<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Daanu Daanu mensuel

Discussion: John Stott's "Cross of Christ"

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

got our work cut out for us and let's begin. First of all, overview, we have studied the biblical teachings concerning human beings, sin, and then the person of Christ, and our schedule tonight calls for us to conclude the work of Christ before we begin next class with the application of salvation. Let's do the quiz, first of all. Did I hear some moans and groans about that quiz? I am still searching for said quiz. Thank you, have problems. I can borrow years. Well, I had one up here with the answers, and not only the answers, I think I could probably guess most of those right, but the page numbers. Well, when I went to seminary, they said they trained us to pray, preach, or die at a moment's notice. No, I don't have answers. Well, I have questions, and I'm sorry I won't be able to give you page numbers. Hopefully, I won't give you wrong answers. You can correct me if I do abysmally on any of these, but true or false, according to John Stott. Yes, I'm stalling because I even lost my questions here. I know what I'll do. I'll go to my extra. I will make the page numbers available to anybody who wants them. I have a feeling where my quiz is, but it isn't here. Put it that way. True or false, according to Stott, 37 true or false questions. Wow. Crucifixion was regarded with horror. It's well for you too. I do have good news for you. I do have good news, although there are 37. I'm only counting. It'll be a numerator over a denominator of 35. So you can miss two and still get 100. How's that for a, how's that for an age of grace? Okay. Crucifixion was regarded with horror in the ancient world. True, it was certainly the case. We have misunderstood the cross, not because we use it for jewelry and so forth. It's not wrong, but we need to take to understand the horror and then do that. It's like wearing a guillotine or electric chair around your neck, a little symbol of that. It was a terrible instrument of torture and death as John Stott accurately pointed out. By the way, are you glad you read this? Could anybody finish the book? Couldn't restrain yourself. When the course is over, anybody planned? God, there we go. I'm glad we have an honest group at tonight. Jesus did not die of his own choice. False, of course, he did. He died willingly. Thus we have to view his death both in terms of God's sovereign control and human responsibility. It was a terrible crime, but it also was the plan of God unfolded. Three, because Judas betrayal of Jesus was foretold in Scripture, he is not to be regarded as responsible for the betrayal. False, of course. It was foretold, but he is also responsible. How can we hold these things together? Both God's sovereignty and human responsibility. I can just tell you, we have to. In fact, that one verse hasn't both together. Is it Luke 22? The son of man will go as it has been decreed. There's God's control, but woe to that man who betrays him. There's real human, not only responsibility, but culpability at the same time. So my thesis is following the a Carson and a couple of his writings is that divine sovereignty and human responsibility are woven into the very fabric of both old and new testament. Those writings are Carson's book, divine sovereignty and human responsibility. A simpler way to get into that book is the chapter on the mystery of God's providence in the book How Long O Lord. There's a good chapter introducing this concept of compatibilism called the mystery of God's providence in how long a Lord then read the bigger one, divine sovereignty and human responsibility. Number four, we must attribute Jesus' death simultaneously to the plan of God and to the wickedness of human beings. It is true. It is true indeed. The Roman soldiers were guilty. The officials, both Jewish and Gentile were guilty. The Jewish leaders at the time were guilty. Any occasions that Gentiles have taken throughout history to base anti-Semitism upon the death of our Lord is a terrible mistake. And sadly, it has been done. It is certainly the leaders. Part of it is the expression in John's Gospel, the Jews, which ordinarily means the Jewish leaders, the Jewish authorities and not the people as a whole because Jesus, of course, loved the people and died for Jew and Gentile alike. Five, human death is not a natural but a penal event. True. Adam and Eve were not made to die. Death was a result of sin as Romans 5-12 teaches. Six, it is exaggerating to say that in the last supper Jesus viewed his death as a divinely appointed sacrifice by which the new covenant with its promise of forgiveness will be ratified. False, it is not exaggerating. The first three gospels do not teach a full-blown doctrine of the atonement but the raw materials are there. Mostly, the event of Jesus' death and resurrection is there but the seeds of the teaching are already planted and that is both in the saying of Jesus that the son of man did not come to be served but to serve and give his life a ransom for many, the so-called ransom saying and then the sayings at that last supper, the so-called Eucharistic sayings of Jesus. Both of those lay a foundation that Paul and the other biblical writers, John as well, writer to the Hebrews and Peter, build upon. Seven, the cup from which Jesus shrank in Gethsemane was the emotional and physical trauma of crucifixion. False, it was the cup of the wrath of God. It was far more than just this emotional and physical trauma which was real and which was terrible. It was much more the prospect of dying and paying the penalty for sins. We've talked about the legal picture of the atonement. Eight, the cross of Christ shows the gravity of our sins. It is true because the cross was necessary. It shows what God needed to do in order for us to enjoy forgiveness. The words of Enselm, around 1100, around the year 1100, ring true today, when in light of his opponents arguing it was not necessary for God to become a man and to die, Enselm said, you have not yet considered the seriousness, the severity of sin. That is exactly the problem. It is certainly the problem of moderns, of modern men and women who conceive of God along the lines that Packer called a Santa Claus theology. God is the great grandfather in the sky who loves everybody and certainly isn't holy and just and would never judge anyone. The Bible's picture is far different. God is both holy and just and loving and he bears in himself the brunt of the punishment that our sins deserve. So the cross shows many things. It shows the love of God and the justice of God and the wisdom of God and so forth. It also does show the depth of our need. It shows our sins offence to God who did not spare his own son to save us. Nine, scripture consistently treats human beings as morally responsible agents. True. I wanted to save page such and such but can't do it. I do not have the book memorized. An acknowledgement of human guilt before God diminishes the dignity of human beings. False, just the contrary. It is the first step toward the kingdom of God and it magnifies God's own holiness and is the beginning to our regaining our dignity. For our dignity is not found in rebellion against God but in the humility of faith and in seeing our need and our utter need of the grace of God given in Christ. 11 because human anger is so often tainted by sin. It is wise never to speak of God's anger or wrath. False because we don't go from below and project human emotions on God. We start above and the Bible speaks of God as loving, hating and being jealous and we're careful not to read human distortions of those emotions into God but to accept the Bible's picture of the way God is and he is a God of wrath in the face of sin and rebellion. Not out of control human wrath but indeed control a controlled divine holy hatred of sin. So we need to be careful that we go from the top down and not from the bottom up. 12 all inadequate doctrines of the atonement are due to inadequate doctrines of God and man. True according to start I don't disagree perhaps somebody could find an exception but that is a general rule especially inadequate doctrines of God. Any doctrine of God that would result in people holding that there is no need for the atonement is most inadequate indeed and as we saw last time when we surveyed the history of the doctrine of the atonement that has oftentimes been the case and I told you a couple ways to take the temperature of somebody's understanding of the cross number one to ask where it's directed. Is it merely directed toward human beings to change our minds and to bring us to repentance or whatever to change our feelings or is it directed toward God himself and also the question of the necessity of the cross was it necessary for God to become a man and to die in our place those views that hold it was not necessary are certainly sub biblical and sub Christian. 13 Anselm taught that the major effect of Christ death was to move the hearts of sinners to love God now that's Abelard it's false the major effect of Christ death was to satisfy the offended honor of God the great feudal lord in Anselm's picture of the atonement in his famous work Cordeus Homo or why God became a man why the God man 14 for God to be able to forgive sinners he himself needed to be satisfied in his inner being it is true this is a little different nuance then in Selmic satisfaction it is in his inner being in terms of his justice and his whole especially his holiness applied which is his justice if I miss one don't be afraid of correcting me okay I'd rather be embarrassed than have all of you mixed up so I easily could miss one I'm working on memory here and didn't read the book real recently but it's a wonderful book there are a few things and I remember most of it I hope there are a few things in God himself incompatible with his true deity false of course that would mean a illogical God now he is super super rational if you will he goes beyond the ability to understand but he's not self contradictory he is truth and there's nothing in God incompatible with God that's nonsense there are many things in God that far transcend human ability to understand amen the Bible itself affirms it Christ death is rarely presented as a sacrifice in the New Testament some have claimed that but it is certainly false it is commonly presented as a sacrifice in the New Testament already there are hints of it in the last supper sayings we have it presented that way in the gospel of John the John the Baptist says in chapter one of John's gospel behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world Paul does it that way in a number of places and Hebrews is loaded with sacrificial terminology as is the book of Revelation 1 Peter 1 16 is certainly false 17 theologians have successfully in italics retained the vocabulary of substitution while rejecting penal substitution they did it but not successfully in stock estimation he is right thus its false number 17 is false there's kind of a there was and it still continues an anti legal atmosphere whereby the legal notions of the biblical faith were attacked God as judge sin as violation of the law of God the atonement understood in penal terms a notion of the last judgment and God as judge now it would be unfair to it would be a misrepresentation of the Christian faith to say any one of those is the only way of looking at God sin the cross or the last judgment but it is also wrong to try to purge that element out that that actually constitutes creating our own religion and making the Bible answerable to our own likes and in this case dislikes I give Lewis Perk off a lot of credit he has the penal the legal penal dimensions all the way through his theology book but for the most and he overplays it a little bit but for the most part he has a richer and fuller treatment whereby those things don't dominate so the only way he does not define sin only as breaking the law understand what I'm saying and his day would be easy to do it because of the attacks on the legal aspects of the Christian faith law is one of the ways God presents himself as law giver as our need as Christ meeting our need as salvation in terms of justification you take law out of justification and it's it's meaningless justification is God the judge declaring guilty sinners righteous because of the righteousness of the son of God and likewise there is a big last judgment motif in scripture in which God's people will be publicly justified declared righteous and the wicked will be publicly condemned God will settle accounts he will do things right that was 17 18 Jesus applied Isaiah 53 to himself it is true it is true 19 the father and son should be separated when we are thinking about the atonement false according to stock and I basically agree they should be I certainly agree distinguished but the Trinity can never be separated distinguished but never separated 20 in the cross divine love triumphed over divine wrath by divine self sacrifice I could see people answering true or false stop says it's a quotation from the book so it's true you are supposed to be arrested by the catchy saying okay understand some have said what do you mean triumph over it sounds like God's against himself in it it sounds like that previous one about contradiction within a divine essence 15 well again this might be one of the two that you end up chucking but it is catchy it's possible of misinterpretation with me but the way he does it in the cross divine love triumphed over divine wrath not unjustly but justly by divine self sacrifice I confess to you the cross of Christ alone viewed exactly from this perspective is a an apologetic for the Christian faith no human beings would make up this way of salvation human religion goes like this it talks about human beings earning God's favor or modern human religion has little concern for the afterlife and says we're all okay there's no such thing as a man made religion that has a notion of God becoming a human being and doing for the human race what sinners could not do for themselves know that theory was made up if you will in heaven and was accomplished on earth so remember the old dictum if you're looking at your wounds right now if you missed one you'll learn best the ones you missed you say I'm learning a lot tonight I'll be an expert next time 21 it is impossible to hold to the historic doctrine of the cross without holding to the historic doctrine of the person of Christ it is true number 21 21 and 12 both point in the direction of the coherence of the Christian faith hey John stop is very biblical he works with the Bible but he also is theological and sees connections between teachings with me and both of those questions 15 was the other one nope that's wrong 12 yes 12 where he relates the doctrine of the cross the doctrines of God and human beings and now 21 where he connects the person and work of Christ his instincts are good his instincts are very good if you have a defective doctrine of Christ you necessarily have a defective doctrine of the atonement if we reject the fact that God became a human being then what Jesus did on the cross is not able to rescue us as we see in the coats as we see in liberal Protestantism and even liberal Catholicism 22 there is no sense in which God needed to be propitiated false there is a godly sense in which God needed to be propitiated not in the pagan sense of appreciation of God demanding his pound of flesh or some notion of a bloodthirsty deity but in the fact that God is holy and just and is unable to forgive without satisfying his own holy anger it doesn't it make you just great very thankful for the cross and for what the Savior did when you'd look your sin in the face and see the punishment that you deserve namely hell and then see Jesus taking the equivalent of hell obviously if he were still suffering eternal conscious punishment on the cross he couldn't save anybody so there was a substitution in three hours the god man suffered the equivalent of eternal punishment it is because of who he is the infinite finite one the creator creature the god man that he was able to make that substitution I'm not pretending to understand the divine mathematics in the matter okay but there was a substitutionary atonement there is a sense in which God needed to be propitiated Romans three and which he was propitiated there is of course not a sense in which he needed to be propitiated and that would be pagan notions of propitiation 23 the New Testament never presses the imagery of redemption to the point of telling us to whom the ransom was paid I would answer true I forget he says true as well is that right some concluded that it's paid to God I know he rejects the notion of any ransom paid to the devil do I stand corrected on this one okay the New Testament never presses that presses that imagery it is true one could conclude and not be outside the bounds of orthodoxy that it was paid to God but the Bible doesn't say and if you make that step or any other step beyond what the Bible says my own method would say label that step it is a deduction it is not bad to make deductions everybody makes them in fact if you think everything you hold is of equal weight and equally biblical you're fooling yourself but label your deductions deductions because if you make deductions from your deductions that is less reliable than the first order biblical teachings understand what I'm saying I'm nervous about big superstructures and the ninth story of the building when only the foundation was actually based upon the Bible and then it was this was based upon an inference based upon that inference upon that inference pretty soon you're your eight steps removed from scripture and sometimes we fight as fiercely for the superstructure as we do for the foundation that ought not to be anyway 23 was true 24 Christ blood does not stand for his death but for the release of his life false stock correctly disagrees with a couple of his fellow brits who taught this and influenced many people Leon Morris in the apostolic preaching of the cross showed that the biblical metaphor of blood in this context speaks of a violent death of sacrificial victims in the Old Testament and even of the Son of God in the New 25 justification is the opposite of pollution false it's the opposite of condemnation sanctification is the opposite of pollution or corruption so 25 as it stands is false

26 since the publication of Hans Cohn's book justification there has been widespread spread proclamation of justification by grace alone through faith alone in the Roman Catholic Church true of course just teasing I couldn't even get you could I on that one as a matter of fact I commend to you a wonderful book 20th century theology it is called 20th century theology if you want to be if you want to be appraised of the development the major developments of theology in the western world in the 20th century from the enlightenment to the present day Stanley Grens and Roger Olson's book 20th century theology is outstanding there's a chapter on Roman Catholic developments the two representatives are Carl Rander and Hans Cohn and Grens and Olson are models at treating people fairly from their own writings so they say some good things about Cohn but in the very end they end up with the last sentence is Ronner's assessment of Cohn that Cohn ended up to all effects a liberal Protestant and that is really true and it was true on his doctrine of justification Rome did not follow Cohn in his adoption of Bart and the reformers concerning justification we give him credit for being teachable of God's word but as you probably know his credentials were taken away and because of this and other teachings he is no longer an official professor of the Roman Catholic church training people for ministry he stole professor at Tubingon and he was afraid in that book it gives some local color he was on vacation when the pronouncement came from Rome that he had lost he was no longer an official teacher of the church he came home from vacation he rushed home afraid he might be losing his job or whatever he had no fears his classes doubled overnight students he was more popular than ever students wanted to learn from a renegade that was standing room only in his lectures he did not seek that and didn't intend to rebel against the church but indeed he had sufficiently rejected the Pope's authority for example and I thought a Protestant doctrine of justification almost a Protestant doctrine of justification to get himself disenfranchised by Rome 27 justification should not be separated from union with Christ it is true you could almost fill in the blank and say any aspect of the doctrine of salvation should not be separated from union with Christ any Asian if you will justification or any other Asian sanctification you want to put in there glorification 28 Christ reconciled the cosmic powers by disarming them I forget I will say true this has been variously handled a very difficult thing in law the notion of the pacification ff Bruce calls it the reconciliation of the cosmic powers it's difficult because there's no notion in the bible of angels being saved being forgiven yes cosmic powers mean yes the demons the evil angels yes it's a difficulty a couple of Pauline passages remember Peter himself said that Paul has some things in his writings hard to understand uh start understands this reconciliation not to be salvation but rather disarming those powers so there's peace in that sense there's peace in the conquering army taking away the weapons of the other army okay not that anybody is not that there's salvation uh it's an it's an enforced peace if you will uh I admit it's difficult and I'm not perfectly satisfied with any explanation I have seen it's easier to criticize other people's explanations than to offer a good one uh I might say a better one 29 god did not need to be reconciled to us false there is a sense that gods need that god need to be reconciled and that was the ground of our being reconciled that is things were not right between him and us understand true scripture never says it exactly in those words but it is implied scripture says we were reconciled to him that's true but do you mean to say there was perfect peace between him and us the problem was only on our side that sounds like a subjective view the atonement doesn't it and it is that I use the expression the the terminology objective and subjective last time did I somebody on the break uh ask me about it I'll do it again objective views of the atonement say something took place outside of us okay purely subjective views say the work of Christ is only directed toward us to change our attitudes change our thoughts our feelings something within us objective means outside of us something happened outside of us whether we believe it or not for example uh orthodoxy traditionally says the bible on the table unopened is the word of god whether I believe it or read it or not okay neo-orthodoxy pretty much said it is the word of god as the instrument of god apprehending me and even a few times the writers use the what has become a cliche that it becomes the word of god as the spirit uses it as his chief medium there's a subjective view of revelation revelation as encounter uh there's some truth to that but it is first of all true the bible on the table opened or unopened is the word of god and then it's true to say god uses it as his instrument of encountering us uh but you don't deny objectivity in the name of subjectivity likewise the cross does influence the people of god but at its base it is it took it did something it accomplished something outside of us even in the life of god himself because that is true then it does change us understand and because god reconciles himself in the work of his son then he reconciles us too because god is propitiated in christ's sacrifice then we are forgiven and we can enjoy peace of conscience and mind but it's not because the cross is chiefly designed to change our minds or to give us peace that is a wonderful byproduct of the divine direction of the cross this is a long quiz indeed yes yes it is both uh reconciliation is peacemaking it assumes for each of these biblical metaphors there is a background that illustrates the need for justification it's condemnation for redemption it's bondage or slavery for reconciliation it is enmity it is alienation it is a strange mint and it is true we were far away from god now it's not true in the same sense he was far away from us he didn't sin against us but it is true there was no peace between us and him and it also is true he was not he did not look favorably on us I mean all together of course he did or he wouldn't have sent his son with me but the backdrop for the sending of the son is that we were in trouble with a holy god there was enmity coming from his direction too it's not equivalent to ours ours is unjustified we were rebels against our maker his was entirely justified and in fact if he didn't have a holy hatred of sin he would not be god he would not be a morally perfect being that he is so reconciliation is twofold fundamentally the work of Christ in reconciliation is directed to make peace toward a holy god himself secondarily and very importantly for us it makes peace with us so Romans 5.1 is so wonderful therefore having been justified by faith we have peace with god through the Lord Jesus Christ doesn't mean as many moderns take it and even evangelical Christians are kind of duped by psychology and psychological categories just permeating the church a lot of pastors are at fault in substituting those for biblical categories I'm not against all psychology but to to to understand guilt as primarily guilt feelings is to shoot ourselves in the foot the peace that's spoken of in Romans 5.1 we have peace with god is not the same thing as Philippians 4.6 and 7 a heart felt peace which is important okay it's wonderful if you could put it in the bottle and sell it you'll be a millionaire overnight honestly but you can't it's a byproduct of peace that peace of heart is a byproduct of peace of relationship and what Romans 5.1 means not does not mean that for primarily we have peace in our hearts it primarily means there is now a state of peace between a holy god and us sinners he has made peace between himself and us and us and himself in the work of his son Christ is our peacemaker because god is no longer mad at me because of my sins because I am now reconciled to him oh then I can have peace in my heart all day long as long as I walk with him but the miracle is the obstacle has been taken away and the obstacle is not just my own unbelief or hard heart or indifferent toward god or insensitivity to spiritual things the problem is there's a holy god in heaven who is angry at sinners and the miracle of grace is that in Christ god bore the brunt of his own wrath so that he could remain as holy as he ever has been and we could be forgiven that's viewed in different ways biblically in terms of reconciliation it's viewed that god takes the aliens and makes them into his daughters and sons through his son who made the peace the biblical metaphor extends to the first century racial antagonism between Jews and Gentiles Christ broke down the wall of partition we think it was the wall in the in the synagogue or in the temple that kept the Gentiles out now the dogs of the Gentiles can enter into the holy place and the holy things of god and no god even as Jews can know god through the Messiah the Lord Jesus Christ it's a good question I hope the answer is satisfying 30 in John the cross is a manifestation of God's glory ironically it is true ironically it is true it seems to contradict question number one the crucifixion was horrific in the ancient world oh it was Roman citizens were exempt runaway slaves were crucified as examples seeing them hanging naked on a cross expiring or expired was such a stigma in the ancient world a terrible terrible thing now how can John possibly in the see the cross as a demonstration of god's glory is the morbid way what's going on here Paul does the same thing we talk about glorying in the cross don't miss the shock of it it'd be like saying glorying in the guillotine glorying in the electric chair or the hangman's news what's going on here because of the one who died on the cross the cross indeed means not glory for him but glory for us through his stripes we are healed as Isaiah said long ago I read today read so many things I lost track some letter some was it was a publication of a gentleman with a Jewish background who was really hostile toward Christianity being led to the Lord by a friend reading Isaiah 53 to him and the guy really got mad he didn't know where it was coming from he said anybody sitting at the foot of the cross could have written that he was just hot he thought it was a Christian writing and he said let me show you where this is from it was from Isaiah 53 and the guy he said he was converted at that point it was incredible he went from absolute hatred to boom he was just god read his mind as it were god just opened him up it was an incredible thing this mention of Isaiah triggered that 31 so so the cross is is both in John it's horror and it's glory and that's it's it's wonder it was a terrible thing for the son of god but his suffering is our glory 31 although in his forbearance god had temporarily left sins unpunished now injustice he has punished them in Christ it is true this is what Romans three is all about 25 and 26 and the doctrine of propitiation in Old Testament times and in New Testament times right up until the cross this is how Joseph and Mary could be called righteous people not because they they kept the law and earned God's favor nobody ever did but because God in his forbearance had temporarily left in this case their sins unpunished now God sets matters straight now he settles accounts now he demonstrates his justice in punishing his son with the punishment that our sins deserved 32 Peter Abelard is the father of the mortal influence theory of the atonement it is true 33 Gustaf Alain's Christus victor argued for the importance of the mortal influence theory of the atonement false indeed I didn't talk about this before did I just a matter of time this is the most influential book on the cross in this century Gustaf Alain is from a Scandinavian thematic school of theology and the theme that he picked up was the theme of victory he correctly saw that Christ death was presented as a victory as victory in a New Testament he set that against the raining liberal notion of his time which was the mortal influence theory okay he also unfortunately set it against the raining conservative view at the time that Christ died to pay the penalty of our sins in terms of a legal picture he was right in seeing victory and the words Christus victor mean Christ the champion those words have come in the Christian theology we talk about a Christus victor motif Christ the champion and just they have just come in it's as the the blurb on the on the cover of the book says this is a theological a modern classic the book really is important it has problems as well the good thing is he emphasized a theme that had been neglected by liberals and conservatives alike the bad part is he said it was the only theme in Irenaeus in Luther in the New Testament can you imagine he says that Hebrews is mainly about Christ the victor no Hebrews is mainly about Christ the priest and the sacrifice so there's a reductionism in his method but still there's a lot of good and it is a very important book he certainly did not argue for the importance of the moral influence theory he argued for the importance of the Christus victor theory he called it the dramatic theory in which Christ and his death and especially resurrection conquers the powers the world Satan the grave hell the law and any other enemy you can name and he's right it's just he over emphasizes one correct idea to the disparagement of other correct ideas 34 in the cross the conquest of our enemies was achieved and consummated false the consummation awaits the second coming of Christ I could see you answering this as true but remember you've got to to spend here's your other one Yang here's your other one the conquest was achieved the conquest was not consummated in its final in its fullest sense I've used the imagery before of D day and V day have I not in this class the cross is like D day the allies landed on the beaches of Normandy the jig was up the the war was over but lots of lives were lost in between that and the Japanese surrender on V day okay likewise the the the chest image of a stubborn opponent you've just captured his queen he's a goner and he reasonable person would flip over his king and give it up he makes you play on and he's tricky enough to make you play on for hours and take every pawn the devil's like that okay he has lost the battle the war but the battles go on and he he forces a cleanup operation as if you will the imagery is not perfect the devil is not God's equal okay he's a renegade servant of God and God will win but there's something in those pictures of an already and not yet already the devil's been vanquished not yet hasn't been cast into the lake of fire we ought not to ascribe saving efficacy to both Christ's death and resurrection equally uh oh we ought not to ascribe saving efficacy to both Christ's death and resurrection equally if I understand him correctly my memory starts to correctly he says true I disagree with him he downplays the resurrection of Christ he needs to discover and in the book is wonderful okay I feel like a hummingbird pecking at an elephant's ear or something here I mean he's the giant okay I'm a little you know a little nothing here I mean he is really it's a great book it is a great book it's easy to criticize his great book but that Richard Gaffin's book resurrection and redemption shows that the resurrection of Christ is if possible equal as almost as important as the cross maybe he's technically right the cross is more important but Calvin was right too they're inseparable so I I would fault him at least here for emphasis the correct answer is it's a good question according to start true 35 we ought to ascribe more efficacy to Christ's death than to his resurrection we need to finish up here take a break and I'll entertain questions after the break because Christ has set us free from the law Christians have no obligation to obey God's law you won't let me fool you on this one so I'll just say false they do have obligation they've got more obligation because they're now sons and daughters of God I want to please him and do his will and honor their father 37 because Christ died for our sicknesses as well as for our sins there is healing in the atonement I don't mean to be funny but I forget what he says I could answer true it would be ultimately he says false okay he's thinking pen ultimately understand there is healing in the atonement ultimately we're going to be resurrected but immediately it's false to say that you can claim it and that type of stuff so 37 is false according to start thank you for helping me give me a number correct over 35 so if you miss too you still got 35 over 35 or if you want to wait till after our break and we'll haggle with you who I'll be happy to talk about clarifications and problems that you have but for now it is break time