<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
ስጦታ ወርሒ ስጦታ

Making Sense of Revelation - Eschatology Conference Q&A

January 1, 1900
0:000:00

Our first question, which is a very profound question, what are the different resurrections mentioned in Revelation chapter 20? And the mic immediately goes to Dr. Biel. If you want the succinct answer, I give you the succinct comment here. That is a great question by the way. I think that's a really important. They heard my answer this one a minute and a half or so. Hey, I was just speaking. Let me up here again. If you're turning to Revelation 20, please. The question was what are the two resurrections? Okay. I'll just give you a thumbnail sketch of what I think. Revelation chapter 4. I'm sorry. 20 in verse 4. Revelation 20 in verse 4. I saw thrones and I sat upon them. Judgment was given to them. And I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of the testimony of Jesus. Because the Word of God and those who had not worshipped the beast or his image, you know, had not received the mark upon their forehead and upon their hand. And they came to life and ran with Christ for a thousand years. The rest of the dead not come to life until the thousand years were completed. This is the first resurrection. The less it and holy is the one and as a part in the first resurrection. Over these, the second death has no power, but they'll be priest of God and the Christ and ran them for a thousand years. So there are two resurrections here. You'll notice those who've been persecuted in verse 4 and there is another group. I think it is a separate group. There's debate about it. It says those who had not worshipped the beast or his image. Perhaps who had died in their faith and not through persecution. That all of them at the end of verse 4 came to life and ran with Christ for a thousand years. Then verse 5. The rest of the dead who did not come to life and ran for a thousand years, the rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were completed. So there are two resurrections. So some think these are both physical. Jews who have been persecuted according to the dispensational pre-millennialists and many pre-millennialists believe that Jews who have been persecuted as Christian witnesses during the tribulation will be raised and they will inhabit the millennium and more children will be born during this period. But it's a physical resurrection and then at the end of the millennium there is another resurrection. Verse 5 the rest of the dead not come to life until the thousand years were completed. So they're both physical resurrections. I rather think that the resurrection of verse 5 I agree it is a physical resurrection. Most commentators agree. A inaugurated millennialist or a millennialist is the same thing. Agree with pre-millennialists that verse 5 is a physical resurrection where the disagreement is is in verse 4. They came to life pre-millennialist believe that that is a physical resurrection. The inaugurated millennialist believe that it is a spiritual resurrection. And so here is why I take it as a spiritual resurrection and not physical. And I want to go back and look at the notion that there are two deaths in this passage. This is really the view of Merineth Klein which I think is he's right on. There are two deaths and we're going to find out if we can understand those two deaths I think we'll get a better grasp on the two resurrections. Look at the first death. It's given to us. In verse 4 I saw the souls who've been beheaded because of the testimony of Jesus and because of the word of God. Okay so that's a physical death there. Then notice verse 6. Blessed and holy is the one that has a part in the first resurrection over these. The second death has no power. Both pre-millennialists and homelanelists tend they're always exceptions but they tend to agree that the second death is an eternal death. It's not destruction. It's not annihilationism. Some Christians hold two but people unbelievers are raised physically and yet they experience a spiritual death forever. Separate from the Lord. So there's clearly here isn't there a physical death. Those who are beheaded and verse first part of verse 4 and then there's a spiritual death. The two deaths are opposite to and different from one another in kind. Could it be that that's what's going on with the resurrections? Just as you have two deaths, one spiritual, one physical. Maybe there's a mirror image of the two resurrections as well. In fact I think it fits the ironic tendency of the book of Revelation. For example in chapter 6 people die but they're exalted to the altar in heaven. Their death just causes them to have an escalated existence of blessing. So likewise the people in chapter 4 who are killed in persecution, physically they're translated immediately to a further resurrection existence. Greater than the resurrection existence they had while on earth because they were regenerated. Their resurrection had begun but it's like they're being raised as a result of their physical death. They go on to an even more escalated resurrection life hence they come to life. At the end of the age there will be a physical resurrection of both believer and unbeliever. Now the unbeliever, very interestingly, when they are physically raised at the end of the age they go to spiritual death. So it's just the opposite. Believers, when they physically die they experience an escalated resurrection life. When unbelievers at the end of the age physically are raised they experience a spiritual death. But let me go further at verse 4 where it says at the end in verse 4, they came to life. It is probable that that is an illusion to Ezekiel chapter 37 where the Valley of Dry Bones, God, breathes them to them and it says and they came to life in Greek. It's very same phrase and there are other Ezekiel illusions in this passage. Dr. Johnson talked about them this morning but even illusions to Ezekiel 37. In fact the last part of this book is based on Ezekiel 37 to 40. And so it makes great sense. In fact this isn't just some random language. They came to life. Is the dry bones coming to life? Now was that physical resurrection life in Ezekiel 37? Well if you read it very carefully it's a development of chapter 36 where it says I'll put a new heart in them and I'll put my spirit in them. It's regenerative. It's regeneration. It's a it's a resurrection life spiritually. In Ezekiel 36 and that's probably what it is in 37. Dr. Mosto-Tolak-El-Tessam-Skullis agree that chapter 37 is about a prophecy about Israel's return to from exile and most agree that it is not a physical resurrection prophecy but the time when Israel would experience spiritual resurrection. Of course the Israel there is really in the light of the New Testament the people of God and so even the use of scripture here Ezekiel 37.4 and they came to life is about in time Israel and the in time people of God coming to resurrection life spiritually. So I don't Dr. Johnson might want to maybe add a little to that. Be happy for you. I'll say Amen. My conclusions are actually what Dr. Vios has said. The one thing I think that would be that I would add is that the view that he's expounded here which shows us that the bodily resurrection of believers and the bodily resurrection of unbelievers is what we would read in chapter 20 verse 12. I saw the dead great and small standing before the throne and the books were opened because in verse 13 the sea has given up its dead who are in it and death and he's given up the dead. The resurrection of believers and unbelievers at the second coming of Christ after the thousand years and death is destroyed at that point shows that John's visions here coincide precisely with what the Apostle Paul says about resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15. At the return of Christ those who are in Christ are raised and the last enemy death is destroyed. The great problem seems to me in what I was taught growing up in a pre-millennial setting is I was taught to think that believers were raised and they were at the beginning of a millennial period and then there was a long period of time and then there was another rebellion and then finally death was destroyed but the connection between the resurrection of believers and the destruction of the last enemy death was separated by centuries of millennium right whereas Paul says it's together the resurrection of believers bodily resurrection of believers that second resurrection for us the entry into the second death for unbelievers but that bodily resurrection of believers at the return of Christ is the destruction of the last enemy death so it fits perfectly with what John sees in Revelation 2011 and following as well. One other thing in conjunction with Dr. what doctor it's wonderful to pat each others back here. There's only one resurrection mentioned in the whole Bible elsewhere and if there are two physical resurrections this is the only passage and in pre-millennials agree with that they say it's progressive revelation all things are possible but not all things are probable I think there needs to be something else by the way some would say we'll be able to really aren't two there's not a physical death and spiritual death it's not called that in Revelation so you can't make the converse be true with the resurrection and yet in chapter 21 it says in verse four got a wipe away every tear from their eyes there shall no longer be any death there shall no longer be any mourning or crying or crying the first things have passed away the first the first physical death is called the first things the first and then you got a second spiritual death right there in 21-8 so we clearly have a physical death and a spiritual death and I think it's likely that there's a mirroring by the way one last point because this is such an important passage it's the one that's debated it's the one it causes us to be called pre-millennial as non-millennial supposed millennials and pan-millennials etc. and it's this Revelation 1 6 and Revelation 5 10 says you are a kingdom and priests that's a past and present tense reality that 5 10 goes on and says you're a kingdom and priests and you and they are raining on the ear there's a textual problem there some have a future tense but what's very clear even if it's a future tense they're raining now because they are a kingdom and priests look at chapter 20 in verse 6 blessed and holy is the one who has a part of the first reservoir in the first resurrection over these the second death has no power now look at this they'll be priests of God and Christ and will reign with him for a thousand years one thing that's true in the book of Revelation scholars are realizing it more and more and more many have mentioned it today is intertextuality the way to interpret the book of Revelation is the way we interpret scripture generally interpret scripture by scripture interpret a book by itself the kingdom the kingdom and priesthood of believers has begun according to chapter 5 chapter 1 verse 6 and chapter 5 verse 10 what's characteristic of the millennium being priests and raining in the kingdom I would say what we have in the light of 1 5 1 6 5 10 in this text and 20 isn't already and not yet millennium clearly this text is developing chapter 1 and verse 6 and chapter 5 and verse 10 and it's clearly inaugurated as far as I can tell well I think we've I don't know if we should keep going but maybe stop this whole discussion brings back a day a long ago as a former dispensationalist reading lad and Dean Alfred being convinced that the first resurrection if it's spiritual destroys the idea of the second resurrection being literal they both have to be physical or the passage makes no sense and then reading Meredith Klein's essay his debate with Ramsey with Michael's good his name correct yeah and they Ramsey Michael's and they debate the revelation 20 and that just I'll never forget that a reading Klein's essay on the first resurrection and the panic that set in but this is huge if you're pre-Malino this is this is the benchmark I think is to whether you're pre or on on that passage and I would encourage you to read the discussions in their commentaries because they both handle that very very well next question no controversy here yes you may you're on we don't want to beat this to death but what's interesting is this is not biblical evidence but around 115 AD a man going to martyrdom in Rome church father Ignatius wrote several letters from Smirna one of these places cities and he has a very similar interpretation of that text it's implied in what he says but he has this ironic statement about not preventing me from coming to life and he's referring to his death I actually think it's an allusion to this text he has a similar interpretation going way back and you know this is we're tied in with people throughout church history and in a sense too often American Christians think back you know 20 years but if you reach back further you'll find that many of the interpretations that you've heard today are really much more ancient and widespread than you may know this is working look at verse four chapter 20 I saw thrones and they sat upon them you do a word study on thrones in the book of Revelation it occurs about 45 times guess what not one time does it refer to a throne on earth a couple of times it's about Satan's throne but it's really in another dimension all the other thrones are in heaven especially in the plural but even the singular you're God's throne Christ's throne this is a heavenly throne unless this is the only use no premillennialist wants to say that the word resurrection one of the words used for anostasis is only used 42 times it's used almost always it's used as a physical resurrection but the word never occurs in the book of Revelation except here in the word Zah-o in so way another word was translated in 24 they came to life Zah-o they came to life that word typically is used of God who lives forever and ever it's used in spiritual ways ways in the book of Revelation and elsewhere so those are just a few important points to add it's an important passage no controversy here to all the speakers the dating of the book of Revelation one of the evidences to support the dating of Revelation after 8070 and is there any evidence for interpreting a dating prior 8070 this gets it's a question of preterism and I look at Dr. Baugh who I know has done a great deal of work in this area yeah there are just too many things to say one of the things that is interesting in the preterist argument in particular they make up a really heavy lean heavily on the idea that Nero's persecution was empire-wide and all the evidence points against that and I actually think it's impossible according to Roman law they didn't have that developed and I can show you text where emperors later in the second century clearly show that there was no empire-wide policy on any topic it was actually developing in the second century so the idea of an empire-wide persecution of Christians really just isn't legally possible and there's no evidence for it the only evidence for Nero's persecution it says explicitly in the city of Rome and it didn't go anywhere else and what we hear from people who want to place the persecution occurring in Asia Minor and John himself in Patmos many of the arguments are really exceedingly weak and I think impossible if you know Roman history or the first century history so you know I don't want to get into all the details of that but it's really I've studied that in some detail and it's really problematic now I personally think that the ancient church testimony that John was written in around the middle of the reign of Demetian so round 95 is the best evidence we have and the text itself supports that in many ways one of them is the interesting the Church of Leodicea who said to be rich and in need of nothing was totally wiped out by earthquake in the time of Nero early on and or at the end of Claudius's reign and it's really if you think about ancient building methods and how long it would take to rebuild a stone city essentially that was their major building material back then to say a few years later while you're rich to this city that is widely testified to that had been utterly destroyed you know a few years after their total destruction to say while you're rich you have noting nothing it just seems too early whereas in the time of demission which would be you know roughly 30 years later yes you could say that they'd had time to rebuild and overcome some of their devastation in fact that's somewhat true of Asia Minor the first century in Asia Minor they were still recovering from some very significant warfare that had taken place throughout the whole region the rise of Augustus and he fought with Mark Antony and a lot of that war and and the plundering of for paying for the wars took place from those cities in Asia Minor they were poverty-stricken they were really overcoming a lot of problems so to trace revelation early on in the time of Nero just that's just one little you know indicator that's really problematic whereas later in the century you do see a bloom in building going on later in the century in that area they they finally had some stability and prosperity so there are also textual indicators but you know again you have to start getting into you know particular texts that I think suggest a later date let me supplement a little but I think the question of dating needs to be addressed in light of the kind of historical and textual thing evidence that Dr. Bajas gave us and I just a little bit of a personal hunch but the the arguments for a very early dating of revelation even before 70 AD before the fall of Jerusalem typically seemed to be to be more motivated by a conviction that the main thrust of revelations critique is against Judaism that has not received welcome Jesus then to warn the church as Dr. Biel as an incident mentioned and to fortify the church to face persecution from Rome often the vision of the that at least begins to begin to talk about the the measuring of a temple and protection of the inner sanctuary and so on is taken as it does clearly allude to Jesus' prediction of the destruction of Jerusalem but it's taken therefore as another prophecy of that as I read it and again it'll take more time than I can explain right now that uses the fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the temple actually is an illustration of how the church will be protected spiritually but also will be made vulnerable to physical persecution and so on and one of the things that leads me to that is that here it's talked of it's called the Holy City and in the book of Revelation the Holy City is the bride of Christ and so you see the bride at the end revealed inner beauty and splendor but in Revelation 11 you see the bride under under attack and under warfare and vulnerable to suffering again that type of reading will tend to read the Harlet Babylon as kind of code for unbelieving Judaism centered in Jerusalem and I I just personally find that very impossible for believers in Asia Minor to have made that connection in the light of the fact that the Harlet Babylon is identified as the great city that rules over the kings of the earth I doubt the people living in that part of the world would have thought oh yeah of course Jerusalem they would have thought Rome I'm quite convinced as well I also have to the priorist view says that the book of Revelation is talking about things that are primarily passed in particular the destruction of Jerusalem in 78 and their interpretation of Revelation is this book is all about that destruction so they really have to date the book before 78 in my opinion the view you the views you've heard today which you know we're in very broad agreement here or deep agreement is not dependent on the dating if we're wrong on dating fine is still means that you know I hopefully what we've gathered that it's talking about this age is talking about the church is talking about the things you've heard today so it could be dated anywhere it really doesn't matter but to me it's just sort of again there's this common sensory can mean if if if this is a letter written about the destruction of Jerusalem why send it to Asia Minor okay we're gonna tell all you California we're gonna tell the Californians that they're going to slide into the ocean by sending a letter to Chicago okay and that regard if you read go home and reach chapter 18 of Revelation it talks about the destruction of Babylon the Great that affects the whole world it's the economic center I for example did just a just a smattering in verse 15 the merchants of all the goods who became rich from Babylon will stand at a distance because of the fear of her torment weeping in morning whoa whoa the great city she was clothed in pine linen purple scarlet adoring with gold and precious stones and pearls in one hour such great wealth has been laid waste and every shipmaster every passenger and sailor as many as make their living on the sea stood at a distance and we're crying saw the smoke of our burning what city is like the great city a three dust on their heads the whole this city is such an economic and cultural hub that when it is destroyed all of the people who were on ships on the seas cry over it because that was one of the main ways that they conducted their economic commerce Jerusalem was not an such an economic hub Rome was in which stand for such an economic hub that would be destroyed at the end of time the problem is they say well Jerusalem was the spiritual naval of the earth as Ezekiel 38 says it was the field of the temple was the center of the world not after judgments proclaimed upon Israel in fact I think that the presence of God left the temple I think I don't think it ever returned at the second temple the building of the second temple I think the temple seeks to be the hub if you will of the world especially by the time of Jesus he's pronounced judgment on them he's reconstituted new Israel on a different basis he's the theological center himself not the temple and not Jerusalem this is another question that folks often have after hearing this perspective on revelation for the first time how can we say Christ returned his imminent if the final beast involves profit of not been manifest and Satan loosed to deceive the nations so this is the stress between signs and sadness how do we handle that and don't all answer at once how can you say Christ's return is imminent if the final beast the false profit of not yet been manifest and Satan loosed to deceive the nations for the things have to happen before Christ returns and how can you say the Lord's return is is imminent and that is one of the arguments the dispensations will raise against us when they say the rapture preserves the imminence of the return you have to read what Dr. Ritalberger's recent book man I'm saying for I first saw in 2 18 to me is really clear little children this is the last hour you've heard that an antichrist is coming even now many antichrist succumbed therefore it's the last hour so there are many antichrist the spirit of antichrist throughout this age yes there's an antichrist at the climax of the age so we got a lot of candidates now live like he's coming today be ready he's coming like a thief that's that to me is the most practical outcome of all millennialism you're ready to go because he could come at any time now maybe it's gonna get a lot worse and we'll be even clearer but I'm ready today we put a long-sighted first John again referencing Dr. Leridra Pongrable by her second Thessalonians 2 announcing a man of lawlessness to come and in the midst of it Paul also says already the mystery of lawlessness is at work yes I do think that not only Paul but also the visions of revelation lead us to expect an intensification of concerted coordinated evil and persecution against the church before the end but not as something that has not is unprecedented from the standpoint of the persecution and opposition that's already at work in the world that's why so much of what was going on the experience of first century Christians what they were receiving both from the standpoint of as Jesus describes them synagogues of that people who say they are Jews but are not but are synagogues of Satan not that they're not ethnically related to Abraham probably but that they've repudiated the Messiah and their persecuting the church and from the from the opposition of the Roman authorities and pagan powers such as the economic power the guilds and so on that is all part of the suffering and the opposition that the church is to expect the face to the end yes there will be intensification we don't know exactly how it's going to be but we're called to be faithful in whatever the opposition is that we face at this point of course I have a comment I think that what Dr. Baugh has said about first John as well as what Dr. Johnson has said about second Thessalonians 2 is excellent and the eminence is this the many anti-Christ you know little children's last hour you've heard that anti-Christ is coming I say many anti-Christ are already come from this we know it's last hour that phrase last hour comes out of the Greek of Daniel 8 through 12 where the latter day tribulation is described as a for a an hour an hour of the end it's right out of Daniel in the great tribulation predicted by Daniel and I think the many anti-Christ throughout history people have you've always heard about how people put their white you know gallons on they go to the mountain top crisis coming we can kind of tell the signs are here we're waiting for it doesn't happen it even happened in Korea in the early 1990s and some people in committed suicide I've been told by some of my Korean students because Christ didn't come back and so but the point is there's they recognize something all these movements recognize something there there was a figure of anti-Christ a real genuine figure of anti-Christ and it looked like we were hitting we were coming to the peak the expression of this this the final one and people got too overconfident I think but and so you get these peaks throughout history these peaks of these anti-Christ and any one of them could be it at some point you're gonna have an anti-Christ figure that boy that's about the highest peak we've reached so far and then it'll get higher and it'll be the real final consumative anti-Christ and I think things will happen so look at the split that we won't be certain that this is the final one until it's all over revelation 20 says it'll be a short time it it will be brief and I think we'll be still is this the final anti-Christ like John I'm wondering with great wonder I'm a star I'm a little confounded and finally when it's over that was it I like to say just a couple things in light of the question one is I think as we look at the reformers for example identifying either the papacy or a particular Pope as the anti-Christ we look back at that now and scratch our heads a bit but if you put yourself in their shoes many of the signings were present and is that an improper identification probably not but it wasn't in God's providence the time because the gospel was still being preached and restrained the gospel went forward throughout the year we had a reformation the 17th century the Puritans were normally very sober until it came to anti-Christ expectation in England and you know the the the Spanish Ramada and you've got all kinds of things historically going on and it looked to all like the end was at hand and you have people you setting dates even Jonathan Edwards predicting a date of 1866 so the signs may be present and it may look as though and yet without knowing the province of God the mind of God we can't tell I think your harvest was answered that in his polyniscatology when he says the best way to answer these is the passage time only God knows when these things will happen and he we will know it when it happens basically let's just take a couple more we're running out of gas and this is a really easy one this won't take long at all what would you consider the major problem with a post-millennial position I can think we can see from the questions what our audience is interested in having started with post-millennial is the math to write pre-millennial stage I've done it all so whoever's right on this I have been right at some point I think I'm right now but I may not be you never can tell so he was a post-millennialist when he taught me the book of Revelation but I've since repaid to go back and I'm sorry about that I think as I think back on it and that's my no my friends who hold strongly to that view I think fundamentally the problem both of both inaugurated millenialists or omelanelists and post-millanists agree that we expect Jesus return after that span of time that John sees and hears as a thousand years where we differ is what we understand conditions on earth to be like during that thousand years in that as omelanelists I would say now I expect the conditions on earth to be the gospel advancing through the preaching you know the church growing through the preaching of the gospel and the power of the spirit in the midst of intense persecution and I would stop there whereas when I was a post-millennialist I would say the gospel advancing the church growing through the preaching of the gospel and the power of the spirit and cultures being transformed and I would say to my omelanel friends back then if it doesn't show in society if the arts and culture are not radically reformed in various countries if justice isn't done by governments as a result of huge numbers of people having their lives transformed by the gospel if that doesn't happen then that doesn't count as millennium that doesn't count as the victory of Christ now Christ does change people's hearts and lives and when he does he changes their families and when conversion comes in large numbers to large groups of people as we've seen in various places in the world in history cultures are changed as well but I don't think scripture leads us to say that Christ's victory is contingent upon our seeing these radical cultural reformations and that unless we see that then we can't count the promises and the prophecies of Christ's kingdom coming before the end as having been fully fulfilled ultimately our hope is the second coming of Christ and when that happens the curse will be vanished from the new heavens and the new earth there will be a society of absolute and complete justice and mercy and there won't be a sort of a halfway house of semi curse semi-blessing but it'll be all blessing that's inaugurated and already inaugurated by Jesus but brought in in this consummation form by his second coming we all want massive conversions we all want renovations of society the question is whether the Bible teaches that as a contingent for the second coming that's that's what the issue is not whether you want that to happen because we appreciate the the growth of the church since the time of the reformation for example it's massive but another problem too was that view is they tend to look at America when if you have a global view I mean things are really hopping in certain parts of the world that are pretty very encouraging as well as very disturbing just one comment I as I mentioned earlier I would call myself an ironic post-millennialist in the sense that there's advancement of the kingdom I would just differ with them that you don't see it with your eyes necessarily furthermore to me the problem and here I think it's the theology of the remnant there's always been a remnant of God's people and I think that continues until the very end now strange bedfellows post-millennialists and pre-millennialists and even a few homilinealists have agreed that at the end of time there's going to be a big influx of Israel at the end and that the majority of Israel will be saved I would contend I don't agree with that because I think that the remnant notion even the remnant of Israel continues on until the end and of course that depends on Romans 1126 but I think the whole idea of the remnant is very important here and there's got to be clear evidence that God is going to work differently at the very very end of time that he's worked throughout all of history we got several questions in this category and this was a good representative when we can have you answer this quickly this comes up why is the number 144,000 not taken literally why 42 months 1026 days why are these numbers not to be taken literally you take all numbers symbolically unless you have to take them literally no look at the 42 months in the three and a half years it's actually pretty carefully arranged you know 42 months three and a half three and a half 42 months it goes back to Daniel so there's with those references it's clear he's tied in with Daniel's prophecy and it has the same significance as Daniel's prophecy which talks about really our era with that numbering system so you're really looking at the text and saying what is that period of time referring to and it's our era the 144,000 again it's some multiple of 12 it's a symbolic number and if you want to if you think that symbolic number has only appeared in you know symbolic books I mean throughout the Old Testament I was reading Leviticus 26 recently I will increase my judgment sevenfold it's repeated four times seven fold sevenfold sevenfold and then you know you just get all these uses of these numbers that are symbolic it was just common commerce back then to use numbers symbolically with significance for beyond the you know the literal number a little more evidence on 144,000 revelations seven and 14 talk about this group 144,000 they are 12,000 from each of the 12 tribes of Israel but if you look at the listing of the 12 tribes in Revelation 7 it matches no list of the 12 sons of Israel or the 12 tribes of Israel it received the inheritance and land in the Old Testament and Christopher Smith has an interesting article from some years ago in a British journal in which he I think has explained the order and the selection of the names of the tribes shows first of all the first tribe is Judah because the Messiah comes from Judah but the interesting thing is that if you compare it with the sons of Jacob and Genesis 25 where they're listed the sons there are listed by the free wives Leah and Rachel and then by the concubines of Jacob but in Revelation 7 the sons of the concubines the sort of second-class citizens are promoted early in the list and Smith suggested I think he's right that it's a signal that that group is not just Israelites but it's all the nations it's really a way of hearing in a census form at the beginning of Revelation 7 what John would immediately see afterwards and that is an account list multitude that cannot be numbered from every nation tribe and and people I think that's confirmed when you get to chapter 14 and you hear that that 144,000 are those who have been purchased from the earth that's the language that is referred that is applied to the whole people of God in the accomplishment of the Lamb in Revelation 5 who purchased people from every race and tribe in time under heaven so again we're driven to think that's a much that group is a much bigger number than we ever had guessed look at the genealogy in Matthew that opens Matthew same kind of theological use of listing the names of the tribes or the genealogical connection he clearly organizes it carefully with a divide into three different units and is selective for the purpose of communicating his message and in that message you see the inclusion of the Gentiles inclusion of the four women it's a very theologically organized piece in Matthew which is not a symbolic book so called and then back to what Dr. Johnson said the sealed from each of the 12 tribes of Israel which is 144,000 in Revelation chapter 7 and verses 4 through 8 he hears the number who were sealed then he sees in verse 9 remember the hearing and seeing they interpret one another but that that is the case here that what's heard is interpreted by what is seen what's seen in verse 9 after that 144,000 heard after these things I look and behold a great multitude which no one could count from every nation now think about the phrase a great multitude which no one could count does that remind you of any phrase repeated meal testament come on Bible quiz Abraham that is the language of the Abrahamic seed not of the Gentiles who would be blessed that is the promise of the ethnic seed of Abraham do you see what's going on let me read it after these things I look and behold a great multitude which no one could count from every nation not ethnic seed but every nation now is seen as Abraham's true Israelite descendants who were the great multitude and hence that's the interpretation of the seal 144,000 you got to listen to the illusions that's the key to the book of Revelation I would throw one more different slant at you if you are wrestling with numbers in book of Revelation supposed to the sake of argument that the thousand years in Revelation chapter 20's literal thousand years as pre-millionarians have to assume put yourself in that position ask yourself what do you get if that position's true well you end up at the end of that thousand years with Satan being let out of the abyss after Jesus's rule on the earth from Jerusalem for a thousand years and at the end of that time there's a second fall the nations revolt against Christ so in a book where numbers are always used symbolically would you rather have a literal thousand years and a second fall or would you rather take the numbers symbolically as I think that as a good way to look at this if you're wrestling with this millennial question well we are out of time and I have to do three things very quickly first a lot of you asked about idolatry and the good news is the bad news is we don't have time for Dr. Biel to go through that but the good news is he has a book coming on this would you tell us a little about your coming book well thank you for that opportunity I have been asked to do a book on the biblical theology of idolatry by university press and I just finished it it's now in proofreading stage on my end and then we'll be sent to university in about a month but it's it's called what you reveal your resemble it's probably about two hundred pages and it's a subtitled biblical theology of idolatry and in which I try to show that the warp and woof of scripture really exemplifies what we saw in Isaiah 6 I could have gotten into revelation the the idea of the name on the head well the name of 666 is on their head because the name represents character they're reflecting the character who they're committed to and so the name the seal of God and and the name of God is on the head in chapter 14 of the reading because we reflect God's character so we take that name on but at any rate it should be coming out probably in about a year thanks second thing as we wrap up I would like to have all of you go home and on your Bible on tape or your Bible on CD or online from one of these online sites where you can actually hear the biblical passages as they're as they're read listen to the book of Revelation in its entirety read aloud that is a great exercise of encourage all of you to do that and a lot of the things you've heard today will just jump out of that reading as you hear John's apocalyptic vision read I think it's really important to do and then the third thing is we've covered a lot of ground today and as I mentioned in our opening remarks these authors have just given you several pages from a 1400 page commentary and revelation and a 300 page commentary and revelation so buy them and study them and you'll find a especially triumph at the lamp great for devotions you'll find Dr. Beals book one of those great reference books to have on your shelf and anytime somebody asks you a question about revelation there you go those books are wonderfully complimentary and I really encourage you to get those and use those so let's give our speakers a big hand and let's dismiss the word of prayer our gracious God and Father we are thankful for the glorious things we have heard today and especially for the reminder of the glorious triumph of our Savior your Son our blessed Savior Jesus Christ and his triumph over death and the grave and his triumph over Satan and all of his forces father we are thankful to live in light of that glorious triumph and as we leave this place we pray that you will fill our hearts with gratitude so that we might indeed reflect of that one who has purchased us in his blood our blessed Savior Jesus so Father bless us as we go granister traveling mercies and as again we pray all day may all that we do bring glory and honor to our blessed Savior Jesus Christ Amen