<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ber Aýlyk ber

Criticisms of Schaeffer

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

I thought today because we're coming to the end of this class, and I feel that there are so many things we haven't covered. It's one of those things. It's very difficult to cover a person's whole life and ministry, or even half of a person's life and ministry, in a two-hour class during the course of a semester. But I thought for today and Monday what I would look at is to consider the charge that has been made against Shae for by many people that his whole ministry changed direction during the last 10 or 12 years or so of his life's work from the early 70s up until his death. So that's what I want us to look at because there have been many articles written in Christian magazines, chapters, books, various thesis by students doing graduate work which have leveled that charge against Shae for that his whole ministry changed direction. One writer puts it this way. He says, some time in the 1970s a considerable shift began only slightly apparent at first but later unmistakable. Now as you read these various articles and books and theses which make this suggestion, I want to start by looking at how they contrast. So they contrast the early and later Shae for. So we'll start by looking at what they say about Shae for in his early years. They would say that earlier his commitment must be an evangelist proclaiming the gospel. An encourager of young Christians to develop a Christian world and life view, a challenger to young Christians to become salt and light in the world as scholars, as artists, as lawyers, as business persons, politicians and so on. But his ministry, if you like, was on the one hand evangelistic on the other hand a challenge to live out a reformed understanding of culture and life in general. It suggested that in his earlier years he was opposed to or at least wary of any kind of political involvement that he was in those early years a writer of serious and energizing books. It suggested that in those early years systemic evil was not part of his analysis that is that he wasn't interested in saying that there was institutional or structural evil in society. It suggested that in those early years he wasn't interested in meaningful social change but rather simply in the transformation of individuals by the power of the gospel. It stated that he was, again as one writer puts it comfortable in his North Atlantic world, that he cared little for the Third World, that he wasn't interested in issues like war and peace, the arms race, the structural injustices or excesses of capitalism, or institutional racism that these things didn't really matter to him. So that's a sort of way his early years are presented. Now let's look at the way his later years are presented and I'll come back to the early years in a moment and seek to answer some of these understandings of his early years. That in his later years his one way to put it his present fixation is with political action and social protest that he became a purveyor of simplistic analyses of America's problems that he accepted the agenda of the moral majority. And tied himself completely up with them that he became a man of single issue causes that he was committed to special pleading for conservative political and social causes. In other words that he became completely enchained by the new American right that he made that he had the fault of what's called an innocent acceptance of the moral majority synthesis of evangelical Christianity and cultural religion. A sort of a kind of a special kind of American civil religion one might say, cultural evangelical religion, that he was naive in his suggestion that there was a reformation base for the freedoms and understanding of justice that existed in the past. He is accused by some of being subject to that virulent Protestant disease Anglo-Saxon anti-catholicism that he endorsed that virulent Protestant disease of Anglo-Saxon anti-catholicism. It's suggested that he was guilty of intellectual dishonesty that certainly the implication of quite a few of these articles that he gave into and I'm quoting somebody he gave into the siren song of media popularity and the slick programs of production companies. That he was guilty of name dropping that he had a kind of messianic consciousness about himself in terms of his place in the American scene. It's also charged by some that his book the Christian manifesto or to be called a fundamentalist manifesto rather than a Christian manifesto. It's suggested that he regarded the American past as a kind of golden age of Christianity and that he regarded the time of the reformation as a golden age of Christianity. It's suggested that he was a theonomist committed to a theocratic view of America that he's a reconstructionist in the kind of Rush Duny mold that he's a triumphalist in terms of his vision of Christian influence. On the culture of the same time I have read people who suggest that Schaeffer was really just a fundamentalist dispensationalist, a kind of doomsayer, a Jeremiah who delighted in being gloomy about the state of America today and its future that as a dispensationalist he didn't really believe that any change in the society was possible. But things would just get worse until the end. It's suggested that he was naive that he believed in a kind of conspiracy of humanists, of liberal theologians, of the liberal and political left wing to crush the Christian church. Or to put it simply that he was a rabble rousing popularizer. So those are some of the criticisms that have been made and I could add lots more to them as well but those will give you a flavor of some of the things that he has been accused of. Now let's come back and look at the understanding of his early ministry. Certainly he saw himself as an evangelist. That's true to all the very end of his life and that never changed though you have quite a few writers who suggest that from the early 70s onwards that sort of dropped out of his commitment and understanding. I meet people all the time all over this country who have become Christians through the Ministry of Shaffer at all points in his work. Not just before the early 70s but right through. He saw himself as first and foremost an evangelist to the very end of his life. Certainly he was an encourager of young Christians to help them develop a biblical world in a white life view and to be salt and light. Is it true that he was wary of political involvement and that that changed or opposed to political involvement in those early years? I would say yes and no to that. He was always wary of political involvement because he saw the tremendous dangers for Christians who become politically involved. The danger of wrapping oneself with a republican or democratic tag. He warned of that right to the very end of his life. I have here a speech he gave in the last couple of years of his life where he warned quite explicitly against that of the dangers of identifying yourselves too easily with one or another side of the political spectrum. He was very wary of the way power corrupts people including Christians who get involved politically in high political office. He was very wary of the way political parties are always ready to use the church for their own short term ends. This was always something he was wary about. I remember him talking about this in the late 60s and again during the period of the moral majority. He was acutely aware of the way the political right was using the moral majority for its own purposes. Without a great deal of commitment to much of what it stood for. So I would say he was always wary of political involvement but all through his ministry there was a commitment to political involvement. Is it true that in those early years he wasn't aware of the importance of structural or systemic evil that that wasn't part of his analysis? I think if you were to go and look through our tape collection in the library there and see some of his critiques of relativism in public law in the United States which were made in the late 50s and early 60s, you would see that that simply isn't true. That is an element that is present right through his ministry and awareness not only of individual evil but of systemic evil in societies. Is it true that he wasn't interested in meaningful social change? I would say take death in the city. That is his great one of his great concerns there for the brokenness of our culture and its radical need for social change. Or even back to that little pamphlet sin is normal written in 1953 here in St. Louis or the Bible believing Christian in the Jew. Is it true that he cared little for the third world at any point in his ministry and that is really the accusation that he never really cared about the third world? I would say again if you look through the tape list you will find for example a series of lectures on African socialism. He had a personal correspondence with Leopold Sengor who was the leader of Senegal back in the late 50s and early 60s. And if you look at those tapes or for example the tapes he gave on India on the development of Indian culture and society from the years BC up to the present time you will see that he most certainly did have an interest in the third world. Did he care about the needs of the third world? Let me just give you one illustration.

Anki Rookmarker who with her husband founded the Dutch branch of Lebrie and who throughout their life together and since that time since her husband's death has been still very closely involved with Lebrie and with the Schaifers started an organization where the Schaifers great encouragement called help a child. That is a ministry which is committed to starting orphanages in India, in various parts of Africa, in Kenya, in Uganda, in Zambia, Zaire etc. It's a wonderful ministry which is deeply encouraged by the Schaifers. Having gone to Lebrie in 1967, it was very evident at that time to me that the poverty, appalling injustice in the third world was something that was really close to his heart. Is it true that he wasn't interested in issues of war and peace? It's suggested, for example, in one article I've read that he really wasn't concerned about the war in Vietnam that his response was well at least there are Western Christians there able to preach the gospel but he didn't really see any wider than that. Again, I would say that's completely inaccurate. I remember him speaking about Vietnam, people may have disagreed with his position, I certainly found it difficult having come from a Marxist background myself but he very strongly believed that America was right to be in Vietnam. And he warned before America's withdrawal of what would happen in both Vietnam and Cambodia when there was a communist takeover that the consequences would be far worse than anything that had taken place before. Now one may disagree with his views but it's quite untrue to say that he wasn't concerned about what was happening there or that he didn't have strong views about that. He made them very, very clear. And whatever one thinks about his views at the time, there's no doubt that what he was afraid would happen did happen between a million and two and a half million people nobody knows how many were killed by the communist government in Cambodia and tens of thousands of people at the very least were killed in Vietnam and tens of thousands more felt compelled to leave the country in the exodus of the boat people. Again, I may disagree with his views but it's inappropriate to say that he was disinterested or that he saw the only value of America's being there as the fact that there could be missionaries there during that period. Is it true that he was not against institutional racism? I don't think so at all. I remember him speaking very strongly about civil rights and racism in the United States. You remember from the early years those of you who were there that when he was a young Christian and a student in college he worked every weekend in a little black church in the town or outside the town where he was at college. I didn't ever see the slightest sympathy for any kind of racism in his ministry and I think if you've ever seen whatever happened to a human race or how should we then live you will be able to say he was a man who was very strongly opposed to institutional racism as it was expressed in slavery and later on in American life. I know personally that he was deeply criticized for his commitment to the rightness of interracial marriage. I had a very dear friend who was at the library at the same time I was or two dear friends one was an English woman the other was a black American from Tulsa who were married and the father of the British girl who was a pastor refused to ever see the husband or the child. The husband or the children again I mean he's never met them yet the parents this was twenty twenty three years ago and they wrote Schaeffer and telephone Schaeffer and accused him of aiding and abetting interracial marriage in an accusation which he was quite happy to accept. But to suggest that he wasn't against institutional racism I think is it's really libelous is it true that he said nothing about the structural injustices of industrial capitalism. I find that an interesting criticism again as when I first went to the Bri in 1967 coming from my Marxist background I found some of the things he said certainly hard to swallow in terms of his defensive capitalism. But I would say throughout his ministry he spoke against the injustices of capitalism. This particular criticism intrigues me because I remember coming here to the States when how should we then live first came out and it was really striking when I was taking a seminar on the film in Washington DC and in other parts of the United States. But one of the aspects of the film that people didn't like was the fact that he was critical of racism and of the excesses of capitalism so strongly. I remember several businessmen and rightly politicians in the conference I was leading in Washington DC being really upset with what he had to say and how should we then live about greed and injustice in capitalism. Again I think this is hardly a fair criticism he certainly believed in a free market but he wasn't committed to laissez faire capitalism but saw the necessity of laws which would restrain injustice. You remember those of you who were here in the early years that when he was working in a factory he was actually one of the leaders of a strike as a young man. You know he never forgot his own working class background it simply isn't right to just stick him in some extreme right wing camp where economics are concerned or anything else. He certainly believed that capitalism was an economic form which would create the greatest wealth and the greatest freedom for people but he spoke strongly against laissez faire capitalism in the sense of a kind of survival of the fittest approach to the market. These are some responses to the understanding of his early years. Does anyone have any questions before we go on here because I know I'm covering a whole pile of issues very quickly yes. I think that is a good criticism to make is it fair to criticize somebody for the things they didn't say rather than for the things they did say particularly when not everything they said has been published. Yeah I think that that is a good response to make the I think the criticism is is coming particularly because he really committed himself very strongly to speaking and working against abortion and that's why he's criticized as being single issue person. And I want to answer that criticism a little later was he actually a single issue person why did he put such a strong emphasis on abortion. He answered that that that question himself on many occasions but I would make two responses no it's not fair to criticize somebody for what they haven't said. It's even more unfair to say that somebody hasn't said something when in fact they have but if you made the attempt to actually read everything that he wrote or to listen to all the tapes that he gave you would find that in fact he did deal with many of these issues like for example the tapes I mentioned on African socialism or his concern for the third world. I'm sure most people who know anything about shape I have no notion whatsoever that Anki Rookmarker's ministry help a child which now cares for probably tens of thousands of children in Africa and India really has its roots in liberty because that was so much a part of their concern. Doing with trying to do something practical about poverty I think Vishal Mangalwadi who came here to speak at the seminary last year for the institute who was an Indian question would protest very strongly against this kind of accusation against shape because he himself would say that his own understanding of Christianity and his own commitment to working in India for social justice was deeply shaped by his indebtedness to shape it and I think you'd find many other people working in third world situations who would say the same thing but I think it is simply an inaccurate criticism of several levels. I think another thing you would say is often when you see people making those criticisms it may be simply because shape it didn't stand for their own particular political agenda and you can disagree with that but my personal agenda would be different but that in itself doesn't stand as a valid criticism. This criticism has to be made at a deeper level. Have these criticisms come mostly since his death or have they where they prior to it? It's both and there were some quite strong negative articles written in the early 1980s about him. I know one article I've been quoting here is this one by Ronald Wells, whatever happened to Francis Schafer. This was exactly his analysis that there is this two period part to Schafer's life the one where he was doing a wonderful job and the second where he sort of got trapped in this kind of media circus and right wing politics is basically his critique. There have been many of course written since his death in some of the books that have come out and some of the theses what strikes me in several theses that have been sent to me to look at which I have to try and respond to when I have the time is that the people haven't done their work well enough. They haven't even made the effort to read all of his books or to listen to everything he had to say because much of what he said was never put in book form. I think there I just forgotten completely what I was going to say to have a total mental blank that's what happens every now and again getting tired towards the end of the semester here. Well what I meant by saying he was wary of the dangers of political involvement was that he was very aware of the corrupting nature of political power because of human sinfulness. He'd seen that so acutely in his own church background the way even in incidents and denominations and in Christian organizations there when people get power it goes to their heads and they start doing all kinds of things they shouldn't do. So he was very aware of that in the political scene as well and that was something he spoke about quite often. And he was aware too of the tremendous seductions of Christians who began to be listened to by people in political leadership. For himself for example in the last years of his life he spent quite a bit of time in Washington DC being asked to speak to groups of senators and congressmen even presidents and vice presidents and so on. One of the things he's accused of in some of these articles is name dropping. I never heard him talk about that in public. Most people aren't even aware that he ever did get to know any of the presidents or any senior political figures. There were quite a few who did get to know him and he asked for his advice on on all kinds of issues but he just simply didn't talk about it. He was very wary of the way Christians personally can be sucked into that kind of media circus which surrounds the whole political edifice in Washington. And even though he was warmly received there and asked to speak there on many occasions he very consciously, self consciously tried to avoid the kind of media circus elements that went along in. Along with that or to take advantage of it in terms of the support of his own ministry or the support of the Louise ministry. He never wrote letters saying I have an audience with the president. I have seen this senator in that congressman or these people have listened to me or I'm having an influence on them. He just simply didn't talk about it. He didn't even talk about it in the context of those of us who worked together in library with him unless people asked him to ask questions. He just simply wasn't something that he boasted about. But beyond that he was very aware of the corruption of political power and of the tremendous compromises and ambiguities involved in political power. And that's why he warned Christians very strongly against just tying themselves too easily to any particular political party or group. And in some of the things I've read about and it's suggested that he saw the moral majority and the election of Reagan as the final hope for the United States. That simply isn't true. He was aware that there were all kinds of problems with the moral majority. There were all sorts of points where he wished to distance himself from some of its leaders, some of the televangelists who were the leaders of it, in terms of the materialism, the kind of medicine avenue and Hollywood style of the programs, the personal grandism and all the trappings that went along with that in that scene. He was aware that very often there wasn't a deep enough analysis of what the problems were in the culture in parts of the new Christian right. And he was very aware that the political right was including humanists on the political right were quite happy to use. Christians in the moral majority for their own short-term political ends with no intention whatsoever of putting into reality some of their agenda. Well, how did he encourage people? He had a very strong belief in the individual calling of each person to a place of God's service. And to Liberia over the years came many people who were from every different walk of life, political, medical, legal, etc. The arts and he simply challenged all Christians to go and serve God in that place. That our calling over the members of all of our churches is to serve God in their own particular places of work. And that political involvement was a place where there was desperately needed Christian involvement at the present time. Precisely because there is so much corruption and abuse of power in the political scene particularly in Washington that says that's what we're speaking about. And where he was able to talk to politicians who were Christians personally, he really challenged them to personal righteousness, to resist the temptations of political power. But then to do everything they could for questions of justice and mercy where the laws of this country were concerned. And clearly if you look at the last parts of how should we then live, the segments from the Reformation onwards, the Age of Reformation, the Age of Revolution, and then the last two sections, the Age of Personal Peace and Affluence and Final Choices. In and for all four of those sections he speaks very powerfully about the influence Christians can have in their culture if they're prepared to really work within the very political and social institutions. And he really challenged Christians to do that. While at the same time being realistic about the difficulties of that, both in terms of the time it took, in terms of the hardness of hearts of the culture, in terms of the dangers of power to the individual himself or herself. I would say you would find probably many individual Christians in Washington today who would say that they are there working as Christians because of the encouragement of Francis Schafer. Just as you would find many Christians working in the arts, trying to be writers or dancers or singers or musicians or painters as a consequence of the encouragement of Schafer. This isn't something that Schafer would talk about. I know, for example, one congressman who has had a Bible study in his home for many, many years where many senators and congressmen's wives come and where senators and congressmen too. But I know I won't mention names. I don't think he ever would and I'm not prepared to, though I could do so. I know you are curious. I understand the question, but I don't think that's really the issue, but certainly there are many for whom that is true. I think often one of the other problems involved is Schafer mentioned this at one point. He was speaking to the Evangelical Press Association and he pointed out that the article that Ken Woodard had written in was a time or newsweek, newsweek I guess. Is it newsweek he writes in? It's religious affairs correspondent, but he had acknowledged to Frankie the night before the deadline for his article that he'd never read a single one of Schafer's books. And yet he wrote this article which just roasted Schafer right across the board for just being a naive supporter of the moral majority for all of these other things, all these same kinds of criticisms I've been mentioning. Yeah, that's a good question. Is this an indication of the shallowness of the criticism? Sometimes that he could be accused both of being a reconstructionist by some people, a theonomist committed to theocracy, and by other people being accused of being a fundamentalist dispensationalist. I just read that in the thesis yesterday. It really amazed me. Now that's one criticism. I don't see how anybody could make with the greatest stretch of the imagination. I think it is a superficial criticism. It arises from the fact that he was a pre-millennialist, that particular one. He strongly believed that there will be a literal millennium on earth after Christ comes back. But he would have said very carefully that he was not a dispensationalist. He was a reformed pre-millennialist. And he would point to an honorable tradition of reformed pre-millennialists. He certainly wasn't into the kind of dispensational speculation about what's happening in Israel and the rest of the world and jumping on that kind of thing. He resisted that completely. And said over and over again we simply don't know when Christ is going to come back. He said that he himself didn't know we certainly don't. To suggest that, like some of the dispensationalists, he didn't believe that there was any point in trying to change society but just to rub one's hands by the fire as society gets worse, that he was just a doomsayer and a Jeremiah is extraordinary. Because in one of the last speeches he gave, which I was reading this morning, he said, I really do believe it's possible for there to be a revival of the church and a reformation of American society. He was passionately committed to that. He didn't know if that was happened but that was what he thought our calling was to be committed at every moment in history to that, to the revival of the church and the reformation of society no matter what our views happen to be about the second coming. So he certainly wasn't a dispensationalist. Was he a theonomist or a reconstructionist? No, he wasn't. It's interesting when he was a pastor here in the States, he protested very strongly or he wouldn't allow the displaying of the American flag in the church where he was a pastor. He was very opposed to any kind of civil religion, which may interest you to hear that. In a one can assume simply because he spoke about the necessity of America returning to a biblical understanding of law and a biblical understanding of the value of human persons that he was a theonomist, he was not. He was not in agreement with Rush Dooney and his whole program for recreating a kind of theocracy. He very passionately believed in the freedom of speech. As interesting I was again reading something this morning which was very similar to what I was speaking about in his lecture on the Williamsburg Charter. That he was committed to the freedom of speech and the freedom of religion for everybody, not only for Christians but for everybody. And that Christians had to be prepared to speak the truth and let the truth stand in the marketplace on its own feet in the marketplace of ideas. So he had no desire to silence people who were humanists or who were Muslims or who were Hindus or anything else. He very passionately believed in the freedom of speech and the separation of church and state. He did not think that Christians should be prevented from having an influence in the public arena quite clearly. And it was something he worked for very strongly. But he did believe in the freedom of speech and we can look at that on Monday. I've got a section to quote you on that where he talks about that.