<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ber Aýlyk ber

Church Government

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

But now today, we are talking about the end of chapter 47, the role of women in the church. Was that all the announcements I had? I think so. Okay, so now I'll go back. Let me tell you what I'm going to tell you first. If you have been at Scottsdale Bible Church a while, you might have noticed something that the pastor is a man. Boy, say so what? But now it's not true in all churches. You go to some churches and you have a pastor being a woman. But we have a man. Jamie's a man. Dura was a man. Hmm, why is that? And then if you've been here a little longer, you'll notice something else. There's an elder board of 14, 15, 16, I don't know, it has varied a number. But the elder board is all men. And when you vote for a choice for elders, it's all men. Why is that? What is the reason that Scottsdale Bible Church has men in leadership, the elder role and the senior pastor role? Then you look around, Scottsdale Bible Church, he knows something else. We've got, Margie is, what's Margie's last name? Galway, Margie Galway is the women's ministry director and she's directing a whole lot. I mean, dozens of activities in the church. We have women directing sections of the counseling ministry at various times. We have, which didn't happen when I was growing up, we have women and men osheres in the church. And we have communion. We have women and men serving communion together. I've at, hard men of you, 30, 40 years ago, we're in church where that happened. And we have both women and men serving in other kinds of paid positions on the staff here. And having position, oh, Paddy Bubna is at the ministry director level directing the communications for the church. And women as well as men involved in various aspects of leadership in the ministry, in the worship ministry here. So, just lots of activities for women as well as men, but not elder and not senior pastor. Why is that? And is that a good idea? Well, that whole question is a question of intense controversy in churches around the United States and around the world. And so, basically, I'm going to say today that I agree with Scottsdale Bible Church. I agree with the policies we have. And here's some of the arguments that go into supporting that. Is that all right? So, if you, that was a summary. So, if you want to leave, you got the main point. The Scottsdale Bible Church is right in what it's doing. But because it's so controversial, there are all sorts of back and forth questions and arguments and things that have come in the last. Oh, I would say since about the late 60s or early 70s in the United States and then in churches around the world. So, are you ready for all this? Here we go. One question can summarize the differences among churches today over this issue. And this is a summary question. And the question is, should some governing and teaching roles in the church be restricted to men? And the word here, some is the key. And there are two positions in the evangelical world. And actually two new names, two new words that you probably didn't hear, you didn't hear 30 years ago anyway. One is complementary. And that position says men and women complement each other. We're different but we complement each other. And one of the ways we complement each other is that there's a leadership role that's reserved for men in the church. And so they would say yes to this question. And that's the position that I hold. The other position is egalitarian. Egalitarian is kind of related to the word for equal. Egalitarian. And the egalitarian position would say, no, no roles are reserved for men. In other words, a woman could be elder or a woman could be senior pastor. So I'll be using both those words. Sometimes the egalitarian position is also called an evangelical feminist position because it's held by evangelicals who are in churches that hold to the Bible. And they say, well, we can get this out of the Bible. And then other people say, no, you can't get it out of the Bible because this and this and this. So these are the arguments. Those are two views. So that's the Bible church is in this terminology complementarian. Okay. We'll start out on your outline reaffirmation or an affirmation of equality in personhood and importance because of equality and image of God between men and women. So right on the first page of the Bible, Genesis 1 and 27, so God created man in his own image in the image of God. He created him. Malin female, he created them. God says that we are both male and female in his image. And I think in his image means we're like God more than any other creature and we represent God on the earth. And in being like God, we represent him. So that means that we both have this greatest status of anything that God made being in the image of God. And we're both that way. Genesis 1, first chapter in the Bible says, we're both in the image of God. And I think we share that image equally. And so we're equally valuable before God equally important to him. But could it be different if we're equal value? And of course, it's the same question of marriage. And I didn't bring the apple and orange today. But in the sermon couple weeks ago, I held up an apple and orange and say, which is more important. But you can't say, apple is good, orange is good. But they're good for different things. If you want to make orange juice, you want the orange. It works a lot better for making orange juice. If you want to make apple pie or apple juice, you want the apple because it's better for making apple pie. So they're different. But you can't say that an orange is more important than an apple. Or an apple is more important than an orange. They're equally important. They're just different. And so I think that we can say that as men and women in marriage and in the church, we're equal in value. But we're different. And different doesn't mean better or worse. And so in the New Testament, church, the Holy Spirit is poured out in new fullness on both men and women. And here's the remarkable thing. Acts 2, the prophecy of Joel 2 is fulfilled. And Peter quotes this as fulfilled. And the Holy Spirit is poured out. It says, in fulfillment of Joel's prophecy, Acts 2, 17, I will pour out my spirit in all flesh and your sons and your daughters see male and female. Your sons and your daughters shall prophesy. And your young men shall see visions and your old men shall dream dreams. So there's young and old. And then even on my male servants and female servants, that's men and women again, in those days, male servants and female servants, I will pour out my spirit and they shall prophesy. And so the Holy Spirit is poured out and that means both men and women have gifts for ministry. And after the service, it's got to a Bible church. Many times there will be an invitation. If you'd like prayer for something in your life, come forward and somebody will pray for you. And men and women from different leadership sections of the church are up there waiting to pray for you. Both men went, why? Because who's the better prayer? A man or a woman? Well you can't say God enables us, gives us the Holy Spirit to minister to one another, enables us in that way. First Corinthians 12-7, to each is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good. 12-7 and 12-11, Paul says. Each one has received a gift that means everyone has received something by which he or she can function in the ministry of the church. So we're all important. Acts 1826, Aquila and Priscilla, I'll talk about this later, Aquila and Priscilla together explained to a Paulist, the word of God more accurately. They're both sharing their insights from Scripture. And first Peter 4-10, again, about all of us receiving gifts from the Lord, every believer, and Acts 8-12, very interesting. When they received the word, they were baptized, both men and women. Now that was a change from the Old Testament because in the Old Testament people weren't baptized but there was a physical act by which people showed they were included among God's people. And that was circumcision and by its nature it only applied to men. But circumcision isn't the act in the New Testament that shows that you're part of God's people. Baptism is the physical act that shows that you're part of God's people. And so baptism testifies to the fact that we're equal in value before God because both men and women now receive that sign. In Galatians 3-28 Paul said, there's neither June or Greek, slave, nor free, male, nor female. For you are all one in Christ Jesus and that emphasizes our equality and our unity in the Lord. So there's a lot there. And I put a note here, women's gifts and ministries have wrongly been stifled in many evangelical families and churches. And I, oh, I just hear all sorts of sad stories about that. In the past, I remember someone telling me, well, she said, I grew up in a church where even at the women's Bible study we had to play a tape recording over the pastor's sermon. No Beth Moore allowed. And that's just going way overboard. The Bible doesn't say it and it doesn't talk about that. It doesn't prohibit that. And I know in the church I was growing up in in Wisconsin. You know, it was just men were doing the ushering and men were serving communion and that was visible kind of, I don't know, indications of who was involved in ministry here was all male oriented. And I don't think that was right. And so I think that out of this controversy as is always the case that when there's a controversy in the church the Lord out of the turmoil brings some correction of past wrongs. And well, here on Sunday morning, who contributes more in the comments and questions afterward, men or women. I think it's about equal. Why? Because everybody has, you know, you're all processing and thinking and the Lord shows you something or has brought something in mind or you're aware of something before and you bring it to my attention. Oh yeah, that's good. I didn't think about that. So we're kind of in that way we're teaching and encouraging one another. And we are, I think that's really right that we do that. Many of you are in or have been in home fellowship groups or men and women together contribute their insights from the Bible and their understanding and it's really good stuff or markets in this Bethmore Bible study and she's look at this about the tabernacle or whatever I say, whoa, that's really good. So we can learn from each other and we need to encourage that and be thankful for that. Okay, so that's point one, but point two, does that mean that there are no differences? No, point two or point B. It seems to me that some, some, some governing and teaching roles in the church are restricted to men. Now let me say in how this works out in actual practice, churches are going to have little differences here and there. Some will say, well, only elders serve community in our church, so we're not going to have women serve communion. Oh, I can understand that and the Presbyterian conservative Presbyterian churches, for instance, would do that. But on the other hand, I say, well, I don't think only elders need to be involved in serving communion. So in our church, we have both men and women serving communion. That's a little difference in an application, but there's still kind of affirming the general truth that there, that these things aren't just for one, for an ancient culture and ancient time, but it's for today. Am I making sense here? So people can differ on the specific application, but in general, the question is, even if we, even if we might differ on like, oh, you want to, should a woman be teaching a Sunday school class or a college, a high school, a Sunday school class, or should a woman be leading a home fellowship group, or what churches can differ on those kind of things, but still be in agreement on the main principle that there is some, some difference that is still for today. This is defined in first Timothy. Okay, so here's the main passage. Paul says, first Timothy 2.11, let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. Now, the context is when the church meets together. The context is a desire in every place, or say, men should lift hands with, we should lift holy hands without anger or quarreling. Women should adorn themselves modestly. It's the context of public worship. And in that context, Paul says, oh, let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man, rather she has to remain quiet. And here, what is being taught in when the church met in the, in the first century, this would be Ephesus, but other churches. Is it geometry that they teach on Sunday morning? Is it biology or chemistry? No. No, it's Bible, isn't it? That's what the church, that's what's being taught. So, teach means the Bible teaching of the type that Jamie does on Sunday morning, or honestly probably of the type that I'm doing right now. It's the church by letting me teach this class, or by letting Jamie authorizing Jamie to preach the sermon, says we want you to do Bible teaching to the assembled group of believers here. And by giving you this podium, the church is saying, we trust you, that basically that you're going to be teaching what is faithful to the Word of God. And we encourage believers to not that you're going to believe every single detail, but in general to believe what is being taught from the pulpit. And so, in that context, Paul says, in the context of the assembled church, Paul says, I don't permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. And I think that's kind of governing authority over the congregation, and we'll get to that in a few minutes about authority over what is being taught. And then, Paul says, here's the reason for, and in Greek, the word God means I'm telling you the reason why I'm saying this. Here's this reason, for Adam was formed first then Eve, that's reason one, and reason two, Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor, and we'll talk about that. So these reasons go back to right at the beginning of time. They're not some other reasons that people are proposing, like, oh, women weren't educated, well educated then, or something like that. So that's the setting, and then he finishes yet she will be saved through child bearing if they continue in faith and love and holiness with self control. So there are some puzzling things in those verses which I'll try to get to in a few minutes, but we'll start with the main point on verse 12. I don't permit a woman in the assembled church to teach or exercise authority, and that's the Greek text which we don't need right now. Well, the setting is the assembled church, I guess I talked about that, and that's setting women could not do Bible teaching or have a government authority over the assembled congregation. Okay, that's the main point I wanted to make. However, the next question comes up. Well, Wayne, don't you see other things in the New Testament that encourage women to do some other kinds of ministry and some other kinds of teaching in the church, and my answer is yes. So lest we go way over to what I would call a too restrictive extreme. I want to come back and say there, as with everything in the Bible, if you teach just one side of it and not the balancing side from other verses, you get a distorted view, so here there's some balancing things. And that is the New Testament views positively, other kinds of teaching and other speaking by women in various ways in the church. For instance, I think the Bible views positively explaining the Bible to anyone in more informal settings. And here's an example in Acts 1826. It's talking about a Paulus who was speaking boldly in the synagogue and you were just an Ephesus, Glenn. You were just a tour of Ephesus. Here in Ephesus, in that city, a Paulus was speaking and he began speaking boldly in the synagogue, but you know what? He didn't know everything about what Jesus had done and how the apostles were teaching this. And so Priscilla and Aquila came around and they're listening to him and say, man, is that guy good at talking about how Jesus fulfills the Old Testament prophecies? Jesus is the Messiah. This guy's doing a great job in the synagogue, but he hasn't heard everything about, I don't know, maybe some of the things that Jesus taught before he ascended into heaven, some of the things the apostles were teaching in Jerusalem. So, and Priscilla and Aquila did that, but they didn't stand up and review him publicly or correct him publicly, it's very interesting. It says, when Priscilla and Aquila heard him, they took him in this, this word, it has the implication of, they took him aside. And privately, they took him and explained to him the way of God more accurately. And this word explained, ectithemy, ethyntah here in this form, that's plural, that verb is plural in Greek. So, they explained, they explained to him more accurately the way of God. Priscilla and Aquila together are saying a policy, we're just so thankful for what you're doing, it's wonderful how you're showing how Jesus fulfills the Old Testament, but you know, we've got to tell you something else about Jesus fulfills, and here's something else, and here's something else. And in the context of the book of Acts, Luke records this as something very positive, it's something about how the gospel was spreading, and it was wonderful, and it's viewed with approval. So, it seems to me that that's analogous to Pammy saying, but Wayne, what about this verse? And I said, oh yeah, Pammy, that's right, okay, I forgot about that. And, or it's analogous to being in a home Bible study, and Margaret's saying to me, but Wayne, wait a minute, how about the verse before that? You forgot, okay, thank you Margaret, I didn't see that. So, there's all sorts of this, what I would call, explaining the Bible to anybody in more informal settings, where it's not the formal teaching on Sunday morning. Am I making sense? Aquila was a man, Aquila's, and Priscilla was a woman. And there's kind of ways to know what's a man's name and what's a woman's name in Greek, so it was a man. Okay, and there's something else that the Bible encourages. Number two, Bible teaching to other women, Titus 213. Paul's writing to Titus here in Crete, and Paul says to Titus, older women, likewise, are to be reverent in behavior, not slanderers or slaves to much wine, they are to teach what is good. They are to teach what is good. And so, what does that result in, train the young women to love their husbands and children. So, older women are to train the younger women, that means, those who are more mature and gone along further in the faith, can train those who are newer in the faith in how they are to act. Example, all these women's Bible, how many going on on Tuesdays here? 12? 14 to choose, I mean, how many? Lots, lots, every Tuesday morning. Just all this, and many of you in other Bible studies, women's Bible studies. And these Bethmore Bible studies. I mean, her video is going to, I suppose, tens of thousands of people, isn't it? Nobody ever made a video of me to go to tens of thousands of people. So, I think it's wonderful. And it shows that both men and women have gifts in understanding the word of God and in teaching and communicating the word of God, that's good. And so, that's another thing that should be done. And I could say Margaret does, she has mentoring groups for seminary wives. And just, I don't know what they do, but they get together. I can't stay out of it. But it's what the church should do. And that's good. Number three, evangelism in any context. Bible doesn't say anything that restricts evangelism to unbelievers and women or men doing evangelism and sharing the gospel with others. And while who's the kind of first example of that in the gospels is the woman at the well that Jesus talked to. And then she went back into the city and said, come here, men who told me everything I ever did. And they began to follow Jesus and believe because she spread the good news about Jesus. And then it's very interesting, after Jesus rose from the dead, who were the first people he appeared to? They were women. They said, they went back and told the disciples, the disciples said, whoa, they didn't believe them, but it was just, I think it was Jesus affirming that women as well as men are trustworthy witnesses to the truth of the gospel. And they were given this wonderful privilege of being the first witnesses to the greatest event in history. I think that's the Lord's work and wisdom. And so what it's talking about is Bible teaching before the assembled congregation and that's not the same as evangelism. And then other speech activities in the assembled church. I won't go into this now, but in 1 Corinthians 11, Paul assumes that both men and women are praying and prophesying in the church meetings. Now I think prophesying is not Bible teaching. I think it's God brings something to mind and you say, I think God brought this to mind and I think we should, you know, and I think it's from the Lord and would you consider it that kind of thing. But that was allowed in the assembled church, certainly singing, singing solos and reading scriptures as well as praying aloud and giving personal testimonies or giving reports on what's going on in a mission situation. And all of that, that's different from standing behind the bulk pulpit and teaching the Bible, which is what 1 Timothy 2 talks about. So those things are all encouraged and both men and women can do those things. But my conclusion and point D is that Bible teaching and governing over the assembled congregation was restricted to men in the early church. Now, how does that apply in practice? I've talked about that a little bit. I've got a book called, and I just, I just brought it along, I mentioned it maybe before, called Evangelical Feminism and Biblical Truth. And on pages 84 to 100, I have 16 pages of saying of this question, but what should women do in the church? And I think I have 83 activities in the church just listen various kinds of things and saying, well, this seems right and this doesn't seem right to me. But almost all of them, I say, both men and women can do these. And I've given many examples, but not all. And so whenever somebody brings up that question to me, I say, well, here's the way we decide a question when the Bible doesn't give every specific example. It doesn't talk about this specific thing, an example. A woman leading teaching a high school Sunday school class. Is that teaching or having authority over men or not? And people have asked me that. And so now what I do in my mind is I put it on this little diagram. The diagram is, way over here, the Bible says yes, and if I could just draw a little stick figures here, Aquila, but I don't know how to do that. I'm PowerPoint yet to draw stick figures, so I couldn't do it. So I would have Aquila and Priscilla and a palace, and they're kind of standing around or sitting around and talking together and Aquila and Priscilla are explaining the word of God more accurately to a palace and a palace is saying, oh, wow, that's really good. Oh, I like that. I never thought of that. That's really super. So that's viewed positively, less formal talking about the Bible to one another. The know is first Timothy 2. That's Jamie on Sunday morning saying, this is what the word of God says, and this is what you should do. Okay, that's the Bible teaching in the assembled church. In between is this, how about a woman teaching a high school Sunday school class? How do we do that? And that falls in this category in between requires mature wisdom. And I want to let churches have differences of how they come to those decisions. My own decision on that is, if somebody asks me for advice, I don't know what's going on here even. My own decision on that is that in our way of living in our culture, our society day, high school boys and girls are still thought to be boys and girls under the teaching authority of their moms and dads still. And it doesn't seem to me that if the Apostle Paul said, I don't permit a woman to teach her authority over men or a man, that I don't think that verse would really speak to it. They're growing toward manhood, but they're not quite there. Bottom line, I'm okay with a woman teaching a high school Sunday school class. But did you see how I kind of reasoned to it? I said, is it more like this? Or is it more like this? Or is it more like other things of women, of mothers and dads teaching their kids or something like that? It seemed to me to be more like this yes side. And so I was kind of weighing and evaluating even though I didn't have the specific example in the Bible. That's somebody might say, well, I would prefer that those 11th and 12th graders have an example of a godly man teaching them. Well, I say, okay, that's a reason you might prefer a man. But others might say, well, but this woman is really well qualified and she's doing a good job. Well, that's a reason. But I don't think you're disobeying the Bible one way or the other. That's just my judgment. Am I making sense? Okay. But an adult class like this, I think, seems like what Paul is doing. But if it's an adult class that's smaller and it's kind of a discussion, it's not like, this is what the word of God says and you should do it. It's not like that. It's more like leading a discussion among adults than I think there'd be more flexibility. Am I making sense? I'm saying there are hundreds. There are thousands of different situations and it's hard apart from being in the situation itself to know exactly what is wise. But we just seek to follow God's word saying there are some knows and there are some yeses and we just want to be faithful. We don't care if we're popular in the culture. We don't care if everybody likes us or not. We just want to follow God's word. That's all we're trying to do. We're just seeking God's wisdom on it. Okay. You're ready to go on for objections. You're going to pause for a moment and see if I open up the door or do a bunch of... Margaret, what should I do? Questions? Why did I do that? Why is life? Okay, John. Okay, John, and then... Okay. I'll start with the fifth hole. And it seemed to me that that seemed to be appropriate. Yes, high school class all women, sure. That seems very... That's older women teaching younger women and it could be not even chronologically older. It could be just older and more mature in the faith teaching those who are younger in the faith, sure. And is it surely here? I can't. Sherry? Sherry? Yeah, just hold on a second. I didn't get the title of the book of 83 activities in the church. I didn't get the title. It's on the bottom of the third page. Number two. Evangelical feminism and biblical truth. Okay. And surely I... Sherry... I'm sorry, I know who you are. Sherry, I listed four books that agree with me there because I wrote three of them. And... And then I listed number five is the best recent book on the other side which I always want to say when I'm teaching a perspective to my class as a seminary, I want to say if you want to read something on the other side, here's at least one, maybe two of the best representations of the other side. And that book number five is the one that's the other view from me. And I know a number of those authors too. Okay, good. Yep, Mike. Yeah, Wayne, I've always been curious as to the question of the word that's translated often as teach or teachers, whether in the cultural setting it may have had a different cultural thought than today. My question is, could it have had an implication of higher level of authority and or position than just just implied by the word teach? I mean, I recall teachers were typically rabbis and or and they were called master and or and rabbi and students found themselves to teachers, you know, in ways that students do not do today. And I'm just wondering whether there, you know, there was a richer idea of authority associated with a teacher than in our applications today. Yeah, my my understanding of it is not in any appreciable way or not in any significant way. The word I don't permit a woman to teach and the Greek word to teach didosco, our word didactic comes from that didosco. And it's the normal ordinary common every day word for teaching in the New Testament. And I think there was a respect according to rabbis, but you don't have to read two pages in rabbinic literature to know that they challenged and questioned one another and and even just interacting interactions with Jesus and the gospels people are challenging him, teaching him, asking him, questioning him, how can this be et cetera. And so I think it's the normal activity, it's not a special word, it's the normal activity of teaching the Bible when the church gets together. And so it's really, it's the primary passage we have here, you know, the speaks to this topic. And it's the same concept or idea where an elder is to be able to teach or an apt teacher. But it's just it's it's the normal Bible teaching activity of the church. But I think surely when you get situations for instance where Paul is in the synagogue persuading, reasoning, arguing, discussing, it would be very much of an atmosphere like what we have here, I think, but good. That's my understanding of it. Okay, let's go over here to Mary, Rosemary, yeah, Rosemary. Well, a question that has always. Have to hold it a little closer. A problem that has always bothered me is about women learning quietly with submission, remaining quietly, and to ask your husband, which I don't have. But in this situation in our class, I see, is it okay for us to question and discuss things? I think definitely it is. I let a woman learn quietly with all submissive, I think the quietly means not interrupting and saying, wait a minute, that's wrong. But most of the women would have been married and if a woman is saying that's wrong, I think it would be go like this to her husband and say, hey, Jacob, something's wrong here. Oh, yeah, wait a minute. I mean, wake up and say, and then Jacob says, wait a minute, that's wrong. I think the picture. Now, oftentimes, Rosemary, oftentimes the Bible speaks of the general case without specifying all the exceptions. So, for instance, the command, honor your father and your mother. That's the general case because most kids have a father and a mother. Somebody might say, well, my mother died. My dad's bringing me up. Well, okay, you honor your father and follow the principle of honor your father and your mother, even if you don't have a mother. So, here, if there's anything that desire to know, let the master of husbands at home, which will come to later in 1 Corinthians. I think that's the general principle of, I think Paul is saying, well, I'll just kind of give an example Rosemary. If I'm teaching on the tribulation and the return of Christ and youth, and I'm saying, I think Jesus is going to come back in two months to the day and all of a sudden you're thinking your mind, wait a minute. Jesus said, you can't know the day or the hour. I think that's encouraging you in that case to kind of wait for one of the men to exercise the doctrinal control over Grudemus, teaching something wrong. And say, and so Jean would send up and say, wait, Jesus said, you can't know the day or the hour. There's kind of a governing role there that is restricted to men. I'm not sure entirely why, but it's just the way it's what it's what's going on, I think. So, is that help at all? Okay. Yeah. Okay. Joyce. I hesitate to say this because I don't want to sound like I'm disputing what you're saying. It's okay if you do. I don't know that I do. Do you have other scriptures besides this one that supports this? The fact that he says, I do not permit a woman to teach or to blah, blah, blah. It makes it sound like that's his feeling. Instead of saying, do not permit a woman. He says, I do not permit a woman, which makes it sound like this is how I do it. And not this is how it has to be done. Do you understand what I mean? So, there are two questions. Are there other verses? And does Paul saying, I do not permit mean that other places that could be elsewhere? What I'm going to do, I'm just going to give you a quick preview where I'm going. After I do some, let's see, now I've got a bunch of objections here. Okay. And look at those. And then the next thing down on the outline is another passage, 1 Corinthians 14, 29. Oh, it's the, it's as in all the churches, the saints, the women should keep silence in the churches. I think that's just what I was talking to Rosemary about. It's when prophecies are being given and people stand up and say, that was right, that was wrong. It's judging. And so it looks like governing authority over the church. And then I'm going to go to 1 Timothy 3 where an elder has to be a husband of one wife and Titus 1 and elder is a husband of one wife. So, that looks like, that's that requirement of governing authority over the church is husband. And then I'm going to say there's a parallel between the family and the church. And I think that's the big picture behind this that God has established equality in many areas and opened us to everything. But there's a leadership role in the family and the church that's reserved to men and their parallel. And then the other is the 12 apostles, the men that Jesus chose all 12, and they had that leadership role. And then, and the other is the whole Bible in this sense. I don't think there's any place in the whole Bible where a woman taught an assembled group of people, God's work. There were a judge people under the palm tree, people came to her with hard cases, but it wasn't like proclaiming thus says the Lord. And so, or kind of teaching, which the priest did in the Old Testament. So in a way, it's kind of the whole flow of thought in the Bible. And then I'll talk about the history of the church and say all this stuff came up since 1969 or so. It's not kind of that there's always been this huge controversy. And then, so that's that's kind of where I'm going. Can you hit the B on the keyboard? Thanks. So that's that. Now, could it be just Paul? He talks that way, like when he talks about the Lord's supper. I delivered to you as a first importance. What I also received that the Lord Jesus delivered to me that the man who was betrayed, he took bread and broke it saying, this is my body. And so Paul does that a lot of times. I appeal to you by the mercies of God that you present your body as a living sacrifice. Paul saying, I appeal to you. Present your body as a living sacrifice. Holy, acceptable God. I think it's him speaking as an apostle whose words are going to end up in the scriptures. So I think it is it's authoritative for us. But in Joyce, look, I want to say not that Joyce wants to do this, but as with everything else I'm teaching, you don't have to agree with me in every detail or you don't have to agree with me in what I'm saying. And I'm happy to have the interaction. But this is what I think is right from the Bible. Okay, Ron. What's your name? My name is Frank. Question for you at the beginning of verse 11, it says let a woman. And when I look at teachers and how they teach, they're always very particular to single out things. And someone, a teacher would look at me and say, notice that that is a not a universal address, because it doesn't say women. It says a woman, meaning a singular type of woman. So I'm curious as to why it can is there any explanation as to why it says a woman rather than women because when you look at the word a woman that implies a particular woman. And as you look at the bottom in verse 15, it says and yet she will be saved through child bearing. So if the phrase a woman in verse 11 is a universal, then how can we go and all of a sudden change our mind in verse 15 and say the she who is the woman. Is now just a particular woman and not universal women. Otherwise you end up with a mandate that all women should bear children. It's this general kind of thing that we have hundreds of times in the Bible. It's a good, it's a good question to ask about. The general kind of way of teaching in the Bible is it takes a specific example and thereby teaches a general truth. So let me give another example. You shall not covet your neighbor's wife. The you and Hebrew is actually singular. It's saying you, individual men, you shall not covet your neighbor's wife. It applies to all men, but it dress it to a specific one and it actually applies to women. Means women shouldn't covet their neighbor's husbands, but it doesn't name that. It teaches a general truth by a specific example. And so here I do not permit a woman. I don't think that we could say Paul means well I don't permit a specific woman named Priscilla or something. He's not saying that. I think it's a general. I do not permit a woman in general to exercise authority. Now here, if the child bearing, I am going to say that's a kind of a speaking in generalizations with recognizing that not all women bear children. But that's again, again, one of these, it talks about specific examples and expects us to make the generalization to the journal truth. Is that, does that help? Okay. Good. Brian. I'm using, I'm going back to your, your linear graph there about, I guess in the one, I think it was first Timothy, you're talking about the pulpit. Kind of Bible study in an X-18. It's more like a home study. Yeah. Where do you see Sunday school teaching along that line there? And I guess more specifically you had mentioned about women teaching high school kids, but I'm thinking in the context of a woman teaching a mixture of adult men and women in a particular Sunday school class. Now, okay, now look, I may be even not aware of what everything goes on in Scottsdale Bible Church. But if it's the kind of teaching that I'm doing, even though it's interacting, I'm basically making an argument each week for this is what the Bible teaches and this is what we should do, whether it's about baptism or church government or whatever else we talk about. I think that that kind of teaching should be restricted to men. Now, could there be kind of facilitating discussion kind of class leadership where people are working through a workbook and there's, it's not really like the teaching authority of the church is entrusted to this person. It's like a coordinator or a facilitator where it doesn't look as much like first Timothy, too, as it does, like just kind of informal talking together. I'd be open to allowing that and saying if I were in the elderboard making a decision, I could say, okay, let's, and it might even depend a lot. I hope it's all right that I hope you understand here that don't muddle everything, but I think it might even depend a lot on the attitude and demeanor of the woman. Because there could be some women that are very much, they're just coordinating and serving and others who are just very domineering. And you know, it's like in your spirit you're sensing, wait a minute, this woman just likes to be in charge and she is really having this authority over a group of adults, they're men and women. And then you say, no, that's right, that's not right. So I could allow for differences there. The question is for each church and each elderboard to take, okay, we agree there are some differences here. Now where does this fit in this specific instance? And that's a hard question, that's to be decided by prayer and seeking the wisdom of God in each case. And give grace to different churches and different people that make just kind of, on the things that aren't specified, they may come down a little bit differently or agree in the general principle. Well, so how did I do on the outline? Where are we? We're on page one. I think that I think that I should come back to this the next time I'm back in the class. Is that all right? And we'll just try to keep on plowing through it and I think in one more Sunday we could get through all of the rest of the outline. But thank you for the good discussion. I don't have a hymn, it's time to quit, let's pray.