<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Faire un don Don mensuel

Person of Christ, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Thou art our shepherd, we are thy flock. Thou art our redeemer. We are the people. Thou has bought back. Thou art our God. We are thy inheritance. Therefore, be not angry against us to correct us in thy wrath. Recall not our iniquity to punish it, but chest as us gently in thy kindness. Because of our demerit, sign anger is in flame, but be mindful that thy name is called upon among us, and that we bear thy mark in badge. Undertake, rather, the work that Thou hast already begun in us by thy grace, in order that the whole earth may recognize that Thou art our God and Savior. Amen. This little chart on the board perhaps will review for us, where we are. Some ways the treatment of Christ, Calvin gives in in book two chapters 6 through 16, is really the heart of the institutes. One writer is called at the nerve center of the institutes, and the all of book one and first five chapters in book two lead up to Christ. Book one does tell us what we would have known about God if we had not sinned, but Adam did sinned, and we fell into sin, and that requires a redeemer. And the first five chapters of book two discuss in some detail the effects of that sin upon us. And then we come to Christ in book two chapters 6 through 16. Actually, that should be 6 through 17. You can correct that. 2, 6 through 17. And from this section, we'll flow a book three and four. Book three has the title, The Way in which we receive the grace of Christ. So we go right from book two Christ, who he is, what he did into book three, which will begin next time. And we'll study the way in which we receive the grace of Christ. And then book four is the external means or aids by which God invites us into the society of Christ. So in a sense, you can see everything leading up to these chapters in book two. And then everything flowing from these chapters in book two.

We've already noted that Calvin divides his treatment of Christ into person of Christ in two 12 through 14 and work of Christ in two 15 through 17. But he doesn't insist on a hard and fast distinction. When we talk about person of Christ, we necessarily talk about the work of Christ. And when we talk about the work of Christ, we certainly have to keep in mind the person of Christ. Calvin's way of beginning his treatment of the work of Christ is to do it under the threefold office, threefold office of prophet king and priest. So we're common for us to think of prophet priest and king. But Calvin's order is prophet king and priest. Not absolutely sure about this, but I think he arranges it that way so that his treatment of Christ as priest could lead right into his treatment of Christ as redeemer in book two chapter 16 and 17. He talked about this threefold office for a bit looking at the work of Christ as prophet king and priest. Calvin was not the first person to think of this. This idea of describing the work of Christ under this rubric had been used for a long time back the days of the church fathers and find it in Thomas Aquinas as well in any other people. The idea was gradually developed by Calvin in the institutes by 1545. There's a clear statement of the three offices. In 1536, it doesn't appear, but by the 1545 edition of the institutes, you do see the three offices. And then in 1559, the edition that we're using, there's a separate chapter devoted to the three offices. Chapter 15 of book two. And it has an important location between Calvin's discussion of the incarnation into 12 through 14 and his discussion of redemption into 16 through 17. So I said already it connects the person and work. It is Calvin's way of putting together the person who came born in this world and the work that he did, which eventually Calvin focuses on as the work of redemption, prophet king and priest. As we'll see, the concepts that Calvin develops there are proclamation, protection and reconciliation, prophet, proclamation, king, protection and priest reconciliation. The three-fold office also has a significant role in reform theology after Calvin, what's Mr. Confession of Faith, chapter eight of Christ, the mediator puts it this way, it please God in his eternal purpose to choose and ordain the Lord Jesus is only begotten son to be the mediator between God and man, the prophet, priest and king. I think one of the reasons that this three-fold office has become popular and useful in theology is that in the Old Testament, the prophet, priest and the king were inducted into office by anointing with holy oil. So each one was anointed with oil to be inducted into office which foreshadowed a fulfillment of the anointed one who is the Messiah himself, Messiah is the anointed one. And we have these pictures of the work of the Messiah in the Old Testament under the three-fold office. So let's look at these three offices beginning with the prophet or proclamation. Calvin says Christ was anointed by the Spirit to be the herald and witness of the Father's grace. Christ, in his work as a teacher, a preacher or as Calvin puts it here, the herald and witness of the Father's grace. And there are two parts to that. Christ taught during his earthly ministry as we know. Calvin speaks of the perfect doctrine he has brought, has made an end to all prophecies to the perfect doctrine he has brought, has made it into all prophecies. So the finality of Christ preaching Old Testament prepares for it and then Christ gives the final word. Of course that word is set forth and explain more fully in the remaining books of the New Testament after the Gospels, but God finally spoke in his son. And that sums up and underscores all biblical revelation. So during his earthly ministry, Christ was teaching, but Calvin also stresses that he still teaches. He's not just that he taught while he was here on earth, but as prophet he still teaches. His office of prophet has not ceased because he continues to teach through his ministers. Christ still teaches in his flesh as he did in the days when he lived on earth, but he continues to teach through his ministers. To 15 to he received the anointing as prophet not only for himself that he might carry out the office of teaching, but for his whole body at the power of the spirit might be present in the continuing preaching of the gospel. So as we listen to sermons and as we preach, Christ is involved in that. In fact, it's his prophetic office that continues as his word is set forth. When Calvin was writing his commentary on 175, he said the words, hear ye him, recall the church to its unique teacher Christ. That's what sermons are, hear ye him. And Christ now preaches through the mouths of his servants who proclaim his word. His office of prophet continues. Commentary on Matthew 20, his ministers cannot put forward whatever they may think, but must themselves defend solely on the mouth of one teacher. Of course, that commits us to the exposition of the scripture because that is the word of Christ. And as we proclaim the scripture, we're not putting forth what we think, but we're putting forth what God says. Just reading on the plane coming back last night article in which a minister was describing the preaching of various groups. He said that Jews have to say it's written in the Torah and Catholics say the church says and Protestants say it seems to me. And he agreed with that. He thought that was a good way to describe Protestant preaching, but it seemed to me that that was a very poor way to describe Protestant preaching. It's never, it seems to me it has to be the Bible says. And when we set forth what the Bible says, we're setting forth what Christ says. Of course, we have to interpret the Bible and there's an element there of personal understanding and appropriation, but we work very, very hard to eliminate the, it seems to me and to elevate the truth of the Bible. So Christ is a prophet and as prophet, he proclaims the truth of God. Secondly, Christ is King, the second of the threefold offices Christ is King. Calvin says 213 Christ was anointed King that he might be the eternal protector and defender of his church. Two points here as well. One, Christ rules now. Christ is King now, it's ruling now. And as he rules now, he does two things. He protects believers. He is our King, he is protecting us. This of course raises the question as to why do we then have so many problems and suffer and die like other people. And Calvin's answer to that is the happiness promise in Christ does not consist in outward advantages to 154. He's our King and so he is protecting us, but he hasn't promised to keep us from trouble, keep us from disease or keep us from death. He hasn't promised that our lives will be easy. That's not what it means that we have Christ as our King. King doesn't consist in outward advantages. The King's ship of Christ is truly spiritual. Calvin says in fact his life under the cross. So Christians can be prepared for suffering and trials and humanly speaking disasters, life under the cross. So he is King, but we have to interpret that in the right way. We have to interpret that as a spiritual kingship, not an earthly one in which he's going to give us outward advantages. This King gives us inward advantages, blessings to overcome the trials, not the absence of trials. So he's ruling now, protecting believers, the eternal protector and defender of his church, Calvin says, and he's ruling now judging the wicked. So Christ as King is active in this world, protecting believers and judging the wicked. But again, as in protecting believers, we have to understand that judging the wicked doesn't mean that there is total and complete judgment in this life. The wicked get away with a lot of things seemingly. And even though we can send some judgment of God upon the wicked, we don't see God annihilating the wicked or destroying them. They often prosper and persecute the righteous. He's reading in a book, this sentence, which I think illustrates what I want to say here. The judgments of God fall often enough in this world to let us know that God judges. You see, as you studied history, you see the judgment of God falling upon nations and people. You see that throughout history. But the sentence goes on to say, but seldom enough to let us know that there is a judgment hereafter, which means that all the judgment is not completed here. And now there is a judgment to come. So that's Calvin's point, too, that as Calvin puts it, the full proof of his rule will appear at the last judgment. There we'll see how our king has perfectly protected his church and how he has judged and at the last judgment completes the judgment of the wicked. Francis Schaefer used to put it, there will be a balancing of the books that hasn't happened yet. Books are not close to being balanced, but eventually there will be a balancing of the books. And everything will be set right. That's the second office. The third office is the office of priest, the work of Christ in reconciliation. The office of king has to do with the actual bestowal of every spiritual good. The office of priest has to do with the removal of spiritual evil. King brings to us spiritual good. The priest takes away sin, reconciles us to God. Calvin makes the point that Christ was anointed both priest and sacrifice for sin. So here there is something unique. We have the Old Testament prophets, we have Christ's prophet, the Old Testament kings, we have Christ's king, the Old Testament priest, we have Christ's priest. But the Old Testament priest were not both priest and sacrifice, but with Christ we have both priest and sacrifice. By his holiness and by his sacrifice he blots out our guilt and reconciles us to God, that is his work is sacrifice. As priest, we have his work of intercession, by his pleading we obtain favor. So as priest Christ died as a sacrifice, and his priest Christ intercedes before the father, that his sacrificial work of reconciliation bring us into favor with God. In his commentary on Matthew 27-12, Calvin has a beautiful illustration, I think, of the relation between Christ's reconciliation and his intercession to parts of his priestly office, reconciliation and intercession. In this passage Calvin describes the trial of Jesus before Pilate, and there he says Jesus remained silent before Pilate, in order that ever after he might speak for us. So in remaining silent before Pilate he accepts the judgment that is needed out upon him by the Romans and dies for our sins, he doesn't object, he doesn't try to escape it. But because he remained silent before Pilate he is now able to speak ever after for us. In the commentary on 1 John 2-1, Christ's intercession is the continual application of his death to our salvation, so it's Christ's death and then his intercession which is the continual application of his death to our salvation. Christ is priest, not only to render the father favorable toward us, but also to receive us as his companions in this great office. That is 2-15-6, in other words just as there is an element in which we are involved in proclamation, Christ's work as prophet, so there is a part of Christ's work as priest that involves us as well. That is not reconciliation, of course, but it is intercession and this is one place in the institutes where the Protestant doctrine of the priesthood of believers comes forth. That is not as clearly set forth in Calvin as it is in Luther, for Luther that's a major theme in Calvin, it's certainly important and we find it from time to time as we do here in 2-15-6. Christ is priest, not only to render the father favorable toward us, but also to receive us as his companions in this great office. He intercedes, we intercede. Any questions on the 3-fold office before we move on to chapter 16? Is this pretty much the extent of Calvin speaking on the priesthood of all believers? No, there are other places but not too often in the institutes, I think we'll see some other places in book 3 and book 4 and I'll try to point that out as we come to it. You can find Calvin's treatment of this idea in the commentaries as well, but there's not a major section or chapter in the institutes to do it, but Calvin certainly agreed with Luther, I think that all believers are priest and we are to serve as in this context as intercessors as Christ is our intercessor. Okay, let's look at chapter 16 then. Christ as our redeemer, he can move right from Christ as priest to Christ as redeemer, question that Calvin begins with is how did Christ accomplish redemption for us? And his answer is by the whole course of his obedience to 165 by the whole course of his obedience, that means incarnation, earthly life and death, that's the whole course of his obedience, but especially Calvin says his obedience unto death. The later reform tradition will divide that into the active obedience of Christ and the passive obedience of Christ, usually theologians refer the active obedience of Christ to his life when he is obeying the law, obeying the will of the Father for us. And his passive obedience to his death, when he accepts and agrees to and embraces death, I'm not particularly fond of that distinction because it seems to me that there is active obedience in his death as well, it's not just that he surrenders to death, but he takes it upon himself, he dies. It's not that he's killed but he offers himself as a sacrifice, it's not totally as he is killed, if we say that we haven't said everything. He has embraced death and in his active obedience, there's a certain passiveness to in that he accepts the sufferings and struggles that God has assigned to him. So people probably will continue to use that distinction, although I'm not sure that it is particularly helpful, but Christ accomplished redemption for us by the whole course of his obedience. Here it is that Calvin gets into his exposition of the Apostles Creed, which summarizes what Christ did for us. Calvin says the Creed passes at once in the best order from the birth of Christ to his death and resurrection, wherein the whole of perfect salvation consists. So he doesn't find fault with the Creed, but when you think about it, it is interesting that the life of Christ is omitted in the Apostles Creed. We say, and in Jesus Christ, his only son, our Lord, who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered unto Pontius Pilate, but places the life of Christ get in the Apostles Creed. Well, I guess we would say a comma, a comma or a synagogue, born of the Virgin Mary, comma, suffered under Pontius Pilate, so we go from his incarnation to his suffering on the cross, but his life is not mentioned. But Calvin says the remainder of the obedience of Christ is not excluded. Calvin wants to say that even though there is not an actual statement in the Apostles Creed that talks about the obedience of Christ through his life is not excluded, Paul embraced it all from the beginning to the end in Philippians 2, 7, and 8. He took the form of a servant. He took the form of a servant. In the sense we could say the Creed this way, and in Jesus Christ, his only son, our Lord, he took the form of a servant and was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate. Calvin doesn't suggest that we add those words to the Creed, but we can certainly think of those words as we recite the Apostles Creed. We just go through Calvin's treatment of the Creed here, not into Teo, but to point out a few things of interest as we move along. He suffered under Pontius Pilate. The point that Calvin wants to make here is that there was not one but two verdicts given at the trial of Jesus Christ allowed himself to be condemned before a mortal man because he will deliver us from the penalty to which we were subject to centered. One verdict is guilty. Your guilty, suffered under Pontius Pilate pronounced guilty by Pilate and the Jews, and crucified on the cross and Christ accepted that, allowed himself to be condemned because it was this way in which he could provide for us our salvation. But Calvin says there's another verdict given there, and that's innocent. Nobody speaks that in Jerusalem, but from his shining innocence it was obvious that he was burdened with another sin rather than his own. Christ moves through the trial and execution. Calvin sees his shining innocence set forth in such a way that even though he's guilty, he's guilty because of the sense of the world that had been laid upon him. Two verdicts, guilty for our sake, but innocent in himself. He was crucified. Christ made himself subject to the cross. Calvin talks about the cross as being a place of shame, so he embraced the shame there, very depths of degradation. But as under the two verdicts under Pontius Pilate, Pilate's verdict, and I'd say God's verdict, even though the father turned from Christ, it was as if the father turned from Christ. Calvin explains it. Go back into the extra Calvinistic one, but it has come into play here as well, but he's crucified, made himself subject to the cross. It's full of shame, but he changed it into, as Calvin puts it, a triumphant chariot. So there are two ways to look at these things, Calvin says, you look at the trial, you see a man being condemned as guilty, crucified for his guilt, but you really see shining innocence, and then you look at the cross, you see a place full of degradation and shame, but it's transformed into a triumphant chariot. I think we have continual illustrations of that in the way we use the cross today. We don't think of it much as a place of degradation because that adorns our buildings, this chapel, and people wear it as jewelry, and treasure it as a wonderful symbol of the Christian faith. But that was because Christ changed what was very ignoble and shameful into something triumphant and wonderful. And then the tree goes on to say he was dead and buried. Why does it do that? Because Calvin said in every respect he took our place to pay the price of redemption. So he dies if he's buried because he takes our place in what we deserve, death, and burial. Well, those are rather straightforward expressions of the creed, although I do think Calvin gives an interpretation which is full of insights and enables us to repeat the creed with more appreciation and understanding. But the next phrase is the disputed one, and we need to look to see what Calvin does with it, descended into hell. Now Calvin thinks that this part of the creed is an essential part of the creed, just reading yesterday article from theologian who said, especially this out now because we don't believe it, and this is an evangelical theologian who just said, descended into hell is not proper understanding of what Christ did. But Calvin doesn't agree with that. He says it's a matter of no small moment in bringing about redemption. Which means I think that Calvin sees descended into hell as the most important part of the creed. It's true that the phrase descended into hell was not part of the earliest forms of the apostles creed. We get one writer before 650 who suggests that it could be included in the creed, but apparently he only used it to mean that Christ was buried, which repeats what has already been said, died in buried, descended into hell was buried. It's not until about 650, sometime in the 7th century that the phrase descended into hell becomes a fix to the creed, and you know the creed goes back to early 3rd century in Rome, so it takes a long time for this particular phrase to be added. I think we would say, however, that the idea that Christ descended into hell was fairly common in the church fathers in the 2nd and 3rd centuries and down to Calvin's time. It was that idea, that traditional view, well it was this, that there was a literal descent of Christ to the world of the dead between his death and resurrection. He died on the cross, went down into hell, and then he's resurrected and ascends to the father. What did he do when he was in hell? People had different ideas about that, but it summed up in a number of ways. He preached repentance and rescued prisoners. Some people think that there's a reference to Old Testament believers. We did not go directly to heaven until Christ descended to hell or to the place of the dead. There's some dispute as exactly what hell means here, does it mean the place of the dead or does it mean the place of eternal punishment? The old view, the traditional view was that Christ went and preached repentance, rescued believers, and triumphed over Satan. This is sometimes called the harrowing of hell, which was a great theme in medieval art, yet many, many pictures of Christ going down to hell and tearing the place up, the harrowing of hell. Before you get it in Dante and the divine comedy, many writings and particularly art of the medieval period, shows a literal descent of Christ in his body as he goes to hell and triumphs over hell. Well, Calvin doesn't take that line of interpretation. Might say that Calvin demathologizes the statement because Calvin says what the phrase means is Christ's spiritual torment on the cross. Or as Calvin puts it, that invisible and incomprehensible judgment which he underwent in the sight of God. Crucified dead and buried, that sets forth, he might say, the external facts of Christ being placed on the cross and dying as a result of that experience. And he's buried, but there was also the phrase descended in hell, which doesn't speak of the external suffering, but the burden that he was bearing in himself as a result of his bearing the sense of the world. Calvin calls this a harsher and more difficult struggle than with common death. In other words, what Christ struggled with on the cross was far more, far, far more than what you and I would struggle with if we had been crucified. You can imagine the anguish and the agony of that experience. But there was something much harsher and more difficult that Calvin says Christ struggled with and that was his bearing the sense of the world. And that's what makes the cross redemptive. You see, without the expression descended into hell, interpreted in this way, you have objective facts but you have no theological interpretation of those facts. This is the setting forth of the redemptive nature of the cross. So the traditional view is chronological. The victory is already won on the cross and then Christ makes a journey after that of triumph to the underworld. But in Calvin's view, it's all simultaneous. As he hangs on the cross, he descends into hell. The descent is the victory. It's not that the victory is won and then the descent takes place. It's that as he dies, as he bears, our sins he dies and the descent takes place as he struggles on the cross.

And that is the victory. He illustrated this way from the catechism for the Church of Geneva. This is the catechism that Calvin wrote and you get it very clearly set forth here. The minister asked, as for what immediately follows that he descended into hell, what does this mean? This is the catechism leading children through the Apostle's Creed and the children were taught to reply that he endured not only common death, which is the separation of the soul from the body, but also the pains of death. Peter calls them. Calvin believes that pains of death in Acts 2.24 has to do with a spiritual torment. The answer goes on by this word. I understand the fearful agonies with which his soul was tormented. And then the next statement from the minister, tell me the cause and manner of this. And the answer, because in order to make satisfaction for sinners, he arraigned himself before the tribunal of God. It was requisite that his conscience be tormented by such agony as if he were forsaken by God. He had the sense of being forsaken. He had the experience of being forsaken, but he really wasn't forsaken. And Calvin does apply that to us because that's our experience, too. We often have the sense of being forsaken. We're not forsaken. As the second person in the Trinity was not forsaken by God on the cross, but he did feel that he was forsaken. Do you? If I'm interpreting things correctly, Calvin would you just send it to hell, walk us on the cross, and the process of dying, and as he died, then it's just a sentence that goes complete? That's right. Yes. That's right. There's no geographical movement then. Well, there is that three-day period, or parts of three days, when he continues under the power of death in the grave. You know, when you compare what Calvin is doing here with the Westminster Confession of Faith, there is a difference. Westminster Confession of Faith doesn't teach the literal dissent into the place of the dead for preaching to Old Testament saints or powering hell. Elijah Catechism, question 50, says in its answer, Christ humiliation after his death consisted in his being buried and continuing in the state of the dead and under the power of death till the third day, which has been otherwise expressed in these words he descended in the hell. George Catechism understands the words he descended in hell is the fact that Christ died and was buried and continued under the power of death till the third day. Now, what do we make of all this? It seems to me that it's probably quite likely, quite true, that the early traditional interpretation are meaning of the words he descended into hell were the words that the meaning that should be updixed to the Apostles Creed. So, when Calvin comes to those words, he doesn't say we'll drop them out because I don't agree with the traditional interpretation, but he changes the meaning of the words and keeps them in. And you could say that even if you like Calvin's view, and I think almost everybody would, you could say that's not what the words meant. So, we should take them out. I think that's Dr. Williams' view. Words did not mean that, I don't know if he says we should take them out or not, but he doesn't think Calvin has given the right interpretation of those words. It's originally meant something else. Calvin doesn't give us any feeling about what he's doing here, he says, takes the traditional statement of the Creed and then reinterpret the words in what I would consider a biblical position. And my personal feeling is that Calvin has convinced me that we need something in the Apostles Creed to say what he's saying when he gives his interpretation of the descended to hell. And so, I'm quite happy to take the traditional words, reinterpret them in the Calvinist fashion and go on using them. It's quite an issue in some churches, and you'll probably be asked about this or you'll have to decide when you're a pastor at what form of the Apostles Creed you're going to use, but this will give you some insight at least into Calvin's interpretation. Or half dozen verses or so, that traditional interpretation could possibly point to, particularly a first-feeder 3, 18 through 20. I'm not going to try to exegiate those verses. You can look at this as you have interest. But that passage of first-feeder 3, 18 through 20, which is undoubtedly the primary text talks about Christ who in the spirit went and preached into the spirits in prison, which of four time were disobedient and so on. I've studied Calvin's exegesis of that passage, and it is pretty complicated. He's trying to not use it in the way that it would support the traditional view of Christ's descendant to hell because of this intricate passage. And I think the main point he's making there is that Christ went by means of his spirit to the prison, but it's not altogether clear exactly where that was or what that was. It seems to me that Augustin perhaps has the better interpretation of that passage. Although Augustin doesn't argue for this, he simply proposes that the first-feeder 3 passage is not referring to something Christ did between his death and resurrection, but something he did through the spirit at the time of Noah. Christ preached by the spirit at the time of Noah to people and actually preached through Noah. So it would be Christ's prophetic office coming forth here as he sets forth his truth through the preaching of the righteous Noah. Any further questions on that, Julia? I'm dealing with biblical words here, so we wouldn't say Calvin is playing loose with biblical words. I expect you could find other things in the church fathers that would be analogous at the moment I can't point to anything that would be exactly in this category, because this is a traditional statement that comes part of the creed. The church has inherited it and yet don't have not exactly known what they meant when they were saying this. The rest of the creed is so clear and we're united on it, but this point is quite different. Well, let's go on through the other points and then we'll come to chapter 17. The third day he rose again from the dead. The substitutionary work of Christ doesn't end in his death. Our restoration to life is completed by his resurrection. The Bible often connects death and resurrection. Calvin does here. The third day he rose again from the dead. Send it into heaven by which he truly inaugurated his kingdom. Calvin says in 216-14, but Calvin also wants to make the point that he descended into heaven in such a way that he did not leave us. Or as Calvin puts it, 216-14, or he left us in such a way that his presence might be more useful to us. Still have the presence of Christ through the spirit. The presence of Christ before the ascension into heaven was different from the presence of Christ after the ascension into heaven. We sometimes think it would have been wonderful to live in the days of Christ and be able to see him and talk to him and listen to him, but only a limited number of people could do that because Christ in his body was at one place at one time. But now he is with us, each of us, in every Christian always and everywhere. So he left us in such a way that his presence might be more useful to us. Just as the incarnation did not remove Christ from heaven, so his ascension did not remove Christ from earth. I think we see the extra Calvinists come into play again here. Christ also exists apart from his body. His body is in heaven, but Christ exists apart from his body. So he can be present in the Lord's Supper, as we will see later. Apart from the body, Calvin says, which is in one place in heaven. When he leaves heaven to come to earth and is born of the Virgin, this is Christ, but also beyond the body, second person of the Trinity exists. At that time he had not abandoned heaven, and he had not forsaken the work that he was engaged in when he became man. And now that he has returned to heaven, he has not left us because as the omnipresent God, he is everywhere, but his body is not everywhere. It is a big point when we come to the Lord's Supper, because that will distinguish Calvin's view from that of Luther. And he is seated at the right hand of the Father, where he is invested with Lordship over heaven and earth. From whence he shall come to judge the living in the dead. Our whole salvation, Calvin says, is comprehended in Christ, which is the way that he sums up his treatment of the Apostle's Creed. Then we have chapter 17, how Christ merited salvation for us. This may have been something you had never thought about before, or worried about. It was something that people in Calvin say were asking, so he deals with it. How does Christ merit salvation for us? In other words, if salvation is my grace, why do we have merit involved? Christ merited, I think Calvin would say, Christ merited grace for us, certainly would say that. But he says this too, certain perversely subtle men teach that any mission of merit obscures God's grace. So if you talk about merit, you have undercut grace. If God saves us by grace, then why does there have to be merit? Calvin's answer to 171 is this, it is absurd to set Christ merit against God's mercy. You've got two things, you've got God's mercy, you have Christ merit. For it is a common rule that a thing subordinate to another is not in conflict with it. He uses a kind of statement from logic here to answer this. You have God's mercy, that's the main point, and then there's a subpoint which is Christ merit. In other words, God's mercy was to sin Christ, and God's mercy was Christ coming in that unity of the Father and the Son in the work of redemption, to merit life for us. Calvin says, there's no conflict if you have the main point and the subordinate point. God's mercy, this is how God's mercy was accomplished for us. God chooses to save us by Christ merit, Christ by His obedience truly acquired and merited grace for us with the Father. When Calvin discusses the work of our salvation, he says that Christ was able to merit our salvation because God willed it. This was the way that God had will that we would be saved. Jesus Christ was unable to merit anything but by God's good pleasure, which was God's decree and God's will.

But at the same time he speaks of Christ's obedience by Christ's obedience. He truly acquired and merited grace for us with the Father, so you could say the merit comes because God said it will be this way. And the merit comes because Christ obeyed. So there's true dessert. He earned our salvation by the whole course of His obedience by His perfectly sinless life and by His redemptive death. Let's say a few words of evaluation and we'll be able to complete this. Robert Peterson in his book, Christ and our Calvin on the Atonement of Christ which is really marvelous book. I was using that a long time before. I knew Robert Peterson. It's recently been reprinted and is available again, but Dr. Peterson says it's difficult to find another figure in the history of the Christian Church who brought together as much data in his sautéiology as Calvin did. That's from Peterson's Calvin's doctrine of the Atonement. That one is on page 87. Comprehensive treatment of the doctrine of the work of Christ. A three-fold office we've talked about that is very important. And sell me in view with distinctive infacies, justice and love, Christ's atoning life. Perhaps that should be stated a little bit differently. I used to think that Calvin was right in the history of doctrine following Anselm, his career day as Homo by the Godman. I think it's probably more accurate to say that in broad outlines Calvin approximates the teaching of Anselm but Calvin's own treatment is somewhat distinctive. It doesn't follow Anselm entirely, but one thing Anselm was concerned primarily to show how through the Atonement the justice of God was satisfied. Calvin certainly speaks of this often, but Calvin's focus is at least as much on the love of God in the Atonement as it is on the satisfaction of God's justice in the Atonement. The good study could PhD dissertation if you're looking for one someday. The studying Anselm and the Atonement view of the Atonement and how much Calvin follows that in where he diverges from that. And then the last point, the extent of the Atonement that Calvin believed in in set forth limited Atonement or universal Atonement. There's been ongoing debate on this. You can get people writing on both sides of this. I'm convinced that Robert Peterson is right when he says that we just can't say whether Calvin held limited Atonement or not. There are some statements in Calvin which certainly set forth limited Atonement or particular Atonement. There are other statements in Calvin that set forth what we could call universal Atonement. Calvin certainly believed in the universal offer of the gospel. That's not the same thing as universal Atonement, but either Calvin just did not find us an issue. It was not an issue in his time. It becomes an issue later. The time of the Senator's door when a theological matter is an issue, then you have to be very precise and take sides and decide what you're going to say unless you just say I don't know. I think that's perhaps one reason that Calvin doesn't answer this question and that was people were not asking this question. So he doesn't answer it. Another answer perhaps is that Calvin is so concerned to be biblical that when a verse seems to go toward limited Atonement, he'll go that way. When a verse seems to go toward universal Atonement, he'll go that way. And either has no way of putting those together or just doesn't think of doing it. It's rather typical I think of Calvin to take a certain line of biblical thought out as far as he can and then another line of biblical thought and fail to make a logical connection when he feels the scripture doesn't really give him the right to do that. So unless somebody comes up with a lot of new light on Calvin on this topic, I think we'll have to say that Calvin can be interpreted both ways in that there are text in the institutes and in the commentaries that could lead in both directions. Okay, we're ready now for book three and next time we'll have a first chapter in book three on the Holy Spirit. That chapter was added in 1559 so it was a very important chapter for Calvin. And really all of book three is about the Holy Spirit but you have a chapter on the Holy Spirit and then the rest of book three of the application of the redemption of Christ by the work of the Spirit. And we'll start with faith, Holy Spirit and faith are the topics for next Tuesday. Thank you.