<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Hatag Hatag Matag Bulan

The Resurrection of Christ and the History of Redemption

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

When we ended last, which was almost two weeks ago, so my memory is probably as hazy as yours. I asked you guys if you wouldn't mind taking a look at Luke chapter 16, sometime over spring break. Last time we were talking about the intention of Jesus and we came up with four kind of major elements to the intention of Jesus. One, he intended to be called the Messiah and considered the Messiah. Secondly, he intended to teach and also to perform his ministry, including miracles, but he intended to teach people. He intended as well to be crucified and he intended as well to be resurrected. All of those things were very much in the intention of Jesus. When we talked about teaching, I highlighted one specific aspect of Jesus' teaching and that was in the parables of Jesus. We looked at Luke 15 together and some of the parables there. If there's one major, I guess there's two big things I want you to remember about parables. The first thing is that they generally make one, maybe two, or three points, but that's it. Generally, if you've got a main character, that signals the point that's being made. If there's two main characters, then you might have two points made, three main characters, three points that are being made. Generally, the details in a parable, although they contribute to the meaning of the parable, should not be taken apart as if you're supposed to apply each of the details as well. There's major points that are made by the parables. If you stay with the main thing in the parable, you're doing a lot better than if you get lost in the details. The second point that I think I made was that parables should be interpreted in the gospels in their context. I noted, for instance, in Luke 15, where you have the lost sheep, the lost coin, and the prodigal son, that especially with the prodigal son, it's important to remember that at the beginning of the chapter, there's a bunch of Pharisees running around. The Pharisees are disappointed with Jesus because he is sitting, eating, having a ministry among, tax gatherers and sinners. Thus, the elder brother in the prodigal son, parable, refers probably to the Pharisees and to those who like the Pharisees would be inclined to say, I wonder why they're in the kingdom. That comes from understanding the parable in this context. What I wanted to do was to further that in our humbly time at the beginning of our first class after spring break, before I ask you guys to actually think, to ease us in by doing a brief humbly on Luke chapter 16, and to sustain those points again, that there's effectively one point or so that's being made by any major parable, and that you need to read them in context.

Let's read, first of all, the parable of the unrighteous steward, which it's the beginning of Luke chapter 16. I'm starting in 16, verse 1. Jesus was also saying to the disciples, there was a certain rich man who had a steward, and his steward was reported to him as squandering his possessions, and he called him and he said to him, what is this I hear about you? Give an account of your steward chip for you can no longer be steward, and the steward said to himself, what shall I do? Since my master is taking the steward chip away from me, I am not strong enough to dig, I'm ashamed to beg. I know what I shall do, so that when I am removed from the steward chip, they will receive me into their homes, and he summoned each one of his master's debtors, and he began saying to the first, how much do you owe my master? And that person replied, a hundred measures of oil, and the steward said to him, take your bill and sit down quickly and write 50. Cut it in half. Then he said to another, in how much do you owe, and that person responded, a hundred measures of wheat, and the steward responded to him, take your bill and write 80. This is now 80%. And his master praised the unrighteous steward because he had acted trudely, for the sons of this age are more shrewd in relation to their own kind than the sons of light. That's the end of the parable. Jesus is going to explain it to us, so here he goes, and I say to you, make friends for yourselves by means of the, and I love this phrase, the maman of unrighteousness. Some of you will have something like the wealth of sin, or the wealth of unrighteousness, or something like that. Make friends by means of the maman of unrighteousness that when it fails, they may receive you into the eternal dwellings. He who is faithful in a very little thing is faithful also in much, and he who is unrighteous in a very little thing is unrighteous also in much. If therefore you have not been faithful in the use of the unrighteous maman, who will entrust the true riches to you, and if you have not been faithful in the use of that which is another, who will give you that which is your own? No servant can serve two masters, for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will hold to one and despise the other, you cannot serve God in man. Now there's the parable. The parable itself is one of the most difficult, I guess we could say, of all of Jesus' parables, because you got this guy who is charged with cooking the books. We don't honestly know at the beginning of the parable whether he really cooked the books or not, but we know that the master is on him about it, and he's going to toss him out of his stewardship, and so the guy makes these kind of backroom deals with all the debtors of his master, and his master praises him for it, because he's true. And what in the world is going on there? And then Jesus has this very lengthy explanation that seems to make actually several points, and ends up with something that we can all affirm, because it's in the servant of the mount, you know, you cannot serve God in man, but where did that come from in relationship to the parable? Now I want to suggest to you that this parable actually is very important in terms of transitioning us from the material in Luke chapter 15 into the point that he's going to make at the end of the chapter of chapter 16. Now we can get lost in all the details of the story of the parable. For instance, is there a significance to barley at 50 percent, and weed at 80 percent, right? And what is it that caused the master to really praise the guy, and especially is what he's doing here? I mean, cutting the debts of the people who are debtors to the master, is that legitimate or not? I mean, in what sense would it be legitimate if it is? There have been a variety of explanations to the question of the legitimacy of what the steward does here. One possibility is that he is simply lying. He has a few more days, ostensibly in the role of steward, even though he's being ushered out the door. And so he quickly makes some backroom deals, and in doing so, he acts as the agent of the master, and the master then no longer has the legal right to come back in and say, no, I know my steward said, just pay 50 percent, but I want the full 100 percent. So there's a possibility that this master simply legally can't reverse this, or there's another possibility that having made these backroom deals, the master would then look bad if he came back to these debtors of his, and said, well, I know part of your debt was relinquished, and you have legal right to just run off and only pay me 50 percent, but come on, I really want the full 100 percent. I mean, that might look bad. That's another possibility. Another possibility that's been suggested, and this one appeals to people, especially to commentators, because it sounds like the steward isn't as bad as we think he is. And that would be to suggest that it was illegal in Judaism to charge interest, okay? So I couldn't make you alone and say, okay, you know, here's 100 check-holes, I'm going to charge you a 20 percent interest, so I want you to come back with 120. This is still actually in Islamic law, illegal in some respects as well. The way that people get around that is, you know, we make a deal. You come to me to borrow some check-holes, and you want 100 check-holes, and I hand over 100 check-holes to you, and I look you in the eye, and I say, I just gave you 120, didn't I? And you say, yes. And I say, when you come to repay me, you'll pay me 120, right? Yes. And what's going on there, then, is not interest per say. I'm just saying I'm lowing you 120 check-holes, but I held back a few. And everybody understands how that works. It's a way of circumventing the interest laws. Now, that is a practice that is continuing to go on in the Middle East. It is difficult to evidence whether that practice actually went on in first century Israel, okay? So I'm not confident that that's what's going on, but then the idea would be that the steward is coming back to her, and instead of saying, I know we said 120, but you and I really know it was 100, so therefore, just pay back the 100. And thus, he's going back to what the law actually permits, the law, meaning the Old Testament actually permits. That's a possibility. I would submit to you that there's a sense in which it really doesn't matter, okay? Because what we're trying to determine here is whether the steward is a righteous steward or not, whether he's acting rightly, but the text actually tells us that he's an unrighteous steward. So in verse 8, and his master praised the unrighteous steward. Now, your translations they have rendered that differently slightly, but the Greek accurately says something like unrighteous steward, or if it says unrighteous manager, or something like that, that's just fine. So it tells us that he's unrighteous. And then it also goes on to tell us that he acted truly. Now this is interesting because that provides difficulty for translators to come up with captions for this. You know, at the top and your Bibles, it usually has a caption right above the parable. My caption here says, the unrighteous steward. Does anybody have a different caption? What's the another you have? Okay, the dishonest manager. So that's the same kind of theme unrighteous steward. So might I have something else? The shrewd manager, and that's the other option, right? So the question is, is he unrighteous or is he shrewd? And the answer from the text is, he's both, right? Because the text in verse 8 says, and his master praised the unrighteous steward because he acted truly. He's acting wisely. And the point that comes out of the parable is, right after that, the sons of this age are more shrewd in relation to their own kind than the sons of light. There's a sense in which this man acted so wisely that we can learn from the wisdom that he evidences even if he is unrighteous at the same time. Okay? Question then, what can we learn from here? What did he do that was right? Well, of course, let me retell the story just slightly. He's going to be tossed out into the darkness effectively outside of the house of his master, which means he is no longer going to have a place to live because as a steward, he probably lived on the grounds of where his master was, got all his food from that, got all his money from that, his whole life is just going to disappear. So he needs to find another house where he can go. Now, that's probably not just a place to lay his head, but he may actually be looking for another place to work as well. And so he goes to the debtors and they become in a sense indebted to him and thus are going to welcome him into their house. So the whole thing has to do about being welcomed into a house. Now, in light of that, let's read Jesus' explanation and see if we can figure out what's going on. Verse 9, and I say to you, make friends of yourselves by means of the maman of unrighteousness that when it fails, they may receive you into the eternal dwellings. Now, apart from this question of what is the maman of unrighteousness, let's realize that he has tied himself very well back to the parable. The guy used maman, that is money and the parable, to gain for himself a house once he gets thrown out of his current dwelling, right? Jesus is saying, use money in such a way that you will have a house when you're all done with this life. You'll have an eternal house. That's the point. Then he goes on, he who is faithful in a very little thing is faithful also in much and he who is unrighteous in a very little thing is also unrighteous in much. So this has to do ultimately with faithfulness and unrighteousness. And the question is, what are we being called to be faithful in or unrighteous in? And here he goes on, if therefore you have not been faithful, there's our faithful word, in the use of unrighteous man, and let's just call it money at this stage, who will entrust the true which is to you? And if you have not been faithful in the use of that which is another's, who will give you that which is your own? And then to drive home the point that we're talking about God and money, no servant can serve two masters for either he will hate the one and love the other or else he will hold to the one and despise the other. What's going on? Well, it seems to have to do with money and being faithful in our use of money as opposed to being unrighteous in our use of money. If we faithfully use the money that's been entrusted to us which is not really ours but belongs to someone else, namely gods, then we earn for ourselves eternal dwellings because we have shown our faithfulness. Does that make sense? Now, I said that this whole parable is needs to be tied into the stuff that came before in chapter 15 and then provides a transition for us until the end of chapter 16. What do I mean by that? What comes next in the series right after verse 13, verse 14? Now the Pharisees, where did we last meet the Pharisees? Chapter 15 where they were listening into Jesus and they were tied into the last parable in chapter 15 because they're the older brother. Now the Pharisees who were lovers of money were listening to all these things and they were scoffing at him because they love money and they didn't hear this right teaching about how money should be used. And just to show you that the Pharisees are still in place, Jesus then says to the Pharisees, you're those who justify yourselves on the side of men, but God knows your hearts for that which is highly esteemed among men, money, is detestable in the side of God. Detestable maybe even to the point of being un viewed as unrighteous man. Money can even be viewed from one angle of things as if in itself is in some sense evil because it's so prone to being misused.

The law and the prophets were proclaimed until John since then the gospel of the kingdom of God is preached and everyone is forcing his way into it so everybody is trying to get into the gospel but it is easier for heaven and earth to pass away than for one stroke of a letter of the law to fail and then he has this weird aside in the midst of all of this. Everyone who divorces his wife and Mary is another commits adultery and he who marries it one who is divorced from a husband commits adultery. Now you think he's off on a different topic then and then this next parable seems to be wholly separate but I would suggest to you that he's still on the topic about dealing with Pharisees because remember weeks ago we talked about Pharisees and their views of divorce and how easy it could be to get a divorce in Pharisee law so he's after them about not just their view of money but their view of divorce here in other words he's kind of keeping talking at the Pharisees and then he's going to tell us another parable and this is going to get back to the issue of money and that's the parable of the rich man and Lazarus. Now you know the parable I'm not going to go through and tell you all the parable again but basically you have a rich man and Lazarus and the rich man refuses to give money to Lazarus. Now again one of the most important things in Judaism in the first century was Almsgiving. It was a show of your righteousness it was what you should do with your money but instead the rich man who is a rich man he has money and Lazarus who's laying outside the gates of the city and is on death's door he refuses to give any of his from his riches to Lazarus. He goes out Lazarus gets to be in the bosom of the father Abraham the rich man dies and he goes to a very different place and he begs that he is able to go back and talk to his his family basically his brothers and warn them about this place of torment but Abraham said verse not 29 they have Moses in the prophets let them hear them now who had Moses in the prophets well all Israel certainly but so did the Pharisees but he said no father Abraham but if someone goes to them from the dead they will repent but Jesus said to them if they don't listen to Moses and the prophets neither will they be persuaded if someone rises from the dead and who is he talking about there himself and his resurrection right now the point is the Pharisees are still very much in mind all the way through chapter 16 and he's telling them that even if I raise from the dead they're not going to believe because of their hard heart however let us not also lose the other major theme that's going on in verse 16 which is what what was it that the rich man did wrong he didn't give money to Lazarus he didn't use his unrighteous man to provide for himself an eternal dwelling will people will welcome him when he goes there and instead the result is that the rich man goes some very plays very different and Lazarus who could have welcomed him into an eternal dwelling is does not do so all right going back to our initial parable then of the unrighteous steward how should we use our money that's the question that comes out of this and the answer is that we should use our money in such a way that we are faithful in the use of it that it does not inhibit our worship of God you know the difference between God and man and especially that we should use it in such a way that it benefits others so that when we go to our eternal home there will be people who are welcoming us there because we were faithful in giving to them and providing for them in their hour of need so that makes sense I would submit to you that the western church needs to hear this today okay I had a very interesting lunch a couple of weeks ago with a friend of mine who's from South Africa and teaches there Charlie you'll know who I'm speaking about and we we were talking about the church and I asked him to kind of contrast his African perspective on the western church in the first place he went is he thinks that the western church is highly materialistic and I have to say he's right we have so much money that we hardly know what to do with it and I think the question God would ask us right now is are you being faithful and what God has gifted you and are you making eternal dwellings and people who will welcome you into those on the basis of your use of the wealth that you have only now a stewardship over for a very brief time it's not even yours that's by the way a major theme in the gospel of Luke and the book of Acts and so we've maybe kind of scratched on a theological theme a theological emphasis that we have in Luke and in Acts I personally find that to be a very convicting set of parables that was intended to be a bit of a homily but if you have any questions I'll take those before we pray any thoughts well I don't think the point about the divorce verse is that who is it that has problems with the divorce that Jesus is already corrected elsewhere in his teaching as principally the Pharisees because they have argued in such a way as to make divorce very easy to get you remember I think I mentioned the discussion of Haleil and Shamai I was just discussing this with a class yesterday and and how Shamai said next Shamai was the more rigorous the Haleil the school of Haleil said that even if your wife burns your meal you can divorce her that's all it takes for sufficient grounds for divorce and Jesus says that's not the grounds it all for divorce and and so Jesus is teachings on divorce which are much more rigorous than the Pharisees certainly but even in the Old Testament he says that Moses granted you the possibility divorce because of your the hardness of your hearts and the the major teaching of marriage needs to go back to Genesis 1 and how God created male and female to be one flesh so Jesus is teaching as much more rigorous than that of the Pharisees but Jesus is teaching on divorce needs to be seen against the backdrop of the teaching of the Pharisees so he's still very much on track here with talking about the Pharisees and the way I see it is he's initially in chapter 15 on them about how they they don't welcome the tax gathers in the centers even though they should rejoice as the father and heaven rejoices when one who is lost comes into the fold then he's on them about money and when they finally wake up and start scoffing at him about what is this guy know about use of money after all he was an tenor preacher that didn't have much you know so it's hardly fair for him to be talking to us about money Jesus comes back at them directly and hammers them on one area where they're particularly weak namely divorce and then he goes back and and fills out more his teaching about money and wealth in the form of the rich man of Lazarus so that's how I see the whole thing flowing

yes that's true he would be on the flip side saying you're promoting adultery and that's inditing them as well that's a very good point yeah so it's another indictment of them yeah all right no no you said it's it's used to talk about the doctrine of heaven and hell and that that would not be a point I would draw out of this actually I would say this is about heaven and hell when I say that the rich man goes to a very different place I mean he goes to hell here that's assumed in the parable now I grant that this is not theologically teaching us a doctrine of heaven and hell but it's presuming the existence of heaven and hell and thus becomes an argument for hell and the horrors of hell and I think that I mean I maybe I was soft peddling it too much do you realize how scary this is I mean Jesus is actually saying your eternal home rests on your faithfulness in the use of unrighteous man and now certainly there's forgiveness in the gospel and all of that and I don't want to say that salvation is predicated on our almsgiving I don't think Jesus is going that far and instead he's talking to people who are of the nation Israel some of whom he is basically saying you are out of the kingdom and others you're saying you're in the kingdom and he's instructing both he's he's showing that the people who are out of the kingdom one of the great sins that shows that they should be out of the kingdom as they they don't use their money rightly but he's also teaching the people who are in the kingdom that they should use their money rightly so I don't think it's their almsgiving that puts them in or out but the almsgiving becomes indicative of what's in their hearts that's been produced by grace so yeah this is very serious stuff and and this indictment of the materialism then of the western church is perhaps much more serious than we realize we think it's a matter of well we didn't give you know a few cents more than we you know enough but Jesus is talking to an attitude of the heart that's literally a difference between heaven and hell in terms of the attitude of the heart is that good good let's let's pray for a moment and we'll move into our topic for the day father is we approach this parable and this couple of parables we recognize indeed the great sinfulness of our hearts that would hold on to the possessions that we have where we may feel ourselves free from the love of money we are constantly amazed at how much our belongings can have indeed a hold over us father we ask that you would enable us as your people to relinquish that whole that we might use our money to great avail for the spreading of your kingdom beyond that Lord we ask that we not have the attitude of the Pharisees that would so love money and that would so despise those who come into their gathering that when there's something different than us we cannot appreciate your work in the heart of repentant sinners father instead use us to your glory and as we ourselves come to you repentant and recognizing the deep sinfulness of our hearts we are thankful that Jesus stands having paid for our sins and having offered us new life in him in whose name we pray amen okay um you know again with these homilies I also trying to make methodological points so that you get a sense not just what does this one text mean but how should I go about reading scripture and one of my points here is how you should go about reading parables and the point is don't just start when if if your Bible study material says the parable goes from verse 1 to verse 13 don't stop and don't start but look at the context and see how the parable is functioning in the whole story and the narrative of the gospel writer because the gospel writer very often will give you keys as to how you should rightly understand that parable by putting it in a particular context so be careful and do that as well all right um our topic yeah actually let me um do one other thing before we get into our topic for today last time I handed out to you a a brief handout on the resurrection of Christ in the history of redemption um and this is excuse me this is uh mostly for your background um and uh I did so before Easter actually I would have preferred to hand out this to you sometime in about October or November and the reason for that is how many times have you heard a sermon on the resurrection in October you know how many times does it does the resurrection come up in your proclamation of the gospel in August that's the real mark of the degree to which you are stamped by the understanding that our that our Jesus is not just crucified for our sins but is raised that we might have new life and that the the combination of that is what constitutes the gospel and it's uh therefore I mean it's it's nice to hand this out around Easter but it kind of falls flat on on uh almost on deaf ears because it's like oh yeah this is Easter time we do the resurrection at Easter time but we should do the resurrection 365 days of a year that's a major point I would I would make coming out of this I would note to you that um this outline suggests that the resurrection of Jesus finds itself in a historical context in which there were resurrections in the Old Testament and at and a kind of a glimpse of a doctrine of resurrection coming out of the Old Testament there was a teaching and a diversity of views within a second temple Judaism with regard to um resurrection the Sadducees did not believe a resurrection was even going to happen not meaning the resurrection of Messiah but the resurrection of any of us where's the Pharisees taught a doctrine of the resurrection um and then there's some clear evidence of of that in second temple Judaism um the next point uh Roman numeral two on the second page the the whole of this is to say that Jesus intended to be resurrected and I I made that point last time um but it's worth reiterating part of Jesus' ministry was the empty tomb and the ascended Christ and his ministry was not accomplished until it until the ascension had happened because he intended all of that to be part of his ministry and his work um and I give some evidences for that in terms of the different sayings of Jesus there are different infacies within the gospel accounts of the resurrection that's point number three if you get to point number four again coming out of um Easter Sunday it's very common especially in evangelical churches for the sermon on Easter Sunday to include an apologetic for the resurrection that Jesus actually physically rose from the dead and that we can historically trust that and I would affirm that that's something that we all as Christians should be prepared to defend especially in a culture which is increasingly skeptical to that claim so you should be able to prepare to defend the resurrection and um there's a variety of evidences that I suggest here and uh there's also some fine writings that have been done on that one of the books I can suggest to you is oh I forgot the author's name it's Stephen something I think it's Davies or Davis and he wrote a book called Risen Indeed and there's a number of very short quick apologetic books on the resurrection that are useful Josh McDowell does all of this and those are those are helpful but the Risen Indeed book is a very uh lay friendly and yet philosophically astute defense of the resurrection and so if you're interested in pursuing that further I would certainly encourage you there the main point I would make because it's often lost um in the typical uh resurrection apologetics and it is often doubted in our world today is that first century Christians were not stupid okay it is often people will rarely say well um Matthew was stupid but they effectively imply it when they say something like this you know we we view history very differently than they did in the first century and in the first century they were inclined to believe that miracles happen like all the time and of course we in our scientific world recognize that that's not the case and when they wrote history they were happy to include miraculous events whether they happened or not just simply because if they heard something happened they figured it must have happened and so they threw it in and you will hear that repeatedly in time and newsweek magazine and on the airwaves of our national television stations etc and you should be prepared to say to uh to to people you know they weren't stupid in the first century and I have a variety of evidences about that in particular um in 1 Corinthians 15 Paul understands the stakes if the if the resurrection did not historically happen the faith is useless and he is willing to take a stand on the historical reliability of the resurrection presenting evidence in the form of witnesses to say this happened because he understands that if historically it didn't happen everything is useful or useless there were people who doubted remember remember remember at the Matthew 28 people when they see the resurrected Lord they fallen their knees and they worship but Matthew tells us some doubted Matthew understands that there were alternate theories that went around in his day that had a certain amount of explanatory force namely the disciples stole the body that has quite a lot of explanatory force except if you realize some of the other issues like the body was guarded and all that kind of stuff but there were other explanations going on in Matthew's day meaning that Matthew didn't just kind of buy into this idea of the resurrection he there were other ways of thinking about it and he knew there were other ways of thinking about so they're not dupes is uh basically my point and I have a few other points to make there it's very important that you develop a healthy respect for the quality of history that we have in the gospels in the book of Acts it is it is a history that's written with different protocols than we use today they don't footnote their sources but that doesn't mean that they don't understand the importance of sources and the importance of sourcing out a historical claim because it's very much the opposite and we'll see that as we study especially the prologue to the gospel of Luke in the next couple of days all right so um these people were much wiser than we like to think and then um finally skipping um Roman number five let me say of Roman numeral six I am interested in that you understand that there are a variety of theological implications for the resurrection there's not just one reason for the resurrection but there's a whole host of reasons that are actually used in scripture for the importance of the resurrection now here's the deal with you guys okay uh you guys are probably sitting there thinking okay we just had a midterm so therefore what's gonna be on the final all right of of this handout um I've decided that the only part that I really want you to be able to um to talk through is Roman numeral six and the question would look something like this should there be a question on the final of the many theological implications that were given in class on concerning Jesus's resurrection list at least three okay so I've got I don't know what is it about nine here right I'm asking that you have reflected on it sufficiently that you can recall at least a third of them okay so on your own please look at those you might want to look up what you should look up the verse references so that you see um what I mean uh and the evidence that I give for uh why the resurrection is important in those respects all right any questions on that before we move into the discussion of the gospel excuse me you might have any questions or comments my my daughter has a coloring book that's produced by a very fine Christian ministry you guys would all know the name of the ministry that I'm thinking of it was given to my daughter by my uh my parents and it is a gospel um presentation effectively in the form of a coloring book it's really cute and well done and it it affirms um that we are sinful it affirms our need for Christ our salvation the need to repent and follow Jesus and nowhere in the 15 or 20 pages of the coloring book does it ever mention that Jesus was raised from the dead not all I would submit to you that that is actually very common in most Protestant evangelical presentations of the gospel that it is very often the case that the pastor at the very end of his sermon when it's time to say to people you need to consider Christ remember your sinfulness remember that it was paid on the cross you need to come to Christ today and they're done and that's not the full gospel folks because there's many places when the gospel is summarized in the New Testament with not the death of Jesus but the resurrection of Jesus and that's what constitutes the gospel so so be careful and don't go any other thoughts canals it can be certainly that's right because do you understand how guilty you are in your sinfulness and Jesus had to pay that and so that's how guilty you are so come that's right so it can be guilt driven it's not all that and honestly I don't want to impeach the motives of the people who are often doing this I mean some of my my favorite pastors I've heard give short gospel presentations that just focus on the death of Jesus and and I want to say that they're they really are earnest about convincing people that they need to come to Christ it's just if you do it too often it's dangerous because you forget that there's a whole other aspect of the gospel as well so yeah that's a good point

and I mean I've done it myself I don't know if I shared with you when I was a college student and was involved in a very active evangelistic work within a campus ministry we had a presentation piece that we used to lead people through the gospel account and it did mention the resurrection but by the time I got there I had gone through several pages of the booklet and I'd already taken you know 25 30 minutes of somebody's time and I'm looking at the clock and I'm thinking you know I got to get through this and I see that little blurb on the resurrection and I say oh yeah he was resurrected and you know turn the page what will you do with this you know and and so I I mean I know that how easy it is to do just that okay um you had a handout today on the gospels the handout is I think front and back as you have it the one I'm interested in is the one that we're gonna start with is the one that says number 11 at the top of the page number 12 this comes after number 11 so we're gonna start with number 11 and the question is why do we have four gospels okay so why do we have four gospels first of all let's just theoretically say there did not have to be four right and in point of fact some churches especially some Syriac speaking churches in the second century instead of using the four canonical gospels chose instead to use a summary of the four gospels produced by a man named Tation um you might need to know how to spell that sorry

and he wrote a work called the Dia Tesseraan in Greek Tessera is four Dia is through so through four and what he did is he wove together the four canonical gospels into one harmonized continuous narrative if you ever see something that is called a harmony of the gospels that is an interweaving of the four gospels into one narrative and people will produce those to this day um I reviewed one just a couple of years ago that was was done and Tation did this right around 150 AD produced his Dia Tesseraan it was done in Greek and also translated in the Syriac and the aspects of the Syriac church liked it so much because then you have one book instead of four that they simply use this but the vast majority of the church is always said we've got four canonical gospels and even though we can harmonize them we don't treat the harmony as if it's canonical we treat the four gospels as if they're canonical and that's been the approach that the church has done but in theory at least one could um bring the gospels together and and people have long realized that Matthew, Mark and Luke share a substantial amount of the same material and actually the percentages when you get to the material from Mark that is found also in Matthew and in Luke is close to 90% of the book so you know why not save the publishers a little bit of money and maybe we see a need for Matthew, Luke but why not just Matthew, Luke and John instead of Mark also right so the question is why do we have four instead of just one or two or three one could also ask why don't we have more but that's a question that I tried to answer more firmly in our discussion on the canon many weeks ago all right so there's a limitation on the gospels but why is it that we have four instead of one that's the fundamental question I'm asking now basically fundamentally there are four gospels because the early church recognized the canonical voice of each of the four and that's that's the fundamental reason they saw the apostolic stamp on each of the four gospels and they could also tell that they each complement and this is crucial compliment the picture of one another now I know I've used this illustration before but it bears repeating because it's very important to understanding the role the gospels play that is the metaphor of a diamond right where if you take a look at a diamond a nice large hunk of rock that's been beautifully cut and you look at it from one end of things and the light hits it and refracts through it and you see these beautiful colors but then you start churning it you'll see even more aspects of that diamond as you're viewing it from different perspectives as you go around and effectively what the gospels allow us to do is they all refer to the diamond namely the life and times of Jesus and they each look at that diamond from a particular viewpoint and their own perspective and the result is that they each have their own infacies but they're looking at the same material and from it we get a fuller picture than we would if we just had one person's take on that diamond okay so that's effectively at least metaphorically I would say that we have four we have them because they're canonical they each bear the apostolic stamp by that I mean Matthew was an apostle John was an apostle Mark and Luke have the apostolic stamp of having worked with Paul and Peter

and through all that we have an apostolically sanctioned canonical set of four gospels that each complement one another and so although the church recognized very early on that there was significant overlap in terms of the narrative they still chose to have four different narratives of the life of Jesus so that's fundamentally why we have four nevertheless moving into the so-called synoptic problem there are three gospels which are most alike and today in this lecture we're going to focus on basically these three gospels and the gospels are Matthew, Mark, and Luke they are known as the synoptic gospels that the word synoptic is they're spelled in Roman numeral point two under the synoptic problem if you're wondering how spelling the synoptic gospels Matthew, Mark, and Luke and the reason that they are called that is that if you put them alongside one another and what is known as a synopsis you will see that they overlap substantially in terms of what they convey all right now a harmony to give you a technical definition a harmony takes the four gospels and blends them into one continuous narrative a synopsis is a work that you can buy in bookstores which puts the gospels in parallel columns and allows you to compare and contrast what what's being emphasized in each of the gospels all right and the three gospels that can most easily be put together in such a synopsis or Matthew, Mark, and Luke all right now between these we have similarities and differences there is similar wording you probably should write down I've got four similarities here there's a similarity in wording between the three gospels at times there is a similarity in order between the gospels and to speak to that for a moment basically the narrative structure of the gospel of Mark is paralleled in the gospels of Matthew and Luke however Matthew and Luke in the material that they had that is additional to Mark put that material in a different structure in comparison to one another so in particular Matthew has five great discourses of Jesus's teaching think of the sermon on the mount which is the first great discourse in Matthew where he brings all of the material of of of Jesus's teaching on a few topics together in one continuous teaching time okay so Matthew does that at five different points in his gospel again the structure of the action in the gospel follows Mark but if you would Matthew then enters inner poses teachings of Jesus in between the action that's described in Mark if you would okay

Luke on the other hand follows again basically the action structure that you have in Mark and also includes a lot of the teaching material that you have in Matthew and some that is distinct deeply only found in Luke but he puts it especially in chapters 9 to the to roughly the time when Jesus shows up in Jerusalem 9 to 19 thereabouts and in those chapters as Jesus is walking to Jerusalem it's not like he sits down and gives a long sermon but while he's walking with his disciples it's like he says oh and another thing let me talk about this another thing let me talk about this so you have similarities in order but you also have some distinctives in terms of the order between the Gospels Matthew and Luke obviously are much longer than Mark but they they continue containing a lot of the material that's in Mark now there is in addition to a similarity in wording and in order also a similarity in parenthetic material so in other words at times in Jesus is teaching there are brief asides that are done and there's similarities in that so it's not like you you have just some sort of abstract teaching source as the main source for all the Gospels because beyond the teaching there's also the action that's similar and there's also these kind of parentheses in the teaching that are parallel between Matthew and Luke and then finally there's there are similarities in New Testament quotations of the Old Testament even when at times they differ from a natural rendering of the Hebrew for instance right now those similarities are very striking especially if you start considering some of the percentages that are found in terms of the various Gospels and I meant to bring the percentages with me and I forgot to bring that sheet with me let me I'm going to have to do this kind of based on my recollection and therefore the percentages aren't going to be wholly accurate but they'll be roughly right I said earlier that roughly 90% of Mark is found in Matthew or Luke and often found in both if you break that down further though roughly Matthew and Luke each incorporate about 70% of what's found in Mark okay so they don't both use 90% of Mark they both use about 70% but about 90% of Mark is then found in those Gospels so you'll find then times when Matthew follows Mark or has the same material that they have in Mark where Luke doesn't and vice versa but so much of Mark then is found in the other Gospels so that's one striking similarity now these similarities have led people to say that there must be literary dependence between the different Gospels Matthew Mark and Luke in other words at least one of the Gospels came first and the others used it as a source and at this stage would say that that's possible we'll talk about source theories more in a few minutes now some qualifications on the similarities issue in terms of the synoptic problem these similarities are not found consistently throughout the three synoptic Gospels in other words you cannot predict based on the statistics alone that a passage in Mark is going to definitely make its way in a Matthew or definitely make its way into Luke more over even where those passages are parallel between Matthew and Mark and Matthew and Luke and Luke and Mark and such although there's often striking similarities in wording they're also striking divergences at times not usually divergences that would change the meaning of a passage but more synonyms that are used instead of saying Jesus ran the gospel might say Jesus went the other gospel might say Jesus went or something like that so there's similarities in wordings but there's also differences in wording so the question is how to account for the differences as well as the similarities

one example of this in a previous class I handed out to you a handout on the passion predictions of Jesus and also on the Lord's supper this is effectively a synopsis right it puts the four Gospels in three Gospels this is just the synoptic Gospels the three Gospels in three parallel columns where their narratives may parallel one another and you'll note that their times when Luke has stuff that's not in Matthew and Mark there's times when Matthew and Mark agree on a citation and Luke doesn't have it or maybe Luke has it much later and then if you were to look at the individual words across each of these columns you'll see what I mean about both the striking similarities and this at the times remarkable divergences between the actual words so you have something here that you could kind of do a many kind of synoptic comparison on and then if you turn to the Lord's supper you'll see again that there's some striking similarities all the way across between Matthew and Mark and Luke that are the first three columns but there's also some ordering differences in terms of material that you find in Luke that's not in Matthew and Mark and vice versa and the specific words have again some similarities but then some slight differences between each again so that gives you kind of an example of how you yourself could do some of this work between the three synoptic Gospels all right now the problem then the synoptic problem is why is there so much similarity and yet divergence and how can we best figure this out well there are some proposed solutions to the problem and the initial set of solutions in terms of the history of New Testament scholarship typically revolved around literary sources assuming that for instance the gospel writers used one another as literary sources and that they might have used other literary sources alongside of that all right the first major in terms of the history of the church solution to this synoptic problem although it wasn't certainly framed in those terms came in the form of saying that Matthew's gospel came first and that other gospel writers used Matthew as a source and chose to supplement him or emphasize aspects of things that were in him in different ways all right this is especially found in the early church off writers such as Irenaeus and Eusavius all right these up here just so you know who they are you've already met Eusavius right we talked about him with regard to the canon so here sorry that's a you Irenaeus and Eusavius but also in the form of a more studied approach to this in the teachings of Augustine that's an e so this came up very early in the church and if you would we could depict that as Matthew came first and then Mark used him as a source and so did Luke okay now there are variations on this in contemporary teachings in particular you could there's a Augustine's view was actually this Matthew came first Mark used Matthew and then Luke used Mark you can see why he might go with this the striking similarities in Luke and Matthew typically revolve around the action that you find in Mark okay so that provides that kind of narrative framework in which the teachings then appear of Jesus so therefore if Matthew came first as Irenaeus and Eusavius had testified because he was Jewish and he wrote initially an eramaic and then it was translated to Greek then if Mark made a kind of summary statement of Matthew then Luke would use Mark and that would account for why Matthew and Luke are similar to Mark in terms of the kind of the structure of the narrative but why Luke and Matthew diverge from one another in terms of where where they place the actual teachings of Jesus so that's actually Augustine's form

there are other there's another form too that is known technically as the Greesbach hypothesis and that goes something like this Matthew came first Luke used Matthew and then Mark used Luke

the problem with that excuse me actually I should probably say it's better to do this way Mark didn't just use Luke Mark used Luke and Matthew if you would okay that's the actual Greesbach hypothesis and what he's trying to do there what Greesbach is trying to do there is to to note that apart from these kind of the overall structure that you have in terms of the flow of the narrative there are times when Matthew and Luke contain material that are not that's not found in Mark but Matthew and Luke's wording is strikingly similar so therefore Luke must have had some access to Matthew or vice versa and that's what Greesbach suggests is this and that Mark actually produced a quick kind of summary statement of the two of them focusing on the action of the narrative all right so that takes us through the Nathanian priority and the reason is called priority Bathy priority is Matthew comes first right on the list we've we've gotten that far and we've also run out of time so what we'll need to do next time is talk about Mark and priority at this stage all I want you guys to leave here with is thinking is it possible that there's literary dependence between the different synoptic gospels I am not yet saying definitively that there is or that we've come across the right solution yet I'm just saying it's worth considering at this stage