<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Daj Daj mjesečno

Doctrine of God

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Well, how are you coming in reading Calvin? It's about this point that students sometimes begin to feel a little discouraged. This was a rather hefty reading for today, 63 pages, and probably the most difficult section of the institute, so be encouraged if you felt it was a hard going. I think you'll find the next assignment on creation a little easier to handle than the one on Providence, but then a big passive reading comes on SIN, 99 pages, on February 20, so plan ahead and do the best you can to keep up. If you get too far behind, it really does become rather discouraging, so try to keep up with the reading, and all will be well. Let's think for a moment before the prayer where we are in the institutes as we come now to book one, chapters 10 through 13. Calvin has told us that God has planted within us an innate knowledge of himself that is placed there to give us some understanding of who God is. It's placed deeper than us, and it's also placed before us, a sense of any tantas in the seed of religion within, and the created order, and God's work in Providence and history without, but he's also told us that all of this is crossed out, doesn't work, not because it's not a strong and valid testimony, but because of our sinfulness, which blinds us to see those things, which are there, God then gives us an objective revelation in Scripture, and then through the inner witness of the Holy Spirit enables us to embrace the Scripture as the authoritative Word of God, and turn to that Scripture so that in the Scripture we can see what we would have seen if Adam had not sinned in general revelation, and we see far more than that as we'll see today. So we come to the Scripture then, this is the place where Scripture begins to function in Calvin's theology, Scripture, Calvin says, tells us, first of all, about who God is, is nature, is triune nature, and then Scripture tells us that it is this God who created all things, and then Scripture tells us that it is this God who preserves and governs all that he has made. That's a quick summary of book one, and today we're going to look at Calvin's doctrine of God. Let's bow in prayer, and I'll use a prayer, this prayer came from one of Calvin's sermons on 1 Samuel 2, and is an appropriate prayer that we can use for this topic. Let us pray. Let us therefore bow before the majesty of our good God, recognizing the great number of faults and offenses with which we have provoked his wrath against us. Let us pray to him that he may etch the fear of his majesty upon our minds, and make us sharers in those things that we have learned in the Scripture. That by his strength he may support our weakness and infirmity, and may make us fixtures by the power of his spirit, and provide sufficient strength for us to withstand any temptations to which we would otherwise be unequal, and run the whole course of our lives and obedience to him, giving thanks to him, for his many and great benefits to us. Finally, that all our senses may be lifted up in worshiping him to his everlasting praise and glory, and we may be led in the pathway of salvation, not for our own private advantage, but for the upbuilding of our neighbors. It's in Christ's name that we pray. Amen. As we come to Calvin's doctrine of God, we see that he stresses first of all the agreement between what creation and Scripture teaches about God. We're still in book one, so this is knowledge of God, the Creator, and that knowledge was there, and it within us placed before us, which we would have been able to see if we had not sin. But because we did sin, Adam did sin, and that sin has affected us, we cannot gain that knowledge from the creation, but that knowledge, that same knowledge, plus more, is available to us now in the Scripture, more intimately, and also more vividly revealed in his Word. I think maybe the best text to use here, to describe what Calvin is talking about, is Psalm 191, the heavens declare the glory of God, the skies proclaim the work of his hands. We would have been able to see that by looking at the heavens if we had not sin. And now as Christians, we see that by looking at the heavens because the Bible has instructed us about God, the Creator, and his glory, and the magnificence of his creation. You see, an unregenerate person without the Scripture and without the testimony of the Holy Spirit in her heart or his heart, would look at the heavens and perhaps be impressed, amazed, odd, but his or her thoughts would not turn to God, the Creator, at least not in a clear way without error and superstition. And so the theology from nature and from providence recovered by the Word of God is still our possession. It's a useful part of the believer's knowledge of God and assist us in our Christian lives. We can look at the heavens and see in worship God. So there's knowledge of God, the Creator, from creation, given to us now through the Bible. Two main thoughts Kelvin develops their existence and attributes of God and the orderly government of the universe. Both of those are reflected in Psalm 191, the heavens declare the glory of God, God exists. He's a majestic God and the firmament show at his handy work. He has arranged things in a proper order and governs this universe by his will, knowledge of God, from creation through the Bible. But as we come to the chapters we have for today, Kelvin tells us that the knowledge of God, the Creator, that we have in the Bible goes beyond what we had and lost in creation and now is recovered in the Bible because there are specific statements, specific truths about God in the Bible only, that we never would have learned from creation even if Adam had not sent. And one, of course, is the doctrine of the Trinity, a second, which will be the topic for our discussion on Thursday, the doctrine of creation, not the fact of creation, but the time and manner of creation. We could have known God the Creator, that God was the Creator, through natural revelation, if we had not sent, but we could not have known the way God created the time and the manner, how God did it except through the Scripture. And there we will also study in our next class, God's creation, not only of the heavens and the earth, but of the angels and the demons and God's creation of human kind, the original state of man and woman. And if Adam had not sent and we could have seen this generally through natural revelation, we would have seen the providence of God, the general ordering of the universe by God, but we would not have seen what Kelvin calls the full scope of God's particular providence. And that's the topic we'll take up next to see. Yes. Question is, if Adam had not sent and we would have received the knowledge of God through natural revelation, would we have known anything about the Trinity? And I think Kelvin says, no, that it's not available to us through creation. Saying that Justin might disagree with that, might comment on that in a few minutes, but Kelvin doesn't see any revelation of the Trinity and natural theology. Yes. Yes, that's an interesting question. Wood would unfollowed man ever have known anything about the Trinity. And I expect Kelvin's answer there is we're getting into speculation. As far as he tells us in book one of the institutes, Trinity is a specially revealed biblical doctrine. It's not somehow stamped on the face of the universe. You can't look up at the stars and see a triune God. You can see a God, but you can't see a triune God. And as you look deep within your self, you have a sense of the majesty of God, but you don't see a Trinity there. So that understanding of God was placed within us and within creation, but not the full understanding of God that we now live in the Scripture, the doctrine of the Trinity. So by as far as I can go, because I think Kelvin would say to go further with unfollowed mankind is speculative, because that was not what happened. And we're back, you might say, in the real world, of fallen humanity as Kelvin deals with these facts of God, this knowledge of God, which comes from the Bible only. That's a kind of introduction of this material. Secondly, I want to talk about characteristics of Kelvin's treatment of the doctrine of God. And we'll learn some things here about how Kelvin views this doctrine and how Kelvin views every doctrine. First, Kelvin places, as we expect, stress on Scripture and warns us against speculation. You might remember, Kelvin says, the question is not, what is God? Quit, sit, deus. Don't ask, what is God? That's the scholastic question, which wants to answer that with a very probing answer that gets into the very nature of God, the very existence of God. So if we can't ask, what is God? What can we ask? And Kelvin says, what we ought to ask is, what kind of God is He? What kind of God is He? Qualis, sit, deus. Now at first that night not seemed like a much of a difference to us. What is God? Or what kind of God is He? But I think you'll see the difference when you read a statement in one, ten, two, which is a very characteristic statement from Kelvin that God is shown to us, not as He is in Himself, but as He is toward us. We can't really see God as He is in Himself. We don't know God as He is in Himself. We can't answer the question what is God? But we can't answer the question, what kind of God has God, what kind of person has God revealed Himself to be? So the difference between the two questions is really a difference between what God has revealed, which is ours to know, and what God has not revealed, which is not ours to know. God has shown to us not as He is in Himself, but as He is toward us. Now that's pretty characteristic and typical of Kelvin's dealing with this question and dealing with all of theology. There's a limit and beyond that limit we can't go. People sometimes wonder and worry about this if we can't know God as He is in Himself. We only know God as He is toward us. Then are there two gods there? Could there be some sort of incompatibility between the revelation and the essence of God? And Kelvin never accepts that sort of situation. It's not that there are two gods or that the will of the hidden God or the essence of the hidden God might be quite different from the nature of the reveal God. I think it's better to see it this way. There is a hidden depth to God that we can't know. Remember Francis Schaefer used to say quite often that we can know God truly, but we can't know God exhaustively. I think that's what Kelvin is saying here. We know God truly. What we know of God is two knowledge of God. We're not deceived by that, but we can't penetrate into the secret things of God and so we should not try. That's Kelvin's warning against speculation. He says, here indeed that is in the study of the doctrine of God, if anywhere in the secret mysteries of Scripture, especially in this quotation from one 13-21 talking about the Trinity, we ought to play the philosopher soberly and with great moderation. So we don't go beyond what we're allowed to know from the Scripture. When Kelvin is talking about God and especially in the doctrine of the Trinity, he can find himself to Scripture, although we will see he is willing to use non-scriptural words that the Christian tradition has developed, the Council of Nicaea and other church councils as appropriate. We'll talk about why Kelvin will use these non-biblical words, but he doesn't want to go beyond Scripture and confines himself as much as he possibly can to the very words of Scripture. For that reason, you don't find in Kelvin illustrations of the Trinity. He doesn't feel that the Bible has given us illustrations of the Trinity and so he doesn't give us proofs or illustrations of the Trinity from metaphysical reasoning or from natural analogies or from psychological analogies, St. Augustine does. St. Augustine goes beyond Kelvin here and sees something of the nature of the Trinity stamped in the very psychological processes of our thinking. It's a very complicated argument. Kelvin almost always follows Augustine, but not at this point. He says comparisons from human affairs are inadequate. So we're warned against speculation and Kelvin, as he stresses the importance of using the Scripture, using all the Scripture, but not going beyond the Scripture in our understanding of God. He also reminds us again that knowledge of God is not that knowledge which he explained earlier is that knowledge which just flits in the brain, but true knowledge of God invites us first to fear and then to trust in him. So Kelvin can't get very far into his treatment of the doctrine of knowledge of God before he starts talking about loving God, fearing God, obeying God, worshiping God. In fact, that is the next topic here. Not only is there stress on Scripture, but there's also stress on worship.

This is quite characteristic of Kelvin. He's going to talk about God. What kind of God he is, but then before he says almost anything about that, he says we must worship God. We must love God. We must obey God. So he's putting into practice that principle which he has already established that knowledge of God is not pure, objective knowledge out there. It's not balancing opinions about God or making nice metaphysical statements about him, but we learn about God, reading the Scripture, of course, but we learn about God on our knees. So let's talk about worship. I hope you followed that in the reading. It could appear that Kelvin has introduced a topic here that seems to fit later, but when you see what he's doing, then I think it's pretty impressive that Kelvin can't talk about God without talking about worship. Chapter 11 and 12 is on the worship of God, and then chapter 13 is on the Trinity. So worship in Kelvin's arrangement here comes even before the very difficult treatment of the Trinity. True and acceptable worship is a basic ingredient of the knowledge of God. One, ten, two, Kelvin says, recognition of him consists more in living experience than in vain and high-flown speculation, and also in one, ten, two, knowledge of God in Scripture invites us first to fear God than to trust in him. So you get many of these statements right at the beginning of Calvin's treatment of God concerning the importance of worshiping God. As Calvin gets into this, he describes both acceptable worship and unacceptable worship.

Acceptable worship is worship which follows what God teaches. 111, God teaches what worship he approves or repudiates. So God not only tells us to worship him, but tells us how to worship him. What do we usually call this? Regularity of principle. This is one expression of the regularity of principle in Calvin. That is, we're not free to worship God anyway we choose. God has given us directions as to how we are to worship him. That is, acceptable worship, reform principle, or the regular ity of principle, can use either expression for that. And then Calvin contrasts that with unacceptable worship and the particular concern that he has here in unacceptable worship is that it is unlawful to attribute a visible form to God. And generally whoever sets up idols revolts against the true God. That's the title of chapter 11. So Calvin says true worship is according to the pattern that God has established in his word. And false worship would be using idols. Calvin is thinking here about idolatry, but primarily about images in Roman Catholic worship. He really doesn't make a distinction between idolatry and the use of images in worship. He knows how the Catholic Church and the Greek Orthodox Church, the Eastern Orthodox Church, would be similar in this. How a distinction is made between, to use the Latin terms dulyah, which is respectful service, that is the kind of adoration that is proper to give to images of the saints or of Mary and even of Christ and dulyah, the Latin word for, or Lahton word for true worship. Calvin knows the distinction between dulyah and lahtriah, but he calls that the foolish evasions of the Papist. He doesn't think much of that distinction. Even though the Papist, he says, justify the use of images by using a different word as to what kind of worship, what kind of adoration is being given to them is over against the true worship of God, a kind of semi-worship versus a full worship, but Calvin is not impressed by that. So his treatment here is rather strict and straightforward in that he says we are not to use images in our worship of God. Why does Calvin say that? Well there are three reasons. One, they're not allowed. He himself has forbidden it, 111, 12, and of course Calvin's main proof of this is the Ten Commandments Exodus 24 which forbids the making of graven images. So worship of images or worship of God through the use of images, it's not allowed. Secondly, it's not worthy of God. 116 bodily images are unworthy of God's majesty because they diminish the fear of him and men and increase error. You can't have a picture or image or an icon that is worthy of God. What these really do is to decrease the majesty of God, not increase it. Calvin says use in worship of these images, the use of these images in worship cannot be done without some defacing of his glory.

Calvin points out that there are, you might say, images of God in the Bible symbols of his heavenly glory in the Bible, but what are those symbols? Clouds, smoke, flames, and these symbols preserve the incomprehensibility of God. They don't deface the glory of God by something inferior and inadequate, but they preserve the mystery when we have flame, smoke, clouds. They preserve the mystery of God and his incomprehensibility. So not allowed, not worthy, and Calvin says not need it. We don't need these images. The argument, the part of those that advocated the use of images, one argument was that these are the books of the unlearned so that the church can be full of images, pictures, of various kinds because people need those images. They are unlearned and these help them to know something of what the Bible is all about. Calvin says if the church had been doing its business, these unlearned would not be unlearned. And here is where he has a very strong statement you noticed undoubtedly in 111, 7, which I call the praise of preaching. We need sermons, not pictures. Praise of preaching. Paul testifies that by the true preaching of the gospel, Christ is depicted before our eyes as crucified. We don't need a crucifix on the wall. We need a sermon about the crucifixion of Christ. And that is the proper way, the legitimate way, the God ordained way of setting forth what we need to see. Christ is depicted before our eyes as crucified. Praise of preaching. And then Calvin says we have the sacraments. We have the wonderful images, pictures of the sacraments living and symbolic images in baptism and Lord's suffer. Remember reading once when I was studying to write the history of Princeton Seminary about not going to Alexander for his president, professor at Princeton, who before that was preacher, Presbyterian preacher, minister in Virginia. And on one occasion, Dr. Alexander was preaching the sermon. The action sermon, as it used to be called, before the receiving of the Lord's sufferer, the table was prepared. Alexander was in a high pulpit in a church somewhere in Virginia. And as he preached about the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world, he leaned over the pulpit, looked down at the table and said, there is the Lamb, the bread and the wine on the table. And some man way up in the gallery stood up so he could see at that point when Alexander said there is the Lamb. We wanted to see it. And that's what Calvin is talking about when he says in the sacraments of baptism in the Lord's sufferer. We have these wonderful living and symbolic images. Now, Calvin does do something else here, which is very important in this section. He talks about the proper use of art. Calvin has eliminated the use of art in worship, but he says there is a pure and legitimate use of art, sculpture and painting or gifts of God. Not everybody picks up on this from Calvin. Calvin has a reputation of being a person who was out to destroy beautiful things. He certainly wanted to remove the images from the churches and turn people's eyes to the word and to the sacraments. But Calvin was not opposed to art. I'm sorry. This is in 117, 117. Calvin says there are two legitimate uses for art. One is histories and events. That is painting or using sculpture to illustrate some event that has taken place in history. And that is a very proper use of art. It teaches us. It admonishes us as these stories or set forth. They could be biblical or non-biblical. It's not improper to paint a picture of Joshua and the wall of Jericho falling down or some event in secular history. What is then quite surprising, though, is that Calvin says there is some art beyond that. He calls it forms of bodies, can paint forms of bodies or use sculpture for forms of bodies. He says, I do not see what they can afford other than pleasure. That's the most, to some people, the most uncharacteristically sounding Calvin statement. Calvin says some things that are legitimate to paint don't teach us anything. They just give us pleasure. We enjoy looking at beautiful things. Not sure what Calvin would have thought about that abstract painting in the back of the room there that I get to look at. I don't know what that is, but as a certain beauty about it, the colors and the shapes and you can read all sorts of things into it. Calvin probably would not have been a great admirer of abstraction in art, but it's something like that that he was talking about. When he says that we can enjoy art that doesn't teach and admonish, but just gives pleasure. He does it to mean that art can be lascivious or that it can set forth pictures, say of nudity and a lascivious way. In fact, Calvin criticizes, you might note here, the Roman Catholic images as being obscene. Many of them. Pictures of the Virgin Mary in churches, for instance. He says, brothels show correlates clad more virtuously and modestly than the churches show those objects which they wish to be thought images of the Virgin. So he has certain constraints there. Not just prudishness, but concern that art be not only legitimate, but be positive and helpful. B.V. Warfield is writing Calvin's doctrine of God, talking about this material that I've just been discussing, says Calvin was a lover and fosterer of the arts. I wish I could say that. I think maybe Warfield is a little overly enthusiastic at that point, but we can certainly say that Calvin was not an enemy of art as such. It was a place for art, a pure and legitimate use for art. Okay, questions? Yes, sir. You said that Calvin would not have been sure of Joshua Jericho as much as he would think about a picture of Christ. I couldn't quite figure that out. He thought that would be useful or valid. I expect Calvin, although he's not, as you say, not as clear on that in this passage, would have opposed that. It gets into a big debate, which Calvin really doesn't enter into, that debate that was particularly focused in the eastern part of the church, the iconoclastic controversy. My guess is that Calvin would say we cannot depict Christ because we cannot depict the two natures. You see, he tells us that what we should do in art is we can paint only those things which the eyes are capable of seeing. That's 111, 12. Because we can't see God, we can't paint picture of God. Can we paint a picture of Christ? There were plenty of people in the eastern church, like John of Damascus, who said if Christ was a real person, then we can paint him as a person. It was important to some of these theologians that the reality of the human nature of Christ be set forth in pictures. One answer that was given to that is if we paint the human nature of Christ, how do we paint it? How should he be depicted? What should he look like? Because we don't have any record of in art or in words of the physical appearance of Jesus. But I expect Calvin would have been more concerned about the fact that when you paint a picture, Christ you're painting only one nature. Medieval artists tried to get around this by halos. That would depict the other nature, but that seemed to be a wheat way of depicting the two natures. Of course people in the eastern part of the church would say we're not depicting either nature alone. We're depicting the person, and how did people in Jesus' time who saw him see him? Did they see the two natures? No, they saw the person. But that brings us back, I think, to the first question and that is what then should he look like? Yes, if there had been photography back then and we had pictures of Christ, what would we do with them? Calvin would probably say, God sold to it, we did not have the photography back then. Because we would have misused those in some way. The shroud of touring is perhaps the closest we get to something like this, and that is not a very controversial, but very problematic in its use. Well, let's go on to the attributes of God. There's a stress in Calvin, as I've said already, on God as he is toward us, but Calvin will admit that there is a brief mention in the Bible from time to time of God as he is in himself. For instance, Calvin says in 113, 1 God speaks sparingly of his essence. We think of the essence of God, and we think of God's eternity and God's self-existence. One, ten, two, his infinity and his spirituality, 113, one. We could say all these words point to the essence of God, but even these qualities function to limit our understanding of God. Calvin says the word infinity, for instance, ought to make us afraid to try to measure him by our own senses. When we say God is infinite, what are we saying about God except we should not try to limit him in any way. When we say that God is spiritual, that forbids our imagining anything earthly or carnal of him. So let us then willingly leave to God the knowledge of himself. That's just once again saying, when I said already that God as he is in himself is not an area that we can explore. We leave that to God. We leave it to God willingly. Calvin says, but there is much that we do know about God from the Bible. What kind of God is he, and Calvin deals pretty briefly with this actually what he does is to use, I would say, two brief Bible studies to talk about the attributes of God. Later theology will get into this in a very complicated way with communicable attributes and incomunicable attributes and all kinds of lists and divisions, but Calvin doesn't do that. He simply takes us to Exodus 34, 6 and 7 and to Psalm 145, which tell us what we know about God. Those two text reveal something of God's attributes. Maybe Warfield, I think, puts it well when he says that in Calvin's treatment the attributes of God are present, so to speak, in solution rather than in precipitate. That is, we're looking at God. The attributes are in solution. They're not pulled out, lined up, outlined in precipitate. You want to see the difference read Birkhoff on the attributes of God. There you get it in precipitate. Pulled out, arranged, outlined, incomunicable, self-existence, immutability, infinity, unity, communicable attributes, spirituality, intellectual attributes, moral attributes, attributes of sovereignty, and all those have some points to. But in Calvin it's in solution. With all of Calvin's emphasis, and this is a point I want to make not just about this section of the institutes, but about all of the institutes. But all of his emphasis on the sovereignty of God, and certainly that's not a missing element in Calvin. Sometimes people think that is the key element in Calvin's sovereignty of God. But there is even stronger emphasis on God's love, thinking of the attributes of God. You don't really see Calvin as such talking about the sovereignty of God just like that. It's more like our father who is sovereign, or our God who loves us and cares for us who is the sovereign God. He links the two things together, fatherly, sovereign, and sovereign father. I think that's important to remember not only the Calvin does that, but we should do it too. It's not just the sovereignty of God. It's the love and sovereignty of God. When we say God is sovereign, we should also say God is our heavenly Father, so that these two concepts of God are brought together. 111 and 12 deals with worship. It's directed two Christians to enable us to know how to worship God. Actually it's not until book 4 that we get to form a worship of God in the church. We'll come back to all of that at that point, but Calvin can't wait to book 4 to get this in, so as soon as he starts talking about God, he starts talking about worship. The particular direction that those chapters go is two-fold. One, to lead us to know how to worship God and to reject the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox understanding of the use of images in the worship of God. 113 comes to the doctrine of the Trinity, and Calvin here wants to set forth the Bible's positive treatment of the doctrine of the Trinity, and also to reject the anti-Trenitarian views that were prevalent in his day. So this point, from this point on in book 1, Calvin deals with knowledge of God, the Creator, not derived from creation via the Scripture, but found, as we said earlier, solely in the Scripture.

Calvin says, the doctrine of the Trinity is another special mark to distinguish himself more precisely from idols. This is a special mark by which God is distinguished from idols that connects this chapter to the two which proceed. The idols are not, the images are not triune, but God is triune, and Calvin is concerned to assert that apart from a Trinitarian knowledge of God, we really don't know God. If we don't know God as Trinity, we don't know God. It's only through his self-revelation, his father-son in Holy Spirit, do we learn what God's true nature is? Calvin doesn't say it here, or anywhere else, as far as I know, but that would mean that the God that Jews worship and Allah, of Muslims is not God, because he's not Trinity. We can only know God as we know him as triune. Background of this, by 1559, Calvin had been through a lot of battles on this issue, and the 1559 version of the Institute says much more in this chapter than the 1536 edition did. Because Calvin had struggled with opponents on this. Pierre Corroly is one, Gribaldi, another, Servetus, his burn, or his anti-trinitarian eras in Geneva is another, and through all of those debates and struggles, Calvin's treatment of the doctrine of Trinity develops. It's not that his ideas shift, he is, we would say, an orthodox Trinitarian in 1536, and he's an orthodox Trinitarian in 1559, but by 1559 he has borne the scars of many battles over this issue. The doctrine of Trinity was an issue in the 16th century, among the radicals, some of the radicals of the Reformation. So Calvin has much more to say about it by 1559. We say a little bit about Calvin's terminology here. There are two currents in Calvin's thought, and we have to hold to both of them. One is the value of technical terms already in use derived from the church councils and from theological use related to the doctrine of the Trinity. Even the word Trinity is such a word, not in the Bible. The word a person to speak of the three persons, and there's a Greek word for that, and a Latin word for that, and the Greek expression Homo Useas, the same substance with the father coming from Council of Nicaea in 325, should Christians use all of those terms, or is that bringing in Greek philosophical language, non-biblical baggage to complicate what would be much easier without them. Well, Calvin says, we can use them, we need not confine ourselves to the exact words of the Bible, and it's a word field puts it for Calvin, the sense of Scripture, and not the words of Scripture is Scripture. That might seem a reticle at first thought, Calvin, pulls to plenary verbal inspiration, as I said earlier, but you can take the words of Scripture and develop all kinds of heresies, like the Jobas Witnesses do. They quote Scripture, they have their text, they use the words of Scripture, but it's the sense of Scripture, which is Scripture, not the isolated words of Scripture, or another way to say it, it's all of Scripture, which is Scripture, not one text, alone, which is Scripture. So Calvin comes to embrace the use of these technical terms. He says that avoidance of this traditional language may indicate a secret poison. People that say we just want to be biblical and not use these theological terms. Why are they saying that? Is it because they want to be biblical or are they hiding a secret poison? The anti-Twinitarians were the people who would do this, the Aryans were people who do this. Jesus said, my father is greater than I, which shows that Jesus is not God. He's on another level, secondary level, so you can take a text of the Bible and develop a heresy from it. In fact, every heresy comes from some text of the Bible, but it's the sense of Scripture that Calvin is concerned about. Certain heretics, such as Areas, have used scriptural language to affirm non-biblical concepts of God. So we must refute their eras by using these theological statements in order to make the truth plain and clear. Well, that's one stream in Calvin's thought. The other stream is freedom to formulate doctrine independent of traditional statements. At first, Calvin did not want to use these statements. He did not want to be forced to affirm his faith in the language of the counsel of Nassia. And he soon realized that because he was hesitant to do that, people accused him of being Aryan. And he began to get the point that it's one thing to say, I'm just going to be biblical, and I'm not going to use the creeds and confessions because these are the efforts of people to put forth the truth of the Bible. But Calvin also realized that these efforts of people to put forth the truth of the Bible were legitimate efforts in some cases. Everything had to be tested, of course, but these words were not words that were foolishly used and could be used with good effect. But at the same time, he still wants to feel freedom. Substance of doctrine must have priority over any formulation of it, Calvin would say. This is actually his words here. Indeed, I could wish they were buried, that is, these creedal statements. If only among all men, this faith were agreed on, and then he goes on to set forth a statement of the orthodox doctrine of Trinity. People just believed in the doctrine of the Trinity, that the Father is God, the Son is God, the Holy Spirit is God. They are equally God, but they are three persons eternally existing within the one Godhead. People just believe that, then we would not have to use Trinity in person, homogusias and so on. Calvin does give us a number of statements concerning our understanding of the Trinity. One is in 1, 13, 5, Father and Son and Spirit are one God, yet the Son is not the Father, nor the Spirit, the Son, but they are differentiated by a peculiar quality. I won't read more of those, because her time is moving on, but you can find quite a few of these summary statements where Calvin will try to set forth in just a sentence or two, the Christian orthodox doctrine of the Trinity. He then sets forth arguments to support these statements. What he's basically arguing is that in the unity of the Godhead there are distinctions, substances of persons, and he argues for the full deity of the Son. The Son is God, 1, 13, 7 through 13. We'll go through those arguments, but they're well-known and arguments that we still use to prove the deity of Christ and then goes through the same list to set forth the deity of the Holy Spirit in 1, 13, 14, and 15. He, as any orthodox sanitarian, needs to want to and must establish two things. God is one, there are distinctions within the Godhead, father, son, and Holy Spirit, not divisions, but distinctions. In God, there is a certain disposition or economy which does not in any way affect the oneness of His meeting. Calvin says something that we all know, and that is that this defies human analysis or comprehension. Christian has to believe in one God, not three gods, or not tritheist. Some people think we are, but we're not, we believe in one God, but we also believe that there are distinctions within that one God which lead us to an understanding of three persons. It's not a distinction in being each is fully God. Father's fully God, Son is fully God, Holy Spirit is fully God. And Calvin is particularly important in emphasizing this point. The Christian tradition at times has been a little unsure, even after Nassia on this, at least in the way it was expressed, but Calvin insists that each is fully God. The Son is God of Himself, auto-fay us, not just God from the Father. He's the son of the Father, but he's not God from the Father. He's God of Himself as the Holy Spirit is God of Himself. So these are not distinctions in being nor are they distinctions in time. The Aryans had said of the Son there was a time when he was not, but Orthodox theology says that the Son is eternal, just as the Father is eternal, and the Holy Spirit is eternal, but the distinction is as persons within the Godhead in which there is a significant and irreversible order, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. It's not Holy Spirit, Son, and Father. It's Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The Father is the fountain of deity with respect not to being but to order. The Father is the fountain of deity, that's traditional theological language in Calvin's time, but it doesn't mean that the deity of the Son flows from the Father. The deity of the Son flows from Himself, and the deity of the Holy Spirit flows from Himself. So we're not talking about deity when we talk about the Father being the fountain of deity, but we're talking about order. Calvin stresses the fact that knowledge of one of the persons of the Trinity involves knowledge of the other two at the same time, and I think would reject the conventional division of labor within the Godhead, which says the Father is the Creator, the Son is the Redeemer, and the Holy Spirit is the sanctifier. Now we're in book one, knowledge of God, the Creator, but when we talk about knowledge of God, the Creator, we're not just talking about the Father. We're talking about the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. The one God who is the Creator, and you'll notice as we come to book two that even the title of that knowledge of God, the Redeemer, in Christ. See it doesn't say knowledge of Christ, the Redeemer, but knowledge of God, the Redeemer, in Christ, because it's God who is our Redeemer, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, and is God who is our sanctifier, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, the Trinity, as a whole, not each of the persons separately is Creator, Redeemer, and sanctifier. But having said that, Calvin is still willing and eager, feels it very necessary to embrace these distinctions within the Godhead. The Father is the beginning, the Father is the fountain, the Son is wisdom, counsel, ordered disposition of all things. The Spirit is power and efficacy of that activity. Nothing can obscure the unity of the Godhead, but at the same time it's not fitting to suppress these distinctions, which he thinks are made by Scripture. When things are at their most complex in Calvin's discussion of this, he comes to a quotation from Gregory of Nazianzas. By the way, a lot of his tunitarian thought is reflecting the thought of this Eastern theologian, who is called the theologian, one of the great capidotians, the two Gregory's in Basel, of capidotia, modern day Turkey, but Gregory of Nazianzas is very much similar to Calvin, Calvin is drawing often from Gregory in his tunitarian thought. But he says this passage from Gregory vastly delights me. He just loves this passage, and you can see Calvin smiling as he writes this down, and here is the passage from Gregory. I cannot think on the one without quickly being encircled by the splendor of the three, nor can I discern the three without being straightway carried back to the line. So as soon as you think of the oneness of God and your thinking of the of the threeness, and then as you begin to think about the threeness you're carried back to the oneness. That's really a Christian orthodoxy. We just move back and forth. Wherever stop we become heretics, either unitarians are tritheists, but we move back and forth. Calvin gives a defense of this, a justification of polemics. He says the truth which has been peaceably shown must be maintained against the calumnes of the wicked. This is the antithetical structuring of the institutes that I spoke about in the first lecture. Calvin not only sets forth positively what the scripture teaches, but feels that it is also important to reject that which is false. So he gives a defense of the doctrine of the Trinity against the anti-Trinitarians, especially servitas that tragic figure comes in here. Servitas' theology was anti-Trinitarian. It was a strange and logically impossible mixture of civilianism and Aryanism. I won't unpack that for you, but if you think about it, you realize that a civilian cannot be an Aryan. An Aryan cannot be a civilian, but Servitas was both. Gerald Bray in the book, The Doctor of God, talks about the logically impossible view Servitas. But I want to come to the evaluation the last four minutes.

Warfield says that the notes of Calvin's conception of the Trinity are simplification, clarification, and equalization. I think that's well put, but Calvin's really great contribution is the equalization, because in medieval tradition, despite what had been established earlier in the church councils, the father was recognized as the source of divinity in a way in which the other two persons were not. And Calvin insists on the consubstantiality of the persons. Whatever the father is as God, the son is as God, and the Holy Spirit is as God. Calvin insists on the self-existence of the son. Sometimes we use the word Asseity, A-S-E-I-T-Y. Greek expression is autofeyos. The son is God in his own right, not merely by divine appointment. The son does not yet his divinity from the father. He is God in himself, the existence of the son. The deity of the son exists absolutely of itself. The son is God, exists of himself, and the Holy Spirit is God, exists of himself. The son, as the son, exists of the father. Use this diagram to set forth what I think is Calvin's great contribution here. God is God in himself, but he is father in relation to the son. The second person of the Trinity, the son, is God in himself. He is son in relation to the father. The third person of the Trinity, the Holy Spirit, is God in himself. He is Holy Spirit in relation to the father and the son. I think it's tolerance that talks about the downright deity of the son, which is found in Calvin, no derived deity, but downright deity. And then just one further point,

the creed speaks of the son as being God from God, and that language can lead astray. Calvin must be sure that any hint of causality, latent in terminology like that, as far as the deity of the son is concerned, be eliminated. And also Calvin is concerned about the idea from Nicaea of the son being begotten of the father before all ages. Now it's not that Calvin rejects that concept, the generation, the eternal generation of the son. He thinks that's a proper way to set forth the distinction between the father and the son. But he does say in 1329, but what is the point in disputing whether the father always begets, indeed it is foolish to imagine a continuous act of beginning since it is clear that three persons have subsisted in God from eternity. I think what Calvin is rejecting here is not the eternal generation, but he is objecting to seeing the generation of the son as an eternal act ongoing generation as opposed to an eternally completed act. It's not that the son receives anything from the father as a continuous emanation that act of generation which is simply a way of speaking of distinction between the father and the son. It's something that's done and should not be considered something that continues for what is the point in disputing whether the father always begets. Calvin says yes the father begot the son, that doesn't have anything to do with subordination. It's simply a word that the church is used to set forth the difference between the father and the son. As the word procession or proceeds is used to set forth the difference between the Holy Spirit and the father and the son. So Calvin is not opposing, I see, but he can't see that eternal generation means something that keeps on going always. It's a description of something that is eternally true but not an ongoing activity. Well that's as far as we can go today, time is up, we'll look at Creation next time.