<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Ҳадя қилиш Ҳар ойлик бериш

Early Church; Europe; Asia

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Do again today as our Father, and praise you as the Lord of all the earth, the Creator and King, and the One who has come close to us in the Lord Jesus. Thank you that He has indeed come and lived among us, and knows what it means to laugh, to cry, to suffer, to become hungry, to become tired, to enjoy friendship, to live in this world, to be misunderstood, to face the challenges of everyday life. And thank you that, through his death and resurrection, you, O Lord, have defeated the evil one, and have thrown our sins into the ocean, never to touch us again. Thank you that those of us who know that redemption in the Lord Jesus are free to serve you and want before you, free to be loved by you, free to rest in your full embrace. And O God, there are many in this world who do not know of that good news, of that wonder of your love and mercy, and help us, who do know you, who do know you in the Lord Jesus, to be faithful witnesses to your goodness. Help us as your people to be salt in light as your people, help us as your people to be able to give, by the way we live and speak, proper prophetic witness to your standards of justice and peace and goodness in the world. As we meet here this morning, today in this class, we pray for your guidance and for your presence, help us to make the most of our time together. We ask it in Jesus' name. Our next several topics, our next four topics, beginning with topic number 12, are aimed in particular towards the objective, the first day of the objective of the class, which is to become more aware of the world. We're going to do so through looking at historical matters, to think historically, to learn from history, to learn through history, to put ourselves properly within history, is also another class objective, of course objective. But in particular, we're going to be focusing on just becoming more aware of what has happened particularly with respect to the Christian church in the world. The topic 12 is the early centuries of the Christian church. First just to think about world history and our notions of world mission. You will know, I trust, that not all peoples have always had the same pictures, literally, of what the world is. This picture that I often show you in this course shows you a more contemporary understanding of the geography of modern nation states, particularly with the boundaries drawn there, across planet Earth. There are other ways of looking at contemporary maps, as you'll know, and different places in the world, obviously, can come at the center of the map. You can turn it quote upside down, which Australians, in particular, like to do, etc. But when you look at other maps drawn at different periods of history, and by different people, you get obviously different pictures. This was one of the best maps that the ancient Greco-Roman world had. Grebo was a great thinker of his day, and this was in 18 AD during the New Testament period. If you look at that map, you can see that there's a great amount of detail, especially around the Mediterranean. Even Britain is included in the Northwest, the world, what we call the Red Sea, the person golf. And to India, there's not the actual complexity that we see today of how the different mountain ranges go. They're all lumped into one straight line, out into the void, if you will, and north of those mountains were certain peoples in south of those mountains where other sorts of people. This was the best image that Greco-Roman peoples would have had, and when you think about, for example, Jesus disciples, when they thought of the world and going into all the world, and what it meant to go to the ends of the earth, you can see where for them, where the ends of the earth were. And certainly when Paul had aspirations to go to Spain, that was for sure to that end of the earth as he understood it. Now we'll come back to this later, but when you think about your own ancestors, and where they fit on this, they might have been within the ends of the earth, or they may not have been in there of view of the world. And so I don't know what that does to you, but you can ponder that one, and we'll come back to that as well. You think about the way we view the world today? We have the advantage, if you will, of pictures of the globe taken from satellites, from spacecraft, and we have much broader images to geographically and cosmologically of what the universe looks like and what the planet Earth looks like. And yet, when we think about our understandings of world history, you can quickly realize that we're rather limited, and our instincts, if nothing else. For example, when you're listening to talks, or when you give talks yourself, when you read oftentimes, and you hear people mention the ancient world, the ancients, oftentimes they're talking about Greco-Roman people, that's the ancient world. Classical literature, that's rather confined, and how we use that. When we talk about classical schools in our day, what does it that we mean, and why is it that we're so eager to get back to the classics? Now, I realize that some of these are heated public political topics in our day, and there's a great deal of confusion as to the motives and the political correctness of matters and those sorts of things. But I would also encourage us, despite some of those landmines along the way, to in allowing God to be the God of all the Earth that he made, and desires to redeem, and in recognizing the worldwide presence of the Christian Church, we need to very much so be able to think in worldwide terms, including historically, and the current crisis, involving such places as Afghanistan and others, shows many of us who are not familiar with that part of the world, and not at all familiar with the history of that part of the world, how limited we indeed can be in our instincts and understandings. The main goal of this particular topic, and looking at the early centuries, is to realize that in the early years, decades, and centuries of the Christian Church, the growth was not simply to the northwest of Jerusalem, Judea, and Samaria, but it was in all directions. Our next three topics are Europe, Asia, and Africa. The Church spread in all of those directions. Now, again, that can run counter to some of our instinctive notions of what Church history is because, for many of us, by tradition of what we inherited, basically, Church history starts in Jerusalem, heads around the Mediterranean, and keeps heading westward, and then mission history covers the rest. Part of what we're wanting to do, I think, to be accurate and to be fair and to be helpful for all sorts of implications, is to conflate, bring together Church history and mission history, and to know that in the early centuries, you have a multi-directional spread of the Christian Church. Now, when you look at the early chapters of Acts, that is clear enough. Acts chapter two is the event at Pentecost in Jerusalem, where the text is telling us all the surrounding areas where Jewish believers have gathered to celebrate Pentecost, Jews living in Jerusalem, I'm reading verse five and following in chapter two of Acts, from every nation under heaven, now remember, for them what that meant, go back to Stabo's map, for example, and when this sound occurred, the multitude came together, they were bewildered, they were amazed, they were hearing languages, hearing the praises of God spoken in their own languages, when the disciples were only Galileans, that was certainly the image of who the Christians were, and the list starting at verse nine, Parthians and Meads and Elimites, that's going into Asia. Now, again, these are Jews, but this is what else facilitate the multi-directional spread of the gospel, beginning here, residents of Mesopotamia, Judea, Cappadocia, Pontus, Asia, Fregea, Pamphilia, Egypt, and the disciples of Libya, around Sireen, Visitors from Rome, etc., Creens and Arabs, people from all over the place were gathered there, and they hear the gospel spoken to them miraculously as the Holy Spirit comes on the early disciples, the church nevertheless stays focused on its ministry and existence in Jerusalem, as you've had through earlier chapters in Acts, you get to chapter seven, and the stoning of Stephen in the wake of that, there's a persecution that breaks out when you enter chapter eight, and therefore the church scatters. They scattered throughout the regions of Judea and Samaria, and you can use here, of course, Acts one-eight, as an outline of what's happening here, Jerusalem, Judea, and Samaria, and then on outward, fun there. Speaking of Judea's Samaria, Philip is in Samaria, he goes and preaches to the Ethiopian unit, many people seeing that as the entrance of the Christian faith into northeastern Africa. Paul is converted to become a special apostle to all sorts of peoples, which he will. God comes to Peter in a vision to convince him that he should go to a Gentiles home. Simultaneously comes to Cornelius saying that someone is going to come, Peter comes, the gospel indeed comes to these non-Jewish people. Peter says, what am I supposed to do? The Holy Spirit fell. He is being compelled to recognize that despite his instincts that it's only for the Jews. And on into chapter 11, as Peter is reporting back that, you see that God is bringing his good news to all sorts of people. And indeed that is an essential part of the good news that it is for all sorts of people. Then when you get the chapter 11, verse 19, those who are scattered because of the persecution and connection with Stephen, they make their way to Phoenicia, Cyprus and Antioch, spreading all around, spreading the word to no one except to Jews alone. But, verse 20 says, there were some of them, men of Cyprus and Cyrene, who came to Antioch and began speaking to the Greeks also, preaching the Lord Jesus. These believers who, due to perhaps cross-cultural instincts, due to being from Cyprus and Cyrene, they come to Antioch up north and they speak not just to Jews but to Greeks also, significant step taken under the leadership of God's Spirit, bringing the good news to all people. Some people as well want to make a good deal of the way Luke puts it, that they preached the Lord Jesus speaking of Purias. We're going to get later to Christology in particular and contextualization. We'll only be able to go so far in this course, but what some people want to stress here is that in preaching Purias, remember this is in Greek, these early believers are taking the risk of entering a whole new philosophical world, religious, philosophical world, to take that notion associated with the term Purias and see Jesus identified by that term, which is an indigenous pre-Christian notion that they take on and see Jesus being described by that term. Then you have to go through all the all the rigor and the pain staking and multi-generational task of working that out as the Christian faith is brought into a whole new setting. In other words, they don't hear a stress Jesus being the Messiah. That's not an indigenous term in the same sense that Purias is, so if you catch the point, I just want to just make the point now, we'll look for more later. Yes. In a limited sort of a way, we'll touch on that in class, but we really don't have time right now. I just want to mention that insofar as that is an indigenous term of one who is powerful, who is over others. That's the term that they use. Take the English word Lord and go back to think why is it that the translators of the Bible in English chose that term, an appropriate term to express who Jesus is in relation to us, as Lord had a particular place in its society at that time. Similar process. All right, a quotation here from Andrew Walls, his page 18, which you've read, he stresses, again, within his scheme of the different phases of Christian history. He stresses the second phase being that what he calls Hellenistic Roman. Then he offers a qualifying statement, and this is what I want to stress here with you. This is not, of course, to say that within that age, Christianity was geographically confined to the area where Hellenistic Roman culture was dominant within the Roman Empire. In port at Christian communities like for instance in Central Asia and East Africa and South India, he wants to recognize that. He's going to stress Professor Walls here that what happens over the ensuing generations is that the Christian faith does gain a particular stronghold within the Roman Empire, which leads to further successive stages in northern Europe, western Europe, and in the spread in modern times to the rest of the world via Europe. But he is wanting to assure us that the Christian faith early on is going into all sorts of directions. All right, here's a map that helps us with that a bit. The spread of Christianity, you don't need to pay a great deal of attention to the colors, the darker gray, and talks about where the Christian faith had grown particularly in the first century, and then after that by 185 or by the time of Iranians were the lighter gray portions, and then a few early centuries of Christianity, and they have here some interactive points that we can consider briefly Rome is one of them. You know one of the early centuries of Christianity. There were believers, there were Jews from Rome as we just read in Acts 2, 10, the church perhaps began through that, Paul writes to the church in Rome and wants to see them become a mission-sending base for further ministry that he foresees in Spain, and a church made up of Jew and Gentile together. Of course the early center in North East Africa, in Egypt, Alexandria, the city itself founded by Alexander the Great, very influential catechetical school, and some of the early church fathers' climate and origin critical and widely influential early church fathers. Antioch, of course, just reading about the beginning of the church there in Acts chapter 11, another important center within the Roman Empire, and then the important early center of Odessa, on the other side from Antioch of the Euphrates River, which is important. You can read for yourself here about the location and background of Odessa at an airmaic named prior to being founded as a military settlement in a third century BCE. I don't know if I've mentioned to you about BCE and CE, BCE is before the common era, CE is common era, and increasingly in literature that's used, those categories are used as more academically neutral, or religiously neutral than the designations BC and AD, which are specifically Christian, just in case you're wondering about that. This Odessa did come into prominent roles in various conflicts between the Parthian Empire by CE from the 3rd century BC, on into the 3rd century AD, or as their asterism, for example, for us religiously, and Rome. Christianity reaches Odessa about the middle of the 2nd century, still an independent state, I.e. not as a part of the Roman Empire, neither Greek nor Latin was understood, the native language Syriac was used in Christian writings. That puts it into a whole different cultural, political, religious setting than Christian centers within the Roman Empire. That becomes very important for later developments. It also is important just for understanding what's happening in the 2nd century as the Christian faith is spreading into a variety of cultural political settings. The Christian faith does not simply early on grow within the Pax Romana within the Roman Empire, it's growing elsewhere as well. Again, that's just important to refine and correct in many instances what our instincts about the growth of the early Christian church might be. That whole different political cultural environment is very important. Yes, Antioch, they spoke Greek. There would have been other languages undoubtedly spoken as well, certainly some Jews would have spoken some Aramaic who had gone there, and my guests would be that similar to what you see in modern cities where you have various immigrants coming and have their own multilingual context. You would see that would reach people. Well, a Greek was a common language, the main common language. It was the Euphrates River that becomes a dividing line between Greco-Roman culture and Syriac, which is a part of more properly speaking, especially as you proceed here, Asian territory. Well, stretching Asia to its outer limit, so again, it gets fuzzy what Asian was isn't that? Yes. Yes. Pardon? I'm sorry? Were there differences between the growth in different settings, or was there something distinctive about the way that Christian church grew wherever it grew? Is it the latter question you're asking? In comparison to the way other religions grew, you mean? Yes, right. And of course, that was one of the questions that you were asking yourself in doing the readings. Probably the single main difference was that in parts of the world outside the Greco-Roman Empire, Christianity does not come to have, generally speaking, the socio-political promise that it eventually does in the Greco-Roman Empire. There are places where it does, but not in a uniform sense in the way that it does in the Greco-Roman Empire, and then the further implications for how Christianity spreads into Europe out of the Roman Empire, which become essentially growing in a way that insists on religious uniformity within territories as Christianity spreads from a position of political prominence. That would be the main difference, generally speaking, which languages did missionaries who went into Asia use? There would have been some, I don't know, I'm speculating that due to contact with Greece and by extension the Greco-Roman Empire from the times of Alexander, there's going to be some familiarity, many circles, if nothing else, as a political trade language with Greek, but that certainly was not a widespread uniform language amongst various territories. You're going to look at a multi-lingual environment. It's interesting to note that as we'll see briefly, as the Christian church spreads throughout Asia, particularly from missionaries going out of Odessa and Syria, part of the church that springs up and originates in India, comes to be known as the Syrian Church. And so one could think, and again, I don't have the expertise, and I'm not confident in my research to go back and verify this, but Syriac would have been the language life in the favor of use, those missionaries, as they went, including in India, and that would have become a liturgical language, even with an India, which would have been imported into the situation. That's an excellent question, and I'm not aware myself, I'm sure there are studies that have explored that, but I'm not aware of one, and that can make a very interesting study that some of you could explore, that some of us would deeply appreciate. Thinking then with Andrew Walls a little bit further, about, as he calls it, reconceiving the study of Christian history, deconstructing notion of Christian history. If you want to call it that, that's fair enough, I think. He notes, and this is from an article that you have not read. It's an article that I'm listing for you here from the July 2000 issue of International Volts in the Missionary Research. He notes on his page 107 there, that one danger is that we think by study of our own tradition we are doing church history. He says, we are not. We're doing our own church history. If this is the only lens through which we study Christian history, we have bypassed the story of the whole people of God in favor of what he calls clan history. Such an approach reduces the area in which we look for the works of God, whereas the promises of God are to all who trust them, and the Lord of hosts is not to be treated as a territorial bail, or as a tribal God. If you're really going to study Christian history, let's see where Christian history truly has grown in its full scope. If you're going to confine Christian history to simply coming through the Roman Empire to the West, he says, that's just clan history. That's not Christian history. It's a slice of Christian history. That would be an example, he would say, of exalting to a universal status, what is particular. And he talks about a desu. A desu indeed often does appear on maps of the early church, go back to the map we just viewed around the Mediterranean. Unfortunately, it is usually at the eastern extremity of a Christianity center on the Mediterranean. Go back to the map we just viewed. If, however, and this is kind of a switch where he wants to turn us on our ear just a little bit, if we place a desu at the western end of the map and pitch and hold the Roman Empire for a while, you can see a different story. Go back to this contemporary world map. Focus on Asia, the fourth center of Asia, to East Asia and into the Middle East. Picture and include Russia. Picture Europe as a western appendage to Asia. Then rethink how Christian history is progressed. Can that force you to reconsider the center of Christian history? When you quickly see, when you see the early centuries, that there is no particular center unless it's Jerusalem from where it begins, but it's beginning, it's going in all sorts of directions. Here's another contemporary world map which has some directives of where, how the Christian faith has grown, it may be difficult to see some of those orange arrows on the map and I'm sorry for that. Many of the arrows are focusing widely so because this is seeking to encompass 20 centuries of Christian growth on growth out of Europe in the last, during the fast, basically 500 years through the modern mystery movement. But if you look here and seeing the arrows going outward from Jerusalem, Judea and Sumeria, they're heading out from here in all sorts of directions, quite properly, into Africa, into Asia, into Asia Minor, into Europe, and that's true to the picture of what happened. They don't have, they can't include everything in this picture, but you have arrows going to India from Syria. I can't tell but they should have and would want to have arrows going into China, etc. That's the way the Christian faith grows in all sorts of directions. He talks as well with a comment, African Church history is equally distorted by attempts to make an independent of a general church history that really is a form of European history. It mustn't see African Christian history as mission history done by the Western Church. African Church history goes back 2000 years, almost. Again, the main point of this topic is to stress the reality that in the early centuries, the Christian faith grew in all sorts of directions into various cultural political settings. Topic 13, Europe, there's a single main point to this topic, it's this, and it's wide in line with the overall idea of bringing together church history and mission history. Overall point, this would be to stress that the history of Christianity moving into and then continuing in Europe, but here we're going to look at the early interests of Christianity into Europe. The main point to stress is that that's Christian mission history. Christianity wasn't there and it comes into Europe in a variety of settings as relatively small as Europe is on a world scale. Europe has its own complexities and diversity, obviously many different languages, etc. And as Christianity comes in, it doesn't occur in exactly the same way according to where you're in Europe. And so as an introductory remark, you're seeing here as the Christian faith comes into Europe, more Gentiles being grafted in using the imagery that Paul uses in Romans, for example. It's not just that it's not on Europeans who are Gentiles, all those who are outside Judaism, Jewish peoples are brought in as Gentiles. Okay. Thinking about Southern Europe, going back to this first map, we are fairly familiar, particularly from the New Testament of how the Christian faith spreads around the Mediterranean, especially northward around the Mediterranean, and especially when you get into Acts 16 and Paul and his companions going into Philippi and Lydia coming to faith at the prayer and breeding and the church beginning in Philippi. That's really what many people call the first conversions in Europe proper. You might go back to Acts chapter 2 as well for people who are in Jerusalem, if any, calls from Rome or what have you. But you're seeing that continue on as you through the missionary journeys of Paul and the Christian faith spreads from there into Southern Europe. That's fairly familiar to us. Western Europe, here's a timeline that is incomplete for our needs, but to remind us of a few particular dates, again this is stressing not everything we want to stress, but we think about the conversion of Western Europe. What sorts of events come to mind? Western Europe and distinction from Southern Europe. Famous missionary to Ireland, St. Patrick, obviously, you know the story of St. Patrick, most of you where he's not a native Irishman, he's in England, he's captured by Irish raiders, taken to Ireland, has to work attending, working and doing menial work, he's a slave, he escapes, get some further theological training, makes his way back home to England and receives a call, a specific missionary call, to go and preach the Christian faith in Ireland, which he does and becomes the St. Patrick of Ireland. Missionary expansion goes into Britain, from Ireland, missionary expansion goes into Britain as well, guided in the 500s, Pope Gregory, for example, sends Augustine, not the St. Augustine, different Augustine, into England, missionaries go from Britain into continental Europe, see that spread of the Christian faith in those sorts of ways, missionary endeavors, here's St. Augustine being sent by Pope Gregory into England in the late 500s, St. Columba, working him on the picks up in Scotland, again, that's out of Iona, and you see listed here in the wider history of understanding what's happening in Europe, the spread of Islam coming into Western Europe really in the early 8th century and what an important role that plays later on when you get into the 9th century, the Viking raids begin, and that's talking about the beginnings of the conversion of Northern Europe. Yes, for a perspective, Sake, thank you for risking showing your ignites and asking about when Muhammad lived and when Islam grows. Preparatory mark, understanding at least in general terms, the history of Islam, and what that means for world history in general, and what that means for Christian history in particular, and what that means for Western history is just fundamental, fundamentally important. It's in the early 600s when Islam begins with the different events that occur in Mecca and Medina, Muhammad receiving the revelations of the Quran, which he gives, and it's after he dies and subsequent generations assume responsibility that through different caliphates, associated with various dynasties, Islam spreads, it spreads quickly in the 7th century across North Africa, you know Mecca and Medina is there in West contemporary Saudi Arabia, and spreads somewhat into Asia, it takes a few centuries to reach India and what is around President Pakistan and Afghanistan, but and it starts to spread northward as well threatening Europe, a few other particular dates, it's in the it's in the 13th century after the Crusades or Islam really begins to seriously threaten Eastern and Central Europe, and as you know Constance and Opal Falls in the mid 15th century, I mean Istanbul, and so you see that, Islam spreads as well on further into Asia, eventually into Indonesia, which as you will have been hearing lately, Indonesia is the most popular Islamic country in the world today, so that's the general perspective. 7th century beginnings, rapid growth across North Africa in particular, and eastward into Asia as well, and that plays an important role in the fortunes of Christianity in Asia as Islam spreads, and certainly in North Africa, and North Africa is a good example of former Christian heartlands, there was strong Christian territory, but no longer is Christian territory, there's a continuous history, but Christians become very much a minority under the political rule of Islam, now there's a continuing African Christian nation further down in Northeast Africa associated with Ethiopia, another that part of the world, but generally speaking Christianity becomes a minority and at the political mercy of Islamic rulers, if you will. Yes, for example, and that's where you have, you know, the Coptic Church, traces its history back 2,000 years, but to do this day is important, but a minority in Egypt. More general point in association with that, in contrasting the spread of Christianity with Islam in North Africa and in Asia, and now in general terms in recent centuries was happened in Europe, we'll consider later one way of characterizing the general spread of Christianity, that it's been a serial spread, it'll spread into a territory and then it will recess.

Look at what's happened in Jerusalem and Judea, again North Africa, you see the recession into Christian faith out of Europe in most recent centuries, Christian faith moves in, then it recesses at some point later, that's a general characteristic of how Christianity is grown in the world, so you can find former Christian areas of the world. With Islam however, almost in every case where Islam has spread and taken hold, it remains. Spain's an exception, but it's very difficult to find any area in the world which is former Islamic territory. Now there are ways to start analyzing that, we're not going to do it right now, but that's just a general characteristic of the spread of those two religious spaces in comparison. One way to begin to analyze it is to see how the Christian faith translates into areas and takes the risk of doing that. Islam however has a much more unifying cultural rubric associated with the Arabic language because the Quran is only the Quran in Arabic, so there's an inevitable essential tie with Arabic. All right, looking at Central and Eastern Europe and the growth of Christianity there, Cyril and Methodius, two missionaries that critical in the study of the spread of the Christian faith and in missions history in particular, and they particularly Cyril translated the scriptures into the local Islamic language. I mean, went through the whole process of you having an illiterate people putting the language into written form and then translating the scriptures and what was risky at that point. Let me back out a minute. Cyril and Methodius says it's written here. We don't have time to get into all the political intricacies of how this happened, but in the old Moravian Empire, we're in the late night century here. The political ruler requests kind of to gain some further freedom of flexibility with respect to what's happening around Rome and what's happening to the East with the Byzantine Empire, how to gain some flexibility there. He goes to the Constantinople, sends a request for missionaries to come from Constantinople, and again, we're not to the great schism of 1054 yet, but there's a growing divide between the Great Christian world and the Latin Christian world. So he wants to have someone come from the Orthodox Great Christian world as missionaries to teach people to become Christian. Cyril and Methodius are sent. What they do is to, again, translate not only the scriptures and the Lord's Prayer and the Ten Commandments, but the liturgy of the mass itself into Slavic language. By the time of the night century, the Latin, you have missionaries and bishops in that part of the world now in Moravia who are German missionaries and bishops who are fully convinced by now that the only holy Christian languages are Hebrew and Greek, and most especially as far as the liturgy is concerned, Latin. And to do anything other than that is heretical. Well, Cyril and Methodius being Slavic speakers and Greek speakers themselves, they're from Thessalonica and that made them bilingual, they go, have the Soluscriptura sense, if you will, of Protestantism. So you see all of the Christian faith translated into the local language, and that is a major risk that they take, but terribly influential in the Christian faith entering the Slavic peoples. And Christianity coming into Central and Eastern Europe can point to Cyril and Methodius as being a crucial starting point. Yes. Yes. I mean, and again they had to start from scratch in terms of written language here. And you can think of contemporary missionaries studies where that same thing is done. That's what they were doing. Don't get confused. Some people do. The Cyril was, there were brother, Cyril and Methodius by the way, and Cyril was more of the linguist who took the lead in the translation of the scriptures. Some people then, when they see the Russian alphabet called the Cyrilic alphabet, they see, oh, that's the one that Cyril created. It's not the same. Not the same alphabet. Don't get confused by that. Sometimes in the literature it is confused. Small point is Dr. Bashal to say it, no electric charge. Here's a website about Slavic peoples in general, and we're not going to be able to dwell here, but when you think about the Christian faith spreading, we're in Central and in Eastern Europe now. We're talking about places like contemporary, Slovakia, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Hungary has its own story, etc. But this is just a general site about Slavic peoples, and you should just glance at that quickly, 250 million peoples from early Eastern and Central Europe and the Balkans, beyond the Urals in Asia. You can see a run down here, different groupings, linguistically Russian, Belarusian and Ukrainian. Being an Eastern branch, Western branch, Polish, Czech, Slovakia, and Sorbian, the South Slavic branch, Slovenian, Serbia, Croatian, Macedonian, and Bulgarian. And this is some background of their migrating into that part of the world centuries ago. And again, we're not going to get into that, but in talking about religion and culture, you can see your Christianity initially introduced to the Slavs by great missionaries, Cyril Mathodis and others who came after them during the night and ten centuries. That's only meant to be a taste and introduction. Hungary has its own particular history, as you're in Hungary, and some of you will know that some of us, just this past August, were in Hungary with Robin Tunifico, who were there, actually via the Roman empire stretching into presently Hungary. You see early Roman ruins and evidence of early Christianity from the second century in present day Hungary. And this is a site that points to that of some of these early Christian, maybe more properly, which is, I sense, the third century from 200 AD. And this points to some archaeological evidence. This is a picture that I actually took myself here that is evidence. This is in a town in University town in southwestern Hungary called Page. And that is an early Christian chapel, the foundations of it, again from around the third century. So when you go to a place like Hungary, you're going to a very early Christian history. Excuse me. When you talk about later Christian history in Hungary, you need to talk about the conversion of the king who came to be known as Saint Stephen, and that occurred in 1000 AD. This is the crown of the Hungarian crown that has indeed become an important symbol. While we were there, just the last month, they were preparing for the annual, one of the annual national holidays, and the crown. This actual crown where you see the cross in the top takes on particular significance. And Hungary in a unique way within Central and Eastern Europe, with the crowning of Saint Stephen by the Latin Pope, Hungary becomes aligned with Western Christianity, with Roman Catholicism. It doesn't become Orthodox. And within that's part of the dividing line in Central Europe, between what comes to be known from the 11th century in particular as Western and Eastern Christianity. Hungary also, as far as Roman Catholicism was concerned, becomes a defender on the Eastern frontier against the eventual encroachments of Islam. And so within the Roman world, the eventual Roman Christian world, Hungary takes on a particular importance. And this crowning of Stephen, you have the massive Saint Stephen's Basilica there, going back 1,000 years, you see it converting to Roman Catholicism and becoming Christian in a more modern sense on top of literally an archaeological sense of ancient Roman Christianity being there at the time of the old Roman Empire. Russia begins at a similar time, as Christianity coming to Russia through the Ukraine, 988. There's a conversion of King Vladimir. And that's seen as the beginning of the Christian faith in Russia. If you think of basically 1,000, the year 1,000, that's when Saint Stephen is crowned in Hungary. It's about the time where Russia starts to become Christian and become a part of the wider, complex world. And you can see the wider Slavonic liturgy developed by Cyril Mathodius comes into the wider Slavic world, including Russia. Here's a timeline of the Russian Orthodox Church, up to 1453. And you can see here some crucial dates associated with Constantine, the building of Constantinople, the early councils. Now here is a reference to Islam because of how important that becomes in Central and Eastern Europe and into all of Europe. And what that means for Constantinople, Constantinople, sending missionaries to the Balkans and to Russia, up into Moravia, conversion to Orthodoxy, etc. And then 1054, the great schism is so-called and envisioned into what becomes known as Western and Eastern Christianity. Getting a little bit ahead of ourselves because we're getting into Asian history here. But what we mean by Western and Eastern Christianity, you need to be careful about that. You need to realize that Western Easter relative conventional terms, like Neil, there's East St. Louis right across the river, but we're in the West, all those sorts of things. From the 5th century on, we talked about Western and Eastern Christianity, talking generally about Christianity associated with the now-overrun Roman Empire, Greco-Roman Christianity, and Syriac-slash, what comes to be known as Nestorian-slash, in the general terms, Asian Christianity. That's Eastern Christianity versus Western Christianity as it comes to be known. Then when as the Greco-Roman Christianity becomes increasingly isolated, in large part due to the rise of Islam, from Asian Christianity, I'm trying to make every word count here, so hang with me, okay? Thus contributing towards the contemporary misunderstanding and total base of your lack of acquaintance with Asian Christianity, for those of us in the wake of Western Christianity. As Western Christianity becomes more self-enclosed, the great schism, so-called, becomes what happens in 1054 between Western Christianity and Eastern Christianity. That comes to be seen as the total Christian world basically. You see how increasingly confined the understanding of Christian history becomes? And as far as what the civilized world was, that's a contemporary term for you, as far as the civilized world, that was Europe and the part of Asia that was right next to it, namely Russia. And if you move ahead, just fast forward in your mind to the 13th, 14th centuries, Islam is encircling Europe, and that's the world for Europeans. Europe becomes increasingly isolated and self-contained. And those notions from several centuries ago help inform and feed into the confinements of our understandings of history today, and of Christian history in particular. Yes, excellent question. Did churches outside of Europe, as this is developing, have a more global outlook in European churches, or were they too more confined in their outlook? I would say the latter, they too would have been more confined. I guess the reason that we're stressing here today and the reason it stressed so much is because of who we are in this room one and two, the more recent widespread European influence, Western influence in the world. But that's an excellent question and a very good point. It's not just Europeans, who are confined to understanding all sorts of people. A helpful point, thank you. All right, moving quickly to Northern Europe. You have a different type of conversion in some ways, because as far as the conversion of Northern Europe is concerned, you have the spread of Latin Christianity for people to become Christian there and we're quoting from Andrew Walls again, to become Christian meant to become part of the wider Latin Christendom. There's a whole literary culture that's been preserved by the church, based on Latin, based on the Vulgate. In the early preaching of Christianity in Europe, missionaries proclaim God over against the old gods, the one over against the many, the new Christ over against the old Thor, and there was continuation of those methods as the Christian faith spreads into Northern Europe as well. A distinction that he makes, and you've done these readings, a distinction that he makes is what has been happening in more contemporary sub-Saharan Africa, where you have the incorporation of pre-Christian names of deity, for example, as the scriptures are translated into the vernacular. And in more general terms, you have the translation of the Christian faith into the existing setting, and you have this encounter and coming to terms with the past, and the Christian faith coming to be at home there by integrating itself into, bringing change, bringing Christian distinctives to what's there, but there is some continuation of the old. If you look at what happened in Northern Europe, what's there is wiped out, destroyed, this new external Christian faith comes in. That's a general difference in what happens. What he wants to claim is that that sort of conversion where whole regions became officially Christian, when the ruler became Christian, and people were forced to be baptized, that was not decisive enough for Christianity. It was a violent force conversion in many ways, and he claims that it was oftentimes much more violent and bloody than what the Kicitors did in Latin America, what you see happening in Northern Europe. And he wants to say, simply substituting a whole new culture, a Latin culture that embodies the Christian religion for what was already there, is not going to be sufficient. There needs to be more of an integration. And again, part of the reason he is saying this is because many people in our day looking at what's happening in Europe, that the recession of Christianity and old religions coming back, some people in Africa are saying, wait a minute, that's being integrated for us, we have a long ways to go. It's just the beginning stages. But did that really ever happen for you guys in Northern Europe? Was Christianity more like kind of a veneer that was brought in forcibly, and now it's recessed, and what's already there is raising its head? Now, my own comment on that is, I think that's very thought provoking to consider that. There are books that are worth reading like was Europe ever really Christian. At the same time, I again would caution us against being simplistic in our explanations, and the Christian faith being in an area that long, for centuries, for generations, is not going to have no effect to use a double negative. There's going to be a deep penetration, and it didn't just remain in Latin with the Protestant Reformation, for example, in various areas. You have a contextualization of the Christian faith into the vernacular in many areas, etc. Yes, there again some people would say those are instances of integration and to think that you can just kind of have, and again, a pure quarantine Christianity that isn't quote, affected by the culture, isn't getting one of the basic points of the Christian faith that it translates into and becomes a part of and integrates with new settings all the time. Remember, we look at very quickly at some of the previous strategies of cross-cultural missionaries, and how, when Pope Gregory sends out Augustine to England, he says, when you have these pagan temples, don't just rip them down and build any churches, use them as churches. They're already there to be used. That's one attempt at, and it's been called different things in our day, assimilation, accommodation, contextualization, inculturation, adaptation, and those different terms of different nuances, depending on who's using them at what time, but to think again that just comes in and wipes out what's there, and you have a Tavirasa, a blank slate to begin from scratch, is not reality, and isn't Christian. That's a harsh way to put it, isn't Christian. It has been a part of what Christian history has involved, but it's not what I would suggest is inherent to the translate ability of the Christian faith. I want to move quickly to begin, at least, our section on Asia topic 14. So, again, thinking back about what's happened with the Christian faith in various parts of Europe, main organizing point, that's mission history. Again, when we talk about world mission here, we're talking about a comprehensive sense where God's mission is concerned about where the Christian faith continues as well, but I'm using mission history in the sense of Europe as we've just looked at it as the beginnings of Christianity into new settings that were a part of Europe. Asia, the main point about this topic is the corresponding point. The tendency can be, again, to think, okay, what happened in Europe? That's church history. What's happened in Asia? That's mission history. Let's flip it. What's happened in Asia is Christian history, is church history. It's also mission history, you say both, but you need to say both. And I want to stress here that it's church, Christian history, because that doesn't receive enough stress. Samuel Muffet, who is a well-known renowned church historian at Princeton, close friend and colleague of our own David Calhoun, I think Sam Muffet himself was a number of years in Korea, is working on this history of Christianity in Asia. Have some readings for you from part one. Part two is just coming out. That takes us up to 1900. Dr. Muffet says there is going to be a part three. We hope so. It took a while for part two to come out. What he says, the beginning of this volume one of his history of Christianity, Asia, is that the story of Christianity in the West has often been told that the history of Christianity in the East is not as well-known. Too often forgotten that the faith moved east across Asia, as always move Western in Europe. And he just is making the point that there has been a Christianity that for centuries has remained unashamedly Asian. These next categories in the notes that you will have note the history of progression, I'm using the outline that Muffet uses in his book. And looking at the growth of the church from the time of the Apostles up to Muhammad in the 7th century with the first 200 years he notes the various main formate empires in Asia in the wide sense, West Asia, the Greco-Roman Empire. He had the Iranian old Persian empire, the Chinese empire and the Indian empire. Those are the various larger empires these earlier centuries in Asia. Then you have the early missions to India. And he concludes in most scholars now conclude and I fully concur that there were indeed very early outreaches into inroads into India of the Christian Church. Some people want to say it's not conclusive. We really don't know the evidence we have. The evidence is there to see it as a first century entrance of Christianity into India. Yes, including spearheaded by St. Thomas. I would. I would. I am depending on the research of Dr. Muffet and many others. I have not done primary research myself, but I think the increasing conclusion in everything that I read is put out is that it's maybe not undeniable, but so very the evidence is so very overwhelming. And part of the evidence is the witness of Thomas Christians themselves in India today. Yes. And then there's the whole Syrian period. The Persian period and we'll stop with this. It's at this point when you get to the the period from the third century onward where you have the development of what comes to be known as the Persian Church and eventually comes to be known as the Nestorian Church associated with Nestorius. And there was this in the fifth century this important theological controversy that emerges. It begins with with Nestorius who is associated with Antioch and Christianity, which has some different nuances than Alexandrian theology and Christianity. Okay. Much of this is cultural. You can't reduce it to cultural matters, but it's related to cultural political matters. Nestorius with a focus on the human nature of crisis as Antioch, Christianity did, doesn't want to use the term mother of God. Fatalkos for Jesus. He says that's not proper. The Alexandrians see that as heresy. Eventually there's these councils drawn together. Nestorius has branded as a heretic and the conclusion that Mothat draws, not in your readings, maybe skirts of he explains it more fully elsewhere in his volume. He says Nestorian, perhaps due to not being as well versed in Latin and Greek as scholars against whom he was debating and not having the same need to be as precise in his philosophical linguistic categories as the Greco-Roman scholars were, he was not as clear as the other scholars were. And in terms of therefore a strict philosophical debate he was fuzzy. But undoubtedly intertwined into the whole discussion where political rivalries and political matters and today scholars are coming around to seeing that Nestorius was not as far off as he has been branded to be. And it's really from that point on where the Asian Church is branded as heretical by the Greco-Roman Church. Comes to be known as the Nestorian Church, missionary activity in the China and elsewhere is known as the Nestorian Missionaries and the two traditions part company. Leave you with that. God bless you. See you next time.