<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Hatag Hatag Matag Bulan

Reform in Italy

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Lecture 33 is entitled the Dignity of Man, the glory of God, reformed in Italy. One of the people that I'm going to be talking about in this lecture, in some detail, is the famous pre-reformer Savada Rolla of Florence. And we'll begin with a prayer from Savada Rolla, a man who suffered a great deal in his life and who was martyred. This is a prayer that he prayed, even though we don't face the same problems that Savada Rolla faced, we face problems too in our lives, so we can certainly join in this prayer. Let's pray. Lord, we pray not for tranquility, nor that our tribulations may cease. We pray for your spirit and your love that you grant us strength and grace to overcome adversity through Jesus Christ, amen. So we think about reform in Italy, having poured the clothes of the Middle Ages, we need to talk, first of all, about the word renaissance. It's a word that means rebirth, it's a movement that began in Italy in the 14th century, and then was well established in the 15th century, and then began to move northward and influence northern Europe in the 16th century, and in the 15th century, it began to look back to the previous millennium, to the previous thousand years, and they saw that period of history as a dark period, the period after the decline in fall of Rome, until their own time, about a thousand years. And they saw it as a dark period of history, separating their time from the glories of ancient Greece and Rome, and so the idea of the renaissance or the rebirth of learning that comes into play, it's the time the renaissance comes into play. It's the time, the renaissance is a time that is characterized by a renewed interest in the classics. In fact, the slogan odd phone case, Latin, it means to the source, was used to describe the interest that the people of the renaissance began to pay to the ancient Greek and Roman classics, the ancient writings of Homer, and Plato, and Aristotle, and Cicero, and also to the scriptures, classics were the all writings of the Greeks and Romans, including the writings of the scriptures. As these people began to emphasize the classics, not the more recent writings of the scholastic theologians, but the ancient writings, both Christian and non-Christian, they also emphasized the importance of reading these writings in the original languages. So the study of Hebrew and Greek, and of Latin, not modern church Latin, but ancient classical Latin, these studies become very important to the men of the renaissance. It was said by the year 1500, in Europe in many places a good Latin teacher could find students, and an average Greek teacher could find students, and even a mediocre Hebrew teacher could find students, or fewer Hebrew teachers, but there was now interest in the study of Hebrew, as well as in the study of Greek, and of course the study of Latin, in order to be able to read the classics, both the pagan classics and the scripture, in the original languages. Actually, it's from this interest in language that we get the word, the humanities, and the word humanism. The humanities refers to the study of languages, in fact in Great Britain even today, the word humanity, means Latin, study of Latin. It's almost as though that is to say if you are truly really going to be human, you need to know Latin. And the humanities become more generally known as what we now call the liberal arts. So the renaissance devoted to the study of the classics, and that led to a new study of the text of the classics, not only is there interest in the languages, the original languages in which these great books are written. But there is interest in the text itself, how accurate is it, and how much can we understand about the writing through the study of the text, and so textual criticism for the first time in history in the West becomes an important concept. And the great name there is Lorenzo Vala, who lived in the 15th century. Lorenzo Vala subjected a number of the famous writings to the scrutiny of textual criticism, and it came up with some startling ideas for people. At that time, for instance, he said that the Apostles Creed was not written by the Apostles, and he was right that people had believed that the Apostles Creed was actually written by the Apostles for a long time. It is also Lorenzo Vala, who established that Dionysius, the Ariopagite, who wrote various things that we studied earlier, could not have been a first century Greek Apostle or follower of the Apostle Paul, as was claimed by whoever wrote the writings of Dionysius. Lorenzo Vala subjected that writing to some historical textual study, and established the fact that Dionysius, whoever he was, was not Paul's convert at Athens, but a much later writer, who probably came from Syria. And so, after this, Dionysius becomes pseudo Dionysius, the false Dionysius. You remember, too, the donation of Constantine, it was an alleged document which stated that the Pope was making a gift of Rome, a territory around Rome, and all temporal power. It was actually the emperor who was making that as a gift to the Pope, and ever since then, Rome had insisted on the validity and the importance of the donation of Constantine to establish the fact that Rome had claimed to the territory of Rome and the so-called papal states. But as Lorenzo Vala studied that document, he decided, quite rightly, that it could not have been a document from the fourth century written by a Roman emperor. He put it this way, what have say traps got to do with the case? Do Caesar's speak thus? Are Roman decrees drafted thus? Who ever heard of say traps being mentioned in the councils of the Romans? See, the word say trap was used there in the donation of Constantine, and Lorenzo Vala noticed that, so wonder others had not noticed it before, but what he said was, Romans don't write like this, Romans don't speak like this, this has to come from another source and from a later date. And perhaps the most significant thing that Lorenzo Vala did was to subject the Volgett Latin translation of the Bible to some very careful attention and point out that at many places the Volgett had mistranslated. The Hebrew and the Greek which caused great concern, of course, in the Catholic Church both then and later. So we're talking about the Renaissance, the importance of the classics, the study of languages, the ability to subject the text to historical and textual criticism. There was another emphasis of the Renaissance, and that was a stress on rhetoric, the importance of rhetoric or speech, eloquent speech. We have interchistory, read some very eloquent speeches and books, for instance St. Augustine was a very eloquent writer, but after Augustine theology tends to be much more dry, particularly the theology of the scholastics. And the men of the Renaissance began to want to recover something of the strength of language, the power of language, the beauty of language. Words, according to the Renaissance figure Petrarch, words can sting and set a fire and urge toward love of virtue and hatred of vice. The words of the sentences of Peter Lombard don't really do that, not beautiful language and powerful language, but the emphasis on rhetoric comes through in the Renaissance and will influence theology in times to come, particularly as we come say to the Institute of John Calvin. Calvin will see rhetoric, again, playing a very major and wonderful role in theology. The classics, the importance of the classics, the importance of rhetoric, and new art and architecture come out of the Renaissance. We just illustrate that last point in three ways. First of all, talking about the Paxi Chapel, built in Florence by Brunellesco in the year 1430, here is a picture of it. As you look at this chapel, particularly if you have already been familiar with the great Gothic architecture in the cathedrals in France and England and elsewhere, there's something quite different about this. The style here has been called the architecture of the Renaissance or the architecture of humanism that I'll explain a little more about the word humanism in a moment, although I've used it already to say it's a study of the liberal arts. But what is impressive about this chapel is that it's not very impressive. At least not compared to some of the great churches like Chartera or the cathedrals of England. It doesn't try to impress us or crush us by its size or weight as all God-directed architecture does. It's much more limited and has a kind of human scale. If you walked into this chapel in Florence, you would not be overwhelmed by it. You might be impressed by its symmetry and by its orderliness and by its neatness, but you would not have the same feeling walking into this chapel as you would walk into one of the great Gothic cathedrals.

About the same time that the Potsy Chapel was built, another building in Florence, the Library of San Marco was built by Casimo de Medici, and here's a picture of the interior of that library, a kind of eloquent and elegant, cool, harmonious place, not really a place of mystery, not a dark place of mystery as in some of the churches, but a place of knowledge, not really pointing to how much we don't know, but those books with the light and the harmony and the proportions of this library pointing to how much we do know and how much indeed we can know. Then the third illustration, and there could be hundreds of these, but to move on quickly, the third illustration is the David, also in Florence. The great sculpture of the famous Michelangelo. Michelangelo, according to one of the encyclopedias, was a man whose giant talent dominated the High Renaissance, and of course, you know, something about him in the many works that he did in addition to this one. And his giant David, you've seen that statue in the Octadavia in Florence, and it is a giant 14 feet high with outsized head and hands, dominates that building. And you think that this is Michelangelo's statue of David, the shepherd boy, you wonder what the giant would have looked like. And some people, particularly Francis Schaefer, have seen in the David, a kind of statement of man's belief in himself, the way Schaefer put it was. The David was the statement of what the humanistic man saw himself as being tomorrow. In this statue, we have a man waiting with confidence in his own strength for the future. So I'd like to use that to lead into the second word here. We've been talking about the Renaissance, the New Birth, and how we put special emphasis on the classics, on rhetoric, new expressions of art and architecture. But we could also speak of this period of history and of this development as humanism. Now, I think it's important for us today to define that clearly because we tend to think of humanism as secular and atheistic humanism. Humanism in the 14th century and the 15th century was not necessarily anti-god or anti-Christian, although it couldn't seem to times to be anti-institutional church, but there were other movements that were posed to the institutional church as well. As we think of humanism, we were to think of the Renaissance and the people of the Renaissance who were coming up with some new infacies without necessarily rejecting the old infacies. But there were two new infacies that could eventually and did eventually undermine the old infacies. One is a kind of this worldliness and the other is an emphasis on the greatness and essential goodness of human nature. It's impossible, I think, to look at this statue of the David, whatever Michelangelo was attempting to do there without being impressed with the grandeur and the dignity and the potential of human beings. The 15th century humanism doesn't reject or attack Christianity directly or intentionally, of course Michelangelo was producing biblical themes not only here, but in the Sistine Chapel and elsewhere, although he tended to mix those with mythological and classical figures. But these two new infacies do come through a kind of this worldliness, a kind of focus on the here and now against the other worldliness of much of medieval life and thought. You know, if you look at other medieval art, particularly earlier expressions of medieval art, you'll find often the dance of death, for instance, one of the themes of medieval art, the picture of death coming and taking people all stages of life and at the most in opportune moments, or else death is very much in the mind of medieval men and women, but this is not the dance of death now, this is a kind of celebration of life, new beginning, the rebirth, potential for life in this world. And that tends to move the emphasis of the interest away to some extent from preparation for life in the next world. And certainly one of the themes of humanism and the renaissance is the goodness and greatness of human beings. In a way it's the kind of plagianism, although the people of the renaissance don't really have interest in putting it in theological terms. They just know that human beings have great significance and importance. Let me illustrate that in three ways through three different figures. First is Petrarch, a man who lived in the 14th century, he was called by Kenneth Clark, the first modern man, and Petrarch who lived during the time of the Avignon papacy was very concerned with the way the church was going, with scholasticism, know what that is now, and the scholastic theology. But also, and more importantly, I think with the worldliness of the Avignon papacy and the worldliness of the church, in general. Notice the quotations there, the third one says, I'm now living in France in the Babylon of the West, the poor fishermen of Galilee have strangely forgotten their origin. I am astounded as I recall their predecessors. To see these men loaded with gold and clad in purple, boasting of the spoils of princes and nations, to see luxurious palaces and heights crowned with fortifications. It doesn't look like the beginnings of Christianity, Petrarch says. It doesn't look like the disciples, the followers of Christ in Galilee, to see the wealth and the worldliness of the church as it centers in Avignon in France. So Petrarch is critical scholasticism and of the worldliness of the church, but as we move to the next figure, we get a much more humanistic emphasis. As we come to Leon Vittista Alverdi, he's famous for a number of statements. This is a 15th century figure, but he's often quoted as having said a man can do all things if he will. It doesn't sound like a gust in or even the medieval theologians. It's a kind of new note here, human potential and possibility. Kenneth Clark says that statement of man can do all things if he will could be the motto of the early Renaissance. We have a portrait of Alverdi. Here it is. In fact, it's really one of the first portraits that we have. The modern portrait came into existence during the Renaissance. Before the Renaissance, it really didn't matter what people looked like. They could all look the same. You know, the pictures that I showed you of the church fathers and others, kind of looked the same because it wasn't all that important to distinguish, just to paint a person. But now, there is concern that the individual be depicted truly to express his or her uniqueness, importance and psychological complexity, and so with Alverdi and others whose portraits are depicted during this time. We have the modern man, the modern portrait depicting modern man. Alverdi addressed his fellow men in words like these to you as given a body more graceful than other animals. To you power of apt and various movements, to you most sharp and delicate senses, to you wit, reason, memory like an immortal god. Kenneth Clark comments, well, it is certainly incorrect to say that we're more graceful than other animals. And we don't feel much like immortal gods at the moment, but in 1400, the Florentines did. Well, at least some of the Florentines did, because this was the Renaissance, this was the springtime, this was the rebirth, and the darkness of the past was going to pass away, and you light would come. And then, I'll just give one other illustration of this, attitude from Giovanni Pico della Mirendola, man with a long name, his book was Oration on the Dignity of Man. Mirendola, Pico della Mirendola, was a young man, very brilliant, handsome, wealthy, energetic, and everything going for him, and he seemed to know everything, seemed to learn everything. And he came up with the plan and the idea to try to combine Christianity and the ancient classics and even Islam in some kind of new synthesis of truth. When he was 24 years old, he went to Rome and published 900 Theses for debate, not 95 like Luther, but 900 Theses for debate created something of a sensation, and the debate never came off, because the Pope said that young man is looking for someone to burn him. And Pico decided it would be better not to stay in Rome much longer. Well, that perhaps gives you a sense of what's going on in one place, in Florence and some of the other cities of northern Italy, but something else is going on in Florence too. And as we think of reform, it's not only the Renaissance, but we have to think of a very different type of reform that comes from the life and teaching of a Dominican monk whose name is Savanarola, is the fourth of our pre-reformers. Waldo, Wycliffe, Hus, Savanarola, all seated at the base of the Luther statue in Barnes as important pre-16th century reform leaders. Savanarola was born in the year 1452, who was born not in Florence, but in the Italian city of Ferrara, and there's a very lovely account of his childhood, particularly of his grandfather. His grandfather was a famous doctor, a physician in Ferrara. And for some reason, the grandfather had a particular contact with the little boy and responsibility for him and really brought him up. And taught him along the way, and what he taught him was very much the truth of the Bible. This famous doctor had a small notebook in which he wrote down different ideas that he came up with and he gave that notebook to his grandson. And in that little notebook, there were statements like these. Neither the Pope nor their vickers have a right to teach anything contrary to the things instituted by God, and all that we need to know is found in the word of God. So Savanarola grows up hearing that kind of teaching. He had a disappointing love affair as a young man and did what many young men of that time did after disappointing love affairs he became a monk, Dominican monk at the age of 23. Eventually he was brought to Florence by Lorenzo the Magnificent, who was the virtual ruler of the city of Florence, the wealthy family of the Medici, controlled the city of Florence, came to Florence in 1482 and he became prior of the famous monastery of San Marco in 1491. There's a story in the syllabus concerning a relationship between Lorenzo, this magnificent ruler, the city of Florence, and Savanarola, the Dominican monk. Savanarola worked away in his cell in the monastery of San Marco. There's a drawing depicting him working there in his cell writing a book. Actually, it looks like he's using a computer, but I don't think that can be the case. Writing a book, in fact he's writing a book called Christian Simplicity, as he sits in his cell in Florence. Dominican monk, who became a great preacher first as Savanarola was not a very good preacher, but he became a great preacher. Florence didn't like him at first because they felt he had a very bad accent. It was not from Florence, it was from Ferrara, which they considered an inferior city. So he preached long sermons for about two hours, shouted those sermons in a very ungrateful accent. His friends urged him to go in here, another preacher in town, who was a very famous speaker, a very eloquent speaker. That was the Augustinian from Mariano, who was filling Santo Spirito, a church across the Arno. Some years ago, I lived in Florence for a year, and studied Italian at Euro-Cintro, was on the same piança with Santo Spirito. So during break and language class, I would go over to Santo Spirito and look around at that church. That was where from Mariano was preaching. Savanarola, when his friend said, you ought to go here, Mariano, he is a great preacher, Savanarola replied that he had already heard Mariano. He said this, he preaches from Cicero and the poets, not from Holy Scripture. Here was a Renaissance figure, he was emphasizing the classics but not the Scripture. And Savanarola said, you reproach me for my lack of style, what has style to do with it? Have something to say and say it as clearly as you can, that is the secret of preaching. Most important part of preaching, not sure style is totally unimportant, but having something clear to say and saying it clearly is certainly important. The thing that is interesting though is that Savanarola became a great preacher, so we can be encouraged. And his Linton sermons in the Dromo, in the Cathedral in Florence moved the whole city. Not only did he have something to say, because he was really preaching the gospel, not Cicero and the poets. But eventually he developed a style that was moving and powerful. One of the people that heard Savanarola preach in the Dromo was Michelangelo, the artist. And Michelangelo said, all that voice, that voice, it can never be forgotten. It's interesting to read too that when Michelangelo was doing the painting and assisting chapel on the ceiling, the painting of the last judgment, which has recently been clean and now rededicated by the Pope in just the last few days. But Michelangelo worked for five years on that painting. He had with him only one book, and that was a book of Savanarola's sermons. Somebody has said that the last judgment in the Sistine Chapel is essentially a Savanarolean sermon in Coen. We have in the syllabus one example of Savanarola's preaching in the sermon on the Ascension of Christ. Not only did he become a great preacher, but he also became an important reformer in the city of Florence. Florence became what we could call a Christian city, with a Christian constitution in 1494. Actually, the battle there was between Lorenzo and Savanarola, each trying to pull the city in a different direction. Savanarola preached Florence as a spiritual wilderness, and it will be punished for worldliness and for the injustices inflicted on the poor. It was a kind of sermon that he was preaching week by week in Florence. The Lorenzo said, I do not like to hear of anyone talking politics in the pulpit or anywhere else, he said. Because Lorenzo had his own ideas to what he wanted to make the city of Florence into, and it wasn't the vision and dream of Savanarola. But I won't go into the long complicated history of the power struggle between these two and others. But the outcoming of it all was that Savanarola eventually became the leader of the city, not only the chief preacher of the city, but the leader, the political leader of the city. I think that was probably a mistake. It was not a mistake that the reformers were to make later. Luther never became a political figure, nor did Calvin, although people think Calvin was the kind of autocrat of Geneva, but that was not the case at all. Nor did John Knox. They remain in their calling as preachers and spiritual leaders, not as political leaders. But Savanarola won the people, and they made him the leader of the city. He said, Florence, Jesus Christ who is the king of the universe, stands before the door and he knocks. He wants to come in. He wills to become your king in this very hour. Will you have him as your king? The people shouted, yes, we will. And they tried to create a kind of theocracy, Christ city, God city on earth with Savanarola as the leader of that city. One of the things that happened in Florence was what is called a burning of the vanities. People brought all sorts of things out into the piazza of the city, the main piazza of the city, and there was a great bonfire. And they threw into the bonfire cards and dice and jewelry, cosmetics, and lured books and pictures. Some of the paintings of Batacelli, for instance, were thrown into the fire by Batacelli, who had been very much moved by what was going on in Florence. As was Pico de la Merendola and some of the other humanists that we talked about already. Of course, the burning of the vanities has not made Savanarola popular with art students and artists through history. But he was concerned that worldliness had captured the city and he felt that something had to be done in order to bring Florence back to a place of godly living. Well, that kind of vision, that kind of concern was going to produce many enemies. And Savanarola made many enemies, the Pope, the aristocrats, the Medici, and finally through a series of miscalculations and misfortunes, the people lost confidence in him. So he was arrested and burned, hanged, and burned with several fellow Dominican monks on May 23rd, 1498, in the Piazza della Signeria in Florence. If you can risk crossing that Piazza on foot, you'll find just about at that place in the center of the Piazza, a bronze marker on the pavement which indicates the place where Savanarola and the other monks were martyred. Machiavelli was also a Florentine. He was 29 years old when Savanarola died. He would later write a very famous book called The Prince, and his comment was unarmed prophets are bound to fail. So Savanarola cannot expect to succeed because he did not have an army. When Savanarola died in the flames in Florence, 1498, was another young man, even younger, only 15 years old, not a Florentine, but a teenager growing up in a little town in Germany, Martin Luther. It shows how close we are to the Reformation now because Luther was already 15 years old when Savanarola died. And Luther said about the Florentine martyr, whereas Antichrist, that was Luther's word for the Pope, has damned Savanarola. God has canonized him in our hearts, seeing that we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us run with perseverance, the race that is marked out for us.