<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
บริจาค บริจาครายเดือน

Biblical Overview of Worship 1

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Let's open a prayer. Father, we thank you for a time of refreshment and as we begin again in this pack together week of all 20 sessions in five days, we pray that you would give a strength and that you would be present with us as we now turn our attention from Genesis through Revelation to try to discern and understand what you've revealed regarding worship and what you desire from your people in relationship to you in worship. We pray that you would show us from your word by your spirit what you want us to know and take hold of and work into and out through our lives to others. So we wait upon you and look to you and thank you that you are God who desires to make yourself known in ways that relate to how you've made us and we pray that we would be attentive to you and to your word and we pray it in Jesus' name. Amen. Okay, we're going to look in this session at the Bible before Moses. Well, there is no written Bible before Moses, I guess, but looking primarily at Genesis and understanding what we can about worship from Genesis, pre-Moses. One of the things I think is important to understand is the way God has made himself known in the Scripture. He has not given us a Bible dictionary. It isn't like, okay, we want to know everything there is no about worship, we turn toward the back to the letter W and there we know everything we need to know about worship including three options for complete worship services and what to preach on when for a year at a time. Anyway, God has revealed Himself relationally in history, interacting with people, making Himself known in what we sometimes call a progressive unfolding revelation that keeps building upon what's come before and going somewhere. There's an end in view and so as we turn to the Scripture, we have to be discerning of the framework of Scripture itself so that we can take hold of the truths that God has revealed there regarding worship in a way that then applies to living in our place in the story between Pentecost, where Jesus sent the Holy Spirit to the church and His return. So even when we're approaching pre-Fall Genesis as we will be now, we're doing it as people who live post-Pentecost. We know more than just right here, but at the same time we have to get inside the part of the story in creation before the fall to try to understand what's being known to the original hearers of the Scripture that is given. So the framework of Scripture, which if you've had other courses, you have creation, fall, redemption and consummation. This is sort of the framework, but you not only have these large categories, but you need to understand that it's headed somewhere and what God reveals at this point, well what God reveals at this point carries forward everything in here as well. You don't just kind of take a slice out and say, this is where we are. So if we're here in the story after Pentecost before the second coming, we don't just open the New Testament. We look at all of the story that's come before starting in creation. And so we have this richness that helps us understand what's going on at this particular time, such as the outpouring of the Holy Spirit of Pentecost. There's pointers to that previously in the story that are very important in our understanding of it, in Joel chapter 2, for example. So you have, in many ways, you have a lot of what fits into, again, a large category of promise and fulfillment. And so when we talk about matters related to worship, I don't know of any church, any Christian church, that says it's appropriate to come to worship with bulls and goats and lambs and slaughtering them as part of our active worship. So everyone does something with what's come before and realizes that there are things that continue forward, and there are things that no longer continue because they've found fulfillment. Everyone would agree, based on 1 Corinthians 5, that Jesus is our Passover Lamb, or John 1, behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world. So there's something about who Christ is and what he's done in relationship to Passover meal in the Old Testament, sacrificial animals in the Old Testament that we need to learn from, but also place into the larger biblical context. So as we begin at Genesis, then, we try to understand as best we can what worship looked like before the fall. And that's a bit challenging because there's not a whole lot there in some sense that you can specifically say, oh, here's instruction on worship, on corporate public worship. You sort of have to put yourself in that context and ask some questions that get out what's going on there. And I would say that what I have discovered is that you have what I'm going to call the regular principle of life, the RPL. And in many ways, any discussion of the regular principle of worship, which we'll have a whole lecture on later, needs to be said in the context of the regular principle of life. What you read in the opening chapters of Genesis is there's a God who made all things and who is the sovereign ruler over all things, who has an expectation that the creatures made in his image will live before him and follow what he tells them to do. So he's created life and he regulates it for our good and for his glory. And so there's a sense in which you have Adam and Eve placed in a garden with certain parameters. They're not to eat of the tree of the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil, but there are other kinds of things. There seems to be a lot of freedom, a lot of latitude. We have the instruction, you know, a man shall leave his father and mother, and he joined his wife, he should become one flesh, and he's moved from multiply. So you have these sort of broad instructions that relate to life in the garden, they're to cultivate and tend to the garden, they're to subdue the earth and rule over it, they name the animals, and so on. So that you have activity going on, life and activity, that's really set in the context of the goodness and the greatness of this God, who has made this amazing creation, creatures in his image with whom he has a relationship, that he calls them to live a life under him. In many ways, you have man in the generic sense, I guess we'll do it this way.

Adam and Eve made in God's image have a relationship of serving and worshiping God in the broad sense of worship. They have a relationship to the rest of creation in which they are to be stewards or caretakers of the creation, and they have a relationship that will use the term a guardian of the dignity and the value of other creatures made in the image of God. So it's man in God's world, a little book that I read years ago and used in a class when I used to teach at Geneva College called Man in God's World, by man named Paul Scrottenbore, which is an interesting Dutch name. I can't tell you much more about the information about that little booklet, but it was very formative in my understanding of these various relationships for Adam and Eve in the garden before the fall by God's design, that they're to serve him, they're to care for one another, they're to be stewards of the creation. And there's a sense in which all of life is lived before the face of God as an act of worship. They walk with him, he talks with them, there's this dynamic of relationship that is there prior to sin entering the world. Now, as we think about that,

there's what I would call it, a closeness, there's an intimacy of fellowship with God and with each other that is by God's design, that they're to live in the midst of. And a lot of these good things that he's developed are there, they're able to be lost, but they've been given from the goodness of God out of his love for his creatures and his creation. So in many ways you could look at the first two chapters of Genesis and say, well, about all we can say about worship relates more to this category of all of life as worship. And I think a great deal of it does. In the pre-fall world, the kind of the moving in and out of what we have called corporate public worship and all of life as worship seems to me to be more seamless in its connection. But I think it's there. And here's where I think it's there. It's in Genesis chapter 2, verses 2 and 3. It has to do with the instituting of the Sabbath, which comes before the fall. Make an advertisement for access, residency classes now to those on film, serving even Starbucks coffee. So you'll want to get signed up for one of this courses really soon. How do you like that?

Okay. Now that that advertising paid an unpaid advertisement. I get paid the same amount regardless. Look at Genesis 2, verse 2. By the seventh day, God had finished the work He had been doing. So on the seventh day, He rested from all His work. And God blessed the seventh day and made it holy because on it, He rested from all the work of creating that He had done. Now what jumps out at you in that verse, those two verses, that would seem to help us understand the significance of this seventh day. Okay? The seventh day blessed. Now, were the other six days not blessed?

Oh, the other six days. There's nothing bad about the other six days. But there is something about the seventh day that He's distinguishing, not in one's bad one's good. But in the all is good, and this one is blessed in some way. Okay? What else? Okay. Holy. What's the root of the word holy?

Does it mean the other days are not holy? Okay. I think it's the number seven. The number seven is a holy number. That's supposed to be number two. I got the seventh day on my mind's there. Okay? It's set apart from the other six days. Now, there's no sin in the world yet. Okay? But the seventh day is being set apart from the other six for a particular purpose. Okay? That relates to what? Rest. Okay? All right. So you have the creation, you have the seven days, and this seventh day, God is resting, and He's setting apart and blessing this seventh day for the purpose of rest. Now, what do you think? I mean, I'm going to give you permission for some sanctified speculation. Okay? Certain other professors at the seminary that don't give such permission. So consider yourself either blessed or cursed accordingly. What do you think the seventh day looked like for Adam and Eve before the fall? I think now in New England or in New England, it's probably looked like all the other days, in a way, and I can specifically what they did of how that seventh day interrupted or that specific seventh day that God rested on. The ongoing seventh days in light of what God does here in Genesis 2.3. That was a prefall. Yeah, probably looked a lot like every other day of them hanging out, enjoying everything appreciated, everything, what should be God. Yeah, it's hard for us to imagine any day without sin. And if every day was without sin, it would seem like one that's set apart for particular purpose in one sense because all the others also don't have sin, that it may not be as, I mean, and that's the problem with sanctified speculation is it's not the way things are. But there is something that the Bible then, and we can't help but know what the Bible does later because of where we live in the story. We know some things about the 10 commandments and the seventh. We know about the second giving of the law in Deuteronomy 5, which where there's a linking not only of a creational rest, but a celebration of God's redemption that's connected to the fourth commandment of remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. Well, the idea of the Sabbath day being holy, it comes here in the garden. The keeping of it holy is the keeping of it holy, but there is a certain, there's certain things that begin to, in a fallen world, be attached to that seventh day that relate to rest and redemption, obviously not redemption in this prefall garden. But there is something special about the day. I think we can say that. What is God told us about the seventh day before the fall? It's a day for rest, reflecting his rest. It's a day that's blessed, it's a day that's set apart. Chapter 215 verse 15 says, the Lord took the man, put him in the garden of Eden to work it and take care of it. So part of what Adam and Eve were to do in the garden was to work it and take care of it. Though we know that the sweat of the brow and the thorns and that they weren't pulling thorns and thistles yet, because that came after the fall. But there was some kind of tending to the garden. Again, we aren't given the detail that we can imagine and might want. But one of the things that I've, again, one of the things that I've recently become, enjoyed more than I ever had in the rest of my life has been sort of taking care of flowers and plants around the house. Maybe Jeremy's wearing off of me in multiple ways. Love, we have brought in a plant today over here.

Thank you. And there is a, there's a, you know, I water them. It's not particularly difficult, although, you know, is that because of the curse that they have to be watered away? I, I, you know, like, pick off the dead flowers. Okay. It's not particularly sweat of the, of the brow sort of work. I guess I can, and again, it's hard to imagine. I guess there are probably certain things that, you know, maybe there's such an abundance of fruit that, you know, some fruit fell to the ground and before they could eat it all and it rotted and they sort of put it over here in the compost pile for something else that God was going to make grow. I don't know. Okay. But it seems like there's certain activity, work the guard, work, work the guard. Well, the other word that it said, work it and take care of it. Well, in some way, they're on, on the seventh day, they're not working in and taking care of it in the same way. I don't know exactly what that looks like, but I think that's fair to say. Because it's, it's pattern after what God does. God is working for six days, morning, evening, and then he enters into a rest and the pattern, especially later in the, in the revelations we'll see, it's following after God's pattern in the doing of God. So I think there's, there's at least some preliminary foundation being laid for what we would call, but we may call it in this course of our corporate public worship. Now, I'm not going to suggest you that this, these first two chapters of Genesis, enable us to say that, you know, Adam and Eve went to church on Sunday. Okay. They obviously didn't get clothed in their Sunday best just yet. Um, because they're already wearing their everyday best, right? So they got together and maybe reflected. Maybe it's a celebration. Maybe it's a delighting in God and what he had made in the way he had made men in a way that was more reflective than the day-to-day. Again, we don't, we don't know for sure, but I think what we can say is that this, in the seventh day, God rested, he blessed the day, he made it holy and this becomes a pattern, a creational pattern of one day and seven for rest and maybe reflection and delight and celebration. Maybe not too much of a stretch to put that in there. Um, that's appropriate to the day. It doesn't mean the other days are bad. This means there's a distinction made to this day. And I think you can clearly make a case for this, there's something distinguishable about this day that doesn't relate to sin just the way it relates to God's design, his structuring and ordering of things. So the main thing to remember, I think, though, is this intimacy of relationship, living life before the face of God, offering up their lives to God, almost as a living sacrifice sort of thing, more under this regular principle of life. He has a few things to say about work, attending the garden. He has a few things to say about marriage and family and Genesis chapter 2, part of the ordering of life, as a few things to say about this seventh day. Sometimes we've called those the three creation institutions, our work, marriage and rest. And beyond that, we don't have a whole lot more than we can say. We begin to see what happens then in the fall, where Adam and Eve, when they disobey God's command, there are serious consequences. They are fear God in a way that they want to hide from you. They are ashamed of their nakedness and want to cover it. They are alienated from God and eventually put out of the garden. So there's distance and separation. This intimacy of relationship is lost. And there are consequences that follow, that are just sort of summarized under the terms of separation and distance. Because this becomes important later in the pattern of the tabernacle and the temple and the drawing near to God and how you come near to God with blood sacrifice and so on. And only the high priest on the day of atonement into the Holy of Holies. It's partly a matter of distance that was lost being regained and restored. Which ultimately is part of what Christ has come to do is to bridge the distance, the separation between God and sinful people, that we might be able to be brought near by the blood of Christ. See, there's that language there too. So there's nearness that's lost by the fall that God in His grace must initiate activity, provide covering for them those sorts of things to restore fellowship between Himself. Now, I think Genesis 4 begins to give us an idea with Canaan Abel. Abel, do you want to say anything at this point or comment or ask a question? Okay.

The account of Canaan Abel bringing of offerings to God begins to show us and reveal to us that there is something going on here that has to do with the manner of approaching God with a sacrifice. We don't have instruction, we don't have what God gave to Canaan Abel or Adam and Eve about any instruction about this. We have a narrative account of two sons of Adam and Eve who are approaching God in what I think we would call worship. Okay. And if you look, let me read Genesis 4 1 to 7. Adam lay with his wife Eve, she became pregnant, gave birth to Canaan. She said, with the help of the Lord I brought forth a man. Later, she gave birth to his brother Abel. Now Abel kept flocks and Cane worked the soil. In the course of time, Cane brought some of the fruits of the soil as an offering to the Lord. But Abel brought fat portions from some of the first born of his flock. The Lord looked with favor on Abel and his offering, but on Cane and his offering, he did not look with favor. So Cane was very angry and his face was downcast. Then the Lord said to Cane, why are you angry? Why is your face downcast? If you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do what is right, sin is crouching at your door. It desires to have you, but you must master it. Now, a lot of people have said a lot of things about what's going on in this passage. And you know, I remember as a child in Sunday school, that was basically the simple version of the explanation of this is Cane didn't offer an animal sacrifice with blood and Abel did, and so Abel's sacrifice was accepted and Cane wasn't. Now, I don't think that's the primary thing that's going on here. The fact that it says this was Abel's work dealing with flocks, and this was Cane's work killing the soil. The fruit of their work was being offered to God.

And I think you can make something of the distinction here between Cane brought some of the fruit of the soil in verse three, verses Abel brought fat portions from some of the first born of his flock. There seems to be a quality of sacrifice, whether it's grain or animal, that I think you can make some distinction here just in the narrative account as it's given. But I think the main thing behind that, that produced the different quality of sacrifice, we actually get some insight in looking at Hebrews chapter 11, verse four, where we have New Testament inspired commentary on this event. By faith Abel offered God a better sacrifice than Cane did. By faith he was commanded as a righteous man, when God spoke well of his offerings, and by faith he still speaks even though he is dead. Now, I think that what's behind, what's the difference between Cane and Abel, what made his offering better is it was offered from a heart of faith. Now, I don't want to diminish the importance of fat portions of first, what's it called, first form of the flock. But I think that was a fruit of a heart of faith toward God. And even Cane here is given an opportunity it seems to approach God correctly. The Lord asked him why he's angering downcast, saying if you do what is right, will you not be accepted? Even if you want to adopt the theory that they're next to be blood sacrifice, and I've talked this issue through with Dr. Collins and he doesn't think the issue is about blood either, so I feel I'm fairly safe, though not infallible ground with Dr. Collins. But even if it were that, the opportunity for him to have given some grain to his brother to get a first born from the flock to offer was readily available there. It isn't like poor Cane didn't have anything to offer well. There are ways of working something out to get something from your brother here in an above board appropriate way. But I think what Cane needed to do in response to the Lord, the Lord is almost coming to him in a gracious manner and saying, okay, you don't need to be downcast, you can go about this the right way. So that point I think would have involved a sort of repentance and faith in offering of the best of his grain, okay, kind of thing. But I think what comes through here is the need to approach God with his distance and separation, to approach God with a heart of faith coming with a sacrifice. That seems to be a principle that as we look further in the story at the way God gives much more information in the most egg legislation regarding the sacrificial system. It's coming in faith before God with the right kind of sacrifice as we approach drawing near to him, okay, and even the priest needing offer sacrifices on their own behalf as the book of Hebrews points out so clearly. When you draw near to God you come recognizing your sin. You come in repentance faith that he invites you, but holding on to a provision of a sacrifice knowing that without that you risk yourself being struck down because of your sin and just in terms of an overall principle of worship that we have here. Okay, any thoughts on that? Questions? Okay.

I jumping forward then to the patriarchs. You have a number of places that we can look at Genesis 4, verse 26, for example. A lot of these things just kind of appear in the narrative without a lot of explanation. Seth also had a son and he named him Inosh. At that time men began to call on the name of the Lord. Again, what exactly does that mean? Obviously it's in the narrative, it's in the account. It seems to be connected to a son of Seth named Inosh. Now, as you remember worship Inosh, the S.H. at the end, it's kind of an evil thing. These are all my little things that I had to pass you know, the Bible content, exams and things like that. But it seems to be implying in verse 26 that people may be implying that people came together to call on the name of the Lord. And that's maybe a new thing that's happening in this time. Enough people have been born in the line of Seth that and of course we know that Adam and Eve had other sons and daughters who were having children and so on so that the earth is being populated so that and they're living a long time and having sons and daughters. So I guess you live to see your great great great great great grand children or something like that. It's sort of normative before the flood. When you look at the ages of people and imagining them, it doesn't say anything. They quit having children when they went through a menopause at 40. Menopause may have been at 400 or something. I don't know. I'm just speculating how sanctified this speculation is but anyway. So it seems like here is things unfold that there is potentially in Genesis 426 a time when people began to get together to call on the name of the Lord together which may be at first at least illusion to something like what we would later call corporate public portion. In the time of Noah in Genesis 8 verses 20 to 21 after the flood, part of the reason that there were seven clean animals and only two of the unclean animals that went into the ark was so there would be opportunity to make sacrifices while allowing time for the animals to procreate and have more. So what what we are told in verse 18 Noah came out of the ark together with his sons and his wife and his sons wise all the animals and all the creatures that move along the ground and all the birds everything that lose on the earth came out of the ark one kind after another then Noah built an altar to the Lord and taking some of all the clean animals and clean birds he sacrificed burnt offerings on it the Lord smelled the pleasing aroma and said in his heart never again will I curse the ground because of man even though every indication of his heart is evil from childhood and never again will I destroy all living creatures as I have done as long as the earth endures seat time and harvest cold and heat summer and winter day and night will never cease. Now to put this into the context of what just happened namely the destruction of everything except Noah misses Noah there are three sons and their wives and the animals two of every unclean kind and seven of every clean animal and again we don't have a description of a list of clean and unclean animals we just sort of know somehow Noah knew things that were not told and God's a lot to do that God's a lot to deal with Noah and tell him things that he doesn't tell us okay it's okay he created us with minds that could ask more questions and he's agreed to give answers to okay and we sort of have to come to grips with that some people died before they come to grips with that sort of like I must know and we sometimes press wanting to know more than God has designed to give us to know I mean we were talking to break with trip a little bit about this whole thing about Jesus as our worship leader in him being fully God and fully man and how he can offer worship and receive worship and we're up against the limits of our capacity to understand two of the deepest mysteries in all of God's revelation that he has given us the Trinity and the incarnation of God the Son and we should keep pressing to know what he has told us and the right implications of it for something like worship which for me is new territory in this whole idea of Jesus being present declaring his name and singing praises but we have to rest that in God as God understanding things that we don't and thank God that our ability to experience the blessings and benefit of these deep mysteries is not connected to our capacity to understand them if we only experience the blessing of the Trinity and the incarnation of the degree that we understood the Trinity and the incarnation we would be at a great loss we experience way more blessing because those things are true

beyond our comprehension than if they were only true to our level of comprehension that was another rabbit trail okay a good one um what we begin to see here is that that Noah Noah has been spared by the grace of God undeserved he found favor with God grace and now the first thing he does when he gets off of the at off of the ark is he offers this humongous bird offering of many animals and and the sweet smelling I mean it says it doesn't say how many he took but it seems like it was quite a few some of all the clean animals and clean birds now if it means some of every kind that they had seven of that's a lot okay I mean this is a the sweet smelling aroma that God smelled in verse 21 um you know there was a there was an approaching of this God who had spared and by his grace there isn't there isn't a presuming upon God's grace huh you know I was spared no one else was I want to go off the ark I'm going to be king of the whole universe there was a sort of being spared getting off the ark and offering as an act of worship to God these these whole burn offerings um I think is a reflection of Noah by faith goes forward in relationship to God and wants to come before him recognizing that he's holding and we're not and to live out life in that context in in Genesis 12 skipping over to Abraham in verses 6 through 8 you see a pattern that begins among Abraham and his his offspring Abraham traveled through the land as far as the side of the great tree of Maurek at Shechem at that time the Canaanites were in the land the Lord appeared to Abraham and said to your offspring I will give this land so he built an altar there to the Lord who had appeared to him from there he went on toward the hills east of Bethel and pitched his tent with Bethel on the west and AI on the east there he built an altar to the Lord and called on the name of the Lord there's this pattern of the building as they are nomadic people traveling around and God meets them and does things in their lives or makes promises to them they build an altar and they offer sacrifice they're called upon the name of the Lord

there's a desire to sort of mark and remember these key redemptive events and promises with acts of worship that are connected to them then you of course have the the Genesis 22 passage of Abraham being called to sacrifice his son Isaac and I think one of the key things to remember here was this belief on Abraham's part that the Lord would provide he tells that to Isaac and and again looking at Hebrews chapter 11 this is he was 11 or Romans 4 where he believed God would bring him back from the dead if that might be in

oh yeah 1119 Abraham reason that God could raise the dead and figuratively speaking he did receive Isaac back from death he so believed in God's promise that he believed he would receive him back from the dead even if he had to go all the way through with the sacrifice of his son and then the ram and the think of his God's gracious provision to Abraham which was not made for God the Father in the giving up of his own son on the cross so I think there's some things we can we can see here one more a joke chapter 1 again we don't we don't know exactly when Job lived or who his forefathers were I think best guess is that he was probably a descendant of Shem not in the line of Abraham who lives sometime approximately around the time of Abraham that's a guess okay we don't know that's it seems in terms of the nomadic nature of things and and lots of sort of flocks and herds in some way he's parallel to Abraham some of that but the key thing about Job is that we see in just beginning chapter 1 verse 1 in the land of us there lived a man whose name was Job this man was blameless and upright he feared God and shunned evil he had seven sons and three daughters and he owned seven thousand sheep three thousand canals five hundred Job de Voxen and five hundred donkeys and had a large number of servants he was the greatest man among all the people of the east his sons used to take turns holding feast in their homes and they would invite their three sisters to eat and drink with them when a period of feasting had run its course Job would send and have them purified early in the morning he would sacrifice a burn offering for each of them thinking perhaps my children have sinned and cursed God in their hearts this was Job's regular custom now it looks like potentially with the seven sons that they took turns each day of the week eating feasting in each of their homes kind of rotating around and you know the three sisters they must have loved their sisters really well you know or maybe they just every third day they went to another sister's house I don't know there was some kind of cycle that Job had the regular pattern at the end of where he would offer sacrifices on behalf of his children and notice here not necessarily because of obvious outward sinful rebellious behavior but he was concerned that maybe in their hearts they had cursed God this is some good parenting principles here in terms of our being concerned not just about the outward behavior of our children but being concerned about what's going on in their hearts as well which I think is a you know to connect offering a sacrifices around a concern for sins in the heart is an interesting convergence here in this account of Job so I think there's some some principles here under the worship of the patriarchs that that seem to be what's going on at that point in the story of redemption the father acts pretty much as the priest there's not a distinction between you know the kingly tribe and the priestly tribe the father acts as the priest offering these sacrifices he doesn't call on a priest to come and do this sacrifices are made there's the the burn offerings of Noah there's similarly with with with Job here burn offering seems to be the the most normal offering as compared to some of the the more sophisticated distinguishing of different sin offerings and peace offerings and burn offerings and so on later there's a calling upon the Lord in connection with the sacrifices and there's a recognition that God in his grace is the one who provides he's the one that's being called upon there's a dependence upon him a desire to be right with him a desire to an approaching of him with the kind of respect and honor and even a right kind of fear of his holiness and yet an approaching him nonetheless to draw near to him coming with a sacrifice when you think back to the garden in that distance an attempt to bridge that distance with some kind of faith in the heart and a sacrifice in the hands calling upon God thanking him seeking his forgiveness for sin like with Job and his children along the way so I think you see some shaping of things in the narrative that as we'll look at next time under Moses are instituted into the very ceremonial law of Israel in the in the sacrificial system later it's more complex it's more sophisticated it's more specific instructions as well as narrative see what we're lacking up to to now is thus say at the Lord when you come together to call upon my name I want you to do this and this and this and I want to have priests to address like this and this and this and this have been purified in this way and this way in this way okay that's to come but I think you see some kind of precursors to that some anticipation of that some principles that work here in the period of the patriarchs as you go along okay thoughts questions on that this is kind of a this is a both both with the Genesis account in the patriarchal period you know working almost completely from narrative passages what what I've tried to do is to show some principles without being too dogmatic about what was actually going on where we don't have sufficient narrative or it or the instruction that would inform the actions of some of these people along the way we're talking about at this point in the narrative right this earlier stage were you saying that we're not sure where Joe actually fits in right okay yeah I don't know if you had what class is that taught in here what did our what do you remember from Psalms and wisdom about the placement of Joe time wise you did not discuss that to refer to old Testament introduction materials I just I just you know step out boldly here and give my speculation I think the principle nonetheless is clearly there the the connecting of sacrifice with sin in the heart I think is is an important convergence here that's overt in the biblical account all right ready for break