<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ber Aýlyk ber

Radical of the Reformation

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Lecture 7 children of light scattered everywhere the radicals of the Reformation. One of the great figures of the 16th century was a man named Mino Simons recognized from his name that the Minonite Church goes back to Mino Simons. His favorite text was 1 Corinthians 3 11, every book that he wrote, he prefaced the book with the text. There is no other foundation that can be laid, but the foundation which has been laid, which is Jesus Christ, and that text appears in this picture of Mino Simons in the Greek testimony that he is holding in his hand. Mino Simons is usually described as an Anababdist. This was one group among many different groups who were not Catholic and they were not Lutheran and they were not reformed. They were something else. Sometimes these people of the 16th century have been called the left wing of the Reformation. That was a title that was given to people like Mino Simons by the great Yale historian Roland Bainton. By calling these Protestants the left wing of the Reformation, Bainton wanted to stress the fact that they move further from the right or the most conservative position which would have been the Catholic position all the way across the spectrum to the left in terms of reform the left wing reformers go as far as you can go from the Catholic Reformation. George Williams who taught church history at Harvard preferred to call these people the radicals of the Reformation. He used the word radical not to mean extremist although sometimes some of these groups became rather extreme by to stress the fact that they wanted to get to the root of the matter, the root of the Reformation, the basic principles of the Reformation. Unfortunately they did not agree among themselves as to exactly what that root was but all of the radicals were concerned to reform completely and fully away from the Catholic Church. As we studied this group today let's begin with a prayer from the Anababdist taking this from an Anababdist him. These people suffered a great deal in the 16th century and throughout their history and as we pray this prayer today from the Anabdist we can think of the suffering that they went through and the comfort that God brought to them as well as the comfort that God brings to us in our lives as well. Let's pray. Our comfort best beneath the ride whenever we are faint in the ol' God in the alone are earthly peace and rest who hope on the eternally are sustained and blessed. Amen. I want us to look at three episodes that took place in the first part of the 16th century and as we do so we'll get some understanding of what motivated the radicals, what kind of people they were, what they wanted to do in the church. The first episode took place at the end of the Black Bayer in Jaina in Germany in Saxony on August 22nd, 1524. You can see on the map where Jaina is located, not really too many miles from Fittenburg but to the east in the area called Saxony. And this episode that I'm going to talk about at Jaina in this end of the Black Bayer in 1524 was just three years after Luther's appearance at Varms where he made his great defense before the Impra and then his time after that at the Vordberg where he translated the New Testament just three years later. Luther is a Jaina, he preached that day in Jaina and went later to the end for represhment and food and who should appear in the end but Dr. Andreas Boedenstein phoned Carl Stott. Now Carl Stott was a Lutheran. In fact he was the man that took over the Reformation in Fittenburg while Luther was away at the Vordberg. Carl Stott was professor of biblical studies at the University of Fittenburg and in Luther's absence Carl Stott was the major reformer in the town of Fittenburg and during those months when Carl Stott was in charge the reform moved much more rapidly. Carl Stott was not patient, he didn't want to wait and delay. So the images began to be taken down from the churches and the Reformation moved much more quickly and in the process of Carl Stott's leading the Reformation and Luther's absence in Fittenburg he began to stress that the really important thing is to listen to what the Holy Spirit is saying and to reform the church according to the directions given by God the Holy Spirit. Carl Stott had been in Jaina that very day when Luther priest in fact he had been in the church and he had heard Luther's sermon that morning and he had heard Luther include him Carl Stott with others called by Luther rioting murderous spirits. Carl Stott was not of course too pleased with that. During the spring and summer of 1524 in the town of Allstedt which is indicated on the map underline not too far from Jaina. Another of Luther's followers, a man named Thomas Munser, had organized. Thomas Munser had organized arm rebellion of the peasants against some of the lords in the area and in the process of this rebellion these peasants had done quite a bit of damage. They had destroyed a Catholic shrine actually because of Munser's activity in organizing the peasants Thomas Munser became something of a Marxist hero. The side outside the Allstedt Castle where Munser delivered a famous sermon I'm going to talk about in a moment as a phrase from the constitution of the former German Democratic Republic which reads all political power in the German Democratic Republic is exercised by the workers and then the second quotation there is from Munser power shall be given to the common people. So as Munser preached he preached a message like this which caused people to rebel against the authorities of the time and that was very much in Luther's mind as he preached his sermon that morning at Jaina that Karlstadt heard Luther lumped together rebellion and smashing of images

in the sermon before the princes, princes of Saxony which Munser had preached defending his actions at Allstedt. Munser depicted himself as Daniel who could read the signs of the times, knew what was happening far better than Luther whom Munser called brother fatton swine and brother soft life and doctor liar and the Lutheran Pope of all the scripture pervertes people did not use soft language in those days even when they were colleagues at one time. Well Karlstadt wasn't happy to be lumped together with Munser and Karlstadt at the end of the Black Bayer denied any connection with Munser and the rebellion and so he said to Luther it's the two mat over dinner why then doctor Luther have you said that there is just one spirit that is the murdering spirit of Allstedt why did you lump me with these others? Luther tended to put all his enemies together and blast them equally it really didn't much matter who they were here and he felt that they were all motivated by a common spirit, a satanic spirit so he could be Ardon's wangli as we have seen and he's certainly Ardon Karlstadt here. Karlstadt acknowledged that he had destroyed images but he said I did it peacefully and he also acknowledged that he disagreed with Luther on the Lord's supper. Karlstadt said to Luther that day if I have aired you should have approved me on a brotherly way and not have stabbed me and struck me thus. Luther said you stabbed me before I stabbed you. Karlstadt said no I didn't do that. Well this discussion was going nowhere Dr. Luther fell silent a while and in the silence Dr. Karlstadt turned to the others who sat nearby and said dear brothers I pray you don't pay attention to my harsh speech but that encounter at the end of the black bear points to a very important divergence in the Lutheran Reformation two approaches now to Reformation from the Lutheran side of things and the first point has to do with the thoroughness and the pace of the Reformation. Those sides agree that the church must be reformed can no longer be Catholic but exactly how to do it and how fast to do it was the issue. People like Munser and Karlstadt wanted to move much faster. They said Luther broke the Pope's picture but he kept the pieces in his hands and they wanted to get rid of it all the mass the images everything right away without waiting after all if it's wrong and if it's sin then it should be abolished and whatever it takes to abolish it was what they proposed and we should move fast they said when Luther came back to Vittenberg very much dismayed by what had taken place in his absence during his time at the Vortberg he said the cause is good but there has been too much haste for there are still brothers and sisters on the other side who belonged to us and must still be one so Luther was for proceeding slowly people don't change overnight and Luther wanted to give them time but Karlstadt preached a sermon in title whether one should proceed slowly and Karlstadt certainly answered that no if I should see a little innocent child holding a sharp pointed knife in his hand and he wants to keep it will I show him brotherly love by letting that little child hold that sharp knife and cut himself or when I break his will and force that knife out of his hands onto the floor and take it from him when you take from the child what injures him you do a fatherly or brotherly Christ like the two opinions as to how the reformation should proceed and not only the pace of the reformation but also the shape of the reform what's to guide the reform is the new church is created what is to be its foundation well we know of course that Luther said scripture alone we go by what the scripture says but these radicals although not denying the authority of scripture began to believe many of them not all of them that there was another authority above the scripture the Holy Spirit who gave the scripture in the first place and who was now speaking directly to them to instruct them how the reform should progress Thomas Muncer thinking of Luther said he who has not the spirit does not know how to say anything deeply about God even if he has eaten through a hundred Bibles Luther thinking of Muncer and especially Carlstad described them as people who had swallowed the Holy Spirit feathers and all another difference between these two groups was that the radicals although not denying justification by faith were much more concerned about regeneration holiness the Christian life

and Luther although not denying the significance of obedience to the Lord was very concerned about establishing the doctrine of the alien righteousness which is powers through Christ death that's the first episode to help us to get into the mind and heart of the radicals a few months later in the city of Zurich Switzerland something took place that we want to talk about next this comes not from the Lutheran Reformation now but it comes from the Swiss Reformation you can see Zurich the bottom of the map with the arrow the town of Zwingli

January 21st 1525 a man named Conrad Grebel baptized another man named George Blowrock who then baptized some other people in the lake this is the beginning of the anavaptist movement now you might think not be anything to cause great excitement that somebody had been baptized but these people according to Zwingli and almost everybody else were being rebabtized because they had been baptized as Catholics as infants but these men had decided that that was not real baptist that was not true baptist and so they did not view themselves as anabaptists but as people who were following the Lord now for the first time as believers in true Christian baptism these people were Zwingli's followers and friends and it was his preaching that had stirred them up to do this kind of thing they believed like those radicals in Luther's Germany that the reform had to move faster now Zwingli was moving faster than Luther but still not fast enough to satisfy the anavaptist or the Swiss brethren as there sometimes call it came out of his movement they press for immediate action against the images and against the mass and their defiant act of baptism was assigned that they were now going to wait for nobody they would take matters in their own hands and if there was not a church that would do what they felt should be done they would do it themselves so they baptized each other without waiting for a decision from the city council so England kept saying we're deciding we're moving the council is meeting but these more zealous brethren said the decision has already been made by the spirit of God and we don't care then what the city council does well another very troubling episode because with this the Zwinglian reform breaks apart as the Lutheran reform had broken apart one of the issues that Zwingli's followers fixed on of course was believers baptism they rejected infant baptism and they rejected it with strong words one said the access and portal of a false Christianity the shite time confession which is in our syllabus describes infant baptism as the highest in chief abomination of the pope so they believed it wasn't in the Bible and must be completely eradicated from the church these Swiss radicals were all way already very much committed to the Bible only view which was Luther's view and Zwingli's view but in a different way Luther and to a lesser extent Zwingli allowed some use of Christian tradition in other words it's the Bible but as the Bible had been understood by the best of the church fathers and by the church at its best and purist times in history all of that was not to be thrown out but these brethren saw very little good in it all I would have no job in a seminary that they would have started because they would have just studied the New Testament and everything that I've been teaching all year would have been viewed as pretty worthless in fact one of these and a Baptist put it this way foolish Ambrose foolish Augustine foolish Jerome foolish Gregory of whom not even one knew the Lord so help me God nor was sent by God to teach rather they were all apostles of antichrist what it puts it pretty strong like especially when you see Augustine in that list but these people were not patient with all the development of church history and so much of it is bad they said and we know that a lot of it was bad so they wanted to throw it all out and start over with the Bible only and they wanted to get back to a church that was not the Constantine church where there is a union of church and state to these people the conversion of Constantine and the conversion of their own empire in the 4th century was a disaster because the church was then converted into a worldly church with its allegiance to the state and its connection to the state and the Antibaptist and the other radicals opposed that the sword of the state they said is outside the perfection of Christ they're two kingdoms and really these two have little or nothing to do with each other the Swiss brethren or the Antibaptist as they're called created a confession the Schleitheim confession it is called we had that in our syllabus so you have read the Schleitheim confession this is the first page of it in German the title here is the brotherly union of the two children of God we call it the Schleitheim confession but it has this other title as well the brotherly union of the two children of God addressed to the children of light scattered everywhere and you know from reading this confession that it's not a full confession of doctrine but it's a list of some of the distinctives of the Antibaptist movement believers baptism church discipline separation from the world the separation of the church and the state and rejection of owes the Antibaptist stress life community they're not all that concerned about doctrine as you can tell from this confession their favorite figure appears to have been the penitent thief on the cross who as one of them said was saved without any knowledge of the substance in persons of the Godhead pato baptism con substantiation predestination and so on and so on so an emphasis on community and life rather than on doctrine after the beginning of the Antibaptist movement these people were persecuted by all sides Catholics often burned them Protestants usually drowned them many were persecuted and lost their lives in the 16th century because they were believed to be guilty of blasphemy in rebabtism and not only blasphemy but sedition rebellion because rebabtism was not only pericy but it was against the laws of the land and they're refusal to swear owes of allegiance to governments and their commitment to pacifism marked them out as very dangerous people so the history of Antibaptism becomes a sad record of exile and martydom there many very sad parts of the story of the 16th century and this certainly is one of them we have in our syllabus the account of the two young noble women Antibaptists who were put to death in holland for their Antibaptist fate now let's come to the third episode Luthor at the Black Bayer the Antibaptist in Switzerland the third episode is in a city called Munster located in west failure in Germany not too far from the Dutch border and it's indicated by the arrow at the top of the map was that this place that a group of Antibaptists were able to take over a whole city the Antibaptists went wherever they could wherever they could find some safety and some peace it was not many places where they could find such but eventually many of them migrated to this city and in time took over this city and then became something that they were not to begin with revolutionary they expelled the Catholics in the Protestants from the city and they set up an Old Testament theocracy and waited for the establishment of God's kingdom on earth city of Munster quickly degenerated into a morass of religious fanaticism terror polygamy elimination of private property and all kinds of other abuses until at last the city was besieged by an army of Catholics and Protestants Catholics and Protestants in the 16th century almost never did anything together unless they were fighting the Antibaptist and the city of Munster was besieged and captured the leaders were executed and that was the end of that but the entire Antibaptist movement was marked by Munster people said see what happens when they get in control when John Calvin the young John Calvin was writing the first edition of his institutes which came out in 1536 was writing it just at the time that Munster took place he wrote a long preface to Francis the first the king of France basically saying we are not Antibaptist the reform in France are not Antibaptist he had to make that point because he was trying to get Francis not to persecute the Protestants said if Francis thought the Protestants were the Antibaptist there was no way that he was going to leave them alone well out of the debacle of Munster there comes a great leader for the Antibaptist the man that we talked about at the beginning of the class Mino Simons he was a Catholic priest and he saw the Antibaptist movement as a true movement of God and he saw the Antibaptist as sheep which have no shepherd and so Mino Simons left the Catholic Church it came an Antibaptist pastor in the Netherlands and provided leadership for this group he wrote a book called foundation of Christian doctrine Mino Simons was completely orthodox except in one point he did not accept the teaching of the church that the flesh of Christ is just like ours he believed in a heavenly flesh his followers did not continue that view which the church had rejected as heretical and modern day mononites do not hold to the heavenly flesh of Christ but Mino Simons did teach that but he defended scripture salvation by faith and he returned the Antibaptist movement to its earlier convictions of pacifism Mino Simons said Moses and his successors with their iron sword have served out their time and Jesus Christ has now given us a new command separation from the world became an important teaching again as the Minonites and other Antibaptists attempted to live their faith separate from the world and often from the state as well they are sometimes described as the quiet in the land as depicted in this 17th century Dutch painting of a Minonite family in Amsterdam peaceful industrious minding their own business but quiet in the land now let me comment briefly on the Antibaptist heritage some of you are writing a denominational papers and you might find your reformation roots in this Antibaptist movement I've divided this into three points the direct descendants of the 16th century Antibaptist or people like the Minonites and the Amish and the Hutterites the Minonite brethren the brethren in Christ these are what I call direct descendants of the Minonites about one million of these people in 60 different countries in the world the indirect descendants or the Baptist I think the direct line of Baptist history comes from the English Puritan theory sometimes Baptist see themselves as directly lined up with the Antibaptist and there are connections with the Antibaptists which are obvious but picket is more accurate to speak of modern day Baptist as indirect descendants of the Antibaptist and then distant cousins all of us because the Antibaptist heritage has very important implications for all Christians today separation of church and state religious liberty these teachings which most Christians would agree with in the modern world go ultimately back to the Antibaptist heritage now let me end this lecture with brief comments on the radical contribution thinking not only of the Antibaptist but the larger radical movement the radicals were very diverse as I've said it is hard to lump them together and talk about them together I've really sort of struggled in this lecture to quickly tell you something about so many different kinds of people there were 40 to 50 different groups and we have just touched on some of the main ones but in terms of numbers not huge numbers of people in the 16th century I would guess that if we had 100 people one would be a radical maybe two so we're not talking about large numbers like Catholics or Lutherans or reform but the radicals despite their diversity do emphasize certain themes that I have time really just to list those separation of church and state we read the two kingdoms by Hans Schnell you can compare his view of church and state with Luther's by reading the comment from Helmut T. Leakey reviewing Luther's commentary on Genesis in the syllabus another radical contribution religious liberty people should be allowed to serve God the way that they choose and not be forced by the state to be Catholics or Lutherans or Calvinists or anything else there is a question about that did the radicals hold this because of true conviction or because of necessity after all if you're only one percent you're probably going to hold to religious liberty and sometimes people say we'll look at what happened when the radicals got in control of a place like Newtonster there certainly wasn't any religious liberty there I think I would answer the question by saying it's probably both certainly there was some expediency in all of this but I think there's more than that a real conviction that religion should be a free voluntary choice and not imposed upon anyone separation from the world is a theme that keeps coming up and sometimes people have seen the radicals as the primary example of newborns Christ against culture so it's not only separation from the world but separation from culture as well and you can think about whether that is an accurate description of the radicals or not as newborn states it in his famous book but the final point is certainly easy the radical contribution a major radical contribution in a sense was just to suffer you know we're a long way from any kind of place in church history where people will no longer be persecuted for their faith actually many people in the world today being persecuted for their faith all over the world but as we study the history of Western Europe persecution for religious convictions is still the major dominating idea until much much later in fact until a little colony is established in America called Rhode Island and we've got to get many lectures to go before we get to Roger Williams and Rhode Island but as these radicals suffered they became the kind of conscience of the Reformation and not only did they suffer but Calvinist suffered Lutheran suffered Catholics because everybody was against everybody and whoever was in control put people to death who opposed them some people to death who opposed them John Fox who wrote Fox's book of martyrs pled for some condemn anababdis during the time of Queen Elizabeth the first and John Fox said I don't agree with him I don't support their teaching I think it's wrong I think it's false but to burn up with fiery flame the living bodies of men who air through blindness of judgment rather than deliberate will is a hard thing and belongs more to the spirit of Rome than to the spirit of the gospel I did read just last night new study on history of the Anababdis in Europe that 85% of the Anababdis who were executed were executed by Rome but I did not take great deal comfort in that because that's still a 15% executed by other Protestants and the suffering of these people began to eventually get through to the hearts and minds of people like John Fox who said we can be very strongly committed to Christian truth but we can't do this we're for seeing that we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses let us run with perseverance the race that is set before us looking unto Jesus the author and finisher of our faith