<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tuku Tuku māhina

God and Government - Part 1

October 2, 2020
0:000:00

Tonight, we begin a two-part series, which I'm entitling God and government, and I should say at the outset, what I am not going to do in these two messages. I am not going to tell you how to vote. Just as importantly, I am not going to tell you how to think about voting. Two weeks ago on my blog, I argued that there are four main approaches Christians might take to voting, one, and here I'm thinking of the American context, one, vote for the best candidate of all the candidates. Look at the list of the candidates, and you simply vote for the one you think is best. Two, you might say, well, we vote for the best or the least bad candidate of the two major parties because we know that one of those two will be the president, and when you think about what is best, you take into account the person's policies, platforms, personal integrity. A third approach might be to vote for the best candidates, either of all the candidates or of the two major parties, so long as the candidate meets a certain threshold for character and convictions. You might have, in your mind, what would vote for the best or vote for the least bad of the two with some minimum threshold, if both say they are for the destruction of all puppies, I draw a line, or whatever your line may be. A fourth approach would be to vote in a way that you believe best advances the long-term interests of your policy goals and convictions, so this may sound like the other three, but it's a little different instead of simply saying, what is best of these options at this moment? You may think, well, over the long haul, what is going to be best and wisest with my vote? What sort of signal am I hoping to send with the vote that I cast? Now you may not find all of those approaches equally compelling, but I do think they are all reasonable ways to approach the act of voting as a Christian in America, so I'm not going to get into how you want to think about voting because actually the Bible doesn't say a whole lot because they didn't vote. I am not developing an entire Christian philosophy of politics, we simply don't have time for that. I am not going to look at all the theological and philosophical building blocks that were put into place at the establishment of the American system of government. I could talk about the importance of certain doctrinal convictions like the ones we've been seeing in Genesis, two of the most foundational convictions, I think, for a healthy and realistic approach to government is to understand that all people are made in the image of God and to understand that we are fallen and we are born to this world with a fallen sinful human nature, those two convictions, the inherent worth and dignity of all persons, of whatever age in the womb or outside the womb, and then to understand that politics and government must be the art of the possible because we're sinners. I could talk about the development of natural law and social contract theory and various strands of 18th century moral philosophy, I teach a course, or at least I did in the spring, at RTS on the Enlightenment where I go into the link in detail on all of those things, but I am not going to cram a course into two messages, so what am I going to talk about? Well, what's left to say a lot and I can pretty well assure you I will try to squeeze in more than I should, I'd like to tackle in these two evenings two big themes. Tonight I want to talk broadly about church and state, and in the second message, two weeks from now Lord willing, I want to talk about those in authority and those under authority, or the rulers and the ruled, or magistrates and citizens. So tonight, the first big heading, church and state, I want to approach in two distinct ways. First, I want to take us through some Presbyterian history. Oh, here's some amen's, yes, some Presbyterian history and theology regarding the spirituality of the church, and then second, we will look at one passage from the gospels to see how Jesus thought about God in government. So as we talk about church and state, then the first thing we want to do this evening is a little bit of history and theology on this term, the spirituality of the church. What do we mean by that? In general terms, the spirituality of the church, that doctrine teaches that given the nature of the church under the mediatorial reign of Christ, there are limits to church power, and that this power must not be confused with the power of the state or limits to church power, and the derivative from that is there are limits to state power, and the two must not be confused. You may have heard that term in there, the mediatorial reign of Christ, I'm not going to say much about that, but it's an important distinction in reform theology between the essential reign and the mediatorial reign of Christ. Yes, Christ rules over everything, the famous line from Abraham Kuiper, there's not one square inch about which Christ does not cry out, this is mine. Christ rules over all of it, but there is his essential reign, God ruling and granting to Christ reign over the universe, and then his mediatorial reign, which is Christ reign over the church as its mediator. He is not the mediator for all persons because not all persons are saved. And so typically theologians have distinguished between, yes, Christ reigns over all things, but he reigns in two different ways. Throughout most of reformed history, the spirituality of the church has not meant that the church could never speak on a, quote, political matter, what is a political matter, it's something that involves the polis, the city, the state, that could be almost anything, but rather the doctrine teaches that there is a commitment to the uniqueness of the church's mission and a principled conviction that the concerns of the church should not be swallowed up by the concerns of the state. The theology behind this is found in Calvin, Beza, the roots of the doctrine certainly can be found in Geneva, but for understanding the spirituality of the church as it has taken shape in the Presbyterian world and through Presbyterians to the broader church, we can start with Scotland and a book that you've probably never read, but has influenced the way we do church in all sorts of ways. It's a book called The Second Book of Discipline. It's not a book for parenting, it's a book for ordering the church. It was approved by the General Assembly in Scotland in 1578, though never approved by Parliament because of its understanding of church property and patronage. This The Second Book of Discipline was a brief manual on church government. It's been called the first explicit statement of Presbyterianism. A central theme throughout the document is that the Kirk, K.R.K., which is Scottish word for the church, the Kirk, and the civil magistrate will at times work toward the same ends, but quote, always without confounding the one jurisdiction with the other. That's what The Second Book of Discipline said way back in 1578. Now we should not think that, ah, they believed in Thomas Jefferson's wall of separation or they had the First Amendment like we do and they believed in the separation of church and state. No, that would be to misunderstand what was going on in 16th century Scotland. They still had an understanding that they were a reformed realm and they were a Presbyterian kingdom, but there are beginnings of this important doctrine that the role and the realm of the state and the role and the realm of the church should not be confused. Now this was different in what was taking place with its neighbor to the south in England, where in England, if you recall some history of the Reformation, they had the magistrates, the king, the queen, was also the head of the church and this is still at least on paper the way it is with the Anglican communion. So even today, we need to make this important distinction. When you hear me say, for example, at a baptism declaration, in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, the only king in head of his church, that goes back to the second book of discipline and to the Presbyterian understanding of these two kingdoms. To say the Lord Jesus Christ, the only king in head of his church is saying two things. It's saying, first of all, they're saying the Pope is not the head of our church, only Jesus, but they were also saying there is no earthly monarch over our church. Our church is not under the authority of the king or the queen. The only king in head of his church is Jesus. This is why chapter one of this second book of discipline begins by examining the difference between policies related to the church and policies related to civil society. Let me just read you a few of these. Section 11. The magistrate commands external things for external peace and quietness among the subjects, the minister handles external things only for conscience sake. 12. The magistrate handles external things only in actions before men, but the spiritual ruler judges both inward affections and external actions in respect of conscience by the word of God. 13. The civil magistrate gets obedience by the sword, the ministry by the spiritual sword, or 15. The magistrate ought to assist, maintain and fortify the well-being of the church, but the ministers, as they assist, the princes and all things agreeable, do so according to their own jurisdiction. That's combining section 14 and 15. So notice a few things here. It's hard to have 16th century documents read to you. First, notice the magistrate and the minister exercise jurisdiction over different spheres. That the magistrate, it says, deals with external things. That is, he cannot make laws that demand certain affections. They said the king should not make a law to compel the conscience to believe certain things. The minister, on the other hand, has the right to judge inner dispositions and obedience, though the minister mainly deals with spiritual things. He handles external things only for conscience sake. So there's a different jurisdiction. Second, notice the minister is not silent on all matters pertaining to the state. It says in one place, he has called upon to teach the magistrates how the civil jurisdiction should be exercised according to the word. So it isn't that the church or the pulpit can never speak to an issue that affects civil policy. But third, even though the minister has a right and responsibility to deal with matters pertaining to the civil realm, the second book of discipline says that is not his chief work. The minister's involvement in civil affairs must not be neglected of his own charge. I'm very interested in politics. I read lots of things on politics. I studied politics and religion in my undergrad. I have lots of thoughts, and I mostly try to keep those to myself. Because, even if I were to just go on Twitter on my blog and just say, well, this is just now just Kevin the citizen speaking. I'm not the pastor when I say this. It would be very hard for people to really say, well, can you really just divest yourself of this? You're no longer speaking in any way on behalf of Christ's church or representing Christ's covenant. So I want to be careful that I'm saying things that can be shown manifestly from the word of God so that if people are to come into this church and there are obstacles, doctrinal, convictional obstacles, those obstacles are things that can be plainly taught from Scripture. We would not put obstacles of preference or obstacles on things that the word of God is not meaning to speak clearly. Let's fast forward 75 years to something that we may be more familiar with, the Westminster Confession of Faith 1646. Again, the confession does not have a Jeffersonian separation of church and state. If anything, the Westminster Confession of Faith has a bit more overlap between the church and the state than the second book of discipline did in Scotland. And we'll see in just a moment that when Presbyterianism comes to America, they pretty quickly changed some of that. But this basic doctrine of the spirituality of the church is present in the Westminster Confession. This is chapter 31, section 4. Synods and councils are to handle or conclude nothing but that which is ecclesiastical and are not to intermetal with civil affairs which concern the commonwealth unless by way of humble petition in cases extraordinary or by way of advice for satisfaction of conscience if they by their unto required by the civil magistrate. What the confession is saying is that in general church synods and church councils are not going to try to tell the state how they should run their business. That is the church is not going to issue an official church document that says here you hear you this is the Christian taxation rate or this is the Christian immigration policy unless the confession says the government says Presbyterian church in America we want to know what you think about this or it does leave a little escape cause there in extreme situations that call for redress when the church is being clearly oppressed by the state. Now I mentioned that in the original confession of faith 1646 there was quite a bit of assumption that the state would play a significant role in supporting defending promoting the church that gets changed early in American Presbyterian history. There was something called the adopting act of 1729 and our very own Don Fortson can tell you everything you want to know and probably things you don't even want to know about that in early Presbyterian history and in that adopting act the Presbyterian church allowed that chapters 20 and 23 of the Westminster Confession were no longer binding on ministers and when the church then formed officially as a national church 1788 the Westminster standards were amended so you don't have the hymnals there in the pews that have the Westminster Confession in them but if you were to look almost certainly at your copy of the Westminster Confession of Faith by your nightstand no doubt the one that you're reading from is amended from the original 1646 version that in American Presbyterianism they changed chapter 20 2331 and the Catechism 109 to do away with the language that had the state intermetaling with the affairs of the church. When the first Book of Church Order was approved at the first General Assembly in 1789 eight preliminary principles were included and right next to the Confession of Faith on your nightstand is no doubt the Book of Church Order and if you were to look in the Book of Church Order you would find that our PCA Book of Church Order has preliminary principles which are substantially the very same that have been in place since 1789 and here's what the seventh principle states in the 1789 language that all church power whether exercised by the body in general or in the way of representation by delegated authority is and here are two very important terms in Presbyterian theology is only ministerial and declarative that is to say that the Holy Scriptures are the only rule of faith and manners that no church judicatory ought to pretend to make laws to bind the conscience in virtue of their own authority and that all their decisions should be founded upon the revealed will of God. Very important in the Reformed and Presbyterian tradition and it's enshrined in our confessional documents is the liberty of the conscience it's not an absolute liberty it doesn't mean you can just do whatever you want but the liberty of the conscience informed by the word of God so it was very important to say that the church's authority is only ministerial and declarative meaning the church has no authority to bind your conscience the church only has the authority to declare and to serve what has already written down in the word of God if you're an officer in the church you may hear from time to time the language about the courts of the church the session is a court of the church the Presbyteria is a court the general assembly the courts of the church there's a reason it's they're not called the legislatures of the church because the idea is we are not making any new laws we are courts because we're only determining how the laws already written in scripture apply and ought to be defended and promoted and protected the church cannot bind the conscience except as the word of God binds the conscience which is why at its best this church state that the church has been careful not to transgress its own bounds there's a famous example of this with Jay Gresham Machen who you may know founded Westminster Theological Seminary and the Orthodox Presbyterian Church and back in the 20s and 30s when prohibition was all the rage and it seemed like everyone if you were a Christian of course you supported prohibition Machen made a very unpopular stand where he said I'm paraphrasing I certainly am against drunkenness as much as anyone but I do not believe that we can find on the authority of scripture that we must insist on the Volstead act or we must insist upon this new amendment to the constitution in other words that you could be a good Christian and disagree that this new amendment was the only way or the best way to address the national problem of drunkenness now in his day that was you don't care about people's lives but he was making I think the right principled stand based on this doctrine of the spirituality of the church almost done with this first part if you've heard of this doctrine before you may have heard of it with a a bit of a suspicion and that's not without some good reason because the spirituality of the church is often linked to certain southern Presbyterians who use the spirituality of the church in the 19th century to avoid having to say anything about slavery so even today it has a certain sense of suspicion with some people the spirituality of the church that's what Presbyterians used so that they could support or not go against slavery and it is true this the issue of slavery took center stage in Presbyterian denominational life in the 19th century and it is true that some southern Presbyterianism took a narrower and narrower view of the spirituality of the church so that they wanted to completely quarantine that issue it said no no that spirituality the church we have nothing to say about it but that wasn't the opinion of all Presbyterians as you might imagine there was some disagreement between northern and southern Presbyterians Charles Hodge for example disagreed with Thornwell's contention that since the church was only to preach the gospel Thornwell said the church had no right to open her lips against the slave trade Hodge who was not an abolitionist he was very much a moderate said well yes but the bible here's Hodge yes the bible gives us no rule for deciding the litigated questions about public improvements a national bank or a protective tariff or state's rights but it does give us rules concerning slave laws the slave trade obedience to magistrates trees and rebellion and revolution so the spirituality the church was not for Hodge an injunction to be silent on all matters at all times wrapping this up the doctrine then as construed throughout most of the reformed tradition does not mean that pastors or churches can never say something that's quote political the doctrine does however give a necessary warning against ministers or churches for getting the gospel charge for civil concerns or churches transgressing their god given powers not to mention their own area of expertise denominations can lose sight of the spiritual aims of the church and movements and leaders can pronounce to exactly and to confidently upon matters that scripture doesn't explicitly address I saw this more frequently in my previous denomination which was on almost all social issues would tend to lean way to the left and we would have official church statements and committees making very detailed pronouncements about how many rounds of ammunition ought to be sold and what sort of embargo we ought to have or not have and how high minimum wage used to be or should be and those would all lean in a certain direction and whether you agreed with those pronouncements or not it was certainly the case that we were very far overstepping our bounds as a church not only did we not have authority in God's word to say what the minimum wage should be or if you should have a minimum wage but if we were honest we were quite a bit far over our skis in thinking we were experts in any of these things and I say we because it was my denomination not because I voted for those statements at its best the spirituality of the church reminds us the state should not try to do the church's job and the church should not try to do the job of the state there's an important distinction in talking about the state's relationship to the church that the state has the authority to make decisions or legislation in things about the church circa sacra that is about concerning so the state tells us what a fire code is and how many people can be in this building or the state may tell us what sort of islands and greenery we need in the parking lot and we don't consider that to be an infringement upon our liberty as Christians that's about the church but the state has no right to interfere with things in the church circa sacra a round or about the church but not in sacra not in sacred things not to tell us how we do our worship services or what we believe and of course the first amendment in this country provides even more than that that's the first half here's the second turn in your bibles to mark chapter 12 and hopefully you will see how these two halves do go together so as we talk about church and state the first half was to look at the history and the theology of this doctrine of the spirituality of the church and then second I want to look at Jesus and his view of God and government because there are more implications it may first meet the eye from this familiar story marked chapter 12 verse 13 and they sent to him some of the Pharisees and some of the Herodians to trap him in his talk and they came and said to him teacher we know that you are true and do not care about anyone's opinion for you are not swayed by appearances but truly teach the way of God isn't lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not should we pay them or should we not but knowing their hypocrisy he said to them why put me to the test bring me a denarius and let me look at it they brought one and he said to them who's likeness and inscription is this he said to him Caesar's Jesus said to them render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's and to God the things that are God's and they marveled at him this is the third confrontation Jesus has with the Sanhedrin in and around the temple leading up to his crucifixion and this is the second time that they've tried to corner Jesus at the end of chapter 11 the chief priest in scribes and elders confront him about his authority and he springs that trap and tells a parable against them which makes them hate Jesus all the more so here they come again with another plan to get Jesus in trouble and they figure what better way to get this rabbi in trouble than to ask him about politics and it's not a sincere question as Admiral Akbar said in return of the Jedi it's a trap if Jesus says well pay your taxes he'll be unpopular with the people they resented this once a year poll tax that's what they're talking about because most of the Jews despise the Romans they were a kind of vassal state of the Roman Empire and many of them thought it was idolatry to pay the tax should we really submit ourselves to Rome if we pay this tax aren't we in some small way helping further Roman imperialism the tax was despised by the people and so they wanted him to say well pay the tax and then the common people would be angry but on the other hand if he says well of course you don't pay your taxes he'll be in trouble with Rome and they'll say ah here's another revolutionary so they figure heads I went tells you lose kind of question answer one way and the Pharisees are there to get the crowds fired up turn against you and the support of the crowd is the only thing preventing the Sanhedrin from arresting Jesus which is what they really want to do but if you answer the other way the Herodians are there and they'll tell the Roman officials and they'll tattle on you so what are you going to do Jesus but Jesus is the master at springing traps he is a little mouse that manages to swipe the cheese and live to see another day so he asks can I see the coin can I see the denarius the denarius was equivalent to a day's wage common coin in Judea you know it's a I would say it's a dollar bill but a dollar bill isn't a day's wage anymore or a hundred dollar bill but you don't see those very often but it's a it's a regular unit of currency everyone is familiar with is a typical day laborer you get a denarius we know what the coin looked like archaeologists have found a number of them the denarius was a silver coin and around this time it had the head of Tiberius Caesar on it he was the Roman Emperor from 14 to 37 AD so it fits with the chronology of the gospels right in this time the coin had a picture of the emperor on one side with these words now didn't have all these words it was abbreviated but this is what it was inscribing Tiberius Caesar Divi Augusti Filius Augustus which means Tiberius Caesar Augustus son of divine Augustus and the flip side had the inscription Pontifex Maximus high priest so you can understand why the Jews hated this tax we're going to give this coin which is literal blasphemy it has a picture of the emperor and it says that he is the son of divine Augustus we're going to hail this Caesar as divine look at what Jesus does he asks to see the coin and then ask whose likeness is on it whose image is on it and obviously everyone can see well it's the emperor's Caesars which prompts Jesus to utter one of his most famous sentences which even people outside the church have heard render to Caesar the things that are Caesars into God the things that are gods that one response that pithy remark says more than you might think it gives the beginning of a Christian view of politics and religion of God and government it's a foundational statement for the way Christians should look at church and state and let me in our last 15 or 20 minutes quickly give you six implications six statements about God and government that can be derived from this one pithy response of Jesus first and we'll say more about this next week be good citizens even if you think the government is bad be good citizens even if you think the government is bad and in a few days literally from Mark 12 after this incident the Romans will kill Jesus in 70 AD they will wipe out the temple in the years ahead they will kill the apostles and thousands of other Christians and before Jesus Rome had squashed a number of Jewish rebellions Rome was the ruler Judea was the vassal state now the Romans weren't the Nazis they did a number of good things they didn't persecute the Jews nonstop but they did what they had to do they didn't always have their hearts in persecuting minority religious groups they just wanted to make sure that nobody got away with insurrection they swindled when they could they cheated when they could it's safe to say no matter how much you may dislike aspects of American politics or be dismayed at our politicians or how much you may think that the government is stupid or unjust Rome was worse and yet Jesus says pay your taxes Caesar's face is on the coin he has a right to levee tribute so pay the denarius be good citizens even when you think the government is bad which surely they all thought and for good reason that the government was not on their side second allegiance to god and allegiance to your country are not inherently incompatible not inherently incompatible some strands of Christian thought talk as if you should have no loyalty for your country as if patriotism was a bad thing as if you should just vote Jesus for president and just wash your hands of the whole messy business of politics or patriotism but Jesus shows it is possible to honor god and honor Caesar this is especially clear if you know something of Jewish history because this tax is the poll tax or the census tax it was first instituted in 6 AD not long before Jesus ministry here and when it was established a man by the name of Judas of Galilee led a revolt why did he revolt later the Jewish historian Josephus will write about Judas of Galilee he said this he called his fellow countrymen cowards for being willing to pay tribute to the Romans and for putting up with mortal masters in place of god so this man Judas from Galilee the generation earlier and then after him perhaps the zealots they believed allegiance to god and allegiance to any earthly government were fundamentally incompatible as far as they were concerned if god was your king then you could have no earthly king theocracy was the only way to go Jesus disagreed by telling the people rendered a Caesar the things that are Caesar he's saying there are duties to the government that do not automatically infringe upon your ultimate duty to god he's saying it's possible to honor lesser authorities in good conscience because they have an instituted by a greater authority see this next week in Romans 13 you could see it in 1 Peter 2 that the normal situation or the desired situation is one of compatible loyalties that you have a loyalty to god and you have a loyalty to government and they are compatible loyalties one is not mutually exclusive of the other we have had a very privileged place in the history of this country that for our entire history those two have been compatible and for a lot of our history they have been more than compatible they've been mutually reinforcing that is changing but that's the situation that Paul and Peter envision that the church is not the state and the state is not god but this does not mean that the church must always be against the state Calvin says about this passage in mark quote it lays down a clear distinction between spiritual and civil government in order to inform us that the outward subjection does not prevent us from having within us a good conscience free in the sight of god in short Calvin says Christ declares that it is no violation of the authority of god or any injury done to his service if in respect of outward government the Jews obey the Romans now this isn't to say what we do in specific situations we know later in Acts that the apostles will say we can't obey what the Jewish authorities were telling them to do because it would be to disobey god but here Jesus is laying out in Calvin explains it is possible to have compatible loyalties to be a good Christian and just to take our own context I know not all of you are from this country but you can be a good Christian and a good American patriotism is not a bad thing singing the national anthem and getting choked up is not a bad thing now it is not the place of a Christian worship service to have a sing the national anthem it's hard for some of us to get but it goes back to everything that we saw in the history of Presbyterianism and the spirituality of the church because we cannot bind anyone's conscience I can say that to be a good American you should put your hand on your heart and sing the national anthem and and mean it and exercise that patriotism I cannot tell someone from another country that they need to do that or that they need to pledge allegiance to the American flag I have no authority on the word of god to tell them that that's what being a Christian means but it doesn't mean that they're mutually exclusive allegiance to god and allegiance to your country are not inherently incompatible and hopefully we can continue to live in a country where the two can be compatible three developing from the second point it is acceptable that there be some measure of separation between religion and government or between church and state god and government or put it better church and state occupy overlapping spheres and it's true the government is always ultimately accountable to god every politician every aspect of our government will stand before god one day but if we can render some things to Caesar and render other things to god it must be the case that they're not one in the same because notice Jesus didn't say rendered to Caesar and when you're doing it you're rendering it to god they're different it's possible to have some separation as the early Scottish Presbyterian Andrew Melville referred to it there are two kings and two kingdoms now I keep saying some separation because there's all sorts of difficult issues that aren't going to be solved by Jesus one statement here so on the one hand we shouldn't pretend that civil legislation is somehow divorced from moral or religious categories people say well don't legislate your morality but it's the case that every law has at its basis some vision of morality so I'm not saying Christians don't bring our convictions to bear on public policy on the other hand it seems from this passage that Jesus did not have a vision for the state that meant it had to be ruled by all the laws of god so I am not a theonomist do not believe that the Bible teaches that the rules of gods kingdom are automatically the rules of any earthly kingdom it takes a lot of wisdom to navigate in his book Christ and culture revisited da Carson argues that the state and the church occupy quote distinct even if overlapping spheres so as I said at the outside this does not mean that Christ is not Lord of all but it means he rules over different spheres in different ways after all Jesus says in John 1836 my kingdom is not of this world and at the end of the age in Revelation 1115 the kingdom of this world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of our Christ so we are more like Israelites in exile in Babylon maintaining a kingdom within a kingdom than we are Israelites in the promised land where gods rule and the nation's rules were identical just want to say that again because it's foundational for understanding the church in the state Christian view of politics we are not so much Israel in the promised land where the laws of the land and the laws of god are identical but rather we are strangers and aliens we are exiles in the world that's how Peter writes his letter to those who are exiles in capadocia and across Asia Minor so we are more like those who are exiles in Babylon trying to establish a kingdom within a kingdom we are citizens we have dual citizenship citizens of an earthly country and of a heavenly country we are not Israel in the promised land we are the Israelites as strangers and aliens in Babylon this is one of the big differences between Islam and Christianity and why it remains to be seen if Islam in its pure form can work in the West I recall an anecdote in Carson's book about a Muslim man who said I find nothing in the Quran that tells us how to live as a minority and I find nothing in the Bible that tells you how to rule as the majority now that may be a bit of an overstatement but it's getting at something profound Islam developed with the state and religion intertwined while Christianity was at the beginning a persecuted minority well we live in a different situation now and we can be thankful that certain rights are protected in our first amendment and not just as a nod to tolerance but they are consistent with Christian convictions the church in the state have some legitimate separation that's the point fourth God's people are not tied to any one nation not tied to any one nation when Jesus says go ahead give to Caesar what belongs to him he is effectively saying you can with your obligatory taxes support nations that do not formally worship the one true God in Rome was not a Christian nation they did not worship the one true God and Jesus said well but you pay your taxes or to put a different way true religion is not bound up with only one country this means the church will be transcultural will be transnational marked ever from Capitol Hill Baptist in DC said in a sermon several years ago Jesus approval of paying taxes to Rome here was revolutionary by this he shows us the legitimacy of a government is not determined by whether it supports the worship of the one true God or even allows for it by Jesus not requiring those who would follow him to support only states which are formally aligned to the true God as Old Testament Israel had been Jesus unhitches following him from any particular nation you follow that argument because Jesus says you can render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's he's saying you can have a subservient responsibility underneath God to this other nation and this nation does not worship and follow the true God so you're no longer tied that you can be a faithful Christian citizen and no longer inhabit this earthly Israel as it were so we have people in this church most of us are born and probably die in this country but we have many who are not from this country and you'll go in some of you to other places and maybe you've encountered from people well Christianity is a Western religion or it's American religion but it's not it never has been started in the Middle East it proliferated in North Africa it was always meant to be international not tied to anyone nation America for all of its good and all that the Lord has used through our country is not the church America as a country is not in a covenant relationship with God as the church is today there are more Anglicans in church in Nigeria than there are Anglicans in England by far there are more Presbyterians worshipping today in South Korea than there are Presbyterians worshipping in the United States the promise to Abraham way back in Genesis that through his family God would bless the whole world that's happened the scene around the throne and revelation as of people from every tribe and language and culture so Christianity is not just tied to one nation and may be that God gives another 250 years to the United States or he gives 25 years or something in between following Christ is not an ethnic thing you can be from any country and worship Jesus five the state is not God so far we've been looking more at the first half of the statement render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's but now we need to look at the second statement render to God the things that are God's because you may think up to this point in the sermon well Jesus sounds really so pro status quo and pro Rome and pro government and he gives him a cute little answer about who's on the coin but it's all with siding with the Romans but look more carefully by saying give to Caesar what belongs to him and give to God what belongs to him Jesus is making clear yes give that coin to Caesar but what it says on that coin about Caesar it's not true Caesar's not God there are two distinct entities here remember the inscription on the Daenerius Tiberius Caesar Augustus son of divine Augustus and if people were listening carefully they would have heard Jesus say look give Caesar his taxes but Caesar's not God and God is not Caesar Tiberius is not divine Augustus was not divine and they are not the ones in whom you should put your trust human government last we checked is always run by humans as such there is a gravitational pull toward idolatry toward official idolatry as they had on the Daenerius or toward more subtle forms of idolatry to make idols out of our leaders or to infuse eternal spiritual significance in the political process or to think that we can somehow form a utopian society that human nature can be changed the 20th century in particular is littered with the tragedy of totalitarian regimes who thought that you could change human nature and at its best it's the genius of the American system James Madison put it in the Federalist papers to have ambition counteract ambition because we don't have a government run by angels and you need a government to check itself if we're not careful we can start to believe that Caesar really may be God the state really may have all the answers that government may be able to give us everything we need but Jesus tells us not only to respect the government he tells us quite clearly the state is not ultimate the government has authority but it does not have comprehensive authority it doesn't matter what country you are from America China Ghana Guatemala wherever your government is not God finally six we owe our ultimate allegiance to God if you notice I drew these connections very briefly a couple Sunday mornings ago in Genesis and we'll make it here more explicitly we see that the state's power is limited our allegiance to country or government is never absolute more about that next week but our allegiance to God is absolute we never are allowed to do other than what God tells us to do do you see the word in verse 16 whose likeness is this it's the Greek word icon you can hear our English word icon the word means image or likeness it's the same word when the Hebrew was translated into Greek make used in Genesis 126 let us make man in our icon in our image after our likeness and certainly as the Jews are well steeped in their own history and in the scriptures when they hear Jesus say whose likeness whose image is on that they could make the connections with Genesis Jesus what are the things that belong to Caesar well look at the coin taxes Paul will say we owe honor to Caesar that's what belongs to the governing authorities but Jesus says even more importantly what belongs to God well look at yourself whose image is on you whose likeness is in you gods so give Caesar his denarius you give God your whole self your whole life you don't live for Caesar you give to God your whole existence your everything imagine one day standing for God and he says to you come up here let me take a look at you and you feeling perhaps in all of your sin and shame he says now just look just look whose image who's likeness do I see and of course he sees his own you are like the coin in a coin maybe dirty maybe rusted maybe nasty looking they'd be barely legible but a penny is still worth a penny a quarter is still worth a quarter no matter how run down it is and still you and I are worth something to God because however rusted however illegible it may be our likeness gods likeness rather has been stamped upon us and we belong to him so the only way to render to God the things that are gods is to give God your whole self and that may be the most important lesson for us to remember especially in an election season give to Caesar what are Caesar Caesar matters but God is everything let's pray our Heavenly Father we ask for your wisdom as we consider these things we might learn from those who have gone before learn from our own history and tradition most importantly learn from your word help us in our dual citizenship to be good citizens of this earthly country or whatever earthly citizenship we may bear if not this one we pray that we would be better earthly citizens because of our far more important heavenly citizenship we pray that you give us strength and grace and wisdom for these days in Jesus name amen