<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ber Aýlyk ber

Rise & Fall of King Saul, III

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

All right, we have returned after the break and we want to pick up the threads where we left them vangling when you left. We are dealing with the rise of Saul and with some of the questions that have been raised about the rise of Saul and some of the concerns that scholars have had that have led them to believe that it really doesn't make sense as a story. We looked before the break at the differing attitudes to the monarchy and also we mentioned another objection to the integrity, the unity, the sense of these narratives relating to the fact that Saul seems to become king in too many different ways. And at the end of the time I mentioned that maybe this pattern of accession, three part, three stages that lead someone to a position of power, might help us understand what is going on in these accounts as we go back and read them in that light. Now let me mention one other problem that is not as often mentioned, but it is a real problem that some have noted and we need to be aware of. That is that in chapter 10, verse 8, we have a reference made by Samuel to Saul's going to Gilgal and waiting seven days for Samuel to arrive. And then lo and behold, many chapters later, well chapter 11, chapter 12, into chapter 13, in chapter 13, verse 8, we have, he waited seven days the time set by Samuel, but Samuel did not come to Gilgal and Saul's men began to scatter. So here we have, I think a clear link between 10, 8 and 13, 8, and the question that arises is how did all these intervening episodes get in there? Shouldn't this be just seven days later? That is the question that we also need to wrestle with and we will discover that wrestling with that question will actually provide a key to understanding what is going on in the rise of Saul. So let me begin by pointing you to the very significant account of Saul's actual anointing by Samuel. What we are going to do is we talk about Saul, we will go over these texts from different vantage points several times, so we will skip over some things that you may say why doesn't he comment on that? Well I will probably hit it later or forget to hit it, but I will try to come back and hit certain things from different angles. Right now I want us to look at just chapter 10, beginning in verse 1, this is a continuation of what happened in chapter 9, in chapter 9, Saul without looking for his father's lost livestock and he encountered Samuel. Samuel let him know that, or rather God had let Samuel know that he had special things in store for Saul and in chapter 16 of chapter 9. God had even said to Samuel about this time tomorrow, I will send you a man from the land of Benjamin, anoint him leader over my people Israel, he will deliver my people from the hand of the Philistines, the Philistines where Israel's arch enemies. And just as God had predicted Samuel and Saul encounter one another and Samuel takes Saul to a banquet where it's apparent that he has been anticipated something has been set aside for Saul. And then after that they go and Saul spends the night, early the next morning Samuel comes and wakes him up and says it's time to go. And as they're going, Samuel says send the servant on ahead and then in private Samuel anoints Saul and in verse 1 of chapter 10 it says Samuel took a flask of oil and poured it on Saul's head and kissed him saying has not the Lord anointed you leader over his inheritance. And then Samuel goes on to predict three signs that will take place that will confirm Saul's anointing and then he comes to verse 7, after predicting the three signs, then in verse 7 Samuel says once these signs are fulfilled, do what your hand finds to do. Quite vigorously correct the text there because the text says not do whatever your hand finds to do it says do what your hand finds to do. And that is somewhat significant for understanding this text. So scratch ever from your NIV, it should say do what your hand finds to do. You may think that an insignificant difference but I think it's significant and I think you'll see why. Once these signs are fulfilled, do what your hand finds to do for God is with you. Go down ahead of me to Gilgal, I will surely come down to you to sacrifice, burn offerings and fellowship offerings but you must wait seven days until I come to you and tell you what you are to do. Now commentators have found a problem between verses 7 and 8 in this chapter. What is the problem? They think that this is somewhat problematic, yes Mark. Okay, Samuel says do what your hand finds to do and he says go down to Gilgal and wait and I'll come down and I'll sacrifice and I'll tell you what you are to do. And so it appears that Samuel on the one hand says okay you're authorized to do what your hand finds to do and then he turns right around and says no go down and wait for me in Gilgal and I'll tell you what you are to do. So which is it? And a lot of theories have been developed to account for this. One of the ones that I'm least convinced by, not at all convinced by is that a later prophetic circle inserted verse 8 as a corrective to verse 7 because the prophets at a later point in history were uncomfortable that their kind of fountainhead prophets Samuel himself had given this kind of unqualified authority to the king. And do what your hand finds to do and they thought no no no we got to make sure the prophet remains in control so they inserted verse 8. Well if that's the case then they created attention and if they had that kind of freedom in dealing with the text why didn't they just expunge or modify the objectionable verse rather than inserting a contradictory verse if in fact we're dealing with the contradiction. So that leads us to a question what does in fact verse 7 imply when all these signs come upon you do what your hand finds to do yes. All right you're moving in the right direction. I wouldn't I wouldn't lead it I wouldn't link it up with the seven days yet. It's verse 7 that says when these signs come upon you what was the purpose of the signs to confirm to Saul that this anointing that he had received was from God because only God could have caused these signs to come about you know that would confirm to him that yeah God is in this. And so then Samuel says once these you've been confirmed by these signs do what your hand finds to do and I would suggest that the designation. The was the anointing and then Samuel is saying all right now once the signs have confirmed this designation this anointing do what your hand finds to do demonstrate that God has chosen you. Now the question is what might that be there's there's some there's sufficient information in the text I believe to suggest what Saul should have done. Look at yeah verse five who said that yeah look at verse five what does verse five say after that you will go to give you of God where there is a Philistine outpost as you approach the town you will meet a procession of profits coming down et cetera and it goes on to describe the third sign this is the place where the third sign takes place this is the location and the narrator goes out of his way to say where there is a Philistine outpost and many commentators interestingly have said that that reference seems to be meaningless there I mean Saul knew that terrain he knew the locations he didn't need to be told where there isn't Philistine outpost why did Saul Samuel I mean why did the narrator put this in there why did Samuel say this at this particular juncture and some of commentators even say I can't make any sense of it so I'll move it to another place in the text which is not a good procedure usually or ever. So what is being suggested here put yourself in in Saul's position when all these signs take place now where is he he's at the site of the third sign Samuel says do what your hand finds to do in other words do what lies at hand what would putting two and two together 10 to yield perhaps attack the Philistine outpost I mean Samuel has gone out of his way to remind Saul you know this is Ghibbia of God the hill of God Ghibbia Elohim some translations you just to translate the Hebrew this is the hill of God where there's a Philistine outpost and remember Saul was being anointed to deliver his people from the Philistines and so Samuel saying now Saul when these when this all happens and when you're confirmed and you're anointing do what your hand finds to do do what lies at hand what would that be attack the Philistine outpost what would that accomplish if Saul had done that well let me ask this it wouldn't yeah what would it have accomplished militarily it would have it would have hacked off the Philistines to use a colloquialism here a modern phrase it would have provoked perhaps we could say it would have thrown down the gauntlet if we can use an elegant metaphor it would have made the Philistines angry but it wouldn't have defeated them it would have just affronted them right so what might then be the sense of verse 8 what to do next okay so Samuel says when once you're once you've been anointed and confirmed do what lies at hand well what lies at hand attack the Philistine outpost what would that accomplish make the Philistines mad they would come out for retaliation what do you to do then Sam Saul go down to Gilgal and wait for me I will come down and offer sacrifices which was typical procedure prior to a battle our offer sacrifices and I will tell you what you're to do and he says wait seven days and I think we'll I think it's sensible to see the two in tandem wait seven days until I come this is significant thing is the arrival of Samuel not the time clock you know you don't put a stop watch on it and if Samuel's slightly tardy you go ahead well technically you didn't get here in seven days which we'll see is a problem in chapter 13 now any questions so far the relationship of seven and eight yes I think I would take it more as a as an estimate of the kind of time it will take him to get there right right that's right yeah all right now let's let's take this understanding of seven and eight and this very crucial what I call the first charge Sal's first commission his first charge he's been anointed now he receives a two part first charge I would suggest that the second part verse eight the trip to Gilgal is contingent upon the fulfillment of the first part now let's look back at the the account of Sal's rise such as as we have it here in the light of this particular structure and the significance of ten eight the elders asked for a king and in chapter 9 1 to 10 16 we have Saul anointed what would that be in terms of the three part structure well that is clearly the demonstrate the designation that's the nature of the designation now what does Saul do as we go on in chapter 10 do we have any reference to his striking down the garrison of the Philistines no we don't the third sign is recounted the other two signs are presumed to have been fulfilled the third sign is recounted in full and as it's recounted some of the bystanders are astonished to see Saul out there with those religious folk we'll talk about that a little bit later in terms of the overall portrayal of Saul but we don't read anything about Saul actually attacking the Philistine garrison instead we read in and verse 13 that Saul stopped prophesying and he went to the high place now this could be perhaps better translated not translated but the text may should read he went home Habama Habaita very close in the Hebrew and it would make a good deal more sense if he went home than if he went to the high place though one could see how the text might have been corrupted this way because it's expected that Saul will do something grand something important after this very significant event in his life and instead he goes and he finds himself in conversation with his uncle in verse 14 of chapter 10 and the uncle says where have you been? Well looking for the donkey he said but when he saw that they were not to be found we went to Samuel Saul's uncle said well tell me what Samuel said to you the uncle seemed to know who Samuel was and be curious about what he'd have to say Saul replied he assured us that the donkey said been found well that is surely the big news of the day isn't it? Good that's fine objective reporting and then as if to drive home the point the narrator says but he didn't tell his uncle what Samuel had said about the kingship why not and how do we interpret that again we'll look more fully at that when we talk about the way in which Saul is portrayed but the point is Saul really didn't do what his hand found to do he was told to do what lies at hand something lay at hand he didn't do it so the designation was not followed by the demonstration that was anticipated let's call this now designation a demonstration a should have been let me just say Philistine Outpost for Garrison that really should have been the first demonstration do what your hand finds to do Saul didn't do it and that begins to explain then this next episode in at the chapter 10 verse 17 we read that Samuel now summons the people of Israel to miss but this comes right on the heel of that inigmatic conversation between Saul and his uncle Samuel summoned the people of Israel to the Lord at miss and he said to them this is what the Lord the God of Israel says I brought you up out of Egypt and I delivered you from the power of Egypt and all the kingdoms that oppressed you but you have now rejected your God who saves you out of all your calamities and distress and you have said no set a king over see how that begins like a judgment speech you're expecting now if that's the problem now we're going to have the judgment and right there we have so now present yourselves before the Lord by your tribes and clans and that's what they do and eventually Saul is the one upon whom the lot falls or the one who is selected by this procedure a procedure by the way that is described very much in the same terms as the lot casting that discovered aiken back in the book of Joshua just kind of curious and commentators have said it's almost as if it's almost as if Saul is guilty of something but we don't know what well see I'm suggesting that we do know what that Saul is guilty of that faltering in the starting gate that first hesitation which becomes so typical of him later you know the kind of a faithless hesitation to move when God says move and so they went when the lot falls on Saul they can't find him and so they have to inquire of God is he here and God informs him yes he has hidden himself among the baggage and so in verse 23 they run and they bring him out and Samuel says to the people do you see the man the Lord has chosen now remember this is the man the Lord has chosen in response to the people sinful request and Samuel makes it clear that this is the people sinful request so it is the Lord's choice but it's in response to their demand you see the man the Lord has chosen there is no one like him among all the people positive negative little ambiguous it's not too clear whether Samuel is perhaps being a little ironic what do you make of Saul being dragged from behind the baggage what's the traditional interpretation of that he's humble self-effacing didn't aspire to greatness here he'd been appointed keen anointed to lead the people and he didn't want to put himself forward he was hiding behind the baggage well is it humility or perhaps timidity you know kind of a faithlessness that made him unable to step out and do what God told him to do it's quite right when God calls upon us to do something to recognize our inadequacy to even protest God I'm not the one for that I can't do that but if God assures us well you're my choice I want you to do it whether you feel up to it or not I will give you the strength I you know Moses said I can't talk and God said well who made your mouth you know I can I can give you words and Moses continued to to protest until God was angry with him he said okay we'll use Aaron then it's okay to protest when God calls us to do something but when he when he reassures us yes you're the one and Saul had had those confirming signs then it is faithlessness to hold back and so it's almost as if Saul was guilty of something yeah he is and as he's dragged from behind the baggage here the guy who was head and shoulders above his fellows hiding behind the baggage Samuel says is there anyone like this guy there's no one like him in all Israel and notice what the people say by the way I would make this lot casting then designation B inadvertently changing colors designation B would be the lot casting and the reason designation B is necessary is that Saul has falter he didn't do what his hand found to do thus he didn't demonstrate that God had chosen him to lead he didn't come to public attention he didn't distinguish himself in any way and so he could have been lost in obscurity if Samuel had not taken the initiative convene the people at misspa gone through the lot casting just to show them what he and Saul already knew and that is that God had chosen Saul so the lot casting is the second designation and notice how the people respond Samuel explained to the people the regulations of the kingship in verse 25 he wrote them down a scroll to deposit them before the Lord then Samuel dismissed the people each to his own home Saul also went to his home and give you accompanied by valiant men whose hearts God had touched in other words God is not dealing Saul in unfair hand he is equipping him with loyal supporters valiant men but it says some troublemakers some troublemakers said how can this fellow save us I have to be very careful here not to side with the troublemakers and they're called the nae billiard worthless men the same thing that the sons of Eli were called wicked men and they are wicked because they question God's appointment of Saul but there is a there's something of a point to their question because how can this guy save us where did we find him you know this is unusual normally the first we know of someone as he does some great deed he destroys the altar of bail or he does something that brings him to our attention as in David's case he goes out and kills a giant and we see that God is working through this person but this this guy big impressive outwardly but hiding behind the baggage hasn't done any there's no demonstration how can this guy save us and so there's kind of a point to their question even though they were wrong to question God's choice they despised him brought him no gifts the Saul kept silent that's hard to know what to make of that goes hard to know whether that text is even right there that last bit Saul kept silent then in chapter 11 we have demonstration B demonstration A remember which should have been the attack on the Philistine outpost what lay at hand at the time of his anointing Saul had the time of his commissioning Saul had failed to do but the defeat of the ammonites in chapter 11 as Nahash goes out against the citizens of J. Bashgiliad and threatens them and they say in a kind of a curious fashion give us seven days to send a deliver out to see if we can find someone to deliver us but if not we will come out to you I think I don't know if the NIV says we will surrender or something like that but they use it yeah we will surrender to you literally they say we will come out to you which is which would have probably brought some some laughter from a Hebrew crowd that understood the Hebrew because the same word is used later when it talks about them coming out in battle coming it will come out to you the assumption being in surrender but later they use the same phraseology to say will come out to you or they do come out against their enemies and defeat them as Saul comes to rescue them so the elders of J. Bashgiliad asked for permission to seek a savior someone to save them to deliver them and it says the messengers came to give you a Saul again it's not so much when they came they're going on some grand tour I think they came directly to give you a Saul because they were aware that Saul was the guy who had been designated now's the time to demonstrate it and as they come into the city the people of of Ghibia Saul city ask what they're up to they learn what the problem is and they begin to weep Saul's gone back to farming and as he's coming in with the oxen he hears with the problem and it says the spirit of God came upon him in power and he burned with anger we will see a number of times when the spirit of God will come upon Saul back at the time of his anointing and even talked about him being changed into a different person being given a new heart a different heart and need to be very careful because that kind of reminds us of new testament heart regeneration it's kind of like is this his conversion experience I think we will learn if we look at all the instances where the spirit of God comes upon Saul that it's more of an external working of the spirit of God to change Saul from what he normally is to what God needs him to be at that time to enable him to do what is necessary and so the spirit of God comes upon Saul in power same phrase used often of Samson by the way and he takes the oxen and he cuts him into pieces and sends them throughout Israel he kind of reminiscent of the judge's 19 thing at time when there was no king in Israel and as Saul has been anointed king but I think he's been faltering along the way it's been a little hesitant to get started and so he didn't do the demonstration a made necessary designation B now finally he's come up to designation the to demonstration B and the spirit of God is not going to let him falter again he comes upon him in power and kind of catapults him into battle and then Saul succeeds. Saul, God delivers the people that day it's a great victory and Saul says probably the best thing he ever said when some of the people want to stone those or deal with put to death those who had questioned Saul's appointment now that they've seen him in action they say who are these guys let's put them to death and Saul says no one shall be put to death today for this day the Lord has rescued Israel probably the best thing Saul said then Samuel said this is verse 14 of chapter 11 come let us go to Gilgal and bear renew the kingship the NIV says reaffirm renew would be a good literal designation renew the kingship so all the people went to Gilgal and confirm Saul as king in the presence of the Lord they're renew the kingship well what does that mean why why renew it what is what is Samuel talking about this is demonstration B why would at the end of demonstration B he would say okay let's renew the kingship Robert Van Oien his writing on these particular sections says that the word renew is used of something that is in a poor state of repair and in need of in need of being repaired of being renewed let's go and renew repair the kingship what's been the problem this bishop okay yeah in a sense it will be bringing everyone in line with what God is doing here but I think also it's you know by virtue of Saul's in action and his failure to do what his hand found to do the the kingship process this three-part process of designation demonstration confirmation was sort of derailed and it required designation B demonstration B and now it's time for confirmation and Samuel says now we can renew the kingship you know it kind of was derailed and now we can repair it we can get it back on track and we can we can get Saul on the throne so at the end of chapter 11 we read so all the people this is verse 15 so all the people went to Gilgal and confirm Saul as king in the presence of the Lord there they sacrificed fellowship offerings before the Lord and Saul and all the Israelites held a great celebration who's missing who's not at least mentioned is celebrating Samuel okay Saul is happy the people are happy Samuel is at least not quite so much in the mood to celebrate yet I think he still has some concerns which then are expressed in chapter 12 yesterday yes sir well possibly we don't we can't tell the intonation it is true that God has chosen this man it's true that he is impressive we know that later Samuel is a human being who is impressed with outward appearance you know once Saul is rejected and Samuel is to anoint one of Jesse's sons he sees Ellie Abney says now that's a big guy that's an impressive fellow he's got to be the one and God has to remind Samuel you know man looks on the outward appearance God looks on the heart so it could be that Samuel is sort of falling into the error of looking on the outward appearance and saying well sure he was hiding but look at him when he stands up or it made me that he was being a little ironic and saying I don't know what to make of this guy there's not there's not another one liking it's got all the physical goods you could want but doesn't seem to have the heart for it at any rate that that kind of feeds into what Samuel's concern is in chapter 12 in chapter 12 Samuel again rebukes the people for their demand for a king according to their timing God had conceded to that and God had told him it calls to Samuel and chapter 8 go ahead appoint for them a king but later we'll see that God had in mind a king for him in chapter 16 he'll say I found for me now a king that was David that was God's plan people wanted their king and that's what they're getting in Saul but Samuel is very clear to warn them that there's still attentiveness to the success of this kingship experiment he makes it very clear that if they follow the Lord if they continue to follow the Lord both they and their king then things can go well but if they stray if they turn back from following him the whole thing can still fail it is not a done deal there's still in a way a test to be stood before the kingship is fully confirmed now at the end of chapter 12 he says be sure to fear the Lord and serve him faithfully with all your heart consider what great things he has done for you yet if you persist in doing evil both you and your king will be swept away there's still attentiveness here attentiveness here and we come then in chapter 13 where we would expect to come we come to a time of testing and it is very clear as we get into chapter 13 that the first charge given at the time of Saul's anointing begins to come into play again in fact we will see someone do what what Saul's hand should have found to do where do we find that in this chapter Jonathan look at verse 3 Jonathan attacked the Philistine outpost in Gaby now recent scholars many many are thinking that Gaby and Gaby Elohim are to be identified and perhaps also Gaby of Saul all one place that's quite possible which would be a site modern Gaby in Arabic Gaby across from Mick Mash to cities that straddle the Wadi Suha need kind of a dry riverbed most of the year dry that goes down into the Jordan Valley these will be significant sites in this battle scene as it progresses but here we see Jonathan attacking the Philistine outpost and you can find in some commentaries the statement here Jonathan does what Saul's hand should have found to do but I haven't found anyone other than my book on Saul available in the bookstore for which I get no royalties I haven't found anyone who's really put together the pattern that this was a two-part charge that Saul received the second action being contingent upon the fulfillment of the first the first action would simply provoke the Philistines it's a provocation and that's exactly what happens here Jonathan strikes the Philistine outpost the Philistines here about it the word goes out let the Hebrews hear or Saul sent the word out had the trumpet blown let the Hebrews hear so all Israel heard Saul has attacked the Philistine outpost well you know George Bush won the Gulf War two so in a sense you can say Saul attacked the Philistine outpost but actually Jonathan did the deed so we don't want to fault him too much but Saul should have and maybe he's taking credit where credit was not due but that's what the report was Saul has attacked the Philistine outpost and now Israel has become a stench to the Philistines and the people were summoned to join Saul at Gilgal now commentators not seeing all the interconnections have said this makes no sense militarily you know Saul had a position of strength in the hill country he was in McMash Jonathan was in Gaba that was a position of strength why in the world would Saul leave that to go down into the valley and allow the Philistines to come up and take over that territory it was not a good move militarily well two things number one I think Saul left his troops in place those who were his standing troops to try to hold that area and we learn in chapter 13 that they were unsuccessful Philistines came out in such mass that the people were in distress and they were hiding in caves and thickets and sisters and every other little capital that they could find throughout the land but Saul went down to Gilgal because he had been told that's the next thing to do once you do what lies in hand or Jonathan attacked the Philistine Garrison then go down to Gilgal and wait for me and that's obviously the background of what happens then at Gilgal and we find that Saul under pressure under duress after seven days have elapsed or perhaps you know we don't know for sure whether the seventh day had actually elapsed Samuel arrived on the beginning of the eighth day the text does say he waited seven days the time set by Samuel but Samuel did not come to Gilgal and Saul's men began to scatter that's verse 8 so he said that is Saul said bring me the burnt offering and the fellowship offerings that was the next part of the procedure and so offered up the burnt offering just as he finished making the offering Samuel arrived and Saul went out to greet him what have he done as Samuel and Saul begins to make his excuse he said well when I saw the men were scattering and you didn't come at the set time and the Philistines were assembling at McMash I thought now the Philistines will come down against me at Gilgal and I've not sought the Lord's favor that sounds a little better in English than it does in Hebrew in Hebrew it's more I've not softened the deity's face which is kind of a more profane expression in Hebrew and commentators have noted that it's not typical pious language being used here so I felt compelled or better I pulled myself together everybody else was falling apart everybody else was escaping running away fleeing but I at least pulled myself together to offer the burnt offering you've acted foolishly Samuel said you've not kept the command again better you've not kept the charge the Lord your God gave you if you had he would have established your kingdom over Israel for all time but now your kingdom will not endure the Lord has sought out a man who pleases him a man after his own heart and appointed him or charged him leader of his people because you have not kept the Lord's charge I re-translate that so you hear that word played it's in there you didn't keep the Lord's charge so God's charge someone else because you didn't keep the charge comes back to it now what's going on here what is Saul's fault what what is the problem here there are commentators then in fact it's the dominant voice you will hear nowadays they will speak of the petulant peavish prophet who has it in for Saul in fact let me just give you a few quotes from them one commentator since I'm quoting him negatively I will leave him nameless at this point but he characterizes characterizes Saul's actions when confronted by Samuel in 1310 as properly and guilelessly deferential Samuel on the other hand is harsh unresponsive and accusatory and despite the fact that Saul offers what appear to be compelling and valid reasons to offer sacrifices before the arrival of the tardy Samuel he goes on and points out that in verse 13 when Samuel says you have not kept the commandment of the Lord your God he points out this is a remarkable statement because Samuel cites no commandment that has been broken nor can we construe one Samuel doesn't tell us what the command what the charge mitzvah is that Saul has broken nor can we construe one now my question is can we construe one what what was the problem he didn't abide by that all important first charge that was given him at the time of his anointing do what lies at hand and then go down to Gilgal and wait for me and I'll comment sacrifice wait seven days until I come I'll sacrifice offer sacrifices and I'll tell you what you're to do now why would Samuel issue that charge at the time of Saul's anointing what is the point and what is the nature of Saul's failure here God had in mind all along that Israel would have a king but would it be a king like all the nations who is the king in Israel God is the king in Israel so in giving them a human king through his prophet Samuel he established a structure by which God could remain the great king this is a theocracy God is to continue to be the king he is to continue to rule and so he establishes as it were a test of Saul's suitability to see if Saul will allow him to continue to reign or whether Saul when push comes to shove will become expedient and pragmatic and say we'll forget this you know we've got to get on with it Saul's excuses sound very good on the outside Saul Samuel was late the narrator tells us he was late the people were scattering it's hard to fight without any individuals the Philistines were breathing down his neck he was in great danger and yet at that point when push came to shove he allowed himself self to be pushed and it's almost as if Samuel's arrival is so brilliantly time that it was either providential or Samuel was waiting in the wings to test Saul to see if Saul would wait at all costs to allow Samuel who was God's spokesman to arrive consecrate the battle and instruct Saul as to what he was to do further so far from Samuel being you know kind of flying off the handle when he said you've acted foolishly you know what's the matter with you and just grasping at straws and rejecting Saul on the basis of a technicality this is a fundamentally important test that was established at the time of his anointing that was meant to test whether Saul would be suitable whether he would work out Samuel alluded to that in chapter 12 you know this could this experiment could succeed or it could fail it all depends on how you respond Saul and how the people respond if you follow the Lord's directive it can succeed if you don't you will fail questions or comments we'll pick up that thread again next time we're going to talk a little bit more about Saul pardon me for talking so much about him but I've studied him more than many other people so we'll pick that up next time but let me ask if there any questions or anything before we conclude for the evening we have a minute or two yes right right yeah the comment the questions a good one and I should have mentioned that as well the question is or the comment is that many commentators say that Saul's fault here was that he offered sacrifices and that was really only for priests to do now the problem is it appears that Solomon David others were sometimes involved in the offering of sacrifices God did designate the priests as the rightful ones to do it that doesn't seem to be the specific charge or the specific command that Samuel has in view here it may have been a subsidiary offense that Saul went ahead with the sacrifices but by far I think the more significant problem was that Saul abused an authority structure which Samuel had set up which was meant to safeguard God's authority and God's right to rule yes one more yeah yeah well that's an interesting comment that Saul was acting as prophet priest and king you know sort of picking up on Hebrews and its development of Christology probably that's too much back reading but he is supplanting the prophet he's not waiting for the prophet he was the king and he is performing a priestly sacrifice so you know in a way you could you could see that in this text I think to keep it text based and pretty straightforward if you simply recognize the link between doing what lies at hand and then going to Gilgal and that being an authority structure that was meant to safeguard God's right to continue to direct the affairs of the king and then you see in chapter 13 just that happening Jonathan does what lay at hand Saul goes to Gilgal but when times get tough Saul goes ahead he doesn't pass the test he doesn't wait until Samuel arrives we'll pick that up and elaborate on it a little more next time thank you for your patience and endurance and we'll see you in one week