<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Hatag Hatag Matag Bulan

Theology of Calvin

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Lecture 9, Knowledge of God and of ourselves, the theology of John Calvin. In Calvin was 27 years old, he had been a Protestant for perhaps two, maybe three years. His second book was published, and that book was the Institutes of the Christian Religion. Modern scholar has said that it's a book which holds a place in the short list of books, which have notably affected Western civilization, and perhaps we can even expand that to some extent through the World Mission Movement. This book has affected at least the church around the world. Today we're going to talk about that book. The entire lecture will be about one book, but it's a very, very important book. And as we looked at Luther's theology, we will look at Calvin's theology, but the difference is that Calvin wrote a systematic theology, and we can study Calvin's institutes and understand what his theology was. As we pray today, I would like to use a prayer from Calvin. Calvin preached and his prayers were recorded as well as his sermons, and this is a prayer that followed Calvin's sermon on 1 Samuel chapter 2. Let's spell together in prayer. I will read these words as we pray together. Let us therefore bow before the majesty of our good God, recognizing the great number of faults and offenses with which we have provoked his wrath against us. Let us pray to him that he may etch the fear of his majesty upon our minds and make us sharers in those things that we have learned in the Scripture. That by his strength he may support our weakness and infirmity, and make us victors by the power of his spirit and provide sufficient strength for us to withstand any temptations to which we would otherwise be unequal. Run the whole course of our lives and obedience to him, giving eternal thanks to him for his many and great benefits to us. Finally, that all our senses may be lifted off in worshiping him to his everlasting praise and glory, and we may be led in the pathway of salvation, not for our own private advantage, but for the upbuilding of our neighbors. Amen. Calvin's institutes was a book that has a history in its own lifetime and Calvin's own lifetime because Calvin did not write it once. He wrote it really many times. And as we think about the history of this book, we begin with that point, the growth of a book. Calvin tells us in his final and definitive edition of the Institutes in 1559 that when he first wrote it in 1536, it was a little booklet of six chapters. By the time he had finished in 1559, it was divided into four large books of 80 chapters. In the English translation, the 1536 edition is about 225 pages, and the 1559 edition is over 1500 pages. Calvin wrote the Institutes in Latin and then translated his own Latin into French. So the various editions of the Institutes that came out between the first and the last had not only the Latin texts, but Calvin's French text as well. Scholars of French language say that the French edition of 1541 represents a landmark in the development of the French language. So Calvin's writing is style. In the Institutes is important not only for theology, but for the history of the French language in its literature. His Calvin developed his book through all these years. He does not really revise it, but he expands it. Calvin does not change his mind on any basic doctrinal issue, which is pretty remarkable when you realize that the first edition was written when he was in his 20s, and then he spends all his life adding to the Institutes, but he doesn't change his mind. St. Augustine had to write the retractions at the end of his life, in which he went back over everything that he had written and said, I still agree with this, but I disagree with that. Calvin never wrote anything like that. And part of the reason Calvin did not have to write retractions was because he could read Augustine, and Augustine had pioneered so much of the theology that Calvin was presenting. So it was not that he revised his work, but he greatly expanded it. He expanded it through his study, the study of the Church Fathers, enabled him to add quotations from the Church Fathers. His favorite Church Fathers were Chrysostom, the preacher, Constantinople, and Bernard of Clareville, who gave Calvin an anchor in the Middle Ages, or some of his thought at least. But most of all, St. Augustine. Once Calvin exalted, Augustine totally is ours. First, the Catholics wanted him to, and Calvin may have exaggerated a bit in that statement, because there is a Catholic side of Augustine that Calvin did not adopt. But when he was thinking about grace and predestination and salvation, he felt that Augustine is totally ours. And so as Calvin grew in his knowledge of Church history and his knowledge of the Church Fathers, he was able to expand the institutes. And then as Calvin grew in his experience in ministry, he was able to expand the institutes. So he saw his first short ministry in Geneva, was not a highly successful one. And then he had three wonderful years in Strasbourg, his pastor of a French refugee church there. And then he came back to Geneva, Chasen and Season, and able to more effectively minister, as he served in the Church then in Geneva for the rest of his life. So all that he learned in ministry goes in to the institutes as expanding the truth that Calvin is putting forth as theology. It also reflects the practical side of Calvin as pastor. And then primarily, as Calvin studies the scripture, he is able to expand his theology by much greater use of scripture and very sensitive use of scripture. Calvin wrote commentaries on every book in the New Testament except several of the shorter ones. And on most of the old estimate, and he was working on the commentary on Ezekiel when he died, almost his last effort went toward writing that commentary until an unfinished senate marks the end of Calvin's life. One book, by the way, that he did not attempt was the book of Revelation. And Calvin said that he did not write on Revelation because he did not understand it. He did not say nobody could understand it, but he said, I can't understand it. And so he did not write on it. One of his contemporaries said, oh, most wise, Calvin. And he wrote on most of the old estimate as I have said. And as he wrote his commentaries, he was building a biblical theology so that as he expanded the institutes, he was able to do so with greater and greater use of the scripture. I have added to the syllabus four words, which I think summarize Calvin's commentaries, accuracy, clarity, brevity, and humility. He began writing his commentaries with the commentary on Romans in 1540 because he saw Romans as a kind of key to interpreting all of scripture. In his dedication of his commentary on Romans, he wrote these words, God limits our knowledge. First, that we should be kept humble and also that we should continue to have dealings with our fellows. See what he means by that. Calvin is saying God doesn't give any of us complete knowledge of the Bible so that we can stay humble and so we can keep in touch with each other. So I'd so nice to have a seminary faculty and a seminary family. We can keep talking to each other because none of us knows everything and we need each other to help us to understand what the Bible says. And that's what Calvin says. And he adds in his dedication to his commentary on Romans that the majesty of the Word of God is somehow diminished if we do not interpret it with great discretion and moderation. Don't guess, don't add, but with discretion and moderation, say clearly and accurately, but the Bible says, and Calvin tempted to do that. He wrote in 1544, God has given me the grace to write what I had written as faithfully as it was in my power. I have not falsified a single passage of the scripture nor given it a wrong interpretation to the best of my knowledge. And I've always aimed at simplicity. Calvin was not a perfect Bible commentator, but he was one of the best to have come in the history of the church up to his time. And even today his commentaries are of great value and significance because they remain wonderful expositions of God's truth. Now Calvin did not revise. He expanded and he rearranged. Calvin spent all these years rewriting his institutes. He really doesn't, once he has written something, he doesn't throw it away. It will appear somewhere in the institutes in the next edition, but not always in the same place. I don't really see how Calvin did this without a word processor, but he would rewrite all of this and rearrange it all. And he said he was not satisfied until the final edition, 1559, when he felt that finally he had gotten it the way he wanted it. Let me illustrate it with just one point. In his earlier editions, through 1554 through the 1554 edition, Calvin talked about the doctrine of providence and the doctrine of predestination together. Early on, as he talked about the doctrine of God, in other words, Calvin would present the doctrine of God, and he would say God is the God who creates all things. And he's also the God who through his decrees works all things out in providence, which includes predestination of individuals for heaven. That all came pretty quickly in the opening chapters of the institutes. The doctrine of God, this is what God is like. This is what God does. God decrees everything. But something very unusual happened in 1559. I think very instructed, very helpful. To read Calvin's institutes, you not only get important theological information, but you get some kind of understanding as to where and when to say what you're going to say. And for Calvin, that was very important. In 1559, he separated these two doctrines. Providence still came in book one, doctrine of God. God creates God-governance. And occasionally, he will get very close to saying something about election, but he will check himself and write, we're not yet ready to get to that. And he goes on to something else about God, God being Trinity and the attributes of God. So book one is about God the Creator. We get into book two is about God, the Redeemer. We have the incarnation, the work of Christ and the life of Christ and the death of Christ and the resurrection of Christ. Still, nothing about election. Come to book three, the way in which we receive the grace of Christ. Now, certainly, we're going to read about election. But Calvin has a chapter on the Holy Spirit, long chapter on faith, chapter on sanctification, which curiously and for another good reason, which I won't get into, he puts before his chapter on justification. And then some more about the Christian life. And then a long chapter on prayer, and then finally, election. Why in such a strange place, in book three, toward the end of book three, after prayer? Well, the way I like to say it is that Calvin gets the person saved first. And then Calvin gets the person on his or her knees praying. And then Calvin slips in the question, where did your faith come from? Who really saved you? The answer is God did. God gave me faith. God saved me. And you see by limiting it that way, Calvin was able to avoid the controversy, because now it's not as part of book one in the doctrine of God so people can say, well, I don't like that. Now it's for the Christian to give glory to God, and to be humbled in the presence of God, because we recognize that our faith in our salvation is a gift of God. It's not of works, less any of us should boast. So in the institutes, the doctrine of election serves to answer specifically and only that one question, where did my faith come from? Well, you might remember that as you plan to preach through the doctrines of the Bible, or even through the Westminster Confession, which puts the doctrine much earlier than Calvin puts it in the institute. So all of his life, he was concerned not only with the content, but the order, because Calvin realized that the order is very important for teaching. People can learn this, they can be ready for this, but not yet for that until they have settled this. Calvin wanted to keep that pace right. So as you read the institutes, it's a wonderful study, not only in the content of theology, but in how to present theology, how to teach it, and when to teach it. Now let's come to some characteristics of the institutes, and I've chosen a number of words to enable me to comment on this marvelous book. The first word is biblical. Now I'm not just putting that there because I'm a Calvinist and I like the institutes, and I want Calvin to be biblical. Calvin wants to be biblical. Calvin, as Dr. Battles, translator, modern, most recent translator of the institutes has said, is a scriptural theologian first, and a user of philosophy and logic and rhetoric, all human tools of organization only second. Calvin uses all those things. That scripture indeed is first, and his use of scripture is astounding. As you read the institutes, you'll come to almost 7,000 quotations or references to scripture. And Calvin does not include these as mere decoration, just to have long list of references after something that he has stated, but he uses scripture sensibly and wisely with understanding of context and when Calvin brings in scripture almost always, it's very appropriate to the issue that he is discussing. John T. McNeil says that his readiness in bringing scripture passages to bear upon each point of argument is astonishing and has perhaps never been surpassed. There's a kind of a curious picture of Calvin which I have in my collection that relates to his posthumous fame, but also to the point that I'm making now because this is a drawing of Calvin. You won't be able to see it unless you get very close to it and even use a magnifying glass, but all those lines or quotations from scripture, somebody has drawn a picture of Calvin using only scripture verses. Well, it's got a strange way to draw somebody's picture, but in the case of Calvin, it's not an inappropriate way because that is indeed what Calvin wanted in his theology. R. C. Reed, the Southern Presbyterian theologian who taught at the Old Columbia Seminary in the last century, wrote in a wonderful little book called The Gospel According to Calvin. This sentence, he was a wholesale plagiarist from Moses and David, Isaiah and Ezekiel, Jesus and John, Peter and Paul. So scripture flows in to the institutes. Dillicol, second word, systematic. Dr. Warfield wrote as a systematizer. He makes his greatest demand on our admiration and gratitude. I've already commented on how Calvin worked hard to get the order right, but let me say a few more words about that because Calvin's concern was to be orderly and to follow an order of teaching. It's very much different from Malinthan's loci communists. Get the impression that Malinthan had a lot of file folders and he just put things in each folder and one just happened to follow the other. Perhaps it's a little severe on Malinthan and Lutherans may not like that statement, but I think even Lutherans would have to acknowledge that Malinthan did not have the ability that Calvin had in arranging theology in an orderly fashion. But what you don't find in the institutes, but what many people think you do find in the institutes, especially people who haven't read the institutes, is an iron clad logical system that just brings everything into some kind of logical order. Calvin bends the facts to make it fit his logic. You don't have to read for, just read a page or two in the institutes and you realize that's wrong. But there is a concern for order and arrangement, a careful tracing out of biblical themes, but Calvin in doing that comes to advocate what he calls learned ignorance. That's where we end up, you know, after we have done all that we can do, after you've read all the institutes and finished seminary, you will come out as a person who has learned but ignorant. Maybe if it discouraging, but it's true because Calvin says we can go only so far even with scripture, we can go only so far and we must not go beyond scripture. His image for going beyond scripture, a bud scripture, beyond scripture is the labyrinth, the maze. And once you take a step beyond scripture, you're going to find yourself lost in a labyrinth and you won't get out. So when Calvin deals with biblical doctrines, he goes as far as he can go, but he won't go any further. He doesn't force those doctrines together into some sort of logical system. He takes the doctrine of God's sovereignty and he takes it as far as he can possibly go with scripture. He'll take the doctrine of human responsibility and he'll take that as far as he can go with scripture. And what does he do when he gets both of those teachings developed as fully as he can according to scripture? He doesn't press them together in some sort of logical way. He just lets them stand out there and the way I like to say it is he sings the doxology there. Usually we'll quote Paul over the depths of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how unsearchable his judgments and his paths beyond tracing out. The third word is the word devotional. Now again somebody might say, well that's a strange word to use when you're talking about Calvin's institutes. You really mean that? Well again let me suggest you read the first couple of pages. You don't have to go far into it and you'll realize that Warfield is right when he says it's not the head but the heart which Calvin primarily addresses in his theology. In the first edition of the institutes this is the first page of the 1536 edition with its Latin title, the subtitle there. The original subtitle was this, the whole sum of piety and whatever it is necessary to know in the doctrine of salvation. You know Thomas Aquinas called his great work Summa Theologii, some of doctrine, some of theology. Calvin called his work some of piety, Summa Fiatatus, some of piety, some of devotion, what we need to know to love and serve God in our lives. Calvin begins the 1559, the final edition with these words, unless we establish our complete happiness in God, we will never give ourselves truly and sincerely to him. Calvin's institutes, see what I mean by devotional, that is true that Calvin will make great demands upon our minds but in his understanding of things we love God with our minds that we must think sincerely and truly and study. That's loving God too so there's no dichotomy between theology and piety in the institutes. As we read through the institutes we realize however to illustrate point that I've already made that when Calvin brings us as far as he can bring us scripturally in a doctrine and he always says, if you can go further, go further. It's not the last word. This is the best I can do but others may be able to understand more but when he brings us to that point for instance in the doctrine of God, doctrine of the Trinity, think of all the mystery in that, all the difficulty of our finite minds, comprehending even what the scriptures begins to say about God. Calvin finally says this in book fun chapter 5, it's a doctrine because it's a doctrine about God which we ought more to adore than to meticulously search out, it's a place where we stop and we worship. For the doctrine of election in book three, Calvin finally says that this teaching once he has said everything he can say about it and he's famous for it, some people think he invented it, of course he did not, Luther taught it, Augustine taught it, Paul taught it, it's in the Old Testament but when all has been said, that can be said by Calvin, he says God would have us revere but not understand that through this also he should fill us with wonder and one of the great doctrinal issues of the 16th century of course was the doctrine of the Lord's Supper, separated Catholics and Lutherans and the reformed and Calvin has long and detailed study of the presence of Christ in the Lord's Supper and he finally ends this way therefore nothing remains but to break forth in wonder at this mystery which plainly neither the mind is able to conceive nor the tongue to express and that a final word describing Calvin's the word practical. Hitted it is already but let me say a little more about it, one of the most striking characteristics of Calvin's work as a theologian is his synthesis of the work of the exegy, the systematic theologian, the preacher and the pastor get it all, you get it in one book because in God's providence Calvin was all those things, you know it was not Calvin's plan to be all those things, he wanted to go and be a scholar and I retower somewhere and not be bothered with the problems of a city like Geneva and a big church but God had other plans for him, if Calvin had ended up in the ivory tower he would have written the institutes but it would not have been the same book that we have, it would not have been a better book, the better book is the book Calvin wrote because as T. H. L. Parker put it Calvin's institutes was written not in an ivory tower but against the background of teething troubles, and baby is crying Calvin's own child died early but for many children that Calvin took in his relatives and family who lived with him the house was full of noise and hubbub and baby was always crying and Calvin had to concentrate in the midst of all that and write and the troubles from the church were always pressing it upon him the difficulties of being a Christian leader in a city that needed a lot of teaching the controversies in the church, the troubles on every hand like Paul Calvin was constantly being buffeted by these things but he went on writing and because he wrote in that context what he wrote is what we have in the institutes. I suppose there is no major theological work in all of history that is freer from technical theological words and expressions this Calvin's institutes. If you want a startling example of that read Thomas's summa and then read Calvin's institutes. Summa is a wonderful work but you've got to get your dictionary out and you've got to really work hard to understand what the title means in this chapter but with Calvin you've got to think you've got to stay away you've got to be alert but you don't need the theological encyclopedia in order to read what Calvin is saying Calvin was not a scholastic like Thomas Aquinas he was a street corner theologian like Paul and in the institutes you get a street corner theologian at work. One of the ideas that Calvin uses over and over again which illustrates this is his use of the concept of accommodation at least 41 times this word and this idea appears in the 1559 institutes and this is what Calvin means by that scripture he says proceeds at the pace of a mother stooping to her child so to speak so is not to leave us behind in our weakness. God talks baby talk to us in the Bible. God accommodates himself to our weakness now God could have given a Bible that none of us could understand but he gives a Bible full of stories and parables and even though there are some things like the book Revelation that certainly challenge us there is so much that we can't understand and so Calvin says if God is like that if he accommodates himself to our weakness in giving us a Bible like that that's God's baby talk then we must be like that too in our teaching you know it's all the other possible for a seminary student to go out and to say some things that nobody will understand preach some sermons that nobody will have a sliced idea what you're talking about and all that is very wonderful and very precious but it must be accommodated to the people that God is going to send you to so that in a sense you need to learn now to talk baby talk to because not everybody that you will serve has been the seminary not everybody will know Greek and Hebrew and not everybody will have studied church history so you have a hard task ahead of you it's much much easier for me to teach church history to this class that it is to teach it to junior high school students but if we love the people that we are sent to serve if we love them if we truly love them will do the hard work that Calvin urges us to do so that we can speak to them and so they can understand the wonderful truths that we want to impart Calvin put it this way in his commentary on Romans we must therefore consider what questions each is able to bear at a accommodate our doctrine to the capacity of the individual so wonderful book Calvin's institute and I hope you will read it not once in your life but perhaps several times let me end this lecture with a word from Calvin may the Lord grant that we may contemplate the mysteries of his heavenly wisdom with truly increasing devotion to his glory and to our edification okay right on target 10 minutes now we can talk about Calvin or anything that we've done so far you know we're gradually making our way toward an exam so forget about that yes Greg I think it's best just to start on page one and keep going you know there are there are compendiums where you get certain selections from the institutes but you miss so much that way the one thing I would say though is read the battles translation don't try to go through it in one of the older 19th century translations be sure you get what's called the McNeil battles edition in the Library of Christian classics two volumes in that published by used to be called Westminster press as a new name now press material publishing house or something like that yes Heidi Calvin put the doctrine of sanctification before justification I think in the polemical context in which he was writing with so many people saying Protestants don't put much stock on love and obedience Calvin just wanted to startle his readers by saying faith and now this is what faith produces in our lives we love the Lord and we love our neighbors and we do these things and then when he's got that pretty well firmly in mind he feels free to go back and talk about justification out of order logically but again because of his concern for teaching you know a lot of people Calvin felt as soon as they moved from faith to justification are going to not go any further so if I can show a link between the Holy Spirit who gives us faith and the result in our lives then I've got him for another chapter and then he will get into justification that's my reading other people perhaps some a different way but it is rather surprising Calvin isn't all that concerned about what we call the ordos salutis he is in a certain way but he doesn't feel bound to always say things in exactly the same order that doesn't mean that he thinks sanctification comes before justification but it means that in the process of teaching he felt that in his context it was better to do it this way yes did Calvin ever make any changes in the Geneva confession the changes that he made were more in the line of what I'm just describing the theology doesn't change but we can see quite a difference between Calvin's earlier efforts in catechisms and confession for Geneva church in his first visit and then after his return from Strasbourg and I think what happens there is that Calvin comes into Geneva for all these in his 20s late 20s and he's never done anything like this before and he's a very smart man and he's not naturally very patient so he expected too much and you can see that his early writings of what people are to learn and memorize and understand seem far advanced to his later writings he's able to do what I was just saying he's able to accommodate the teaching to the level of the people he did do that at first it took the Strasbourg years to teach him at last Dan's question is related to Calvin's doctrine of election was that a distinctive mark of Calvin's teaching in his own time or is it viewed later by later scholars as a distinctive mark let me just say this and then I'll get more directly into the question two things that people think they know about Calvin who really don't know much about Calvin and that includes a lot of scholars and university professors and important people who write books one is Calvin burns the Vedas two is he created a horrible doctrine called predestination well we've already talked about Calvin's burning of servitas and that was indeed a tragedy and sad and it's nothing we can really say about that except it's wrong and Calvin is implicated in that by on the point that you just raised first thing to say is that of course Calvin did not create this doctrine Luther had taught it in very much the same way in his bondage of the will and they were both getting it out of a guest in who was getting it out of Paul but Calvin is more organized about it he does hold to what we call double predestination because of the horrible doctrine by horrible that's the wrong translation of the Latin word because that seems to mean that God is horrible but when Calvin uses the word horrible he means it is awesome it is something that we almost can't handle but he doesn't pull back from it now some people do pull back from it and the question is should we pull back from it Calvin doesn't think so now he does you know he does put it in that particular place in book three but when he gets they are it's fully developed and he says everything that we know as Calvinism in that place and he writes books on it elsewhere and he preaches sermons on it so it's not a minor point in Calvin it's not unimportant it's very important but it should function the way it functions in the institute to give glory to God and to cause us to be humbled in the presence of God but because Calvin is so persistent and so clear he does get a reputation of being somebody who is a teacher of election and he is the next question though is do the Calvinist follow Calvin faithfully in this or do they develop the doctrine further and I'm not going to answer that one yet because we'll have to look at that a little bit later but strangely enough it you don't think of Luther as the great teacher of election but he is and you don't think of Calvin as the great exponent of justification by faith but he is John Gerstner used to give a lecture called Luther the great Calvinist and you could give a lecture called Calvin the Great Lutheran so that was not a point of difference in the first generation of the reformers. Next time we'll look at the English reformation