<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bagi Bagi Bulanan

Christ: Psalm 110, Christological Heresies

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

We move from studying the doctrine of doctrines of man and sin to the doctrine of Christ, what a wonderful subject to study. We have three weeks, that is three class days. Three evenings on this good topic. And today we want to discuss crystallological heresies we can learn from the mistakes throughout the ages, but also to take some biblical soundings. It would be nice to take one in both testaments, but at least Isaiah, I'm sorry, at least Psalm 110. I'm thinking of Isaiah 53 and the work of Christ, but we're doing the person of Christ and Psalm 110. I'll explain this in a few moments, but let me just read the Psalm. See in your own mind where the break occurs. The Lord says to my Lord, sit at my right hand until I make your enemies a footstool for your feet. The Lord will extend your mighty scepter from Zion. You will rule in the midst of your enemies. Your trips will be willing on your day of battle, arrayed in holy majesty from the womb of the dawn. You will receive the due of your youth. The Lord has sworn and will not change his mind. You are a priest forever in the order of Melchizedek. The Lord is at your right hand. He will crush kings on the day of his wrath. He will judge the nations heaping up the dead and crushing the rulers of the whole earth. He will drink from a brook beside the way. Therefore he will lift up his head. This structural analysis is the work of Dr. Van Groeningen versus one to three and four to seven form two different units. One to three and four through seven. Why do you say that because one and four begin with an oracle, a direct word of God to David's Lord. The Lord says to my Lord and then the words follow verse four. The Lord has sworn and will not change his mind. You are a priest forever. Not saying that to David. He's saying that to David's Lord. So a divine utterance begins verse one and verses four as well. There's a divine utterance. There's a a bit of an elaboration and then an explanation and that same pattern holds true. The outline isn't crucial for our purposes. It is crucial to see the divine utterance beginning each of those two sections. Let me work through the Psalm briefly. The Lord, notice its capital L-O-R-D from at least the King James, from the time of the King James version at least it's been customary to distinguish Old Testament names of God by the way they're spelled in English. Either G-O-D or L-O-R-D in caps and capital letters indicates that tetragramatine, that sacred name of God, sometimes called Jehovah or Yahweh by different scholars and that indicates this in the beginning of verse one. The Lord, Yahweh, says to my Lord it's the word Adon. Sit at my right hand. The fact that David is the writer is important and it is demonstrated by the fact that in the New Testament, Matthew 22 and Luke 20 for example, the Lord Jesus ascribes this Psalm to David. Old Testament scholars are debate whether the Psalm titles, the descriptions following the Psalm number are authentic whether they're inspired or not but in this case Jesus corroborates the fact that David is the writer. That is important because as the King of Israel, David has one Lord God in heaven. Any other Israelite could be said to have two Lords, God in heaven and David on the throne, the King. You with me? He's the earthly Lord. He's the Theocratic King who reigns in the place of God. David has one Lord and yet he says the Lord says to my Lord and some of the things said about the Lord go far beyond David or Solomon. You'll be a priest forever according to the order of Melchizedek was not said of any Jewish King ever. They're amazing words. It is David's, the Messiah is David's Lord, the second Lord mentioned. The Lord says to my Lord, sit at my right hand. It's the place of honor and authority. Sit at my right hand, the place of equality with God, until I make your enemies a footstool for your feet. First one already throws us into a context of conflict, of warfare. David's Lord is thus a warrior ruler, a warrior King. He is David's Lord. He is a King and God will fight for him. The Lord will extend your mighty scepter from Zion. You will rule in the midst of your enemies. David's Lord, the Messiah will be successful. He will defeat his foes because the Lord will fight for him. Your troops will be willing on your day of battle. It is not going to be hard for this King to gather recruits to fight on his behalf. A raid and holy majesty from the womb of the dawn, a figure that means from the beginning of the day, two possible translations. One is, your young men will come to you like the do, an IV marginal note. That would thus be a repeat of the first part of three in sense. Your troops will be willing on the day of battle. They will volunteer. That is your young men, your youth understand? Collectively, your youth in that sense, not your individual youthfulness, but your young men. The warriors will come to you like the do, as the do glistens the grass in the morning. So it'll be, it'll be countless recruits. There'll just be hosts of young vigorous men willing to fight on behalf of David's Lord. In any case, the beginning of verse three says that. So if we follow the NIV marginal reading, we have the same idea reinforced, which is not unusual in Hebrew. If we follow what's in the NIV text, it's a slightly different idea which is taught in verse seven. So truth is not at stake. The two ideas represented by the two possible translations. One is taught in the beginning of three, one is taught in seven. So they're both true. I'll just explain the other one. A raid and holy majesty. Apparently he's dressed as a warrior king. From the womb of the dawn, you will receive the do of your youth speaks of God's invigorating, David's Lord, so that from the beginning of the day to the end, he fights with great vigor. He's going to be successful. The do of his youth is going to be restored with me. Both ideas are in this very Psalm so it's not a matter of concern for theology which one of those two is preferred. Verse four is very important. Here we have a shift, a divine utterance again indicating the second part of the Psalm and an amazing thing now, just an amazing thing. Not only is David Lord Lord and a warrior king who will conquer because God will fight for him, but David's Lord is a priest. And what a priest. Of course a priest according to Aaron, right? According to Levi. Wrong. A priest according to Melchizedek. That is just shocking. The Lord has sworn and will not change his mind. You that's a solemn God has taken an oath. Hebrews brings out that aspect of it. God has solemnly said these words. He has given an oath and he most certainly will not take it back. You are a priest forever. A king of Israel is going to be a priest forever. That doesn't fit any earthly king. Even if you would say that David is speaking of Solomon and a coronation ceremony in some way, then Solomon is a type of Christ. I personally don't think he's talking about Solomon at all. There are messianic Psalms that work like that. They work of David or the king at his own time as a picture of the one who is to come. The things that are said here so far transcend any earthly monarch. I think it is a directly messianic Psalm, one of the few that speak solely of Messiah to come. You are a priest forever in the order of Melchizedek, the mysterious figure who pops into the biblical record in Genesis 14 or Abraham. Abraham pays him tithes. He comes out as a priest of the most high god. We don't know how he got to be that. He pops into the record. Abraham pays him a tenth of the spoils. He pops out of the record. He recurs here and in Hebrews 5 through 7, and that's it. That's where he appears in the Bible. And here in Psalm 110, David says, you are a priest forever in the order of Melchizedek. One in the world is going on. Rabbis would pluck their beards over this one. He's not in the order of Levi or Aaron. He's in a different order altogether. Hebrews 5 through 7 opens this up and shows the wonder of the human being Melchizedek. I take him that way, who's a type of Christ. It's the fact that his genealogy isn't recorded, nothing that he doesn't have one that is emphasized, and he is thus perfectly equipped to be a type, an acted prophecy of the one who is to come, who in fact is eternal and so forth. The Lord is at your right hand. This is different in verse 1. In verse 1, the Messiah sits down at God's right hand at the place of honor and authority. This is the Lord of the at your right hand. It's a battle scene, and you can imagine if you're doing hand-to-hand combat, you would like to have good fellow warriors on both sides of you. Understand? Because if you have a weakling on your right or your left, you could be in trouble. That person could go down, and before you know it, you could be stabbed. You could be hurt. Here, this warrior has God at his right hand, fighting alongside of him. He will crush the very strong word, shatter, crush kings on the day of his wrath. Messiah is fighting a big battle here. Kings were talking. He will judge the nations, heaping up the dead, a graphic reference to corpses being piled. We're talking gigantic battle and victory for David's Lord. And crushing, there's that word again, the rulers of the whole earth. Verse 7 speaks again. Well, maybe again. If 3B is the way the NIV does it, then 7 reinforces that idea. And this is just like Hebrew 2, to end each of the units with the same notion. He will drink from a book brook beside the way. Therefore, he will lift up his head. Modern paraphrase, he will have a gatorade at half time, and he will keep on trucking. That's the picture, okay? He's restoring the warrior taking a break and drinking. Lifting up his head, he's back at it again, conquering the feeding his enemies. An Old Testament Psalm, I don't know how much David could even have understood of what God spoke through him. But the Messiah is David's Lord.

He is David's Lord. He is a king and a priest. We see it in the New Testament. We see it in the New Testament. In Matthew 22, 41 to 46, and in parallel passages, let me show you briefly what Jesus does with Psalm 110. His enemies often came and tried to trap him with trick questions and so forth. You're familiar with that. This time, he gives them a zinger instead. Matthew 22, 41. While the Pharisees were gathered together, Jesus asked them, what do you think about the Messiah? Whose son is he? They answered correctly, by the way, the son of David. They mean he is in David's line. He's the descendant of King David. That's not wrong. And Jesus doesn't say it's wrong, but he doesn't say it's right either. What he does instead is he throws a monkey wrench into their theological machinery. Son of David, he said to them, oh son of David, how is it then that David noticed speaking by the spirit? This passage has relevance to the doctrine of the inspiration of the Bible. I'm going to skip over that and keep going because that's not part of my duties right now. How is it then that David speaking by the spirit? Notice David, okay? He describes Psalm 110 and verse 1 to 2, David, calls him Lord. How is it then that David speaking by the Spirit, calls the Messiah, Lord, for he says, the Lord said to my Lord, sit at my right hand until I put your enemies under your feet. If then David calls him Lord, how can he be his son? This is a great singer. This is a hard one. They would have to understand that the Messiah is both God and man in one person, okay? It is a hard one. Furthermore, they don't want to admit that he's the Messiah in any way. He's got them between a rock and a hard place. No one could say a word in reply and from that they own no one there to ask him any more questions. In one of the parallels, the people are just happy to see their leaders confounded, oh perhaps it's in the Markin parallel unless I made that part up myself. Yes, the large crowd, I didn't make it up. Listen to him with delight. The Messiah, Jesus does not deny that the Messiah is David's son, okay? He is his descendant, but he's also David's Lord. He's God and man in one person. So the Psalm contains a lot. Oh, it's in seed form, I understand. And it's only with, oh, Hebrews 5 to 7 and looking back with 2020 hindsight, we understand what this priesthood according to Melchizedek is. And it's only as Jesus gives us his exposition of at least one verse of Psalm 110 that we understand, but there's enough here in seed form to blow our minds. The Messiah is David's Lord. He's a king and a priest at the same time. And that indeed is a remarkable combination. Other comments or questions from you all? I just wanted to sample a couple of passages. The sample a couple as we begin our study of the person of Christ. I'd love to get to John 1, but I do feel obligated to teach you about heresies. Bottom of page 87 of the notes. Christological Christology is the doctrine of Christ. One of those big words that keeps us employed and we're grateful for. The agitival form is Christological. Christological heresies or heresies dealing with the person of Christ. The study of the history of Christian doctrine is in large measure a study of controversies. It has to do with the effects of sin on the human mind. And we can organize these Christological heresies according to the aspect of the person of Christ that they attack. After a while you forgot where you borrowed everything from. I think I got this from Millard Ericsson's good Christian theology. But here are two attacks. Let's think about not that we want to invent any heresies today. But if we want to invent a heresy, what could we do? Well, you could attack Christ deity. Or you could attack his humanity. You could go after the fact that he's one person with two natures. Or you could attack the incarnation itself. All of these things have been done. And that way there's nothing new under the sun. Although there are new twists. But a lot of this is contemporary in different emphases. First of all, ebionism concerning which we don't know a great deal was an early Jewish denial of Christ's deity. Go with the final examination study sheet for what you need to know about these. If you need to know anything, I forget. My forgetter is good tonight. Then it's what's already written. So I'm giving other information. You don't have to write if you want to. You're welcome too. An early Jewish denial of Christ deity. It's part of the early Jewish apologetics. When Jews started to become part of the church. In time, Judaism had to have some answers. They had to come up with some explanations. An early on, some denied Christ deity. The ebionites seemed to be an offshoot. A comment? A question? Okay. An offshoot from the New Testament, Judaizers such as appear in Galatians. They were strongly monotheistic, which makes a lot of sense. There's one God. They rejected the virgin birth. It is curious. Somebody could, you can actually affirm the virgin birth and still be mixed up in your Christology. Islam, I believe, the Quran teaches the virgin birth of Christ. But denies that God has a sun and that Jesus is God incarnate. An offshoot from the New Testament, Judaizers, emphasizing the oneness of God, rejected the virgin birth and taught that at his baptism the Christ descended upon Jesus in the form of a dove. Here's a man Jesus and the Christ descends upon him. That is a strange separation of those concepts. It sounds like Christian science. It is erroneous, of course. Near the end of Jesus' life, the Christ withdrew from him. You guessed it. It's when he said, Father, into your hands. I commit my spirit. Thus there are occasions in the Bible. This is not correct in understanding the Bible, but at his baptism when the Spirit descends as a dove. On the cross, when he says, Father, I commit my spirit into your hands. Those are occasions for cultists today to do funny things still. They shouldn't do them, and it's not a matter of really patiently studying the scriptures to see what those passages teach, but there are little openings through which they rush with false teaching. Ebi and Islam. They reject his deity, plainly overtly reject that he is God. There's only one God. It's impossible he could be God. That's a pagan notion. He is obviously the descending of the Christ business, even the Talmud calls him a sorcerer. That is an acknowledgement of some miraculous deeds. Understand? They got just not a false prophet. They call him that too, but a sorcerer. That is, he was doing some activity here. That's hard to explain. That's the notion of the Christ descending on him to account for some of his extraordinary qualities, his miracles. That's a hard question. I don't have a great answer concerning Jewish thought today. There's a great neglect and just avoidance of some of these things. In some congregations, there's even an avoidance of say Isaiah 53 in terms of scripture readings. That'll just be skipped over, but where people do it, they would do it in more contemporary, unbelieving ways than this business. Okay? Arianism is more subtle and is Christian in the sense of arising within the Christian community. Arianists taught that Christ was the first order to add an highest creature of God, thereby denying his deity. Notice the way deity is spelled. It is not deity. I have a list of the 10 most abused words in theology. In terms of spelling, Millennium has two Ls and two Ls anyway. Not for that stuff. There are some funny ones, but it looks like the Lord needs an ultra slim fast sometimes, the way people as well. It is not D-I-E-T, the E-I-T. Arianist taught that Christ was the first and highest creature of God, thereby denying the fact that he is God. This emphasized the absolute uniqueness and transcendence of God. The Father worked and still works through the Word. The Word had a beginning to use the very words of Arianist. There was a when a time when he was not. It's technically not a time. It's before time, but there was a once. There was a when when he was not. He was thus the first creature. If this sounds very familiar, it is very close to so-called Jehovah's Witness Theology. I don't like to give them that designation. They're not really Jehovah's Witnesses. They're witness against Jehovah. They call themselves though, but their Christology is Arianism. The JWs have three Christs. None of which is the biblical Christ. Before you can't call the incarnation, they don't have an incarnation, but before his earthly life, he was the Archangel Michael. There's a transference of his life principle to the man Jesus is a mere man. And after the you can't call it a resurrection because it's a transference of a life, you say, what is the transference of a life principle? I have no idea. It's just a kind of a hokey phrase, actually. There's the Archangel Michael again. So you have angel, man, angel, no continuity in the person of Christ. You can't have an atonement. You can't have salvation. There's no wonder they're out knocking on doors, virtually trying to earn their salvation. It's so sad. I'll say this as we move along. The codes have many errors. Some of them ludicrous, some of them fatal, denying a blood transfusions, denying of use of doctors, okay, for people who are sick, but the damning error of the codes involves the person of Christ and denial of his deity because such a denial cuts one off from grace. You say, why is that so? It doesn't change who he is objectively. If you deny his deity, you cannot be saved because you cannot believe in him properly if you deny he is God. I'm not saying you even have to have heard about the Trinity to be saved. And you may not, you don't even have to make an overt affirmation of his deity, but you at least need to implicitly confess his deity in this regard. You put your faith in the Son of God as someone able to save you from your sins. That is an implicit confession of his deity. I like even an explicit one is even better, but you could implicitly believe he's able to save you thereby believe he's God without even say conceptualizing it or articulating it and be saved. And later on in discipleship, you should, you would learn that. But if you deny he is God and you think he's the finest flower of humanity or an angel or something else, then you cannot trust him to save you. Understand? And so the cults all add works to grace and unprecedented thing has happened in the past ten years. The worldwide church of God, Herbert T. Armstrong's cult has discovered the gospel of Jesus Christ. It is unprecedented in the history of American cults. For years we saw it in the works. Now it has happened. As a matter of fact, the leadership it started with one little chink in the armor and one point point they were studying and it never stopped. They just kept studying more and more things. They now confessed to Trinity, the deity of Christ is but atonement salvation through him alone. It's exciting. They're not done with every other aspect, but they've got the gospel and it's a wonderful thing. As the leadership came to these views, they dealt patiently with the ministers and gave them a couple of years to study things through. If they did not agree with the doctrine of the church, I should say the new doctrine of the church, they had to leave. But I heard interviews concerning these leaders, these leaders a couple of times now in the radio. What was the response of the ministers who went along with the program? They said when they came to understand that Jesus was God and that his death and resurrection alone saved us. He said the results we got, the letters we got were so heartwarming. I have been set free for the first time in my life. I understand the grace of God. A tremendous burden was lifted off of my shoulders. These are the ministers and the congregations are now largely filled. Of course, there are splinter groups, all kinds of splinter groups, carrying on with herbratees, pure gospel, and all the nonsense that Israel and Judah being great Britain and the United States and all of that and the dietary stuff and all the bondage. But the main body which has suffered tremendously, financially, in terms of persecution, some families have been rent. Others have been gloriously saved, has understood that the gospel of Christ involves confessing the deity of Christ. It is an unprecedented thing and I just thank the Lord for it. The Sun, according to Aryanism, is different in essence from the Father. The Council of Nysia and ICEA in 325, the first major council of the Christian Church after that one in Acts 15, the Jerusalem Council, condemned Aryanism and they said, expressly, the Sun is of the same essence as the Father. He is Homo Usios. He is of the same stuff. He is of the same essence. So, attacks on Christ's deity, attacks on his humanity,

dosatism and apolinarianism. Dosatism holds that Jesus only appeared to be human. We can hardly understand this one today because of our philosophical climate, which is likely to deny his deity. There's was likely to deny his humanity. God was considered so other, so transcendent that contact with the physical world was deemed impossible. That is in Greek philosophy.

Oh, matter was considered bad in the Platonic schools. According to Aristotelian philosophy, you don't have to write all this down. God is just impassable. He cannot be affected by the world. God could not become human, therefore, since all matter is evil and God is holy. Dosatic teachers say that Jesus passed through Mary. There was not there was not nine months being in her womb for nine months. That would just be totally contaminating. It was a notion of transmission rather than her carrying him.

He appeared to be a human being. He was not a human being. First John is answering some dosetic strains, who is the inner Christ, the one who denies that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh and so forth, those emphases. Apollonarianism is more subtle. It didn't deny outright the humanity of Christ. It denied the completeness of his humanity. John 114 was read like this. The word became flesh. It means only flesh. He took a body to himself. Some evangelical Christians approximate apollonarianism. Oh, God took a body. Well, he took a body, but he took more than a body. God became a human being. This wasn't just a special species of indwelling. God became a human being.

According to Apollonarius, Jesus was part human and the rest divine. The word, the logos, was the spark of life, animating the body. Greek philosophy held to this notion of a governing principle of a human being, held to be the mind. Jesus had a human body, but not a human soul. He did not have a human will. The word took the place of a human soul. This was condemned at the Council of Constantinople in 381. Constantinople, 381, apollonarianism. As we summarize the teaching of the scriptures concerning the humanity of Christ in our weeks to come, I will show you how there's a dosetic tendency in evangelical Christianity. I will confront you with passages that affirm the full blood and humanity of our Lord, and you will be nervous about those passages. There will be tendencies within you, if you're like my students in the past, to be hesitant, to confess his true humanity. And I will show you how you shouldn't be. We can't fully understand. Remember, I often talk about three mysteries of the Christian faith, divine sovereignty, human responsibility, the Trinity, and here's the third one, how Jesus could be God and man at the same time. We can't understand. So there are mysteries. There are places beyond which we cannot go in our understanding, but we need to affirm what the Bible affirms, and it affirms that God became a human being. More about that in the future, but for now, attacks on his unipersonality. So you can just draw lines on your sheets here and combine some of these. One and two go together, three and four go together, and so forth. Five and six are both attacks on the fact that he is one person with two natures, Nestorianism. Nestorianism was installed as the patriarch of Constantinople in 428, a very important leader in the Eastern Church. He allegedly is an important word. We now can say with confidence, one of the ironies of Church history, that Nestorianism was not a Nestorian. Doesn't help the poor guy or his reputation, however, allegedly Nestorianism divided Christ's natures into two persons. He did use ambiguous language and inconsistent language, but he himself was not in Nestorian. He was attacked by serial of Alexandria who deserves some blame. It is not uncommon for people to misrepresent their opponents, to abuse their inconsistencies and so that is exactly what happened. This was condemned at the Council of Ephesus in 431. You say this is dismal. We're studying one heresy after another and listing where they're all condemned. Well, let us not repeat the mistakes of the past. If Nestorianism, you could say it. Nestorianism didn't do it, but Nestorianism did. If it tears Christ into, eutichianism makes of him hybrid. If Nestorianism rends him into two and holds the two natures too far apart, if you will, eutichianism blends them, so we end up with what philosophers call a tertium-quid, a third something else that is neither God nor man. Eutichese denied the distinction between Christ's natures. Eutichese was a layperson and a good guy apparently who should have kept himself out of the halengi. He was not a clear thinker and he just set himself up. He gave an underhand pitch to anybody who wanted to jump on a heretic. I mean, he just was looking for trouble and he found it. There were two natures before the incarnation, which is just nonsense. There was no human nature of our Lord separate from the incarnation. Understand that? There was no man that God came and indwelt. There was no man Jesus. The humanity of our Lord never existed for a split second apart from union with the word beginning in the Virgin's womb. Get it? It is not Christian doctrine to say there was a man Jesus. Right away, red light grew up. No, there wasn't a man Jesus. He never existed apart from union. For all eternity, he was the second person of the Godhead. He was God the Son. He was the Word or the light as John calls him in chapter 1. So God always existed in three persons. The Son always existed, but the Son became a human being. He didn't indwelt a grown man. There was no man. There was no previously existing human being or even a baby or humanity. There were other persons. I'm not denying that human persons, but Jesus humanity from the moment of its conception was united with the Word in the Virgin's womb. Understand? That's the incarnation. This guy's got two natures before the incarnation. What in the world does that mean? One nature thereafter. Oh my goodness. The humanity of Jesus was absorbed into his deity and became virtually eliminated. Some Christians veer close to that. They veer close to that. Now at God's right hand, Jesus is still God and man. He said, wait a minute. Is there not a difference between his time on earth and his life now? Yes. And Christian theology has seen fit to express that by a doctrine of the two states, his state of humiliation on earth and now his state of exaltation. But the difference does not consist in the fact that he shed his humanity, that he is no longer a human being. That is actually an ancient heresy. This error was condemned by the council of Calcedon in 451. We're talking the big council that gave us the definitive statement on the person of Christ. So poor Yudikey's got himself condemned at the most famous of the councils of the Christian church. Oh, it's a sad situation. Indeed. Lastly, I'm not recommending these approaches mind you, but one could attack the incarnation itself. These are modern errors. Adoptionism has some affinities to evianism. I admit, but it's very much a 19th and 20th century phenomenon. Adoptionism was an attack upon the incarnation and thereby on Christ's deity. It held that God adopted a human being by bestowing the spirit upon him. Modern liberal Christologies are often adoptionistic. We distinguish between Christologies from above and Christologies from below. From above starts where the Bible starts. The word became flesh, John 1. It starts with God in heaven who becomes a human being. One could say, well, the Bible doesn't always start. They're the gospel of Mark starts with Jesus as a servant as a man on earth. True enough, but modern Christologies that start from below start with a mere man. Understand? They start with a mere man and then they have God come and in dwell the man. Oh, beyond measure, but still, if you start with a man, you're not going to have a Christian incarnation. He's never going to be God. Of course, this is a Christ that is not the Bible's Christ, so they're making it up. It's not true. It's the Christ of the Jesus seminar and so forth. The Christ of the Bible comes from above to below and becomes a human being. Jesus of Nazareth according to adoptionistic Christologies was merely a man until his baptism when God adopted him as his son. There is not a true incarnation. More subtle than this, again, is canoticism, a 19th century heresy. The Christology of Rudolph Pothman, for example, is adoptionistic. This is preacher Jesus and the spirit comes upon him and even the church went so far as to make him the divine figure later on and worship him. Oh, he never intended anything like that. That was a creation of the church and the burden of some of Boltman's writings is to explain how the preacher became the preached, how the herald became the subject of the message that is heresy. And if we had church councils doing their job, these things will be condemned too. Canoticism. It taught a reduction of Christ's deity in the incarnation. It doesn't start from below with a man and have God come and endure him. That's better that way. Starts from above but there's a reductionism. Philippians 2.7 is a proof text for this. Oh, they didn't start with the Bible and come to a new conclusion. They had a theology that grabbed the hold of a verse. Jesus emptied himself literally. It's a verb. Cannot. Oh, from that you get canotic and canosis. The second person of the Trinity according to canonicism laid aside some divine attributes and took on human qualities. Doesn't say he laid aside the independent exercise of his attributes which I would agree with. Okay, it says he laid aside those attributes which I cannot agree with. That is Jesus is God and man but not really simultaneously sort of successively. He was God and he became a man and he retains some of his divinity. As soon as you have God giving up some of his divinity, you don't have God anymore. But wait a minute. You mean to tell me Jesus wasn't Galilee and Jerusalem at the end of your day at the same time? Was he on the present in a body? No. Well then he gave up the attribute of on the presence, right? Wrong. It's possible to have attributes and not to exercise attributes. He has all the qualities of deity but he only exercises them in obedience to the Father's will. The temptation by the devil in the wilderness seems to be an appeal to try to get Jesus to use his divine qualities out of the Father's will and he steadfastly refused to do that of course. More about this later on when I tried to and we're bubbling up against mysteries already but there has been some progress made by evangelical thinkers especially in this century and we'll try to preserve his possessing those attributes and at the same time talk about him only using them according to the Father's will. It is break time again and let us take a break and come back at quarter after prepared to wrap up for the evening.