<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ber Aýlyk ber

Respect for Human Life, III

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

I put this website back up on the board for your information. This is Trinity University, the Center for Human, Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity that's associated with Trinity University. I received in the mail yesterday some booklets that I ordered from that website. One of which is, well two of which are directly on the topics we were discussing today, basic questions on suicide in euthanasia, and the basic questions on end-of-life decisions. These are extremely, I think this one in particular on end-of-life decisions is particularly valuable for, in your fear, in a pastoral situation and folks need to think through some things. This has a series of questions. It's done in a series of questions. Foundational issues is death a natural part of life, what should be my attitude toward it, so forth, and decision-making issues, including is it ever ethical to withhold fluids and nutrition. That's the most problematic question that people have. So it's for, you know, giving people something to read and then to talk to them about it in the implications of the going through that process. These can be bought in bulk, and I would think as a pastor you find them very useful in that respect, and there's another one in this series that I think could work that way. Basic questions on sexuality and reproductive technology for couples who are going through that process or thinking about that process, couples who are having difficulty having children. They need something, you know, manageable for their thinking. These are, this was an excellent idea. Answering the typical questions that people have on Christian point of view. It's worth knowing about this website. They're continually, yeah, it's bioethics.org, and they're larger books that they keep producing in this area, and it's just worth visiting this website from time to time. They have a new book out. It hasn't, hasn't yet, I haven't yet received my copy, but it's on the full discussion of reproductive technology. So, you know, you want to have that in your library to have the full discussion, but I think that these are extremely useful tool in bringing people up to speed and getting the discussion at that level as they're going through these decisions. The PCA report on heroic measures was done before a lot of this material was was available. So, we were sort of working out to that position, and I think it's, I will refer to that later today, but I think that it's useful to have something that represents a wider Christian consensus now on these issues. There's nothing in here that it's not compatible with what we say in the PCA report, and it's in a more attractive and useful format, and it's more current, also, you know, this area just goes out of date so quickly. So, I wanted you to be aware of those booklets, speaking with prayer. What happened we recognized our dependence upon you for every breath that we've drawn. We pray for strength to do what you have given us to do at the end of the semester. We are overloaded with issues. We cannot resolve all these issues. We ask for your wisdom and blessing upon us as we study them, create in us a disposition that seeks in everything to subordinate itself to your will. But be with us in these last days of the semester to honor you by seeking to fulfill what you have given us to do, complex and exhausting as it is. We would not fail to pray for our nation also in this day of prayer that you would turn our hearts to you. We know that we are to pray for the peace of the city in which we dwell. For it's well-being, we also know that true well-being comes from the gospel of our Lord Jesus. We pray that the gospel may go forth in power in our generation. To turn hearts back to you, those who departed it, that our national life may reflect the principles that you have established for godly living in community. Be with us in this hour we pray in the questions we discuss for Jesus sake. Now, last time we started the second part of respect for human life. I divided it in terms of nascent human life, and then respect for human life at the end. And we began with neonatal neglect right after birth. There's a problem with respect for human life. And we've got started on position assisted suicide, which the state of Oregon now has made legal and about 14 a year, or opting for that assistance. There are several problems with position assisted suicide that I want to mention to focus our attention on why we should be concerned about this issue as a societal issue. So far, there's only one state that has actually enacted into law, but it is a very radical thing that they have done. Only Columbia South America has a similar legislation. It is practiced without legislation in many cases, but not even the Netherlands has enacted euthanasia into law. They have a non-possicution issue so that they tolerate non-possicution in terms of various forms of assisted suicide and euthanasia. But even strictly speaking, even in the Netherlands of law has not been changed. It was changed in northern territories of Australia, but then changed back. So it's really radical. What the state of Oregon has done is really radical. These are the problems with it. First of all, it endorses suicide. That is, it co-ops a society in what said to be the autonomous choice of the person. And that is a very dangerous matter. If you study suicide, you know that people are ambivalent about that up until the end most times. And what they need to hear from the community is that their life is worth living. Even if they cannot recognize it in their present suffering, we have no right as a society to say, go ahead. We don't care what you do with yourself, which is in effect what you're saying. If you adopt a policy that sanctions suicide, which is what is done here. So I think that the case against suicide is really the foundational here. The American legal system has, I learned since the last class, never had the same laws against suicide that Great Britain had up until 1960s. We never enacted into law laws against suicide, but we always had laws against assisted suicide. And most states, in fact all but six have explicit laws, or common laws, clear laws against assisted suicide. In a few states it's ambiguous in Oregon, it's now the law. So it's a very radical step. And it's the opposite of what society should say to its members. It's presented as an autonomous issue. And that suits our radical individualism. Everybody does what he wants, but we have a responsibility for one another. And we can't really give up that responsibility for a member of our community. The community needs to say, though you don't think your life is worth living, we do. And we will care for you. We'll do what it takes. So it endorses suicide. It compromises the medical profession. Medical profession is to be a healing profession. Can't always heal, but it must always care. So it's a healing and caring profession. But it's to always heal, always to care never to kill. And although it doesn't directly kill in a position assisted suicide, it nevertheless is co-opted into the process by giving the means by which the autonomous agent takes his own life. Now the appeal to this, the feel of this in the medical profession is because it is to compassion. So can't you do something for me in my suffering? And a caring profession is you feel the pull toward that. But it really compromises the profession. Once you move in this direction, you have become not a healing and caring profession, but a killing profession. It seriously erodes the concept of medicine as a profession that goes back at least 400 years before Christ to hypocrite. So this is also a radical development. It's really returning to an era before the Hippocratic oath was instituted. And for those reasons, we, I think we must resist it. And the article that I gave, the handout that I gave you on medicalizing suicide, I think is right on this point, and we need to interact with that. The third point that I would make is that it inevitably invites euthanasia, the state of Oregon, went the direction of position assisted suicide after trying a more broadly use of the medical profession in California and Washington, attempts that would actually have allowed the doctor to administer the fatal dose of medicine. That was turned down in both of those states on referendum. And the state of Oregon then realizing that public sentiment would not support euthanasia went the root of assisted suicide. However, there is no way to logically not allow the doctors to administer the fatal dose, but simply require the patient to take it. You can even expect discrimination suits, where a person has expressed their wishes, has received the medicine, fallen into a coma, you can expect lawsuits for the against, oddly discrimination against the handicap, for not allowing the doctor to administer the dose. The patient clearly wanted had in hand, but was unable to take. And so I think that there is no, we should be careful about slippery slope arguments. What this, what this one means is that there is a momentum once you introduce physicians into the death process to move toward, on the grounds of compassion, the more compassionate thing is to let the doctor administer the dose, because death by taking pills, they tell them it can take three hours or more. And there are risks because people are sick, patients can spill the medicine or choke vomit, fall asleep before the full dose. With an injection, the patient lapses into a coma within about 10 seconds, and death comes often 10 minutes later. If you allow the autonomy issue, and you involve the medical profession on compassion grounds, which is more compassionate. Well it's obvious to take euthanasia. Physician administer death is more compassionate. So I think that this is a clear example of a slope on which it's impossible to gain a foothold and not move toward the other thing. The logic is toward euthanasia. I think it's wrong in itself. Physician assistant suicide is wrong in itself. So I'm not saying it's wrong because it invites euthanasia, but I think that we should recognize it's inevitable. The logic is inexorable, that if you involve physicians in death to this extent on grounds of compassion, you're going to take the next step. The fourth objection that I have is that it puts the vulnerable at risk, say this, just put it vulnerable. It puts vulnerable persons at risk. Once you create the option as a matter of societal permission, you create an expectation for that, especially in a society where the great fear is being a burden on somebody else. I think that that fear of being a burden comes on somebody else probably stems from our unwillingness to take on burdens, and so we don't want to be a burden because we are rejecting the idea of taking on burdens. That's latent there. But if you have in the climate where the main fear is you don't want to be a burden, if you create the option of a way out that's painless, socially sanctioned, then people are not autonomous in making that decision. It undercuts the grant, it undercuts the autonomy of the decision because there are subtle and not so subtle pressures to get on with the final exit. That's already happening as documented in a number of things. I think that for these reasons we need to be alert and aware and to oppose the movement of position-assisted suicide. It is involving the culture of death. So for those I think that's sufficient. No, not to my knowledge. I don't think that there are most

successful suicides or by white males in terms of percentage, and they're mostly with with guns, with firearms, and so there's another issue that is there, but that's the way most suicides happen. More women attempt suicide than men, but more men are actually successful in carrying it out. It is one thing about this booklet on suicide in Euthanasia. It answers the number of those statistical questions about suicide. It's very handy for that kind of information.

One of my kids when he was coming along taking Piano asked me to get him the theme from mash and to play, and so I did, and then to my astonishment I didn't know this, the theme to mash is suicide as painless. If there is ever a lie, that's it. Suicide is not painless.

No, it's a terrible event, and the family is left with the consequences. Yes. What about lethal injection? I'm not talking about the pain to the person that's involved. I'm talking about the pain to the family, but I'm also talking about the pain that comes from being isolated and allowed to commit suicide, when suicide is mainly a cry for help. The best best the authority on suicide in this country is Hinden. Let's see if I can give his full name here for you. It's Herbert, Herbert Hinden, one of the foremost American authorities on suicide. The Executive Director of the American Suicide Foundation, Professor of Psychiatry at New York Medical College. He came to my attention with a book published in 1997, seduced by death. It's an account of the medical situation in the Netherlands, which he interviewed. He went with sympathetic toward the Dutch tour when he started out, but when he found that the safeguards were violated, he really changed his mind. The various safeguards that are put into law are being ignored. It's a very important work in 1997, seduced by death, and in that book he does go into some of the things about suicide, as well as how there is a movement from assisted suicide to Euthanasia, from Euthanasia for people who are terminally ill, to Euthanasia for those who are chronically ill, for Euthanasia for physical distress, to Euthanasia for psychological distress, and from voluntary Euthanasia to non-voluntary Euthanasia. It's a good exploration of that movement and virtually every guideline that was established can be violated with impunity. It's a lesson as we move into that area. We ought to examine what the actual experience has been in Holland. Now, we need to talk about a third area here that I call medical non-intervention, or well, no, wait, no, wait, I forgot. Today I'm calling it medical non-treatment, medical non-treatment, is what I meant to say. On the last page of the handout that I gave yesterday, I'll do dying patients really need IV fluids. I have from the Christian medical fellowship, that's the British Christian medical fellowship, from their file 1999, some reasons why a doctor made decide to avoid delay, start, or stop a particular treatment, and then teach 10 key concepts that guide their discussion. That's a handy grid. It's useful to take a look at that. I want to say something about the PCA report on medical non-treatment. We've already seen that sometimes that constitutes culpable neglect when down syndrome babies are allowed to die through either medical non-intervention or not feeding them, and hydrating them. That is culpable, and by design, so that they would die, and you're not to burden with a down syndrome child, that is euthanasia. The intention is that the child die through its non-treatment, so that there are measures that are necessary means of preservation of life, and I report to the physician that food air water by natural roots, that is without technical assistance, may not be denied by the patient or anyone caring for him, and medical treatment that is clearly efficacious to heal or to restore may not be denied either. If it is a reversible condition, then our respect for life requires us to make use of that medical intervention, that's a treatable condition, and including the sustenance that's necessary while that's going on. But on the other side, the PCA report says, treatments that are ineffective, mental-moly-effective, or have frequent and serious side-effects, are not obligatory. In other words, they're limits to what we can impose by way of medical treatment. We're going to say in the report, specific effective measures should be chosen with clear cut goals for the patient's condition. These are patient-oriented. You have to, you can't deal with these in this abstract. You have to deal with the particular patient and choose those goals in there. We say in the report, I think this was important, ethical choices may become more clearly evident if the goals of medical care in these situations are first the heal or restore, but we can't do that. Secondly, to relieve suffering, and then I underline this, it is not the goal of medicine simply to prevent death. It's not the goal of medicine simply to prevent death. The underlying disease takes their life, and a person in the terminal stages of an illness, one that is irreversible, has a right to say to physicians, not help me to kill myself, nor kill me, but it does have the right to say, it is time for me to die, do not intervene. Now there's now widespread agreement that patients that are in an irreversible condition should not be subjected to troublesome treatments that cannot restore to health. And a corollary of that, of relieving suffering, is that doctors may use drug to control pain, even though they may have the effect of shortening life. Your intention in those cases is not to shorten the life. Your intention is to relieve the suffering to make the life more bearable, but it does have, as a side effect, the shortening of life. Now this is very, very different. Dr. Koop made this way. The intent behind the gradual administration of drugs to a lay suffering is to keep her comfortable as a person slips away. The intent behind the drug overdose is to get her out of her misery, off our hands, quickly as possible. Now this comes down to intent. It's been argued that if we allow drugs that we know will shorten life, well, why not just give the fatal dose all at once? Well, it does depend upon your intention, and there is a legitimate intention to relieve suffering even though it hastens death, that doesn't intend to hasten the test. That's not the motive. Whereas a drug overdose is to relieve suffering by taking the person's life. That is a quite different thing. And that is a matter of fact, was recognized in the Supreme Court as one of these cases came up to it. So that that is, that's now a standard recognition, difference between administrative drugs which may have the side effect of shortening life, and the intentional use of drugs to take away life. Now I think that their care for the dying mandates a number of things. You put it this way, over the summer I want to try to learn and use PowerPoint. Then we can save all this in a room that I don't have an overhead end, but anyway, there are these four things that we'll always have caring for the dying. First of all, this companionship, companionship, so that a person does not die alone. That human contact that really says that to die with dignity means to die as a human person to the end, and I'll be with you in through the dying process. And the hospice movement has established itself as a truly viable alternative to the death with dignity movement that involves a suicidal euthanasia. It's the positive attitude that is transferred to the dying person through this, lifts the feeling of helplessness and helps the patient to die with a sense of worth to the end. That's true dignity, to help the person die with a sense of worth to the end. Now, along with that is spiritual care, which is questions we must always provide. Spiritual care, to pray with and for a dying person. Even when they slip into unconsciousness, they may be unconscious from our point of view. There are various testimonies when a person, apparently unconscious, has been able to make some motion that they recognize what is going on. But in any case, we pray for people if they can't hear it. But our presence there in the spiritual care is there. Then there is hygiene as a part of respect for human life to the end. Keep people clean and comfortable. That is a part of the care that will miss all, always give. And the fourth thing would be analgesics or painkillers. And those should be administered aggressively. It's now recognized that aggressive use of morphine is not incompatible with respect for human life. It may have the effect of shortening the life. But persons may be lucid in those final days and the value of being lucid and free from pain outweighs the shortening of the painful experience until the end. It's not a biblical principle that we should suffer as much as possible. We accept suffering when God has it. The God has also provided us ways to alleviate suffering.

So this is comfort care. When we can't cure, we can always provide comfort care and out of respect for human life. We certainly should do that even when we can't treat symptoms, let alone cure. Comfort care is always mandatory on us. Now the question of nutrition and hydration because that is so basic to the care we all want another and symbolizes the bonds of nurturance that we have that this sometimes people add that is a fifth point that we may never deny a dying patient the food and water. If we can't administer them through natural means that then artificially we may do that. We came to the conclusion in our committee, it was a result of the medical doctors on that committee that even taking nourishment may impose excessive burdens and when artificial administration is sometimes excessively burdensome in that connection.

Fluids can be administered by intravenously by needle for only a limited amount of time then you have to go into more radical things and nasogastric tube down your through your nose to the stomach or an operation called gastrostomy and we need some question as to when it is mandatory. I take the position and I'm happy to see that this is also the position of the booklet end of life questions. They recognize that this is controversial and so they leave it to the judgment of the person involved is whether this is always necessary but they defend those who would remove it. I take it on the ground that this is although this is not medical treatment it is an invasive medical procedure and the conditions when medically assisted nutrition and hydration are not obligatory or I think these three when they're futile that's clear. God doesn't requires to do something that's futile and sometimes the effort to provide nutrition and hydration may very well cause suffering and offers no counterbounds in benefit. The body is shutting down, it can't metabolize food and it's pointless and so that is to lose sight of the purpose of medicine to hold up that a patient must be subject to predictably futile sort of intervention is to lose sight of the purpose that we're there for. A second I think that that's clear cut if it's futile it's obviously not obligatory. A judgment is called for when my second point when burden is disproportionate to any possible benefit that is when you're when you're postponing death by measures that increase suffering that is that's a judgment that we need that we need to make and if and the the article that I gave on our IV foods always necessary makes that case that sometimes though you may you may postpone the hour of death it's only by at the expense of suffering the third type of condition is when when the patient cannot benefit because of pathology. We're talking here about an irreversible condition in which a person is rendered permanently unconscious. Now you have to make a judgment when there are many different kinds of coma there are whole books written on the different types of coma so we have to be very careful here is to whether we're talking about an irreversible condition or one that's that's a reversible there have people who've awakened after years of being in a coma because there it was not the irreversible and respect for life requires us to maintain them. We're talking about the kind of pathology that is irreversible a person is not dead because there is the brain stem is still working so the metabolism functions are still going on but the all upper brain activity is gone so that the person will never regain consciousness and will never function as a person and I think that that's the question where we have to ask it what is the benefit to the patient of under those circumstances let me say something about the criteria of death or the clinical signs of death before I get back to this question on the clinical signs of death we now have the traditional clinical signs irreversible succession of circulatory and respiratory functions okay irreversible succession of circulatory and respiratory functions that's your heart and lungs once those are gone you're dead but now in with our modern technology we can keep the blood circulating and the lungs are oxygenated indefinitely through machines and so we've had to adopt when those traditional signs cannot be applied then we have had to take as a criterion of death irreversible succession of all functions of the entire brain including the brain stem human life is then no longer present because unified human function isn't present and cannot be restored and in biblical terms the body without the spirit is dead now we don't identify the spirit with the brain but that brain is the organizing of the life in this organizing principle in this life and when the brain is dead when the whole brain is dead the person is dead so it turned off the machine it's clear cut and I think that we should be careful about that that turning off the machine it is

people have because of the transplant industry been precipitous in their wanting to pronounce people dead so this is something that is again it's an area of caution but in principle when we can't apply the traditional signs because we've got a respirator going then you take the person off the respirator do we then wait until cart and lung function actually cease before we allow transplant I think yes but that's there to be further discussion of that yes well I don't think that I entirely agree with that I think that when that it's entirely entirely financially motivated you have to if you cannot imply the the the we're talking about person that has no brain function not a person that brain stem is still function but no brain function that person from a biblical point of view is no longer there and I think that the only way we can the reason we cannot apply the traditional clinical signs is because the technology is in the way we have to remove the technology in order to to to see that that will be the result you you you the circulatory systems function is to supply oxygen to the brain if the brain is no longer working it's pointless to supply with oxygen and so you know you're you're to to keep a person in a state of artificially suspended animation seems to me to go against the biblical principle what is more difficult is where the financial thing does come in is when people are in reversible coma because that is a hundred thousand dollars a year and it goes on and and on and it is indefinite but there is for respect for life that that there is when a person is conscious or has the potential of regaining consciousness that's one set of circumstances this other circumstances is that the person will never be conscious because the brain is dead as we say when the brain is dead the person is dead further complication is when you have the brain stem so that there's still light there there's a movement now to say that that that we define death in terms of just the upper brain rather than the whole brain and so these people who have still brain stems are are dead I think that's a big mistake they are alive the question is the ethical question is whether we're obligated to keep them alive though they will never regain consciousness they will never function as a person because of their the brains that they're still a person but question is whether it's obligatory on us to sustain them knowing that they will never regain those functions now the pamphlet here see if I can hope I can get the right pages 18 and 19 this is the let me just read you a couple things perhaps the most perplexing category of patients are those who are permanently unconscious but not imminently die you gotta brain stem but you don't have enough of brain it's so called persistent vegetative state we avoid that terminology but that pds is what it's called in the literature what do we do about these people this is the most agonizing decision we can't say that they're dead now they are still alive and I agree with their caution about talking about a vegetative state because that involves a loss of respect second people understandably struggle as they try to locate such patients on the continuum from life in this world to life in the next when does a Christian for example move beyond interaction with this world to interaction with the spiritual realm belong beyond experientially permanently unconscious patients experientially experientially

permanently unconscious patients have left this world so the benefit to the patients of continued symptom care that merely keeps the bodily functions from ceasing is far from clear I think you have to ask what does it benefit the patient now it ought to be very clear about what the patients will is we all ought to decide and get it in writing what our will is and if we want that symptom care if we're in that kind of a state we should say so and if we don't want it we should also say so we don't put other people in the position of having to infer that decision or make that decision it ought to be clear but it's a judgment call and I think that some symptoms care can be elected out of respect for human life but in some circumstances I think it is appropriate to not intervene with intrusive measures for the purpose of keeping an unconscious person a permanently unconscious person from dying you know what benefit is that to the person and I do think it's I do think it's not wrong to factor in the cost of that $100,000 a year in order to maintain a person in that unrecoverable unconscious state it seems to me is excessively burdensome not just financially in terms of the patient in terms of the family in terms of the nature of the care itself what are we what are we doing when we go to these measures simply because we have them now in our modern age rather than allowing a nature to take its course the person we're not choosing death in those situations will be bowing before the inevitable death course is advanced by the pathology itself and be some beyond some point it's a judgment call it's useless to fight it so I take the position that for anticefalic infants children without a brain that we allow them to kill them but it's not culpable neglect to not to feed them we make them comfortable we switch from hydration to moistening the lips to do everything we can to make them comforting all the scientific details are in that article that comes a time in which it's it's futile and of no benefit to the patient to maintain them in that state they're not dead and we don't have a right to kill them but I think that non intervention or non treatment and I think that the treatment in this case with food and water though that bothers us is an invasive procedure yes the bill. The reason why we have the criterion of brain death in which we declare a person dead at that point and and remove the machine is because the person cannot function in that condition we are artificially maintaining a course in its from taking its natural course that's that's why we declare a person brain dead now whether we should actually wait until the person ceases all those functions before we start removing organs is a question I haven't decided but I think that the brain death criterion is clear that that person is gone it's no longer with us and that it's wrong to maintain that that person in suspended animation you know the death is an event that is clinically analyzed but but thanks keep cell division and growth of fingernails and hair and so forth you know on morticians you know have to shave and clip fingernails and all that because processes are still still going on what the person is dead so I think that the criterion of brain death it seems to me is sound in terms of looking at biblical principles we don't have a clinical definition of death in in the scriptures but I think that this is the definition of the brain is compatible a brain death is compatible with everything that we know from the scriptures yes well I think that it depends on the individual case obviously but I think in principle where there's that kind of resistance food and water by natural roots is one thing now sometimes we go to the other route because it's easier on us it takes a lot of time to feed in a person I think it's still taken by natural roots we ought to do it even in those cases there is the liability of pneumonia because the food gets into the lungs and then should we treat the pneumonia well at some point you have to decide whether the treatment is more burdensome and for the patients benefit we're talking about individual patients rather than an abstract concept of going on with life that our tendency because of our strong pro life commitments is to overtread and and for families to require more treatment than they want for themselves and so we have to make we have to make some judgments and there are there's a growing set of criteria that they do have to be applied in individual cases but what's the good of the patient that's the question what what benefit does this have for the patient and is it worth it not all medical interventions are worth it to the patient and so a person can say I've lived it long enough this isn't going to cure me and the side effects of this particular procedure are so horrific you know that at my age and given my circumstances don't intervene that's a rational and biblical decision that we can do the only one that I can think of is is in James as the body without the spirit is dead I mean Paul is arguing there but it's it's like Ecclesiastes the the the body returns to earth as it was in the spirit to God that that gave it now the death of the the brain is not the this we don't identify the spirit in the brain but the brain is the organizing function where the spirit operates in this in this life so I think it's legitimate it's as close as we're going to get in in a authority that was produced before we had all of this advanced understanding okay well we need to start our next topic we'll have to we'll have to finish up I really propose to talk about too many issues that these last couple of days but we do want to say something about homosexuality something about role of women and something about race relations those latter two I'm going to have to just give some some principles for guidance rather than a full discussion but homosexuality as you know just is is very much in the news right now terms the Boy Scout thing terms of the March on Washington terms of the Vermont civic union legislation so this is this does require that we give a serious attention to it if you if you'll take the by wave introduction if you'll take the the handout that I gave I really meant to put Mary Stewart Van Lewin on the on the front I punch this in the wrong side but logically her article comes first just sort of oriented to orient us toward the homosexual discussion I think this is this is very much to the point most mainline church study documents on the issue simply assume that it's that is the biological origins of homosexuality are scientifically established but this is far from the case now Mary Stewart Van Lewin is a psychologist she's a reformed Christian teacher at the Eastern Baptist College has written gender and grace I think that that's a book she's best at known for but she approaches this from the side of a trained psychologist and what she talks about about establishing causality requires a broadly accepted definition of just what it is we're deserving and consensus is lacking a couple of weeks ago I attended a conference at St. Louis University sponsored by various homosexual groups and I heard a really fine lecture by a lesbian psycho analyst I was glad I'd taken Dr. Winter invited Dr. Winter to go along with me because you really had needed to have some background order asked the right question but under his probing she really admitted this what's in in this paper in the psychological point of view this this is accurate and she said you we hear in the news when there's some supposed genetic connection with homosexuality well we don't hear is when further research turns out that that didn't pan out so she was very honest I really really thought it was it was good to hear some of this from the other side so to speak she also said in her practice as Dr. Winter pressed her on the question of whether for the persons can change well you know it sort of depends on where you are along this continuum she had and desire for change is a factor she said she had an orthodox Jewish woman who was lesbian who came to her and the psychotherapist took the view it's not my my role to make a judgment here but she led her to to decide you know you're going to have to choose whether to remain true to your orthodox Jewish Bay or your lesbian inclination and she chose her orthodox Jewish Bay that was more important to her than the expression of her lesbian inclination she made you know she made that choice so that was to me illuminate you know that is a that's a psychotherapist who lets who doesn't impose her view on on her client I'll have to get it it slips me at the moment sorry um not in my permanent memory I have to consult my literature but I'll bring her name I um from Eastern college but I forget the name of that too the second paragraph from Ben Lewin um you getting this all on tape okay that was wonderful clearly biology does matter this also was admitted and there's still some perplexity it follows a predictable if complicated course biological aspects of sexuality usually correspond with each other and with psychological aspects to lead to the male female sexual bonding and subsequent reproductive activity that's the way we're made you know that's what usually happens the concordance of these multiple aspects can break down on rare occasions you know the 10 percent rule has been undermined it's at most 3 percent now we'll recognize the homosexual supposed persons adopt that figure that now but the norm is clear human biological program is based is biased toward heterosexuality and as a species we are not infinitely valuable in terms of our potential sexual orientation I think this is well put but now here's the point that that I latch on to the interplay between nature nurture human freedom also helps to explain that our Old Testament New Testament ancestors were correct in treating various non-normative sexual acts as thanks to which anyone could be tempted the the Bible as we will see approaches this on the level of behavior on the baby on the level of actions and um that's because a number of influence number forces can influence people to engage in variations that's why people are tempted to speak of the social construction of sexual sexuality she rejects that but you can sort of see why that is the case last paragraph we need to remember that the concept of constitutional homosexual orientation arose when Victorian doctors shifted attention from individual homosexual acts to the concept of homosexuality as a pervasive personality structure this is recent in terms of approaches and she suggests here might it not even be preferable to return to the language of our recent ancestors and try to deal with each case on a compassionate individual basis that declines to make global fatalistic attributions about the sexual orientation but I think that sound advice and so if we um start let me get a start on um my outline on homosexuality it's it's it's pretty simple Bible church and society um but is this now seven it's eight oh it's seven almost sexuality um I begin with the the biblical testimony whenever I um approach this subject um in a forum or whatever I always try to get three evangelical assumptions out early on they are that all human beings are created in the image of God I think it's important to say that that all human beings are created in the image of God that has certain implications for the way we treat one another all human beings are created in the image of God all have all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God and so we recognize our solidarity and sin as rather as well as our common dignity as human beings in the image of God all have sinned fall short of the glory of God and the third uh aspect of the evangelical perspective is that all are offered forgiveness and renewal through Christ

now you will recognize that our standard uh framework of creation fall and redemption all human beings created in the image of God all have sinned fall short of the glory of God all are offered forgiveness and uh renewal in Christ that's that's a bait it's a basic framework and I think it's useful as you're getting the discussions of this to let that come through in some way or or other so that's the evangelical perspective that we um bring that we look at uh when we consider the the biblical testimony specifically with respect to um homosexuality um we have a uh a theological framework that I think is useful for for that I begin with the creation ordinances I think it's important to begin with Genesis 1.27 and 2.24 the passages that Jesus coordinates uh in the gospel since actually talking about divorce but he he collates these two passages and I think they're relevant here God created humankind as complementary sexual beings male and female and erotic desire is rightfully fulfilled in the one flesh relationship of heterosexual marriage I'll run that by again God created humankind as complementary sexual beings male and female obviously

carlary is that erotic desire is rightfully fulfilled in the one flesh relationship of heterosexual marriage actually you could just say marriage but to be explicit about it now it's heterosexual marriage we're talking about now the the reason why I think it's important to begin with the creation ordinances is that the norm of heterosexual marriage is uniformly presented in scripture from the creation narrative to the vision of the New Jerusalem it's literally from Genesis to Revelation creation narrative God's creation male and female Adam and Eve one flesh relationship of marriage and the New Jerusalem as a bride beautifully dressed for her husband you know the marriage supper of the lamb is based on a heterosexual figure of marriage so it uh and there there is no counterweight no countering text now on the issue of women's ordination we have some countertext to deal with you know you have to sort that sort that through with do you give greater weight to uh relations and there in Christ there's no male or female or greater weight to uh first Timothy and which uh Paul doesn't allow a woman to teach your exercise authority over man well you've got you know you've got at least counter veiling text in that case no counterveiling text with respect to homosexuality now I think it's useful to say that because it's sometimes argued there only a few texts that deal with homosexuality that is true there's just a handful but there against the background of the whole teaching of scripture in which heterosexual marriage is a norm for the fulfillment of their erotic desire okay um creation ordinances then the law of Moses I go to I skipped the uh the account of Sodom um that is I think that that is a homosexual activity that was envisioned there but it's gang rape nobody is going to approve gang rape a heterosexual or homosexual and so I think that uh it's not the most useful passage uh to bring out I think that you better go to the explicit tech in in Leviticus it's Leviticus 1822 and Leviticus 2013 and Leviticus 1822 uh says that you shall not lie with mankind as a woman kind and Leviticus 2013 is example of case law where that uh the death penalty is prescribed for that activity now these passages are frequently dismissed as part of Israel's ceremonial law specifically the concern with cult prostitution and therefore you know for both of those reasons they they aren't applicable to um homosexual relations today but um not everything in Leviticus is temporary Leviticus 1918 you should love your neighbor as yourself many folks don't realize that that comes from Leviticus and it happens to be sandwiched in between chapters 18 and chapter 20 so we have to we recognize we've got to make some distinctions when it comes to Leviticus some of it is what we call the moral law and when you look at the surrounding context of uh Leviticus 1822 Leviticus 1820 refers to adultery verse 21 child sacrifice verse 23 beastiality so it's talking about moral concerns now it is true that Leviticus 1918 has some other things in there Leviticus 1819 prohibits intercourse during menstruation so there's ceremonial mixed in we would say the blood laws have a specific reference uh in uh in the Old Testament law and the consequences are certainly not on a par with Leviticus 2013 compare Leviticus 1524 and Leviticus 2013 for the penalty of having intercourse during menstruation the the the uh well we're out of time just to say one thing um the the the in in Leviticus 18 homosexual acts are called an abomination that's that's clearly a term that's used for moral wrong but it's not the only moral wrong sometimes the only term that the only time abomination sin is referred to as abomination is referred to that this sin and that's wrong you've got to you've got to read Proverbs 6 verses 16 to 19 for the seven things that are an abomination to the Lord and homosexuality is not on that list but sewing up but sewing dissension among brothers is so let's be uh even happy in what we call abomination now to reserve it for homosexuality fails to take account that all have sinned and fall short to the glory of God okay we'll start here next time thank you