. I was really amazed when he ordered 45 sets of my two volume history to give to all the trustees of Princeton seminary. I thought when I wrote that history, I would be persona known grata forever on the Princeton campus. But among some of the people there, the books were well received. And perhaps God will use that influence in some small way to bring renewal to Princeton. The other interesting exciting thing about Princeton is that Bruce McCormick teaches there. Bruce went to covenant seminary for two years. He came from Kansas City as a Nazarene. I thought he would try to reform faith for a bet. I did battle with Dr. Jones and others for two years. I went back to Kansas City to get his theology straightened out again and became a Calvinist back there at his Nazarene seminary. I went on to Princeton. I did his doctoral studies at Princeton and it was all taught at New College in Edinburgh for several years. I visited him there some years ago. Mary McCormick, his wife is also a graduate of covenant seminary. And then Bruce was invited back to Princeton to teach. Recently, David Jones told me that Richard Mao, who is the president of Fuller, heard from Dr. Gillespie, this story that at the end of last semester, Bruce had been teaching a class in theology at Princeton. And he said at the end of the class, class is over, you can go, but I'm going to stay here and pray a bit. Because I have an idea that for some of you, we've been studying about God in the Bible and Holy Spirit and salvation that these things are rather theoretical, rather academic. And it's not right to study theology that way. Actually, Bruce is famous as a professor who begins his class with prayer at Princeton seminary. It's not the usual custom, but on this occasion, he invited students who wanted to stay behind to stay and pray with him. And Gillespie said half the class stayed and prayed with Bruce for an hour. And Dr. Gillespie said to Dr. Mao, we're going to have a revival yet at Princeton. So I think with his attitude and with people like Bruce McCormick at Princeton, there is hope there. Bruce did his doctoral work on Bart, he probably is a Bartian, but he takes to my mind at least the best side of Bart. And there is a good side of Bart, and perhaps is overly influenced by the other side too, but still there's a lot of conservative Orthodox power there. When I studied at Princeton or at Covenant, Bart was viewed as a real liberal, somebody who had forsaken the faith practically. When I went to Princeton, they talked about him there as though he was a fundamentalist. So I was confused as to what Bart really was, as he was a liberal or a fundamentalist and he really was neither. But that's Princeton, some good things happening, student Charles Hodge society, founded among the students. There are beginning to the issues now of the Princeton theological review coming out again through the influence of the student society. Union as union enrichment has been through a big upheaval lately. And the president there I don't think is very sympathetic to some of the conservative causes that are being promoted at union, so I don't know as much about union, but not as hopeful with union. And neither with Columbia, it's really sad that these two southern seminaries have lost a great deal of their theological orthodoxy. So let's pray that Covenant will not only now but for years to come, forever until the Lord comes back, stand true to his word and to the teaching of that word.