<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ber Aýlyk ber

The Canon of Scripture

November 17, 2008
0:000:00

This is from last week. How many of you need this because you forgot to bring it? Yeah, it's okay and Garth has a hundred of them, so But don't let that make you lazy. All right, Garth. Could I have one incidentally? And if you could hold your hold your hand up quietly and I'm gonna take the first five minutes here and review from last week It is so hard from first grade on holding your hand up and keep your mouth shut. It's really hard Same time do it the same time. Okay, so I'm gonna I'm gonna try to go forward We keep your hand up if you need one of these handouts a can in a scripture. Well, this is really important. Do we have? Do we have the correct writings in this or not in this book? Are there some books in here that don't belong shouldn't be part of scripture? Or are we missing some secret books that somebody kept out? So we wouldn't know what they said that claim pops up again and again and of course It's one of the central ideas in Dan Brown's book the Da Vinci code that these New Testament writings We have we're not the real story of Jesus the real story of Jesus was suppressed by the church and Catholic church Especially wanted to keep all these true stories hidden and so they just gave us these other things and in 325 A.D Council of NYC under under under under constant team the the church Put these new books into place, but they're not the true ones. Well, what do you think about that? Is that how do we answer that and of course the Mormons come along and say they've got extra books the that The Prophet Joseph Smith had and those should be added in addition to scripture What do we answer to all of that last week? We spent on the question of the Old Testament canon and so I'm just going to quickly Click through those slides, but not talk about them in detail But we said this the canon is the list the word canon means the list Canon is the list of all the books that belong in the Bible and we shouldn't underestimate the importance of it because these are the words by which we nourish our spiritual lives The address of practice from God's word would be to prevent God's people from obeying him fully and we talked about the Old Testament canon First we had the earliest collection of written words the 10 commandments which God himself wrote on two stone tablets And they were the writing of God and then the then so that so that we had this and I'm going to draw this picture again because we'll add to it now with the New Testament but the picture was that God himself Started this collection of written words that were the very words of God and that was the collection That's called the 10 commandments that God himself gave those tablets to Moses on the mountain and people had them And there was no question there God's words he wrote them but they're written in Hebrew So they're human words as well and then Moses added some books Genesis, Exodus, Solidicus, Numbers, Deuteronomy, and then we had Joshua God told Joshua to add more and so the the prophets primarily recorded the deeds of the kings and And added to the to the books of scripture and then there were other things added over time until historical writings prophetic writings wisdom writings until 435 BC about Approximately 435 BC where the prophets came to an end with hey guys actory and Malachi And the history Ezra Nehemiah and Esther And then we looked at some of those Jewish writings outside the New Testament All right outside the Old Testament after the time of the Old Testament that talked about keeping His the historical documents of the Jews were kept but like Josephus said in 95 AD They weren't deemed worthy of equal credit with the earlier writings because of the failure of the exact succession of the prophets so The Jewish people understood that that was the collection of writings that were God's words these other writings the history books of the macabees and things like that and Wisdom writings that were kind of like Proverbs, but called Ecclesiasticals or or Syrac and Some other stories Judith Tobit those stories of heroic Tales of faith of the Jewish people those were kept but the Jewish people didn't think going to be God's words They just thought they were other writings And so those some of them went into what is now called the apocrypha by the Roman Catholic church and we talked about that now That was that was the overview and that was as far as we went last week. I'll go through these other Moses wrote additional words works and Then Joshua added to the words in the book of the law of God Others in Israel usually prophets wrote additional words Samuel wrote Samuel to see your Nathan the prophet wrote et cetera always writing down interpreting the events of history In the light of God's viewpoint giving God's interpretation on what was happening to the kings and the people and the nations and the armies and all of this Prophets were writing that so it grew until 435 BC With the completion of Malachi other writings by the Jewish people were not considered worthy to be included in the scriptures And you have even in macabees in the in the apocrypha book of the macabees They didn't have a prophet around they were waiting for a prophet to come and tell them what to do about this or that They were the prophets ceased a long time ago And so Josephus says

From our asserties that's the time of Esther to our own time the complete history has been written But it hasn't been deemed worthy of equal credit with the earlier records because of the failure of the exact exact succession of the prophets And he talks about the scriptures being just that collection of scriptures And we talked about things in the Babylonian Talmud with that list of writings Tosefta Other things from the apocrypha the Dead Sea scrolls all of these writings testifying That there is a firm collection of Jewish writings, but they didn't include these books of the apocrypha as scripture They were just other historical material and of course these weren't written in Hebrew They were written in Greek and so the Jewish people didn't count them part of their authoritative words of God so And there's no record of any dispute between Jesus and the Jews over the extent of the canon Jesus and the New Testament authors Quote as authority in the New Testament, which we're coming to later They quote these books of the Old Testament over 295 times Approximately 205 times and there are maybe a few more that are illusions or quotations is a little hard to tell because they're short But they quote these 295 times and they quote the apocrypha Zero times as the word of God which I think shows that they didn't count it to be the word of God even though they knew it was historical material It's interesting We talked about some other things they quote but they don't quote the apocrypha So the apocrypha Books were not accepted by Jews or Jesus or New Testament authors as scripture and The Roman Catholic Church didn't officially declare the apocrypha to be scripture until 1546 at the council of Trent when they were responding to Martin Luther And his teachings on justification by faith alone and his teachings that there wasn't any such thing as purgatory And you shouldn't make offerings for the dead and they got some of that out of the apocrypha So they decided okay the apocrypha is scripture So we concluded the writings the apocrypha should not be Included as part of scripture and they do contain teachings inconsistent with the rest of the Bible especially on earning your salvation and on prayers for the dead and things like that Now we come to this new material and that is what about the New Testament canner Picture yourself as a Jewish person Living In the land of Israel in the first century And it's been 435 years what they call the silence of heaven It's been 435 years since any prophet appeared among you no more Moses no more Samuel no more Jeremiah or Isaiah Knowing you the words of God it was probably a sense of abandonment. Why is God not speaking to us anymore? And they're waiting and they're waiting How long is 435 years That'd be like waiting since 1570 for us

70 60 or 40 to 70 years. I mean, you know, that's many many generation So it's like us. No, I don't get anybody remember anything that happened in 1570 I won't ask for volunteers So that's a long time and you're wondering as God forgotten us forever

All the sudden one day Someone comes running down the street pounds on the door your house and said a prophet has appeared And he's out at the river Jordan and he's baptizing people telling them that the Messiah is coming The prophet is down the bathroom All of a sudden after 435 years or so over 400 years The people of Israel here, but there's there's another prophet that has appeared on the scene and God is once again speaking to us Can you imagine the excitement all Jerusalem went out to hearing And preached a gospel of repentance Saying that one was coming after him and he was sent to say prepare the way of the Lord And so there's not only the prophet is coming if any saying the Messiah himself is following soon after and then And then he sees Jesus coming says behold the Lamb of God Who takes away the sin of the world There's tremendous excitement so now John the Baptist introduces Jesus Jesus has his earthly ministry he begins going about teaching and you know There's something very unique about Jesus teaching the Old Testament prophet said thus says the Lord thus says the Lord This is the word of the Lord here the word of the Lord Jesus said I say to you But I say to you So he's teaching on his own authority and I think that's another it's one of many many indications that he is himself God He's not just a prophet speaking for God. He is speaking the very words of God when he speaks What we have then in the New Testament is the story of Jesus life recorded in the four gospels Matthew Mark Luke and John and then the book of Acts It starts out and says it's written by Luke You've also wrote acts and it says in the first book I told you all that Jesus began to do and teach the implication is in acts He's telling what Jesus continues to do and teach through the spread of the church as the gospel is proclaimed and then the epistles All these epistles from Romans first and second Corinthians all these letters for the church all those epistles Really interpret and apply the life of Jesus and his teachings to the church and then you have the book of revelation Which is It starts out the first sentence the revelation of Jesus Christ which God gave him to show what must Take place and so that is also a revelation that Jesus Christ is giving with regard to the future So what we have here is it's recording Jesus life and teachings And then this is interpreting

interpreting and applying it to the church The life of Jesus and as a whole then we could say The revel that the New Testament is the story of Jesus Christ I don't think anybody in the world would want to contradict me to say that is what the New Testament is about. It's about Jesus Christ So here's how it came about The New Testament canon the New Testament canon begins with the writings of the apostles who were given the ability from the Holy Spirit to recall and interpret accurately the words and deeds of Jesus So in John 14 Jesus promised the helper the Holy Spirit whom the father will send in my name He will teach you all things. This is right at the end of his life. Jesus is speaking to his disciples He says now here's what's going to happen the Holy Spirit will teach you all things and bring to remember it's all that I've said to you So they were walking with him. They were living with him. They were hearing him teach and the Holy Spirit was going to come and Supernaturally Superintendent direct their memories so that when they recalled what Jesus said they would do it after The Holy Spirit would bring to their remembrance all that I've said to you when the Spirit of truth comes He said to his disciples he will guide you into all the truth He will not speak on his own authority whatever he hears he will speak and he will declare to you the things that are to come He will glorify me He will take what is mine and declare it to you. So Jesus is promising to his disciples a special ministry of the Holy Spirit to remember and then And then understand what Jesus taught Now the old the New Testament the Jesus disciples became the apostles They that was the other word that Jesus gave for them and They claim an authority equal to that of the Old Testament prophets So What we have here in the Old Testament is first Moses who was thought to be the first and greatest prophet and then Samuel and And all these other prophets recording the history of the kings and then Isaiah, Jeremiah, Lamentations, Ezekiel, Daniel, Hosea, those prophets all writing But now we get over here and when the apostles write They don't say it isn't like Peter a prophet of Jesus Christ to the church or Paul Paul doesn't say when I open up to First Corinthians Paul called by the will of God to be a prophet of Jesus Christ. It doesn't say that What does it say Paul called by the will of God to be and They know what what name they call themselves when they're writing not prophet Not the cycle that sometimes he called himself servant, but There's a more important title that has authority over the churches Paul and Apostle Paul and Apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God and Timothy our brother and Philippians No flippancy calls off servants. Oh, Ephesians Paul and Apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God Galatians Paul and Apostle not from men but nor through men But through Jesus Christ and God the Father to the churches of Galatians. So what is happening is The Old Testament was written by prophets

By and large, but in the New Testament it's the Apostles who write this

by and large and so the Apostles Claim an authority equal to the Old Testament prophets second Peter three two remember the predictions of the holy prophets And the commandment of the Lord and Savior through your Apostles look at the parallel Peter says What do you what should you meditate on what should you build your life on? Well the Holy prophets and the commandment of the Lord and Savior through your Apostles see the parallel Prophets and Apostles and with his wife's knowledge um This is Ananias kept back some of the proceeds Later the Apostles feet Ananias Peter said Ananias why I say it and filled your heart to lie to the Holy Spirit and keep back for your part Yourself part of the proceeds of the land um To lie to the Apostles was to lie to the Holy Spirit and Ananias fell down dead um That was an awesome authority that he had that the Apostles had and Paul says what know I have seen your ear heard and the heart of man Imagine we impart this in words not taught by human wisdom but taught by the Spirit So Paul sang when he teaches he even has his very words given by the Holy Spirit And if the Corinthians didn't like that or didn't agree with him it was too bad for them If anyone thinks he's a prophet or spiritual he should acknowledge that the things I'm writing to you are command of the Lord This is plural in Greek the things and I think it refers to the whole of first Corinthians um Not all translations bring out that plural sometimes they say what I am writing to but it really is plural and I think he's saying hey Uh, you guys think your spiritual well step one and being spiritual is I'm writing command of the Lord a command of the Lord That's like the ten commandments Paul is claiming an incredibly strong authority for his teaching So Already Peter and Paul are saying that these writings of the Apostles are Equal in authority to the Old Testament scriptures. They're not just like the books of the Maccabees or something like that Uh, Paul talks about seeking proof that Christ is speaking in me and second Corinthians And in fact, it's very interesting that a couple of places we have New Testament authors Speaking about the writings of some other New Testament authors Peter no doubt had a very important role in among the Apostles in the early church But the question is what did Peter think of Paul's authority? Well second Peter three sticky no John three sixteen This is second Peter three sixteen. This is also good. It's very important Uh, our beloved brother Paul wrote to you according to the wisdom given him as he does in all his letters now That one Peter can say that Peter's writing fairly late He's recognizing that there's already a collection of Paul's letters People are saving them all in all his letters, okay? And they and he's writing and he's saying we guys know about Paul's letters So it must be there was collection of circulating There are some things in Paul's writing Paul's letters that are hard to understand Which the ignorant and unstable twist to their own destruction as they do the other scriptures Now he doesn't say they twist the things in Paul's writings as they twist the scriptures That would be putting Paul's writings outside of scripture He says they they twist Paul's writings As they do the other scriptures other than what other than Paul's writings Does that make sense any following it has to imply that Paul's writings are scripture and then they're also twisting the other scriptures That is important because the Greek word that there is In Greek word that is there said to be scriptures. This

That word scriptures That is the Greek word Show up very well graph A It's the Greek word graph A It looks it looks like this in Greek and we would spell it g-r-a-p-h-e graph A That word is used 51 times in the New Testament And 51 out of 51 times it refers to the Old Testament writings

That's enough times to say this is a technical term It's enough time say this is a specialized word scriptures mean the word of God and Peter is here saying Paul's writings are scripture and then there's other scriptures So Peter is looking at Paul's letters as a collection and saying they are scripture and scripture in this technical sense of the very words of God I said 51 out of 51 times they refer to the Old Testament scriptures that is true Except for these two verses where they also includes the New Testament writings So here's one other scriptures and then what does Paul think about some of these writings Paul first? 1517 to 18 let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor Especially those who labor and preaching and teaching for the scripture says and here we have the word graph A again The scripture says you shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain That's a quote from Deuteronomy 254 and here's the other thing the scripture says the laborer deserves his wages Where is that in the Old Testament? The laborer deserves his wages Well knowing the Old Testament as well as you do you immediately say hmm. I can't remember that in the Old Testament any place And you are right The laborer deserves his wages is not in the Old Testament any plate, but Paul says the scripture says the laborer deserves his wages Where is it? It's in Luke 107 and it's word for word in Greek oxy-os-ha Erica tastes to miss throughout to worthy is the worker of his labor It's word for word in Greek exact quote from Jesus words in Luke 107 so Here we now have Paul writing to Timothy and quoting Luke as scripture He's saying that this gospel Luke is the word of God and Peter is saying all of Paul's writings are the word of God So we're seeing evidence of what Jesus promised was fulfilled Jesus promised that the Holy Spirit would guide them and bring to the remembrance all that Jesus had said Now it's happened and it's being written down as scripture Now someone might say how did Paul know about Luke's gospel? How could he know about that? How could Paul know anything about what Luke wrote? scripture how did Luke yeah, well, I think just hold on a minute Did Paul have anything to do with Luke? That's the question

Yes, in the book of Acts can Luke traveled with Paul and there are some sections in fact Luke is writing the book of Acts and there are some sections in Acts where it's so saying they did this They did that to start saying we did this we did that we did this we did that's called the we section in Acts And then later later they did this so Luke is traveling with Paul and I think what is happening is Luke Had done his historical research maybe continue to do it But sometime while he was traveling with Paul he was writing the gospel of Luke with all the records of what Jesus did And I imagine it wasn't just in connection with Paul. I think there were others Of the circle of apostles who were with him and kind of saying yes, that's right That's what I remember that's accurate. That's true and the Holy Spirit was directing all that process But remember Luke has two books Luke and Acts at the end of Acts we've got the very last chapter of Acts It's still talking about Paul. He's in Rome preaching the gospel openly and unkindred though he's in prison in Rome And so yes Paul Luke wrote this while he was traveling or before or while he was traveling with Paul and this as well And so now Paul knows it well maybe has a copy of it and He's quoting it as scripture So we've got strong evidence now into the apostles like Paul say What I'm writing to you is a command of the Lord there they're in some you know get liberal scholars saying Oh, they didn't have any idea that their words were going to be in the Bible Well, sure they did what I'm writing to you is a command of the Lord And uh and then uh they're talking about each other's writings They're saying we're calling this scripture. So I think that's pretty strong argument that they're that they're Understanding that there are writings that go alongside the Old Testament writings as having equal authority

If we accept the arguments for the traditional views of authorship for the New Testament writings Then we have most of the New Testament in a canon because of the direct authorship by the apostles So Matthew and Apostle John and Apostle um Romans versus and Corinthians um Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Boschians, Persians, Seconds and Seconds, Persians, Seconds and Timothy Phileum and all Paul's Epistle Paul's an Apostle

Hebrews wait a minute James and Apostle uh Peter and Apostle the Epistles of John okay, so we get most of the New Testament, but you say wait a minute What about Mark? He wasn't one of the 12 Uh, he wasn't really considered an Apostle. What about Luke and Acts? Well, Mark was traveling with Peter and It's not in the Bible itself although Peter at the end of the first Peter says something about Is someone sent, she was a Babylon sent you greetings and so does my son Mark that is Mark is with him and right there early history of the church is that it's Mark wrote down the gospel of Peter preached So I think what happened was as Peter went around preaching Mark was recording the gospel And then Peter read it over and said yes These are the true teachings that uh that are the teachings of Jesus and uh, these are what are to be accepted as scripture So I think we have the Apostolic authority of Peter endorsing Mark and I think Luke with Paul What about Jude? There's a small book. It's got some funny things in it It's unusual things. It wasn't accepted as early in the church because he quotes first Enoch It's another Jewish writing that was out there But it was eventually accepted in virtue of the author's connection with James And the fact that he was the brother of Jesus and so um there was a little bit of a vague history We don't know all the details but Jude was eventually accepted again because he was um Either an Apostle or Connected closely with Peter and James And thought that the Apostles endorsed his uh his writing now. What about Hebrews? That leaves Hebrews That's a big question Who wrote Hebrews? Many urged acceptance of Hebrews based on a through assume Pauling authorship That is many people thought that Paul wrote Hebrews And some people today still think that Paul wrote Hebrews However many others rejected Pauline authorship and origin one of the great leaders and teachers in the early church 25480 that's very early origin In his writings he says who wrote the epistle of Hebrews Some say Paul some say a Paulus some say Barnabas But in truth only God knows That's very early 25480 he didn't question that it was scripture but he said only God knows who wrote it I've taught Hebrews a number of times When I look at the book of Hebrews the the style of writing the way sentences are put together You can see it even in English and it's it's very clear and Greek It just is a different kind of argumentation a different style of writing doesn't identify himself at the beginning Like Paul does not know his other pissell So I don't I don't think that Paul wrote Hebrews um I don't think anything crucial is at stake there But um in the early church some thought it was Paul's But others didn't know but its acceptance was due to the intrinsic qualities of the book in other words you say I think thousands of people have said In the early church or hundreds of people said Does Hebrews belong in a canner? It's so good who could leave it out John Calvin said we don't know who wrote it but the glory of Christ shines forth from every page of this epistle I mean, and I don't know if that's been your experience It's certainly been mine you read Hebrews and you say my goodness what an incredible unusually wonderful book This is these are the words of God And so there's something about the unique qualities of the book That must have led to its acceptance in the early church I suppose historically there were apostles saying yes, this is scripture Maybe some of them someone saying yes, I wrote it is scripture. I don't know Ultimately then how do you know what belongs in the detestinance for a book to belong to the canon It's absolutely necessary that it have divine authorship has to be Human authors writing under the direction of the Holy Spirit And it had to have been approved by the apostles for preservation and inclusion in the canon When people were wondering about Jude when they were wondering about Hebrews, there were still apostles alive And we don't have any historical evidence about you know The apostles that were alive saying yes, that's scripture or not, but I think they must have where the church wouldn't have accepted it So Where does that leave us? well

In in once in people had facts and Xerox copies all around to each other and they all signed off on them

But it wasn't that fast no facts machines no Xerox machines no email no typewriters even Copping by hand and we've got the Church spread throughout the Roman world So for all these epistles the large ones and the small ones to go from this church to that church to this church And all these churches accept them and it was a lot of process and The first list that we have that includes all the books in New Testament is 367 AD You're probably saying I wish there was an earlier one than that Me too But it just what it is I'm going to tell you before 367 AD You have many many early writers quoting the books of New Testament as scripture all of them in various places And so that's other kinds of evidence and there's some earlier lists But not all of but not Jude didn't circulate as fast as all of some of the other shorter epistles But here's Athanasians in Alexandria the Bishop writing in Easter in 367 AD He says there are four gospels Matthew, Mark, Luke and John afterward the acts of the apostles and the epistles called Catholic 7 that is of James 1 of Peter 2 first and second Peter of John 3 for second 3rd John After these one of Jews in addition, there are 14 epistles of Paul

14 he's going to think Hebrews is Paul, but we'll find out You're written in this order the first to the Romans then two to the Corinthians after these to the Galatians next to the Ephesians the Philippians the Lashians after these two to the Thessalonians and after the Hebrews and again two to Timothy one to Titus and lastly the Byleman and besides the Revelation of John that's the whole New Testament

and There's a Council in Carthage just in 397 that also affirms that list Now here's Athanasius I'm going on just in the next paragraph or two Athanasius says but for greater or exactness I had this also Writing of necessity that there are other books besides these not indeed included in the canon But appointed by the fathers to be read by those who newly join us and those who wish for instruction the word of godly is I'd be like saying My utmost for his highest by Oswald Chambers. That's a good book to read Okay, or it's wind all sermons or you know whatever you know other other things like that So he said there are some other books to read the wisdom of Solomon the wisdom of Syrac That's part of the apocrypha and Esther and I think of what he means there's additions to Esther in the apocrypha Judith and Tobit those are the and the teaching of the apostles. That's the dynarchate Which I'll talk about in a minute and the shepherd shepherd of Hermas. It's an erudic testament times but not from the Bible The former my brother are included the canon as the earlier group But the latter being merely read nor is there in any place a mention of apocryphal writings But these are an invention of heretics who write them when they choose I think those are other writings probably what we today call the pseudopigratha So he's saying these are not part of the canon But so you say 367. Oh, come on Wayne. Can't you get any evidence earlier than that 360 seven that's solely But now here there is something else that's very important That is book Revelation ends 90 AD Right after that We have some other writings 95 AD We get the epistle of climates 110 AD we get their writings of Ignatius and then I'm going to talk about something in 170 AD These are close now look at first Clement He is an elder or a bishop in the church at Rome And he's writing to Corinth and he already looks back on the Apostle and he doesn't think of himself in the Apostle He's different. He's less So he says our Apostles knew that there would be striped for the title of bishop They appointed those who have been already been mentioned And they said other men should have proved to them is he's writing to Corinth The church at Corinth was wanting to kick out its elders and get a new elder board and Clement is saying hey, don't do that the Apostles chose these and they had good judgments to leave But look he's looking back at the Apostles. He's five years after With the latest time. We know the New Testament writings would be and he's already saying look back at the Apostles I'm not one of them. He's a leader in the church of Rome. Okay. He doesn't take the title of Apostles Ignatius to the Romans 110 AD I do not order you as did Peter and Paul they were Apostles I'm a convict. They were using prison for his faith. They were free. I'm even now a slave So again, it's the idea that the Apostles are in the past and they're looking back on them very very early Ignatius again, I do not think myself competent as a convict to give you orders like an Apostle so Right away they knew that those writings were different and the Apostles were different. I'm gonna mention 170 AD I don't have it on the on the transparency on the slide But there was a man named Tation And he wrote something called the D I A T E S S A R O N D a Tesseron It means through four and He put together the words of Matthew Mark Lupin John in one long narrative one long story We can all together and so right away 170 AD you've got Matthew Mark Lupin John no other gospel Dan Brown The Vinci code the church only accepted these and imposed them in 325 AD. That's really bogus You see you you already hear have looking back on the Apostles First Clement quoting some of the books in the New Testament and you've got Tation in 170 AD using those four books Are the Gospels and nobody else so Although they're quick sometimes today liberal scholars suggest that other books are equal to New Testament Gospels like the did a K I mean it's teaching or the Shepherd of Hermus or the Gospel of Thomas But these books are there's a lot of strange stuff in them I've spent quite a bit of time looking working the did a K just for linguistic purposes of word purposes Shepherd of Hermus is really painful to read through. It's always weird visions of this woman in black coming to this man And showing him this and that and it's very strange. You don't want to hear Bible

I had I was sitting in my office at Trinity Seminary in the Illinois one day and The switchboard called there's a reporter on the phone from the Minneapolis start to view She's wants to know something about the Gospel of Thomas. Could you take the call sister? So she said, well, hello, what's in I told her she said well now we're hearing that Jesus Seminar They're saying the Gospel of Thomas should be part of the scriptures along with Matthew, Mark, Lupin, John And I said, oh, that's very interesting. I have a gospel of Thomas right here. We want me to read you a sentence from it She said, okay, so I turned to the last sentence of it And I read this the gospel according to Thomas Simon Peter said to them let Mary go away from us for women are not worthy of life Jesus said low, I shall lead her so that I may make her a male that she too may become a living spirit remember it resembling you males For every woman who makes herself a male will enter the kingdom of heaven and this reporter from the Minneapolis start your Beauty said oh, I don't know where this stuff came from. It's just weird The Gospel of Thomas it doesn't really lay out a life of Jesus. It's just a whole bunch of collections of things that Jesus supposedly said and There's other stuff like that. I brought I brought some of it

New Testament apocrypha of volume one and New Testament apocrypha of volume two by Henika H And then easy pay he if you want to buy and read some of it you can It's a strange stuff. It's stuff that was floating around Christianity started to grow and everybody wanted to get in the act and they made up stuff and so Here you go when the boy Jesus was five years old He was playing at the Ford of a Brook and he gathered together into pools the water that flowed by and made it at once clean Commanding if I his word alone and he made soft clay and fashion from the clay 12 sparrows And it was the Sabbath when he did this There were also other children playing with him Now when a certain Jew saw what Jesus was doing in his play on the Sabbath He went and once and told his father Joseph see your child is at the Brook and he has taken clay in fashion 12 birds and profane the Sabbath In other words making these play birds would work It was sin And when Joseph came to the place and saw it He cried out to him saying why do you do on the Sabbath what ought not to be done But Jesus clapped his hands and cried to the sparrows off with you and the sparrows took flight and went away chirping The Jews were amazed when they saw this in other words What sparrows? I didn't do any work. I didn't make any sparrows you see they're going Well Now it's it my first reaction is this is just stupid And it's not but my second reaction is my hardest kind of grief to read it And because Jesus wasn't that way disobedient and then destroying the evidence And third the gospel of John tells me when Jesus changed water to wine it was the first of his miracles This the first of his signs Jesus did it came in Galilee and manifested his glory in John too So he didn't do miracles when he was a little kid and and you get these other stories about Jesus playing games and somebody bumps into him and falls down and dies and something you know just But it's it's people making up just the product of their imagination. It's not the word of God It's just strange. This is the infancy story of Thomas So It's there. It's around the church knew about it. They didn't take it a picture. It's not Didn't have the authority to passels. There's another story. I guess I won't read you about John and the bedbugs But It couldn't sleep so he said you bedbugs leave the holy apostle And so they watched and all the bedbugs go over into the corner and then when he wakes up in the morning after a good night Sleepy said all right, you can go back to your place and they all march up into the bed. Well, there it is

So it's out Inventive creative people. Okay So where where does that leave us on the New Testament canon? Should we expect more writings to be added to the canon? Oh, I want to say one more thing. I didn't bring this in but it's respected Dan Brown and this bogus claim That the church imposed these writings for the first time in 325 AD I brought just I guess I brought two volumes from what's called. It's a it's a Nine-volume collection the anti-ni-seen fathers. That's before and I see it in 325 AD. This is small print in English. Can you see it? It's thousands of pages of early church writings early Christians writing anti-ni-seen means before 325 AD Before Dan Brown said That the church took these books as scripture and the reason I wrote this I brought this is There are pages and pages and pages in the scripture index of quote of where they quote Matthew Mark Luke John Acts Romans 1st and 2nd Corinthians Galatians Ephesians Philippius Ploshes all the way to Revelation pages and pages of index thousands of quotations from these books Not from other books as scripture Dan Brown is just bogus. It's just historically a laugh. It's it's just but people believe it because They don't have to believe the Bible and they don't have to accept the Bible's claims on them and they can make up their own religion So should we explain but all I when I read that in the Da Vinci code I thought I've got nine volumes worth of writings that quote our New Testament No, and that's before the time you said this was a New Testament I think that's not a very good argument Should we expect more writings to be added to the canon? Well here, I think is what is the answer? There's a finality to the revelation of God in Christ and once this revelation has been completed no more is to be expected The apostles and their coast companions report Christ words and deeds and interpret them with absolute divine authority Therefore the canon is now closed and the overview of that process is in Hebrews 1, 1 and 2 Long ago at many times and in many ways God spoke to our fathers by the prophets But in these last days he has spoken to us But in these last days he has spoken to us by his son when we appointed the heir of all things So the big picture on this the big picture on this Is that the Old Testament is many parts

many ways whether David or Moses or Isaiah or all Many parts many ways and here the whole New Testament is the revelation in the sun This is the revelation of Jesus Christ long ago many parts many ways But now at the end of the ages he's spoken to us in his son And this revelation of Jesus Christ is the final and greatest revelation of God That to me is the answer to Mormonism Because Mormonism comes along and says we have more revelation You have a better revelation than Jesus You have a better revelation of God than God's very son to see There can be no greater revelation And so the answer is no Jesus did not authorize any others than his apostles and once that's recorded and interpreted the canon is closed

Revelation 22 says I warn everyone who hears the words of the prophecy of this book If anyone adds to them God will add to him the plagues described in this book And if anyone takes away from the words of the book of this prophecy God will take away his share in a three of life of the holy cities Which which are inscribed in this book. That's very strong warning When I first read that probably as a seven or eight year old during a boring sermon one Sunday morning I'm sitting in my Baptist church in Wisconsin I thought that meant the whole Bible That was my first seven year eight year old reaction As I kind of grew older and I realized that the words of the prophecy of this book Referred to revelation then I thought oh no. I wasn't mistaken It just applies to the book of revelation. I think that's the right interpretation But then I got older yet and I thought It's not an accident that this morning occurs in this book and this book occurs Here it can't go any place out some of them you can put in different order But Genesis you have to put first because it's the beginning and revelation you have to put last because it's the future And so at the end of the last book at the very end chapter 22 Here's a warning and I think though it initially and primarily applies to the book of revelation I think that that my seven seven year old instinct to say it means the whole book is probably a good healthy spiritual Instinct and it's therefore a purpose How do we know we have the right books? Primarily Ultimately I haven't talked about this much yet. Primarily my confidence is in the faithfulness of God He wants his people to have his works And I think that this whole process of collecting and preserving and preserving the books the Old Testament and the books the New Testament So we have the right one. I think that was ultimately overseen by God and his providence And I trusted that he's preserved for us the right books But we are individually persuaded by the work of the Holy Spirit as we read scripture We understand his God's word to it and the historical data that I've just gone through Those are helpful in informing us and giving us additional confirmation It's there that Mormonism falls down flat It just got dozens and dozens of historical contradictions and inconsistencies and false claims about Jesus coming to North America and People the Indians being related to the Jewish people and all this it doesn't born out by the DNA evidence by the historical evidence totally different from scripture But the historical data are very in helpful in informing us and and confirm this are there other books that possibly deserve a place in the canon no no Either they just like first clement Distinguished themselves some canon or like gospel Thomas. They're just strange Or are there any strong objections to any book currently in the canon no the canon of scripture today is exactly what God wanted it to be but we'll stay that way until Christ returns and we can be thankful for that. Okay Couple of minutes for questions and then we'll have to clear out

Yeah John Okay Why don't we see the incredible outpouring of miracles like there was in Jesus and in the book of Acts Why don't we see that so much today? It's a complex question John part of the answer is um I think there was a unique Empowering of Jesus and the apostles Part of the answer is Our lack of faith Part of the answer is there are things like that occurring From time to time and sometimes Especially in third world countries where there isn't this Western rationalistic unbelief mindset and the people have more faith They're seeing more of these things. That's a complex question. Good question Rose Yeah Yeah Yeah, well get good question the Muslims. They think well, how much more recent than Jesus. Yeah, but he's not better He's not the perfect revelation of God that's in the Sun. He has seen me has seen the Father And so I think what we have to claim is that the greatest revelation of God that he's going to give until the second coming is the revelation in the Sun and the New Testament tells about that so I interrupt it before you end Yeah, well we bear witness the truth and the Holy Spirit has to pursue What else? Yeah, Mark Yeah Yeah, yeah, this angel will angel Moroni. I don't think he was a good angel to be honest The Period to Joseph Smith or angel a period of Muhammad I think actually those were genuine spiritual events But I do not think they were good spiritual events. I think that was a demonic deception

Right, and it's yeah, so Mark's name is a good point. These are inconsistent with the gospel and Paul says in Galatians If anybody preaches a gospel different to the one I preach to let him be first even I range will come out so um Yes Islam and And Mormonism are inconsistent with the gospel the heart of the gospel of salvation by faith in Christ alone Okay, good reasons reject last one. What's your name? Christian Caldwell How wide to divide on Mormonism Mm-hmm. Yeah, I disagree Greg Bloomberg is a friend but If but the statement that the canon is Open and theory but closed in practice. I think this falls. I think there's going to be no better Record of the life of Jesus and anybody today is going to give there's going to be no better Interpretation of the life of Jesus than anybody's going to give and I don't think anybody today has the authority from the Holy Spirit To act like an apostle and write the word description. What you see right here Beginning the early church nobody claims the title of apostle after that. It's a special Roll you had to have seen the risen Jesus with your own eyes and been specially appointed by him as an apostle So yeah, Greg Bloomberg New Testament scholar at Denver. He's been a friend of mine for years But he was quite widely criticized for what he wrote in that book Yeah, and I I don't agree Next week the gym See you