<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Tum Den Tum Den Mɛ

Goal of Human Life

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Just a couple of things before we go to work, I mentioned last time Scott Ray, the book on with the title Brave New Families that is out of print. If you're interested in reproductive technologies as an area for your term paper, there's a substitute book. This is Andrew Kimbrale, K-I-M-B-R-E-D-L. The title is The Human Body Shop, subtitled The Cloning, Engineering, and Marketing of Life. I got this at Concordia Seminary Bookstore. It's not a bad idea once in a while to go down there and browse. I found that very, very helpful. It's Regenery Publishing 1997, so it's fairly up to date, and it covers the ground in terms of these issues. Andrew Kimbrale is an attorney-writer and activist director of the International Center for Technology Assessment in Washington, D.C., so it's, you know, this is stuff, and that might be a good substitute if you're working in that area. I'd like to begin class today by reading a couple of stanzas of a hymn by John Dryden. This is actually an English-versification of an ancient Latin hymn, Come Creator Spirit in Latin that would be Vini Creator Spiritus, and there's one reference to the Sevenfold Energy of the Holy Spirit here. That is an allusion to Isaiah 1112, where the Sevenfold powers of the Holy Spirit are set forth, just so you know, when we come to that part, what it's talking about, okay. Let's make this our prayer today. Creator Spirit, by whose aid the world's foundations first were laid, come, visit every humble mind, come, poor thy joys on humankind, from sin and sorrow set us free, and make thy temples worthy, thee. Plentious of grace come from on high, rich in thy sevenfold energy, make us eternal truth receive, and practice all that we believe. And must I sell that we may see the Father and the Son by thee, in the name of Jesus, amen. Now let me begin by a summary of where we were right at the end of the hour last time. This sentence is on the page 16, the last paragraph of chapter 1, but I want to repeat this as we get started. Here I give a kind of definition of Christian ethics. Christian ethics is the study of the way of life that conforms to the will of God as revealed in Christ and the Holy Scriptures. It was making the point from Romans 12 to that we refer everything to the will of God. That defines for us the good. And so I think we may reasonably define Christian ethics as the study of the way of life that conforms to the will of God as revealed in Christ and the Holy Scriptures. Of course our sure knowledge of Christ comes from the Scriptures themselves, but still I think it is necessary for us to highlight Christ as the embodiment of what human nature is supposed to be and what human morality is to keep that in mind in our definition. Later we will explore the example of Christ as the pattern of obedience for us. But there it is, Christian ethics is the study of the way of life that conforms to the will of God as revealed in Christ and the Holy Scriptures. Of course we need the illumination of the Holy Spirit in order to perform that study well to give us both knowledge and insight. And so I add that clause as illuminated by the Holy Spirit to remind us of our dependency, especially in light of our sinful condition, that we need the Spirit who indwells us to illuminate our hearts and minds, to renew us after the image of Christ and to enable us to apprehend those things that are for our benefit. Now tucked away in H. Richard Niebuhr's classic treatise on Christ and culture, that's a book that's been continuously in print since 1951. Jeremy assigns it in some of his courses, I don't want to overlap with what he assigns so I've awarded it for here, but it's relevant to this course, especially the dimension of social ethics, but there is this sentence that I want to repeat, page 131, if you want to look it up, Niebuhr writes, the Christian and any man must answer the question about what he ought to do by answering a previous question. What is my purpose, my end? I agree with that, and more importantly, so do the Westminster Divines, the authors of the Westminster Short of Catechisms. So our topic for today is to explore that just a little bit, the goal of human life. Now I mean, of course, the goal of human life from a Christian world and life view. Now we're talking about human life as it was created to be and will be through the redemptive work of Christ, alternatively you can call this the goal of the Christian life which I've done in the book, but I have come to prefer this to make the point that when we're articulating the Christian life, we're articulating the pattern of life that has been shown to us by the one who claims to be the way, the truth and the life. So this is a universal ethic in that sense that it's offered to all, it is the way to live. Now I was not brought up on the Short of Catechism. I had a typical fundamentalist upbringing in the 40s. When we still call ourselves fundamentalists, later on we began to call ourselves evangelical circles, sounded better, more importantly it enabled us to identify with the tradition that comes from the Reformation, but always thought that an evangelical is a fundamentalist with a smile and a shoe shine, I think that we believe the fundamentals and we still do. So there's a reason for that. Anyway, I didn't hear of the Short of Catechism until I got to college and it's a famous question and answer. You'll find it in the Oxford Dictionary of Quotations along with Shakespeare and all those other Englishmen. The question is, what is the chief end of man and the answer comes back, man's chief end is to glorify God and to enjoy him forever. It was a sophomore in college that rang true to me and it was also helpful to me to put things in perspective. It was the beginning of the development of a broader world and life view to look at things in terms of the glory of God and the goal of human life to enjoy him forever gave me a helpful perspective. Got me interested in the Reformed faith, but it wasn't until I began to teach ethics that I began to ask myself, why does the Catechism begin with that question? Heidelberg Catechism doesn't begin that way. Heidelberg Catechism begins, what is your only comfort in life and in death? And the wonderful answer comes back that I belong not to myself but to my faithful savior and it goes on to expound upon the evangelical theology coming from the Reformation that makes that case. It's a wonderfully warm and personal and devotional Catechism. The short of Catechism is more technical, more definitional and it begins with this question of the chief end. We are so struck by the answer that we don't often pause to think, why does it begin that way? What does it mean, chief end? Well, the Greek word for end is telos, it's also the word for goal. And what the Catechism is doing here is really aligning itself with the classical, tele-o-logical tradition in ethics, tele-o-logical derived from the Greek word telos. It is a goal-oriented ethic and it sees the other parts of ethics as subordinate to the question of our chief end or as the Catechism puts it, the chief and highest end. The second question is, what rule has God given to direct us how we may glorify and enjoy him? And the answer comes back, the Holy Scriptures, are the word of God which is revealed in the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testament, are the only rule to direct us how to glorify and enjoy him. So the rule is there, the norm is there, the standard is there, but subordinate to the goal. By the way, that second question and answer, which is really crucial, it didn't make it into the Oxford Dictionary of Quotations, people are not as familiar with how to get to the goal as they are with what the Westminster Catechism posits at the goal. But what the Catechism presupposes in beginning this way is that there is some supreme purpose for human beings, some ultimate goal or telos that fulfills human nature, that there is some absolute value that gives meaning to the whole of life, that there is some supreme good that is intrinsically worthy and totally satisfying, some highest good, some supreme good, some greatest good that we ought to seek. So the Catechism begins the way it does because it understands that we are purposeful beings, we are teleological animals, if we can put it that way. As moral agents we choose our end, this end doesn't happen automatically, we as moral agents created in the image of God must choose this end, the Catechism wants to know what we should aim at in life as a whole, and then the specific questions are subordinate to that. It wants to know what we should aim at for life, aim for in life as a whole because that will determine our notions of what kind of persons we ought to be and what kind of standards we ought to practice. It's the goal that determines the persons and standards, and it's the goal that sustains our commitment when the going gets tough. Now in the history of Western philosophy, this is the question of the summonum as it came to be called. The highest good or the greatest good or the supreme good, it represents what the Greek simply called the best, what is the best thing to aim at in life, meaning that which satisfies and fulfills human nature, and although we associate this question of the highest good, the summonum with the Western philosophical tradition, actually the question is older than the Greeks, as you would expect. This is a human question. What is the goal of life? What is intrinsically worthy of human pursuit? What is it that will fulfill a human being and totally satisfy? There is this piece that I found from the Acadians, they discovered a number of Acadian documents. This fortunately is in English translation, but it was written in Acadian around 1800 BC. This is from the ancient Near East and anthology of texts and pictures edited by James Pritchard and there is a big book of this, but this is the handy paperback edition. It is really worth having to show parallels with biblical material. But this is in this book it is called pessimistic dialogue between master and servant. I have also heard it called the obliging servant, I kind of like that title better, but listen to what it says, servant, obey me, yes my lord, yes, bring it once the chariot, hitch it up, I will ride to the palace, ride my lord, ride all your wishes will be realized for you, the king will be gracious to you, no servant, I shall not ride to the palace, do not ride, my lord do not ride, he will send you to a far place, you will be captured and night and day you will see trouble, servant obey me, yes my lord, bring it once water for my hands and give it to me, I wish to dine, dine my lord, dine, to dine regularly is the gladdening of the heart, no servant I shall not dine, do not dine, my lord do not dine, to be hungry and eat, to be thirsty and drink comes upon every man, that is much too common for any significance servant obey me, yes my lord, yes a woman will I love, yes love my lord, love the man who loves a woman forgets pain and trouble, no servant the woman I shall not love, do not love my lord, do not love, woman is an iron dagger, a sharp one, cut some man's neck, show anism is not the new, let's go back, let's go back away is servant obey me, yes my lord, yes I shall give food to our country, give it my lord, give it the man who gives food to his country, his barley remains his own but his receipts from interest becomes immense, no servant food to my country I shall not give, do not give my lord, do not give, giving is like loving, they will curse you, they will eat your barley and destroy you, servant obey me, yes my lord, yes I will do something helpful for my country, do it my lord, do it, the man who does something helpful for his country, his helpful deed is placed in the bowl of Marduk, now servant I will not do something helpful for my country, do it not my lord, do it not climb the mounds of ancient ruins and walk about look at the skulls of late and early men who among them is an evil doer, who a public benefactor, servant obey me, yes my lord, yes now what is good to break my neck your neck and throw both into the river that is good what you notice the servant doesn't say do it my lord, do it he begins to be a little philosophical who is tall enough to ascend to heaven who is broad enough to embrace the earth we really don't know enough about things to take that drastic action no servant I shall kill you and send you ahead of me with my lord wish to live even three days without me written according to the original and collated now that I said is 1800 BC that is just the time that God speaks to Abraham fear not Abraham I am your shield and your exceeding great reward in the dialogue they they explore the whole of life and they cannot find meaning in anything there's an upside there's a downside nothing finally satisfies in this life not food not love not even benevolence comes to nothing in the ends so why not suicide that's the only serious philosophical question Kamu said well the Indians knew that you know approaching everything without a transcendent orientation doesn't provide much hope that's the human condition we're going to die God says to Abraham this it comes at the same time as that dialogue fear not Abraham I am your shield and your exceeding great reward and God makes promises to Abraham and Abraham believes them Abraham look for the city with foundations whose builder and maker is God God promised to be Abraham's reward and Abraham believed in the Lord and was reckoned to him for righteousness that's Genesis 15 where the Lord comes to Abraham and says that and that's the great annunciation of the gospel Paul says in Galatians that those words to Abraham were the gospel they promised eternal life in Abraham knew that they promised eternal life through the seed which was to come to provide us with his righteousness in order that we might be accepted before God now Abraham the narrative goes on excuse me with Abraham and that's in Genesis chapter 15 we need to skip over to Genesis chapter 18 to pick up something that's particular relevant to our our question of ethics it's said Genesis 18 verse 17 the Lord said shall I hide from Abraham what I'm about to do it's about to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah shall I hide from Abraham what I'm about to do seeing that Abraham shall become a great and mighty nation and all the nations of the earth shall bless themselves bless themselves by him no for I have chosen him that he may charge his children and his household after him to keep the way of the Lord by doing righteousness and justice so that the Lord may bring to Abraham what he has promised him it's the two parts you get to God's sovereignty and making this covenant with Abraham which is certain to be fulfilled Abraham believed the Lord was counted to him for righteousness the Lord also elicits Abraham's responsible activity in teaching his children the way of the Lord in righteousness and justice in order that all this may may come about it's a wonderful testimony about the goal of life and subordinate to that goal or walking in in God's ways so the biblical orientation I think that we need to orient ourselves toward a that view of teleological ethics now there's a slight problem in terminology here that I'll try to sort out in recent discussions of the ethics there has been a tendency to dichotomize ethics into the teleological ethics and the ontological ethics and these are said to be the two competing types of ethics the ontological ethics is derived from the Greek word Bayon which means duty so either you have a goal oriented ethic or you have a duty oriented ethic this is the classic debate between utilitarianism which makes what is right depend on consequences for good the greatest good for the greatest number and Kantian ethics Kantian formalism which makes the acts right depending strictly on certain formal characteristics that are intrinsic to the act itself now when when some Christians hear that there's a dichotomy between teleological ethics and deontological ethics they tend automatically to opt for deontological ethics because they want to avoid any form of consequentialism or utilitarian ethics or really situation ethics that's what situation ethics was it was a form supposedly Christian form of utilitarianism and so many Christian writer evangelical writers on ethics have have have have agreed that there's a dichotomy here and it opted for deontological ethics now that's a mistake in terms of the classic view of teleological ethics in which principles of intrinsic right and wrong were incorporated into the idea of the goal you don't reach the goal just as a reward of of what you acts that you do the way to the reward or the way to the goal is a part of the process of development but I think it's possible to go back to the classic view of teleological ethics and learn a lot from that we need to get away from this polarization between goal and duty as though we have to opt for a duty oriented ethic it makes much more biblical sense to view the standards the norms that God has given they are intrinsically right but they are subordinate to goal of human life which is expressed in the catechism as to glorify God and to enjoy him forever I think we need to recover the authentic classical form of teleological ethics and not be dismissive because of this modern dichotomy that has developed it's it's superficial in terms of the the reality of what's going on the biblical teleological ethics incorporates intrinsic principles of right and wrong but it's still a goal oriented ethic and I find it very liberating when we look at that that broader perspective then we see how the commandments really fit with God's purposes and design for human nature more about that later on one reason and I'm zealous to recover the teleological tradition in ethics is because it can be traced to Saint Augustine particularly his celebrated saying from the opening chapter of the confessions you have made us for yourself and our heart is restless until it comes to rest in you Augustine agrees with the analysis of human conduct in that the desire for happiness is a human given but the highest good is not happiness itself but it is knowing and loving God it's the problem with the Greeks is not that they didn't ask the right question what will fulfill human nature and truly satisfy rather than they looked for it in all the wrong places the good life according to Augustine consists in knowing and loving God now let me say a word about the term happiness it's not very the English word happiness doesn't quite represent the Greek word that lies behind that which is eudaemonia in Aristotle's view eudaemonia was a combination of fulfillment and satisfaction that resulted from moral and intellectual excellence so it's not just pleasure eudaemonia is not the same as hedonae the other Greek word that's familiar to us as in hedonism the pursuit of pleasure Aristotle's view is much more subtle than that contemporary ethicists tend to translate happiness rather as flourishing to get away from the poverty of the English word happiness which leads to subjectivist interpretations as intended by Aristotle and as a matter of fact as intended by the phrase in the declaration of independence a creator is in Dallas with certainty an alien will write among which are life liberty and the pursuit of happiness that that sounds like an odd third companion to life and liberty but what they mean is that which will truly fulfill human nature as an objective condition rather than mere satisfaction a gustant picks up on that thing he finds fault with the Greeks for not looking to a transcendent ground for their happiness pagan philosophers are not in seeking happiness because God made us with this itch our heart is restless because of the human condition God has made us with this itch for him problem with the pagan philosophers was in trying to find happiness in themselves and in this life only and the Christian message comes in that vacuum with the the right answer we don't have to we don't have to deny that people looking for happiness are are trying to answer are asking the wrong question they in somewhere other are trying to find the goal of the human life are we've got good news there's a way to the goal we know what the goal is it's finding our satisfaction and fulfillment in God's plan for our lives and that's possible through the work of Christ now there are various ways in which the scriptures present to us the goal of human life that which will truly fulfill human nature and that totally satisfies us there's both an objective and a subjective aspect to it it fulfills human nature and what fulfills human nature is it's satisfying to us so it's fulfillment with satisfaction that the biblical idea of the goal of human life resounds the first way of putting the goal of human life in the scriptures the most prominent way one which is pervasive through the scriptures is that it is the glory of God this theme is so prominent to it you know the heavens declared the glory of God and the Ferman it shows its handiwork and so do the scriptures practically every page are dealing with the glory of God as the goal of human life God's plan Ephesians chapter one is to redeem a people for his glory or the verse that I proposed as a text for this course Philippians 1 9 through 11 consider what Paul says in that prayer I pray that your love may abound he begins with love remember the context Paul has talked about his love for the Philippians his joy when he remembers them because of their fellowship in the gospel this is a love that's produced by God's love and he goes on about that I have you in my heart you know you're always in my prayers I long for you with the affection that is in Christ Jesus and I pray that your love he's talking about our love for one another in response to the love that his God has given to us he touches the affections first that's it characteristic of Paul when it comes to ethics is to begin from the inside out I pray that your love which is in response to the the gospel your love may abound not just in any way that you might think appropriate I pray that your love may abound in knowledge and inside now that double expression is is important knowledge points us to objective standards that God has revealed the second word is is the grasp of those principles those standards those norms expressions existentially in our situation as they apply to the sometimes complex situations of life but it's it's our love the only way we will grow in knowledge and inside is if we have an affinity for the content and application of scriptures Paul wants us to have the proper disposition you can't have biblical and sound ethical inside without something happening internally that enables you to perceive those knowledge and insight in order that you may and here's a little difficult to word in order that you may discern the things that really matter or the things that are excellent King James the things that best or what is best according to the NIV it's one word in Greek it's it's only used in one other place it's used in Romans 2 where it says about those who have the specially revealed law of God understand the things that really matter because they're instructed out of the law of God so I think it's hard to capture it in a single word but I think it has to do with moral excellence that is that that sensitivity that discerning application of scripture that flows from love that will innate us to live morally excellent lives not morally mediocre lives but morally excellent lives for what purpose well that we might be filled with the fruit of righteousness the fruit of righteousness that comes through Jesus Christ this is the fruit of our justification by faith now the only righteousness we have Paul goes on to say later is the righteousness of Christ that's his longing to be clothed with the righteousness of price well that righteousness of price produces fruit a faith works itself out through love so the faith that by which we are joined to Christ and his righteousness is productive of fruit and the goal of that fruit here we go is that we may be to the praise and glory of God and you see what Paul is doing here he gives us a many course in Christian ethics begin with the disposition you work through the principles of scripture the norms that are oriented toward moral excellence the goal of that disposition and discernment that comes from knowing and applying the law of God is the fruit of righteousness the goal of which is the praise and glory of God that's the ultimate goal that we reflect something of what God is that's the goal by being conformed to his moral excellence by bearing the fruit of righteousness we image God that's the goal of the glory and praise of God there are great many other texts that can be cited in this respect one that we tend to neglect is second Peter one verses three and four and let's look at that second Peter one three and four Peter writes his divine power God's divine power has given us everything we need for life and godliness through our knowledge of him who called us by his own glory and goodness okay there's a lot to unpack in that in that verse but it's it's God's glory and goodness that places us where we are with this power for everything we need for life and godliness the all sufficiency of God's grace for our lives and to fulfill his calling verse four through these he has given us his very great and precious promises so that through them you may participate in the divine nature and escape the corruption in the world caused by evil desires that you may participate in the divine nature that you may have communion coinonia is the word that's used there in the divine nature now that's that's a pretty awesome goal that is the goal of our redemption the goal of our ethics is that we may participate in the divine nature that we may share in the divine nature the eastern church has made more of this than the the western church and I think that they have a point they call this theosis sometimes translated the divinization of human nature and that that sounds bad but it's like what Mark Twain once said of Wagner's music it's better than sounds and the so-called deification of human nature is better than it sounds it goes back to a phrase and in Athanasius Athanasius wrote a wonderful treatise on the incarnation toward the end of which he says god became human in order that we might become divine well that's it the a lot has been made of that that's the key text in the eastern church Athanasius was writing in Greek and he's respected both east and west but the eastern church makes a lot of that and of the doctrine of theosis that comes from that but it's it's a comes toward the end of that treatise and it is not developed as a doctrine really in a gust in Athanasius what is developed is our renewal in the image of god that's the main for us that Athanasius is concerned about the christ became incarnate in order to provide the sacrifice and the means by which we might be renewed in god's image and so when he says god became man that we might become divine he means that we might be restored to the image of god that we might be renewed in knowledge and holiness and righteousness that we might glorify god now for all the the talk that we so I think I think that there's a way to appropriate what the eastern church has elaborated in this in this area and and to make more of that text in second Peter there is an analysis of that text in John Sanderson's book The Fruit of the Spirit among reformed writers on the glory of god it's it's amazing in a way that there are not there isn't much written on this thing we we simply use it as a principle but don't find us often giving an exposition of it the best exposition that I know of is that of Jonathan Edwards the Jonathan Edwards dissertation was published after his death on the reason god created the world in that's what he's he's thinking through why did god create the world god who is all sufficient in himself with which nothing can be added what moved god to create the world and Edwards idea was that it was an internal disposition of god to share his effulgence with the creature so that the creature would reflect back into god his glory so that and that are renewal in the image of god reflects back something of gods on nature and this is very a very useful thought because it it incorporates our interest into gods interest according to Edwards we don't have to choose between a theosythic and an anthropocentric view god makes our fulfillment his concern in this way god has in creating human beings in his image has decided to share his infinite or to make the creature a reflection of his infinite knowledge so as rational beings who are capable of receiving his word we he is able to we are able to reflect that the knowledge of god gods knowledge of course is because it's infinite it is beyond us but still our knowledge is a reflection of god's infinite knowledge also in terms of our moral agent we are called to reflect gods are created to reflect god's infinite holiness so that our renewal in the image of god is this refulgence of the god's glory back to himself by being renewed in knowledge and holiness and what is unusual to us is that Edwards includes god's infinite happiness and we have an image of Edwards we picked it up from our high school or preamps college English and American anthologies of American literature which reproduces always Edwards sermon centers in the hands of an angry god and so we have this image of of Edwards that's derived solely from that one sermon now that sermon was a powerful warning sermon and it is a part of the Christian responsibility to warn people you know folks are going to call for the rocks and the mountains to fall on them at the day of judgment I mean it's a serious business and so Edwards warned them but there's another sermon of Edwards it comes at the end of his exposition of 1 Corinthians 13 charity and its fruits it's it's title of the the exposition as a whole the last sermon is heaven is a world of love that doesn't sound like Edwards it's not most of this but the Edwards was preached much more on that theme than he did the warning thing the warning is there it's necessary but Edwards elaborated on the gospel and he understood that God is a joyful God you know there's that verse in Zephaniah that says he will rejoice over you with singing God sings over his redeemed people and his goal is to share the divine happiness the divine joy you know what's the fruit of the spirit the fruit of the spirit is love joy it's a very wonderful thing we need to make more of it the so the glory of God is our goal and I think that this threefold pattern is is helpful now John Piper has taken a part of the catechism answer and run with this he says we should really the catechism should really read the chief end of man is to glorify God by enjoying him forever and so he develops what he calls a Christian hedonism I think it's a partial truth it's been very powerful in people's lives because it's neglected part of the truth God has made us to glorify him by enjoying him that is a part of what it means that's a significant part of of what it means to glorify God to enjoy the things of these of this creation as his gifts God has given us richly all things to enjoy you know there's you don't get a hint of Christian asceticism in those kinds of statements God it wants us to be happy joyful in him but I think it's a partial truth I think that we need the whole truth is that we glorify God also by being conformed to his knowledge and his holiness as well as his happiness you can't it's reductionistic to say we are created to glorify God by enjoying him forever without these other parts so I just just as a word of caution take what's good from Piper that's a very important thing because it's a very liberating thing lots of Christians are dragged down in a kind of the heaviness that's unbiblical and that understanding that God has created us for for happiness to really to share in his happiness to reflect his happiness is an important thing although it's not the whole thing some years ago we had Mitch Glazer of Jews for Jesus here on campus speaking to us on reformed missions to the Jews and it was the Scottish Church that had the first mission directly for evangelism of the Jews now the Southern Baptists have got in on the act and and we've a bit more or less to keep it under wraps but he was explaining to us our history well at one point he invited some of us to go down with him to wash you which as you know has a heavy Jewish concentration of students to hand out broad sides well I hadn't handed out tracks since I was in high school I never liked it and but I decided to go down so you know we've been out of Yusha with T-shirts and we went down and handed out those well it led to some interesting exchanges and but in our you know debriefing at the end Mitch told us about one exchange that he had and I thought he's very he's very good at grasping the moment he was used to the New York reaction to broad sides which had rippled up for the problem of throwing your face in it but you know Midwesterners are polite and we take they would take them look at them and then hand them back rather than throw them away or destroy them and he thought that he really preferred the other reaction I mean that's the type of person he is but once he had it back and said I don't need this I'm a hedonist and Mitch immediately said I got good news for you I've been looking for a hedonist because my god says at my right hand there are pleasures forever more you know turn that question on is it what what is true happiness what is true joy I think that there's a point to that that's what a gustan was after to try to reorient ourselves so that we understand that in terms of reflecting god's happiness I'm going to stop now and take questions that you may have anybody got the question yes sir Michael could the word theosis be interpreted as definitive or progressive sanctification as I understand yeah as I understand as I understand uh Athanasius the context in Athanasius he is talking about progressive sanctification of which theosis is the goal in other words we progress toward that from one degree of glory to another so he's talking about our renewal in the image of Christ which comes to its fruition in the life to come so yes that's a good observation I think that it's um it has to do with union with Christ and uh and the working out of the implications of that union with us with him in our lives so that's exactly what it gets thank you the question is this dichotomy between deontological ethics and teleological ethics am I saying it's really both and that is what I'm saying teleological ethics when the dichotomy is set up is really talking about consequentialism that is what is right is determined about consequences for good so the right thing to do is what will lead to the best consequences well all sorts of things follow from that to that to view if good consequences can come from fetal experimentation then you can you can conduct any kind of fetal experimentation because the greatest good for the greatest numbers to sacrifice some embryos in order that people may live longer or live better or whatever and that's that's the new designation of teleological ethics which which we would raise a question with that of whether there is some intrinsic limits to what we may do in order to produce good consequences and it's not permissible to as a matter of justice to sacrifice a human life for the sake of others that that's what I regard fetal experimentation is doing it's sacrificing human lives for others I'm going back to an old there is however this older and more classical understanding of teleology which incorporates absolute principles of right and wrong within it so we so I'm saying we cut ourselves off from an important strand of biblical truth really a crucial strand of biblical truth in forsaking in making and buying into that dichotomy and saying Christian ethics is not teleological it is deontological it's both explained on Christians assumptions in the right way we need both of those aspects and I would say we need to subordinate the principles of right and wrong to the goal in other words god has given us his his law in order that to provide the direction by which we are renewed in the image of Christ for his glory so the the the law serves the goal I think is very helpful to understand that otherwise we get focused in on duty without duty as an end in itself and you can live that way but it's not not the most freeing way to live okay yes sir we will cover that in class next time and before we before we go any further let me let me make some assignments if you should finish reading chapter two I won't spend a lot of time on what I've written in the book but so you should be familiar with them I'll say enough to to orient the class and and the folks on the tape and then we can take some questions on it but then we need to move on to the third chapter which I call the motive of the Christian life in in that time it's in connection with that the motive of the Christian life there are five parts to that first two parts I call the human heart and then Christian freedom and connection with those two parts you should read Sanderson it's pages 13 to 44 so you get an idea you know it's about 30 pages it's the if you want to write it down this way it's the first four chapters but remember there's short chapters that goes with the human heart and Christian freedom I think we'll do that next time so you should get into that and then the other three things that are under motive of the Christian life love of God love of neighbor self love that's Sanderson pages 154 to 77 which is chapters 15 to 17 154 to 77 org chapters 15 to 17 so in connection with my chapter three you'll be reading Sanderson one to four and 15 to 17 okay okay and then then we'll come back to Sanderson under my chapter five and under chapter six when we get to my outline in chapter six we'll take up the abolition of man so that's that's coming and then I have a handout I have a handout for you before we take up my chapter seven which is the resolution of moral dilemmas okay any other questions okay we we know know where we are okay thank you I'll see you next time