I thank you for your patience on this difficult topic. It is difficult. Let me tell you as a group, but I told one person in private already, that is there's no reason we have to make up your mind tonight or next week of the week after, okay? If it's as important as some of us think, and if good people have come down both sides of it, there's no reason why you couldn't take a good time to make up your mind. Again, I'll tell you, you'll never be graded on your conclusions, okay? There is your own before God, but I'll also tell you I do teach to persuade. So I leave you to your own conscious before God. Structure of the passage in Ephesians 1, 3 to 14. There seems to be a trinitarian structure revealed to us as we attend to the expression to the praise of his glorious grace in verse 6, and then what I take to be shorthand for that in verses 12 and 14, to the praise of his glory. The Father is praise for his work of election, the Son for his work of redemption, and the Spirit for his ministry of sealing. What is the purpose of the passage? To tell us what he was doing before creation? In part, a little bit, it's a bigger purpose than that. In light of the refrain, what's the purpose? Answer that we might praise the trinity. Here's what I'm saying, the purpose of the doctrine of the doctrines of election, redemption and sealing, are that we might praise the trinity for our salvation. So if you're a person who works as doctrine or hers out to the nth degree, you have all the right answers, but you're not filled with praise to God for his salvation and for his grace. Now I suggest you go back again and work it out again. Understand? We could treat it in a doctrineary manner, in a theoretical manner, in a merely academic manner. Now it is academic. We don't apologize for thinking, but we want to think under the lordship of Christ. We want to think in the power of the Holy Spirit under the word of God. If we do that, even if we disagree. If we give God all the glory for our salvation, the purpose of the passage is fulfilled in our lives. I don't mean to equivocate. I certainly think that we will better praise the lord if we understand these things correctly. What is the timing of election according to this passage? Yes, the timing of election is given to us plainly in verse four, for he chose us in Christ in him before the creation of the world. I will come back to the expression in Christ, because it's one of the ways Armenians try to handle the passage and be able to fit it with their own theology. The timing of election is plainly before creation. Question. Why does the lord tell us that he chose us before creation? Yes, Tim? I think that's a pretty good answer. Why did the lord tell us he chose us before creation? Answer so that we would be careful to realize that we didn't have anything to do with it. I think that's right. I don't rest my case on unconditional election on that reasoning, but he told us that he chose us before creation for a purpose. It seems to me it's God's way of taking our hands off of it, of pointing to a time, if you will, when only the Trinity existed. Yes, William? Well said, I especially like your qualification. One person shared is this for the benefit of those taken to course by extension, who can't the out in the audience and hear all the questions. I need to repeat them for their sex especially, but for all of us to have it by way of remembrance and repetition. If someone said coming from an Armenian background, which emphasized the freedom of the will, if this is true that it is all of God's grace, that is his choice of us ultimately, rather than our choice of him, we choose him, of course, but ultimately we choose him because he chose us, is the reformed understanding. Then that takes the pressure off. It takes my pressure off to perform, to do, and then it was a beautiful qualification that William gave. It doesn't take all my responsibility away. I agree with that completely, you said it very well. Indeed, we can rest not in our easy chair, but we can rest in God's grace even in the midst of vigorous activity. That is, we repose in him and his grace given to us. In fairness, can't all Christians do that? Amen. All Christians should do that. Notice that unlike the Old Testament presentation, which is a corporate election of Israel, this is an election unto salvation. We see it in verse four. When it says he chose us in Christ, to be holy and blameless in his sight. This is what we call sanctification. It could be initial, progressive, or final sanctification. I understand it in context, especially in light of the parallel in Colossians 1, to be final sanctification. I think the meaning is, and chose us before the creation of the world, that we might ultimately be holy and blameless in his sight. In any case, it's plain, the election is on the salvation. The same thing is shown in verse five with reference to the doctrine of adoption in love, and therefore he predestined us to be adopted as his sons through Jesus Christ. Adoption is a wonderful and neglected teaching. Its background is that we are by nature, by our sinful nature, children of the devil. We were enslaved. Galatians four tells us, but God who is rich in mercy predestined us to be adopted as his sons and daughters through Jesus Christ. Galatians 4, 4 presents Christ as the unique son of God, the capital S. He's the son of God by nature. We are sons and daughters of God by grace because of his work on the cross, especially in this context presented as a redemption, same picture used here in verse seven. Redemption means buying out the slaves because of Christ's work of redemption. We are no longer slaves, but we are now the sons and daughters of the living God. Romans eight and Galatians four of the great passages in the Bible on adoption. There are many other passages that mention it. Those are the two big ones, but here already in Ephesians one. Romans eight, 14 through 17, Galatians four through seven, or you can even go back to Galatians three, 26, which says you are all sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus. Adoption is similar to justification in this way. It is by means of faith, but that faith is not the ultimate reason we are adopted. The ultimate reason is given here in Ephesians one. In love, God predestined us to be adopted as his sons and daughters through Jesus Christ. The election is unto salvation. It is plain. It is not the corporate election of Israel as is presented in the Old Testament. It is corporate in a sense. It is election of the church. I don't deny that, but it is an election of individuals who comprise the church. It is they alone who are redeemed, who have redemption through Christ blood, verse seven, of forgiveness of sins. It is to believers alone, verse 13 is very plain. Having believed you were sealed in him with a seal, the promised Holy Spirit. The election here is corporate, but it's also individual, onto the corporate election of the church. As a matter of fact, the election spoken of here includes Jews and Gentile Christians. That's the meaning in verse 12 in order that we who were the first to hope in Christ and Jewish believers might be for the praise of his glory, and you also were included in Christ. It means the Gentile recipients of this letter. As you probably know, it's a circular letter we think. The oldest manuscripts, some of them don't have the words in Ephesus. We think there was a blank there and it went to different cities in Asia Minor, perhaps Colossian Leodicea and Ephesus, and the Ephesians put their names in there as was a good thing for them to do. So different Gentile congregations are involved, although there were some Jews in those congregations as well, of course. The basis of election in this passage is twofold. It's based upon God's love and the pawn his will. We see his love spoken of here in a number of places. Well, once explicitly, in verse 4, there's a problem here in terms of punctuation. The manuscripts of the Greek New Testament do not include punctuation. You say, how could people read them then? If you were raised that way, and if I was, we would not have read and would put commas and so forth in there just by experience with me, by getting, but by getting used to it, listening to our parents and other people speak, we would learn how to do it, how to write that way. There's a debate, not too serious, once it's the major translations I usually consult all include the words in love with the beginning of verse 5, but it is possible those words begin belong at the end of verse 4, and we'd read, he chose us in Christ before the creation of the world to be holy and blameless in his sight in love. It's a little awkward, it certainly speaks of us being holy and blameless in his sight. In love, I suppose would mean we would be perfectly and finally in love with him, it's not impossible, but it's a little awkward, so perhaps for that reason, the new international version, revised standard version, and new American standard Bible unanimously put the words in love with verse 5, I would take them that way. In love he predestined us to be adopted as his sons and daughters. The basis of election is love, we found that in Deuteronomy although it was election of the nation, I understand, but God's loving and choosing of Israel went side by it, went hand in hand, so it is here we have his love. The idea of love of a gracious election is also implied in the notion of adoption, because adoption involves God setting his great love upon us, think of first John 31, how great is the love the Father has lavished on us that we should be called children of God, and that is what we are. So the very word adoption speaks of God's love for us, his children, but we also have explicitly God's love. God's will is what is emphatic in the passage however, although I wouldn't really separate them both are involved. They answer the question ultimately why are we saved. Answer God's sovereignty and his love, his grace and his will and so forth. Show me you say I have heard people say this passage teaches election, but it doesn't tell us why God chose. Well, I beg to disagree. In love he predestined us verse 5 to be adopted as his sons through Jesus Christ in accordance with his pleasure and his will. There's God's will spoken of. It is the same in verse I'll just skip down and do verse 11. In him it's in Christ we were also chosen having been predestined is hard to find stronger language than this. In him we were also chosen having been predestined according to the plan of him who works out everything in conformity with the purpose of his will. That's a hard one to get around. I'll tell you the way Arminian Christians try to heal the passage as a matter of fact next, but for now likewise verse 9 speaks of the mystery of his will. It is mysterious and God hasn't told us everything about it, but I believe that which is implied in John, gospel of John, in book of Acts is made explicit in Paul that why did God choose us to save us because he chose to do it and because he loved us. Why did he love me? I can't answer that. I can just tell you not because of anything in you wonderful person that you are, but because of a lot of a couple of things in him because he is a gracious God who chose of his own will to make us his people. Here is a datum, a piece of information in the text that is customarily appealed to by Arminian Theologians as a way around the strong emphasis on God's sovereignty. Repeatedly the passage says that God chose us in him or in Christ when it says in him the pronoun certainly refers to Christ. How do they construe this? They construe it this way. In Christ means that God chose us in prospect of our believing in the Lord Jesus Christ. Again God chose us taking into account our response to the gospel is a way of fitting the passage into a free will theology. Is that what in Christ means? My answer is no it's not what it means as a matter of fact throughout the passage we have that language. More than these times watch. Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ who has blessed us in the heavenly realms with every spiritual blessing in Christ. Number one for each of us in him number two verse four before the creation of the world to be holy and blameless in his sight. In love he predestined us to be adopted as his sons through Jesus Christ and accordance with his pleasure and will through the praise of his glorious grace which he has freely given us that grace in the one he loves third time. In him fourth time we have redemption and on and on it goes. Almost everything God did for us he did in Christ. Jumping over to verse 13 and you also were included you guessed it in Christ when you heard the word of truth the gospel of your salvation. Having believed you were marked in him again with a seal the promised Holy Spirit and so forth. What does this language mean in Paul? Well it means a number of things as a matter of fact but the usage that is found here is a reference to what we call union with Christ. Okay yes sir. Having believed you were marked in him with a seal you were also included in him yes Ephesians 1, 13, two times. Says in him or in Christ and all these refer to the same thing union with Christ. Christian theology is an organic whole. The only problem is we divide it up to teach one part at a time so we can understand but we're constantly appealing to other parts because they intersect and here I've got to talk a little bit about union with Christ. Its background is separation from God. We were separate from Christ without hope and without God in the world. Paul says later on in Ephesians chapter 2 and verse 12 especially speaking of Gentile Christians union with Christ is the work of God whereby he brings us who formerly were separated from God. He joins us to his son spiritually so that the benefits of Christ become ours. The Bible presents this in Paul's writings anyway in two major ways in more than that but two major ways. One way is to take verbs that speak of what Jesus did for us dying, being buried, rising again, ascending, sitting down at God's right hand even coming again and he puts a with a preposition with on the front of those verbs and in English we translate it this way we died with Christ, we buried with him, we raised with him, we were ascended with him, we ascended with him, we sat down at God's right hand with him in Romans 8 and Colossians 3 and even uses the language of the second coming with reference to us. The meaning is our life as Paul says in Colossians 3 1 and 2 is so wrapped up with Christ that he could say our life is hidden with Christ in God and when Christ returns our true existence as it were will be revealed when Christ who is your life appears Colossians 3, 4 then you also will appear with him in glory. It's not saying we're literally going to have a second coming but we are so joined in the Son of God that we do not yet see, it's not yet evident what we will be 1 John 3 and that him that we sing sometimes but it is only when he comes again that the true revelation another second coming word Romans 8 of the sons and daughters of God that that's when we will be revealed our true identity. Anyway in Ephesians 1 all these times no special pleading no special case it means union with Christ the only difference is this is a prospective union with Christ we couldn't be joined the Son of God until we were created so thus my understanding of Ephesians 1 4 is that God planned to make us his sons and daughters he chose us but he chose us in Christ the meeting is no sooner had God elected us as his people we didn't even exist yet but it is own mind he chose to make us his people then he also chose the means of making us his people remember God uses means it was not an afterthought to send his son it was planned from the beginning or even before the beginning if you will because God chose us in Christ I thus do not see it as turning the whole passage around and saying that God chose us because you knew we would choose him rather it's the same meaning as in the every place else in the passage that is union with Christ it just speaks of God's plan to send his son and to join us spiritually to his son so the Armenian out does not appear to be a very good out I'll just finish and then entertain your questions we will tackle Romans 9 next week and we'll have plenty of time to do that Lord willing the goal of election is given in verse 4 in terms of holiness and blamelessness God chose us in His son before creation in order that we might be very literally holy and blameless in His sight there's the goal remember a Romans 8 the goal there was conformity to Christ image and final glorification I said conformity to Christ image looks like final sanctification to me conformity to His image and holiness I think it is correct here explicitly it says that we'll be holy and blameless in His sight show me the Colossians passage that you said earlier convinced you that the reference here was to final sanctification rather than initial or progressive I'm glad you asked that question I'll be happy to Colossians one thank you for that chuckle extra credit Janet extra credit Colossians one oh twenty one Colossians one twenty one as my pastor says turn right two books he's always having us turn right your turn turn right two books once you were alienated from God I see a fellow church member out there chuckling Colossians one twenty one once you were alienated from God and were enemies in your minds because of your evil behavior but now he has reconciled you by Christ's physical body through death to present you holy in His sight without blemish and free from accusation aha is that initial sanctification which the Bible teaches in some places is it progressive sanctification which the Bible certainly teaches or is it final sanctification which the Bible also teaches it's final look at verse 23 if you continue in your faith established in firm not moved from the hope held out in the gospel that is verse 23 says if you persevere as the saints have to do perseverance of the saints is sometimes presented as a requirement for final salvation the goal of election is presented in verse 10 in cosmic terms not just corporate not just corporate as any Ephesians 5 for example where we read that Christ died for the church to make her holy cleansing her by the washing with water through the word to present her to himself a radiant church without staying or wrink or any other blemish but holy and blameless it's not just corporate but it's cosmic seems to include the new heavens the new earth perhaps even good angels God made known to us Ephesians 1 9 the mystery of his will according to his good pleasure which he purposed in Christ to be put into effect when the times will have reached their fulfillment I'm sorry Ephesians 1 10 it's a sword drill today back and forth we go to bring all things in heaven and on earth together under one head even Christ here the goal is the final restitution of all things under Christ that is of course not absolute that is not everybody's going to be saved in the end the devil's not going to be saved last in 2541 the part from the Eucharist Jesus will say when he comes again into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels the devil's not going to be saved in the end the demons are not going to be saved and neither are unsaved human beings I'm done let me give you a few minutes to ask questions or make comments yes sir let me repeat the question and I will speak to your intention I don't think this verse teaches what many people think it does number one but I do think the Bible teaches what many people think this verse teaches quickly in context read second Peter 2 sometime it is one of the strongest passages of the of God's condemnation of people anywhere in the Bible okay the false teachers are condemned it is such strong language verse nine of second Peter 3 says the Lord is not slow in keeping his promise as some understand slowness he is patient with you in context not wanting anyone to perish but everyone to come to repentance I agree with Richard Balkham in the word biblical commentary on second Peter that the use of you governs the anyone that follows he is not saying that he doesn't want those heretics in chapter two that he just condemned to help to be saved just doesn't follow uh he is saying he does not want these this group of professed believers for some of them to be influenced by those false teachers and indeed to defect to have been false professors and not true believers in Christ but let me talk to the real issue okay which is is there not an expression in God's word of his universal solidific will isn't it the will of God for example for the gospel to go to all people yes it definitely is the disciples are commanded in the great commission in Matthew 28 to take the gospel to everyone a better verse than that one is given in the book of Acts where the Lord commands we read Acts 17 30 in the past God overlooked such ignorance but now he commands all people everywhere to repent for he has set a day when he will judge the world with justice by the man he has appointed he's talking about the word Jesus Christ the next verse implies that from the notion of the mention of the resurrection it is unavoidable it seems to me for Christians that distinguish between different wills in God say aha now I think you're I turn my head and you're moving the p under the symbol here to make this thing work out see if you don't agree with me that God's will in creation is different than his will in commandment okay we talk about God's will by decree his decreative will his will by decree his preceptive will his will by precept or commandment and then his desiderative will or his will by desire I don't see how you can avoid the first two isn't there a difference between God's will when he says letter B light and there was light and God's will when he says thou shalt not steal and every day at least thousands of people steal around the world I think we have to make a distinction God's will by decree is that which he decides to do and it unfailingly comes to pass okay by the way the distinction this doesn't this doesn't decide making the distinctions doesn't decide for us which type of will it is in any particular in any particular passage God's will by precept his preceptive will is where he makes a command thou shalt not fill in the blank steal and every day people steal there's a difference between his will by decree is there not in which it most assuredly comes to pass was there any possibility of God not creating when he said that there be no there wasn't his will by precept is different here he addresses his creatures in responsibility he holds on the countable he commands them not to transgress his will positively he commands them to do his will every day people break those the commandments I would understand the intention of your question in appealing to the second Peter three passage to refer to what I would call God's will of desire that is he doesn't he takes no delight in the condemnation of the wicked he commands people everywhere to repent he tells the disciples to take the gospel implied in his explicit statement to make the disciples of all the nations and we make no distinctions and God gives a well intentioned free offer of the gospel to who so ever will I appreciate your question because just studying the doctrine of election is one sided by the very nature of it it speaks of God out of his own good pleasure and grace choosing moditudes for salvation we need it doesn't give us the full picture of everything in the Bible this just that particular slice and it is a very one sided picture in the Bible itself but the Bible does give a broader picture for example if you study the judgment passages there's a different one sidedness there people are judged according to what they have done in the judgment passages in the human responsibility which comes to the fore it makes sense God is a just judge of all the earth let me dismiss us in prayer and well maybe right down a question if you've got a good one if it's a bad one forget about it and seriously we'll keep working at it thank you for your patience with me I will try to be patient with you hopefully sprawls book will help you to think you're allowed to get mad at it sometimes you're allowed to get mad at me too if you will but please understand my attitudes toward you regardless of your conclusions and I appreciate your fellowship in return let's pray together father we confess that there are many things in your word we do not understand and we certainly do not understand all of your eternal counsels before the creation of the world lord and we don't pretend that we do help us be faithful students of your word help us submit our minds our lies our emotions our wills to what you plainly teach give us progress as we search your word help us be fair to the different viewpoints lord and not misrepresent anyone lead us in your truth we pray for your glory through Jesus Christ our lord amen