<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Bagi Bagi Bulanan

Synoptic OT Histories, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Now that we have returned from the break, we are going to do a little comparative work on First Chronicles 17 and Second Samuel 7, the two renditions of the Davidic promise or the Dynastic promise as it is sometimes called and so I want to write some things on the board even as you Tell me some of the things you've noticed in comparing these. Remember last time I gave you a handout from James Newsom I think it's James Newsom's book. Yes James Newsom's book a synoptic harmony of Samuel Kings and Chronicles using the RSV text but laid out in such a way that you can more easily Spot the differences between the text the similarities and differences For those of you who go on and learn he brew. There's a nice little Hebrew rendition of this with some of the differences in red The text is mainly in black But the differences are in red and of course gaps are left where material is in one text but not in the other So in terms of differences that you think might or might not be Significant obviously I'm aiming more for those that might be significant. I'll write some of these on the board if you will just tell me What difference is you noticed? Who has who has wants to start us off in doing this synoptic comparison? Yes Okay Okay, so second Samuel. How did you describe second Samuel was more more formal and legal using the terminology King whereas Chronicles was more informal or personal using David and second Samuel seven also used Lord or Yahweh more often and Chronicles used God, okay now you actually get a kind of a switching back and forth in in both of these texts which is some a bit curious in its own way. All right. What else did you what else? What other differences did you notice? Yes Okay Okay, so the the difference in pronouns there your kingdom my kingdom Might well be significant. What else? Okay, can you can you specify the the comment is that first Chronicles seems to be more encouraging Leaving out some of the negative aspects of the second Samuel text. What what can you specify one of those negative or one or more of those negative aspects? Okay, what that is second Samuel 713 or what is it? 14, okay first 14 Okay, so that that whole statement there is actually left out of first Chronicle 17 All right, except perhaps an oblique references it. I mean What what is set of Saul in the second Samuel 7 passage? Okay, it it mentioned Saul explicitly does it not I don't have the text right here before me. Oh dear Okay, am I still do you still hear any sound here in? The second Samuel text. Let's see where is this Verse 15, but my love will never be taken away from him as I took it away from Saul whom I removed from before you and here it just says I will never in in set in first Chronicles It says I will never take my love away from him as I took it away from your predecessor Okay, so it does it does mention Obliquely Saul but rather than using the name small Saul Explicitly, it just says your predecessor sort of more generalizing in a sentence other differences more minor differences Yes Okay Okay, the arc of the covenant little abbreviation of the Lord as Distinct from the or not distinct from but as compared to the arc of God So again, maybe emphasis on covenant there might be Significant what else they Okay, yeah, now Samuel talks about the comment is it Samuel talks about the tribes of Israel Whereas Chronicles talks about the judges of Israel Now that that's a tricky one because that is really just a text critical question the word judges or leaders of Israel would be Shofate or Shofte and Tribes is shifte so it's a difference of one letter and the likelihood is that there's no significance to that difference Other than the the reading judges is probably the correct reading Rather than tribes Okay, yeah, William Okay, the words used in Chronicles are more dramatic, right? Okay All right Yeah, I don't know how to some that speaking of the go ahead and say it again Okay, so so the Chronicles references to the what men will do wasting them seems to be more Dramatic than afflicting them all right. I don't know quite how to summarize that on the board But we'll take that under advisement as well. You had a comment Okay, yeah, the difference between Samuel does speak more about rest and and Chronicles more about subduing subduing enemies All right, we're going to talk about the significance of these in just a minute We're more just kind of noting them at the moment. Yes, gentlemen Yeah, then in the early in the early verse there just leaves out the the reference to the Lord giving David or giving the king Rest from all his enemies round about that's not included in the Chronicles text Any others other things if I mean there there are other minor details What about the Mention yeah, no mention of the flogging. I think we got this one in terms of the chastening with the rod of men Yeah, William Okay What verse were you in in Samuel over nine right okay? Yeah, right okay, so in yeah interesting idea and the Chronicles passage by leaving out the word great after name or before name in the English And I'll make you your name great or give you a great name leaving that out may Put the emphasis more on the one who is is giving The blessing rather than the one who is receiving the blessing and thus becoming great although in Chronicles It does say like the names of the greatest men of all the earth so there is still this notion of greatness in there somewhere What about verse 6 in the in IV it says I have not dwelt in a house from the day I brought the Israel Israelites up out of Egypt to this day in Chronicles it says I had not dwelt in a house from the day. I brought Israel up to this day Okay, so the Samuel text has this phrase out of Egypt and And the Chronicles text does not have that particular phrase, but does speak of bringing Israel up There's another difference I think in that in that verse I have been moving from place to place with a tent for my dwelling and in The Chronicles passage it says I have moved from one tent site to another from one dwelling place to another The site difference there as well the Samuel text may be being more Suggestive of the tabernacle as a place in which God dwells whereas the Chronicleer is really saying from tent to tent from place to place Okay Yes Jennifer in in Second Samuel where up 21 I wasn't aware that we had gone then I'm not sure we wanted to go that far Yeah, I know I'm in the right chapter, but Hang on just a minute Yeah, I really was thinking we should probably stop at 17 because if we if we go on beyond that we'll get into More and more and more interesting things it is it is a I told you once I read through this particular book And it's a great exercise you're going to do a read through this and look at them in parallel and buy your own copy and make a lot of Marginal notes. This is the library copy my copies at home, but it is a very interesting exercise to do that And it what we're doing now in a micro scale you do that on macro scale you really get an impression of what is allowable in scripture What what are the working habits of a biblical? Historians now what we learn from this just As a start is that we need to be very careful with Looking at English text which have direct quotation marks and assuming that what we're getting is tape recordings You know or verbatim transcripts because if you have compare these two texts we discover that they're not exactly alike as one might expect if they were both Direct quotations such as you know according to the standards that we employ today now. It's a good for us to know that It doesn't undermine the veracity of the text it just helps us to understand it on its own terms as God intended it But what can we make more specifically? What kinds of inferences can we draw about the the the different purposes of The Samuel material these would be the Chronicles material perhaps thinking about the Audiences that they were addressing and the questions that they were asking what can we make from even these kinds of differences? Maybe not we may not be able to make something of all of them. There are various different reasons that Chronicles and Samu kings differ from time to time sometimes it's a text critical question as we saw with the Tribes and judges, you know shift a shoftay very much alike in Hebrew There sometimes it may have been that the Chronicle was drawing on a forelaga or a primary text that Differed slightly from the Samuel or King's material as we now have it Okay, so it may be something as simple as that sometimes it may be that the Chronicleer is is simply summarizing or generalizing What he is reading but sometimes I think the Chronicleer intentionally brings in some small alterations for a purpose and again I'm not saying he's distorting the facts and we'll talk about exactly what he is doing in just a minute But what would you make of some of these? What about that first one a shift from speaking of David in terms of King and speaking of David as David what might that accomplish? Yes Okay, okay It might help to help the people focus on the kind of King that God's going to accept being a Davidic kind of King all right? Yes Okay, it Okay, yeah, it might help them to Take a more personal view is the comment on what God is doing with David now think in terms of Again, thinking right here think in terms of the audience that the Chronicleer is addressing as opposed to David Bishop Okay, yeah, a possibility that that by by expressly naming David it clarifies what King is in view I think probably I mean if we looked at the Chronicleer's text. I think that's probably contextually clear Already in the broader context because this is the story as it was known so that probably would have been clear Yes Okay, is it to clarify that the covenant was made with David as a person rather than With the King as a position is the comment. Yeah, I think so I think that could be well What's going on here because think about it the the addresses of the Chronicleer coming back out of exile There is no King on the throne There is no throne the kingdom has fallen now people are returning to try to rebuild the temple But they're not rebuilding the throne. There's not a there's not a king. There's not a visible human king Insight and so the question it press is pressing if God promised something to Davidic kings Are those promises still in force and if so in what sense? Well the answer is God made a promise to David To a person now his descendants are still amongst us It wasn't so much that God made a promise to a king as that he made it to David a person so the Chronicleer wants to stress That this promise was a personal promise from God to David and his children after him and those children are still amongst us And so the promise is still in force We don't need a throne. We don't need a human throne for these promises to continue in force That's one possibility, you know, I think that makes sense. What if some of these others? What about this one your kingdom my kingdom in Let's see in second Samuel Chapter 7 Let's see where it is 16 all the way down there. Okay, your house and your kingdom will endure forever before me Your throne will be established forever Those are the words Spoken by God to David as recorded in second Samuel 7 and if someone had to say well Which is closer to the tape recording? I would probably choose second Samuel 7 as being closer to the tape recording closer to the actual words spoken But the Chronicleer rather than that says in second and first Chronicle 17 14 I will set him over my house and my kingdom forever His throne will be established forever. What do we make of that? Yes Okay, yeah, the the comment relates to the fact that when David was chosen He seemed to be God's choice as opposed to the people's choice. There is a real sense in which God identifies himself with David and David David is his king and in fact, he talks about I will I will be his father and he will be my son It's it's implicit in those words is the fact that the throne of David being established is in a very real sense God's throne and So if we look at the implications of that we we recognize that the the the Vedic kings in a very real sense occupy God's throne on earth now. They're not God's themselves. They're his representatives You know, they are his human But by his choice they occupy his thrones his throne look at first Chronicles 28.5 Now this is this is describing David's preparations for plans for a temple, which is described much more fully in Chronicles than it ever was in in Samuel and in verse 5 It says of all my sons and the Lord has given me many he has chosen my son Solomon to sit on the throne of the kingdom of the Lord over Israel So I see even David understood that his kingdom was really God's kingdom Visibly being manifest on earth. This was a theocracy Now the reason it's important then for those returning from exile to realize that the Davidic kingdom is not so much the thing as God's kingdom Is that the the the Davidic King is not on the throne, but God's kingdom remains nevertheless And so by this subtle change he takes what is implicit in the promise and makes it explicit in his particular Representation of the promise or in his rendition of the promise. Let's see what else might be significant well, you know this verse 14 of 2 Samuel 7 Chasened with the rod of men of with the flogging inflicted by men Those who had gone into exile were well aware of that they didn't need to hear that yet again They knew that they knew that happened because it had happened to them now. They're coming back They don't need that that discouraging word again. They've they've they've experienced that and so the chronicle Says you don't need to hear that again. You know it. You know it's there in in the the words that you and I know so well I don't want to major on that. I'm not even going to mention that as I as I recall this incident for you I want to be a little more encouraging than that Likewise, rather than being very specific and talking about Saul The the chronicle is interested in a way in expanding the promise and generalizing it and using more general terminology like your predecessor or this business about out of Egypt where he says In verse 6 in Samuel set for 2 Samuel 7 I have not dwelt in the house from the day I brought the Israelites up out of Egypt to this day Well by and by leaving out of Egypt in the text he would have made it very specific and Made and made the focus entirely on the deliverance out of Egypt out of the bondage there by leaving that out He's saying, you know, you could apply this promise really now to The deliverance we're experiencing coming out of another land of bondage You see so the chronicler is painting the picture with some different brush strokes including detail You know leaving out a few details that are not as pertinent for the picture He's trying to paint for his particular audience to get across the message that they need to hear Likewise with the arc of God the arc of the covenant of God By stressing the covenant again. He's saying yeah, the covenants are still in force for us And we could go on about this in fact if you hadn't noticed I did go on about this in the art of biblical history in chapter two at the end so You can go there and read more about that I didn't want to tell you that right off because I wanted you to go and do your own inspection of these texts and find these things again But there's a nice little parallel chart there that you can find that will help you with this if that's of any advantage But I think by looking at this kind of thing it does us alert us it does alert us to the way in which historiographers work now Let me see what else we may need to say about this as we think generally about the book of Chronicles In comparison to Samuel and Kings we noticed some other things if you were to look at a over arching structure of the two We would discover that there is an idealization of David in his line There's nothing said about the power struggle and the death with with Saul and The power struggle that went on with the house of Saul after his death There's nothing said of the murders of Abner and Ishma chef nothing of David's problems with Michael Saul's daughter his wife Or his son with Bathsheba none of these things are mentioned or are the the darker sides of Solomon mentioned What is the significance of this? I don't think the chronicler is at all attempting to rewrite history remember He's not trying to overpaint the earlier painting. He is painting another picture of the past to highlight certain elements that are important to his given audience Leaving out some of these darker tones does not mean at all that he's trying to distort the picture of the past he's he's giving a different he's looking at the past From a different light and that's very important for us. I think to understand The the shift of focus from David's kingdom to My kingdom that is the Lord speaking the shift from David's kingdom to Yahweh's kingdom I think encourages then the Messianic hope which comes more and more to characterize this time period The the idealization of David and the and the stress on the kingdom of Yahweh I think both stirred hope in a Davidic Messiah who was to come and these idealized kings like David or Solomon or Asa or Jehossaphat or Hezekiah or Josiah all of whom are perhaps a little more I hate to use even the word accurately but in kings we get a more well-rounded picture of their pros and cons They're good sides and their bad sides. They're their virtues and their flaws in chronicles. They're they're idealized and By virtue of this then the the Messianic hope is bolstered as we see them in Dwelling the throne of Yahweh and we have hope that as they were victorious over God's enemies and promoted covenant faithfulness so they serve as types of a greater son of David who would come and do even better than they who would fulfill these hopes of Victory and of covenant faithfulness in a way that even they were fell short of Okay, so I hope you know we could go on and on about the different aspects of the Chronicles method here, but I guess the main point I'm trying to get across is let's not just say to ourselves I think this is the way the Bible should have written its histories We need to look at it and see how it actually wrote its histories and then say what do we make of that? How do we understand it? How do we account for the differences when we know that both of these texts are divinely inspired? God knew what he was doing these are the paintings These are the pictures of the past that he wants us to to see and embrace What do we make of the differences? You know some critical scholars would say well, you know, they're simply contradictory and you can't have them both Well, I think that is as simplistic as looking at two portraits of an individual and saying they don't exactly match Therefore, they're one of them or both of them have to be inaccurate I think what we have in the Chronicleer is an attempt to draw out of the text that which is actually there But they're implicitly and make it explicit and actually present it as God's saying my kingdom rather than your kingdom

Any more that needs to be said on that any comments or questions on that I'm gonna kind of stop there because I do want to have time to do other things tonight So we're gonna take a funny break here in a little while, but not yet Yes, William Yeah, although I think that I think that concept was birth really with second Samuel 7 Already, you know, and those exceptional promises which David himself seemed to recognize were exceptional I'm sorry. I didn't repeat the question Would the people have thought of the of the phrase son of David as Messianic prior to the time of Chronicles it's hard to pin it down exactly, but I think so I think it was something that was gradually Growing in their consciousness. I don't think the people of Israel knew with certainty what shape the promises to David would take And probably most of them imagined a visible king sitting on a visible throne But there was there was something that about the promise that was so Magnificent that it exploded those normal categories and in time I think it became clear that God had something larger in view than than just that Okay, any other comments or questions Let me take this opportunity. We're not gonna take a break just yet And I don't know in terms of taping whether we want to get this or not We may because I want to take a little time now to talk about the exam while people have not Completely crumbled in the slight night session to talk a little bit about exam and to ask questions It may be good to go ahead and tape this in as much as people who view these tapes someday will be taking an Exam if not exactly the same exam that I'm going to talk about now so let me make a few general comments and Then I'll let you ask some questions. Hopefully not too specific questions like could you give me the answer to question number five or whatever the exam is going to be objective in nature is going to deal very largely with Bible content that is to say don't ignore everything else But Bible content is is very important. It will pick up where we left off in terms of The last the midterm, which means we pick up

Really it yeah, okay, I'm trying I was trying to recall myself Second Samuel you can tell I'm not quite finished with this exam yet At the beginning of second Samuel Okay, yeah, I The question is since I didn't ask a lot on first Samuel or anything on first Samuel in that test And people are standing here in the back am I gonna am I am I gonna pick up there? I'm trying to recall questions. I've already composed I you know I hate to make general statements. Let's say let's say haven't have a nodding acquaintance You should you shouldn't have a nodding acquaintance of what happens in first Samuel anyway. Yes Well, I think she's probably referring to after Saul is that right? Yeah, because there were some other questions on on first Samuel certainly the first seven chapters and such No, I don't think I did because I can't I can't I can't honest I'm trying to think through questions. I have already composed. I would hate to say nothing on first Samuel Yeah, I wish you weren't taking it. Um, yeah I Really for this for the midterm had we finished first Samuel before the midterm We didn't talk about Saul at all after that. Okay, crumbs. Okay, there will be nothing on Saul on this on this final and Yeah, well, I will go ahead and say nothing on first Samuel will pick up second Samuel and forward Now was that clear enough for you? Not second Samuel and forward Okay, all the way through Revelation All right Now there will be there you'll want to know the kings of Israel and Judah Okay, as I said, you know, we've drilled that from time to time. You'll want to know that you want to know significant dates Let's see in terms of in terms of secondary reading such as you've done in Howard You want to have a knowledge of the big things for instance in his discussion of Ezra Nehemiah and we are going to come to Ezra Nehemiah after a break and just a second But only briefly in his discussion of Ezra Nehemiah he does draw some conclusions on debated points in terms of You know, what was the what was the order of arrival of Ezra and Nehemiah was it Nehemiah Ezra was it Ezra and Nehemiah? Yeah, there you know exactly what does Howard think so when he comes to the bottom line of those discussions You should know where he stands on some of those things I wish I had my questions before me. I could be more helpful. Maybe I will be a little more helpful next time when you come early Yeah, you will have already studied, but you know that icing on the cake could be helpful Yes, questions Andrew Oh, yeah, I'm talking about the actual dates that are in bold Again, I don't have my I should be looking at a sheet really the dates are on the left hand column those are the ones I'm talking about I'm not talking about the the years of the King's reign Now if anyone wants extra credit by learning all of those will consider it, but I wouldn't suggest that that would be the profitable use of your time Yeah, so largely objective Kings of Israel and Judah important

Secondary reading be sure to know the main things there are a few questions about the artificial history questions you've seen before a Word to the wise questions you've seen before You can go visit the secretary and and have a look at them which is a good idea and part of the reason I do that is so that you can go and see Oh, I miss that I might want to go over it and see what you did or didn't miss Okay Her hours are really 7 30 to 4 4 30 Monday to Friday Is that impossible? That's true. It's hard for the evening classes Can you put a call in from work? Yeah, but there are all kinds of complications dealing with an evening class. Aren't there? Huh Yeah, there are all kinds of complications They're only a few by the way of these questions. Yes No, can you fax the quiz? You know can they fax the quiz to them? yeah I I really don't know how to handle this one if you're if you're locked in and can't possibly ever get by When the secretaries around Questions off the exam. Uh-huh Anyone have a better suggestion? No, there's a there's seriously there are only a few I would say if you can't get by to look at your Test the best thing really you can do is to to look back at your whatever few notes you may have taken on the book about the book I'm sorry, but I mean, I don't think it'll make a massive difference to you in a big way, but there are a few Yes It's more important that you know what you know it the well the order and the centuries the question is should you know what chapters the kings? occur and now you should you should have in terms of your knowledge of kings the books of kings you do want to have a Major block understanding of what happens where but when the kings of Israel and Judah or Judah are toggling back and forth and very confusing fashion That's going to be more difficult But you should know where a half for instance comes in his relationship with Elijah and Elijah and kind of the sequence That goes on there and the way in which I'll ask questions there if you have a a pretty straightforward knowledge of the of the larger Flow of the narrative you should be able by process of elimination to figure out what goes with what Okay other questions That means that means you don't have to have an exact knowledge that this king And this event occur exactly in this chapter As long as you know within a few chapters where it occurs because I'm not going to have things bang bang bang right together so that Intending to confuse you All right There are there is there is a matching format in there and also I should mention that the material we're going to cover after this break dealing with Ezra Nehemiah is on the exam and is reasonably important It'll be reasonably fresh so you want to give some attention to Ezra Nehemiah to in terms of Having a basic outline in mind for those and I hope you are turning in Ezra Nehemiah outlines tonight. Yes

Yes, there was one significant type of yes, yes I have but that's not that's not any security I will make I will try to get someone else to prove free to make sure Yes any other questions comments caveats yes at well Would you like an essay at this stage at this stage at this stage I have in mind purely objective so we can have a quick turnaround on grading Which is something they press us to they they throw us into inner term and yet they want our grades right away And it's going to be tough because I've got all kinds of exegesis papers to grade and some papers in this Class to so they'll As things now stand there is not an essay component to the test

Volunteers to prove free. Yes. Hold by all mean good suggestion. Yes Yeah as opposed to yeah Right and that question was rectified though. I don't know if you've seen your more recent grades But though we did go back and deal with that because that question did arise. Yes that question That did arise and so the grades were actually adjusted to make that better Okay, so obviously I mean I'll work I'll be working off my own understanding of The content of the books so what I put down as an outline you might think well that's kind of the way he sees it But I'm not gonna I will not have something exactly like that last that last one Okay, did you have another was that it I I don't think there's any going to be any fill in the blank you know, so it's all just you know Russian roulette Look we better not we'll stop with this one We'll stop with this one or that one these two because we do need to get some Ezra Nehemiah under our belt before we can quit tonight So yes Jennifer for Will there be anything from Matthews and Benjamin book? Um, have you read it? Yes, no Yes I just want to make sure you'd read it because that's the profit of doing it. Yes Yes, the answer was no How in death will I go with chronicles only the kinds of things we've talked about here? Okay, so I'm not gonna I don't expect you to have read chronicles All right, such an enlightening time. Did I say that was the last one one more? Oh, this is important. Yes, good question. Thank you for asking it. We were talking about it during the break The infamous reading report which never you've never seen You know be sure to fill it out according to the form which you never received You know, I had that had completely escaped my memory that you had never received that what I will do is next time When you take the exam there will be on the exam a place to record percentages So come prepared to say I have completed such and such percentage of the secondary reading Or the Bible reading Give me an honest answer. You will be signing your name to that So come prepared to give me that and that will suffice in this instance as as you're reading report save yourself the The trouble of recording every jot and tenel. Okay Can we stop and take a break? All right, we'll take a break. I'll talk to you during the break We'll take a break and come back and talk about Ezra Nehemiah Before our time is completely gone