<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Doe Doe Mensalmente

Postmodernism & Epistemology

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Let's pray together. Heavenly Father, we thank You for this beautiful morning with the sunshine and the warmer weather and the hint that spring will indeed come. And Father, we are so thankful that we are living in Your universe, that You are the one who has made all things. You have committed Yourself to this creation. And You do promise that the seasons will come one after the other, that spring will return. Father, You are the one who has committed to new life, and You bring new life to us. And Father, as we think of that promise of spring and Your work in our hearts to renew us day by day, we look forward to the regeneration of all things when Jesus comes, both of the creation of Randas and of ourselves as well. And in the meantime, Father, we pray, that as we look forward to that day, You will help us to be those who serve You faithfully, who love Your truth and who delight in making it known to those Randas. Teach us today, we pray, for Jesus' sake, our men. And then we are going to turn thirdly and to see, to post-modernism and say a little bit about epistemology, that is the philosophy of knowledge, how we know anything. Now, I'm not going to take a lot of time on this. It isn't fair to those of you who were in biblical and cultural hermeneutics. So I would ask those of you who were not in that class to make sure you read those quotations, which we didn't go through all of them last time about language and literary criticism. Read them carefully, try to understand them, ask questions about them if you have a problem with them, because those who are in the class who are in hermeneutics will have a much clearer grasp of some of these things. So I want to go quickly through this section on epistemology. It's the third area in which we hear the word post-modernism used in the context of the philosophy of knowledge. Now, to give some background to this, it's important for us to recognize that we as Christians, for example, who would be considered pre-modern by post-modernists. We who are Christians, and many others who believe in God in some form or another, Orthodox Jews, Muslims, Hindus who are monotheists, the most Hindus are pantheists and pagan, but a few are monotheists, believe in one God. Not only those who believe in God in some sense, but anyone who has any sense that there is something ultimate in the universe, would be regarded as pre-modern, and pre-moderns like the Christian have the conviction that because God knows everything, but even though we are finite and limited in our understanding, that's not so much of a problem, because God knows everything truly, and God has made himself known to us. And not only that, but because we are made in the image of God, the Christian would say, because we are made in the likeness of God, of God is able to communicate with us in language, to reveal truth to us in a way that we can understand. And not only that, but God has made us with a coherence with the world around us. We are part of this universe. God has set us here. We are like God in terms of the fact that we are persons made in his image, to understand, as he understands, to think his thoughts after him, but we are also part of this creation. And consequently, because there is a coherence between us and the creation and God has given us the gift of understanding and rationality, we can understand the world in which we live. We can come to a true understanding of it. So the Christian, while we recognize that knowledge is sometimes difficult to get, because of our sinfulness, believes that God is so committed to revealing truth to us, and not just to the believer, but to all people, but it's possible for all human beings to have true knowledge about the nature of the world in which we live, a true understanding. So that's, if you like, the background to this discussion. In the period of modernism, that is the period of the Enlightenment from say approximately 1,650 up until the very recent past, the period of what is called modernism. Modernism, if we want to use the term rationalism, or secular humanism, rejected the need for the existence of God, and said it's simply possible for human beings to know truly by the use of our reason. And that's really what is called the Enlightenment Project is all about. The sense that reason is sufficient to lead us to a clear understanding of the nature of the universe, the nature of human existence, and reason will teach us as well how to live, give us a set of valid and universal ethical standards. That was the conviction of the Enlightenment of modernism, of secularism, for a couple of hundred years or more. Postmodernism is a reaction against that, a passionate reaction against that confidence in reason. Fundamentally, postmodernism is saying, if there's no God up there, let's be serious about what that means. We are alone here in this world, and there's only us, and we are finite. And where, for the Christian, finiteness is not a problem because of the existence of God and his revelation, for the postmodernist being finite is an enormous problem. It's a barrier over which one can never leap, and that brings us to the points we're going to look at here today. Number one, there is nothing transcendent that is nothing above us, neither God nor anything else that understands everything. Consequently, there is no objective truth available to us. There is no objective truth available to us. There cannot be, because it is not possible for a finite, limited person existing at a particular moment in time, in a particular setting, to know enough to ever be able to say that they know truly the way things are. That's the fundamental problem for postmodernism. If there's nobody there in heaven, there's nothing transcendent, then there is no way we can possibly have access to objective truth. How can I ever know that what I think is objectively true? That's why it doesn't help you to do what obvious men does in this cartoon, to say this is a contradiction, to say there is absolutely no possibility of knowing anything. And you say, well, that's an absolute statement. If you respond that way to somebody who's truly postmodern, they won't pay any attention to what you're saying. That's exactly our problem. We just don't know anything. So even what I say is absurd, and what you're saying is absurd too, so it won't help you very much to make that kind of comment. And that's why Wiley has obvious men doing it, saying things which are so self-evident that it's pointless saying them. For the postmodernist, its pointless to even ask the question, whether there is an objective world, for we have no way of knowing the answer to the question. There's a postmodern book on epistemology published about five or six years ago, which has at the beginning of the book a kind of account of a brain in a jar. And the point of that parable is that we have no way of knowing whether that's true or not, whether I really exist, and I'm standing here in front of this class teaching you today, and you are sitting there listening to me, I believe. Or whether I'm actually just a brain in a jar in somebody's experiment in a laboratory, and they are causing my brain to have the sensations of you sitting in front of me listening to me and Christy back there recording this on video. That's the point of the parable, and that's a typical kind of parable for somebody who has a postmodern understanding of epistemology. We're trapped in our finiteness, and we have no way at all of getting out of it. All that is available to us, and it brings us back to what we were talking about last time. All that is available to us is the language we use to describe what my personal senses perceive. So this is a huge dilemma, and David Hume already understood this at the very foundation of the enlightenment that this was a problem that I can never be sure that what I think I know is the truth. And in particular, Nietzsche, at the end of the 19th century, developed this very carefully, and there's a very famous parable of his, which we'll look at later in the semester, if we have time, where he talks about a madman, who comes into the marketplace where everybody's carrying on as if life is perfectly normal, and everything's fine, and he says don't you realize that God is gone. And that means everything is gone, the possibility of knowing anything, and all the people in the marketplace are secularists, they're modernists, and they just laugh at him. They just laugh at him and say you're crazy, what an earth you're talking about. Everything is going to carry on just the same, even though God does not exist. The modernists were optimistic about the absence of God. Host modernists and Nietzsche's expressing this in this famous parable recognize what an awful problem it is that God doesn't exist. We can't know anything, and Nietzsche uses the image of the sun being removed from the horizon, so that we're dwelling in complete darkness, and in absolute coldness, and Nietzsche then goes on to say in some very famous words, which are like a prophetic vision of the culture in which we are living now. What would happen, he said, when this truth begins to sink in, that is that without God, we do not have the possibility of knowing anything, what Nietzsche prophesied that would produce is a culture which could be identified by annoying skepticism and relativism, annoying and crumbling skepticism and relativism. It absolutely describes the culture in which you and I live today. A deep skepticism, an uncertainty about what we can know and about the meaning of human life, and a relativism that is a loss of confidence that any moral standards by which we can judge our human life or call ourselves or other people to account. And that's a prophetic description of the ruined world in which we live, and that's what Nietzsche is foreseeing. It's a very thoughtful man, and he really understood what this would mean for people at a time when most people around him, most modernists had no understanding at all. So that's the fundamental point here. Number two, number two. In knowing I am not ever free, that is, I never stand by myself able to see anything objectively or even clearly. I always come to every issue with prejudices, with beliefs, with a background. My parents, the culture in which I live, has taught me to look at the world in a particular way, and that determines what I am going to see. It's as if we're wearing a set of colored glasses, and we don't realize it, so that everything that we look at is colored by those glasses, or to use another image, and this would be a helpful one, some of you in this room are probably color blind, and many of you, for example, there are several of you. Now, in a group this size, there's bound to be some. That's not an absolute prediction, but it's probable, let's say, that there will be some people color blind in a group this size. Now, some people who color blind don't know they are, and then suddenly we'll discover it one day, when I was in seminary, a very dear friend of mine, had a common gear. And it was a sort of dirty brown color, and ever since he'd had it, he'd been driving it for years, he didn't realize that was the color it was. And he got a scratch one day when somebody where he was parked just brushed against his car, so he went to buy some paint to cover up the scratch, and he painted it bright green. And that's what he thought his car was, and I said to him, why on earth did you paint it that color? Well, he thought it was exactly the same, and he didn't see it. Now, that's a good illustration of the problem that the postmodernist is pointing at. The person who is color blind doesn't know that that color blind. They see the world that particular way. They can't see it any other way. And the postmodernist is saying that's true of all of our knowing. I'm never free from my color blindness. I cannot set it right. To every issue I think about, to everything I look at, I come with a set of prejudices with my background, with my beliefs. Now, some postmodernists will emphasize that there are communities of knowledge. Some postmodernists would look at a group like us and say, there's a community of knowledge who have a shared view of things. They share the same prejudices, or they might look at a group of Muslims and say, there's another group, a community with a set of shared prejudices, or a group of, let's say, gay rights activists, or a group of radical feminists and say, they share the same prejudices. So some postmodernists emphasize those communities of knowledge, people who abandon so closely together that they're looking at the world, not in absolutely similar, but very similar ways. Others will stress the isolation of the individual knower. That is that each of us is trapped completely like the color blind person in their own particular view of the world. And can never get out of it to understand what anybody else thinks, because I can't get inside somebody else's head. And that's the reason why we have the problem with language that we talked about last time. We can't ever really communicate with each other. Our words are constantly slipping past each other, because we can't even know whether another person really understands what we've said, because they have automatically interpreted our words through their own set of prejudices and convictions. So that's the second problem. Number three, we better move up the screen here a bit. Number three, reason is a weak tool and can never lead us to true knowledge for it is always constrained by our prejudices, where modernism emphasized very passionately the validity of reason. As an adequate tool to lead to truth, to true understanding of the universe in which we live, to a true understanding of the human condition, to a sure set of ethical standards. What the postmodernist says instead is reason will never lead me to the truth, because my reason is always under the control of my prejudices. There's an element of truth in this, which we all need to recognize. So at each point here, postmodernism is saying some things which we need to take seriously, because modernism was wrong. It was really wrong. Reason does not lead to the truth. We have no access to ultimate truth without the revelation of God. So the postmodernist critique of modernism is an accurate critique. Now reason and the claim of knowledge, the postmodernist says, this is still under three here, are weapons used by the powerful. To maintain their power and interests at the expense of the powerless. So postmodernism regards people's claim to have truth as just being a weapon to impose their views on other people, under the guise of being reasonable. Now again, you see how what a challenging situation this makes for us as Christians. You can't just stand up there and say, this is true. And the postmodernist says, why? You say, well, I believe it. You say, well, that's exactly what I thought. That's your personal faith. I'm going to help you at all. I believe something quite different, he'll say. And so you say, well, let me reason with you about it. And he will say, well, the reasons you're putting forward only makes sense within your set of prejudices. They don't make any sense to me. Makes it extremely difficult to communicate how to get somebody out of their subjectivity because the postmodernist insists that reason is always banned by the subjectivity of the individual. For the postmodernist knowledge is simply a weapon in society, a weapon to be used in the culture war. And this is why our society talks about things like the culture war. It was a Christian sociologist, I think, James Davidson Hunter. He's actually a member of the PCA who teaches at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, who first I think coined that expression, culture wars. That is that we are in a society where there are different cultural groups at war with each other. And knowledge becomes a weapon in that war. Knowledge which we use to our advantage to try to push our agenda in for society and impose it on other people. And again, we have to be very careful how we say things and how we do things in this cultural context. Because the attempt to use money and power to influence people is immediately seen as suspicious as a kind of imperialism, just a misuse of our private knowledge to attack other people with. So that's the fourth or the third rather element of the postmodernist view here. And I'll run through the last couple quickly. Number four, postmodernism is passionately anti-abstract. A lot of modernist philosophies seems to the postmodernist very abstruse dealing with all kinds of theoretical questions. And the postmodernist is just a waste of time. That's just a waste of time. We want philosophy to actually deal with the practicalities of human existence. And I quote here Jean-Paul Sartre, who said he wanted to create a philosophy that makes human life possible. Sartre was an existentialist and think about that word existence, your list. He's saying, I want my philosophy to be of that existence, to enable me to live, to exist. I want some just theoretical abstract ideas about the universe and about the human condition. I want to be able to live. And existentialism, I suppose, is in one sense a precursor of postmodernism. So it's passionately anti-abstract. A very strong rejection of the way philosophy can just play games with words. Number five, there are no grants for optimism about humanity or about the future. It's the second fundamental aspect of postmodernism, or modernism. The first was a confidence in reason. The second is an optimism about the human condition. And postmodernism strongly rejects that. We have no grants to be hopeful about our future, about the future of the individual, about the future of our nation, about the future of the human race. There are no grants for optimism whatsoever. People are not necessarily basically good. In fact, history is filled with the polling examples of human evil. And the postmodernist would delight in pointing out that it's in the 20th century where Western society prides itself on its modernism. It advances its scientific and technological achievements that we ended up doing some of the most wicked things in the whole of human history. The Second World War with 50 million people being killed, and the gas chambers in Ashwitz with 6 million Jews killed in that kind of consequence, context, or in the Soviet Union with an enormous number of people put to death under the time of Stalin. The 20th century is a century of very great wickedness. And the postmodernist delights in pointing that out, not in the sense of thinking this is something to laugh about, but of saying stop having the folly of being optimistic. Or your scientific advances just enable you to kill each other in great numbers, and in more brutal ways. And so the postmodernist points to the awful destructiveness, for example, of nuclear weapons. We make these things, but we can destroy the race, destroy the planet on which we live. But point is well to the way technological advances, like the television, actually dehumanize us. We sit in front of them like vegetables becoming more and more passive, less and less creative, less and less involved. We live in this extraordinarily advanced society, but community has almost disappeared from among us. So the postmodernist is pointing out all sorts of practical realities. Those science and technology do not deliver us from the problems of our human condition. They simply make some of those problems even worse. So a passionate rejection of optimism. Okay, before we begin, does anybody have any questions just for clarification before we move on here? Or are you ready for me to move to our next section? And you want to keep your questions to the end? Yes. That's a very good question. I need to repeat it for the video here. I was pointing out that the postmodernist tells us that all of us has a set of prejudices, many of them taught by our parents, by the community, by the cultural context in which we were raised. And I'm being asked what's the difference with coming to seminary? Are we just being taught another set of prejudices? It's a very good question. And of course, the postmodernist would say, that's exactly right. That's exactly right. You come to seminary just to be reinforced in your prejudices. You already have them, and you just knowledge is just a tool to make you feel more comfortable and secure in the prejudices you already have, which will make you even more inflexible. And even more incapable of communicating with anybody else. So that's precisely what the postmodernist would say. It would regard theoretically a postmodernist ought to regard any educational institution as doing that, including one in which he's teaching himself. And you can't escape from that. And that's why someone has said postmodernism is nealism with a smile, because the postmodernist will happily acknowledge it. If you say, but you're doing the same thing, you're accusing me of just communicating prejudices to people. And that's what you're doing, and you'll say, I know it perfectly well. The difference is with you, you don't. And he will be amused by that. That's why it's not easy to respond. And that's again the meaning of this cartoon of obvious men by Wiley Miller. His known sequitur, it's really worth reading because he has a very cute understanding of what's going on in our culture. And yeah, this is that's challenging. And you need, it's something you need to reflect about. And I would say just at the level of listening to any of us teach, the scripture of course teaches us to respect people and authorities. So I hope you respect me and my fellow professors here on this campus. At the same time, the scripture also challenges you to be discerning. So Luke says about the Bereans in Acts chapter 17, where Paul is preaching into the Bereans. He says they were of more noble character because they examine the scriptures every day to see if what Paul was saying was true. So you don't want to just sit here listening that you need to reflect about it. And ask yourself, is Jerem just communicating his prejudices? It's a very good question to ask. And that's why I said at the very beginning of the first class, if you disagree with me, please don't hesitate to say so because I'm interested in finding out truth. And not just communicating the prejudices that I already have. So at that level, yes, we need to be aware of the need to reflect on everything we hear, as the New Testament says, test everything and hold fast only to that which is good. Now, at a deeper level, of course, the postmodernist really is saying to us is that you can't know anything and you can't actually test everything, though he always puts himself in the position of critiquing other people, far more consistently than he critiqued himself. And it is important to point that out, though you're not going to win a great battle by saying that, but it's important to get that, to try to get the postmodernist to come down from his own particular pulpit and truly realize that he's in this position himself. But what I would say in responses, you know, exactly right, if God doesn't exist, you're exactly right. And I recognize that. And I would not be a Christian without God's having made himself known to us. There's no reason to be at all. No reason to be at all. Now, we're not engaged in wishful thinking. And the New Testament is very clear about that. And it makes this point in all sorts of different contexts. Paul says, if Christ wasn't raised in the dead, if this isn't true, then the people who died are still dead and worse than our sins, and that Zedrin can be married for tomorrow we die. So we, there's a challenge here, which we really have to reflect on. Do I believe this is the truth or don't I? And if I do not really, if I'm not really understanding this is truth, I have nothing to say to my contemporaries. Absolutely nothing. Except as I said last time, all I can say is well, really, this is like music and it'll just make you feel more comfortable. There's very interesting story here. Let me tell you, this was a debate once that took place between Rudolph Boltman, his very famous German, very liberal theologian, Boltman regarded all that the New Testament teaches us about the person of Jesus Christ as mythology. Christ wasn't the son of God. He wasn't one of a virgin. He didn't do miracles. He was not crucified for our sins. He did not rise from the dead. He is not coming again. Boltman did not believe any of those things. He said, all we can know is that there was someone called Jesus who existed. He was a radical, historical skepticism and he had a debate once with a Swiss existentialist philosopher named Karl Jasper's. And Jasper's is a person who holds this postmodern view of knowledge that it is not possible for us to know anything with any certainty at all. It's Jasper's who, see if I can think of a couple of examples, he says something like this, the God has withdrawn himself as the sun has set below the horizon. We are living in absolute darkness and he says all we have to hold up against that absolute darkness is a tiny flicker of light that is our hope and longing for something better. And he has this debate, this public debate with Boltman. And at first they discussed the possibility of knowledge and the inadequacy of reason and Boltman completely agrees with him. Because Boltman is really in this same dilemma, though he is a Christian theologian teaching theology at a university and preaching in churches. And Boltman preached that people should put their faith in Christ and his death and resurrection, though he did not believe in them. But he preached that, so Karl Jasper's after they had agreed on we have no possibility of knowledge, we know that life is ultimately absurd, there's no meaning to the human condition, we can't know anything truly. Jasper said to him publicly, while this talk about the resurrection, how can you possibly talk about the resurrection of Christ? If you agree with me that knowledge is impossible, that reason leads us nowhere, that there are no answers to the human condition and to our problems. And Boltman's response was, I have to have something to say to people in need. I don't believe the resurrection happened. I don't believe anybody else is going to be raised from the dead. When we die, that's it. We go out like a candle. But people need to hear something in their need. Now, you remember last time I quoted Francis Young using this image of Christianity's like music, and that's a perfectly appropriate to describe what Boltman is doing. That we go to church and we worship and we listen to sermons and we proclaim the gospel to people, because we know actually that the human condition is completely absurd and meaningless, but we need some comfort in that. And this is the way we feel comforted by going to church and worshipping and listening to sermons. And we have to understand that that's how people hear us, that we're just sharing to quote Shakespeare a tale told by an idiot, signifying nothing just for the sake of comforting ourselves. That's how people hear us. And it's not easy to break out of that. The next area of our outline here, we're coming to post-modernism D, consequences. And for those of you who are in hermeneutics, this is where we are going off in a new direction. What does this mean? At the moment, it would be easy for somebody to respond. Oh, the issue of style doesn't matter, that's just buildings and paintings and music. You know, that's just a kind of intellectual game. You've been talking about language and literary criticism and now about epistemology, that's just something that affects a few university professors and a tiny number of intellectuals. You know, this is all completely beside the point. What's this got to do with us? And maybe some of you have been thinking that. I hope not. If you have been thinking that, let me tell you, you have nothing to say to your contemporaries. You have nothing to say. If you don't understand, the problem this creates for us. It means you don't have any idea how the unbelievers around you are thinking and living. If you really, if any of you in this room think that what we've discussed the last class and a half is really kind of irrelevant. Let's think about the consequences. What are the consequences? And I want to go through this carefully here. Number one, human reason is inadequate to lead us to the truth. Human reason is inadequate to lead us to the truth. We have no possibility of finding objective truth, no possibility of finding absolute truth. All there is for us is personal truth. You have your truths and I have mine and that's all there is. We can't get anywhere else at all. There's a story which comes from a book by Walter Truitt Anderson called Reality Isn't What It Used To Be. In which he illustrates the problem. And his story is a joke about three baseball empires sitting having a bite to eat and a beer after the game is over. And this is what they say to each other. The first one says this. There's balls and strikes. I call them the way they are. And the second one says there's balls and strikes. I call them the way I see them. And the third one says there's balls and strikes and they ain't nothing until I call them. Now that expresses the postmodern dilemma. We really can't know anything even with regard to a game of baseball. What's really happening out there? What's really happening? There is only my personal truth. I have no access to truly understanding the world in which I live or the human condition or the future or anything else. Truth is what I decided is. There's balls and strikes and they ain't nothing until I call them. I'll take your questions a little later if you want to hold on when we get through this section here. Now does this really affect the people around us? Well you remember the story I told you at the beginning about the young people here in St. Louis, a group of kids at Washington University, a group of kids in the inner city. Both of them are exactly in this place. That is skeptical about the possibility of knowing anything at all. Now in terms of the actual figures, the figures are something like this. You know, I am not particularly into surveys and statistics, though they certainly have some value. But if you won't find me quoting lots of them, but if you look at the surveys that George Barna and George Gallup have done over the last, let's say, ten years, the figures you'll get consistently are something like this. That around two thirds to 70% of the whole population in every part of the country does not believe there is absolute truth. Those are the figures. It doesn't matter how you answer the question. You can ask it in a sort of abstract way. If you believe there is absolute truth, you can ask it in all sorts of much more practical ways that are easier to get access to what you mean, no matter how you ask the question, that's the answer you'll get. There are over 70% of Americans of every racial, cultural, educational, social, economic group right across this nation in every part of it, from the Bible belt to the far west to the northeast. So in this way, the figures are astonishingly similar across the whole nation. When it comes to people of Generation X, the figures are over 80%. And I would say simply for myself, just chatting with friends of my boys when they were in high school, I have three sons who are in their 20s now. They had one or two Christians they knew in school, but apart from them, there wasn't anybody for whom would it even enter their mind that knowing truth about the world would be possible. See, it's not that they have come to conclusion that you can't know truth. They take it for granted that you can't. They don't even ask the question or recognize that they doubt it. Because it's so much part of the air we breathe in the society in which we live. Now it's not because people have all been listening to postmodern lectures, that's not the point. It's the air we breathe in the culture. You just listen to the music that young people listen to. Just think about the discussions, for example, about the impeachment trial in Congress. Listen to the discussions about what happened with the election in Florida. People just talk right past each other. People come at things with prejudices which prevent them from seeing what's happening. They impose their views on things. You see, there's an element of truth in what postmodernism says, but at the very deep level, people don't believe that access to truth to absolute truth is possible. There's only their own personal truth. You have your truth, and I have mine. Now there are all sorts of things that reinforce this. Point A here, pluralism reinforces this. Now we may use the word pluralism in several different senses. The first sense, and this will be true if you look up the word pluralism in a dictionary. The first sense is that what we might call descriptive pluralism. That is, descriptive pluralism says, we are living in a society in which there is a vast diversity of groups of people. Different races, different cultures, different religions, different ways of looking at life. That's descriptive pluralism, and of course this is accurate. This is true. America at the level of religion, probably every other level as well, is the most diverse society the world has ever seen. That's the reality of the culture in which we live. This is true. America is extraordinarily diverse. It's extraordinarily diverse religiously. I was in Houston two weeks ago, three weeks ago, teaching a doctoral class there. There are at least 40 Islamic mosques in Houston. I was in Chicago not long ago. There are more than 50 there. It's the same in New York, the same in Los Angeles. St. Louis has several. In a city like Houston or Los Angeles or New York or Chicago, there will be two or three dozen Hindu temples. What is temples? I just think about where we live right here. One day I drew a radius of five miles from this seminary campus around here. Just to look at the religious diversity where we are right here. Just within a radius of five or six miles from here, you'll find something like 60 or 70 different Christian denominations represented. In the greatest St. Louis area as a whole, it's well over 100. All sorts of different denominations and endless churches which have no affiliation to anybody else at all. And then as well as the Protestant churches, there are also women, a five or six mile radius of here, lots and lots of Catholic churches, of various different kinds. There are several orthodox churches, Greek orthodox churches, Russian orthodox churches, Serbian orthodox churches. And then there are synagogues, just five or six synagogues within five miles of here, and schools, Jewish schools. This is one of the largest Jewish communities in the United States because of the Jewish community center here. It's a city where Jews come from all over the world and start their life in the United States and then spread out from here across the nation. There's least half a dozen synagogues within five miles of here. There's an Islamic mosque, Mosque at on Wyman Road, which is just built three or four years ago. Huge mosques, some of you will have seen it down there. There are a couple of other Muslim groups as well as that mosque. There's a Hindu temple on Wyman Road. Again, less than five miles from here, a huge Hindu temple, and there are other Hindu meeting places as well. There are endless new age groups meeting within this area, dozens of them, of all sorts of sizes and of vast variety of beliefs. There's a Mormon temple, just down the road, the 50th Mormon temple in the world, right here. There are several Jehovah's Witnesses, Kingdom Halls, and several other Mormon churches in the area too. Just in this immediate area, there are several Christian science churches and a huge Christian science high school, just a couple of miles away. They have the biggest campus of any educational institution in the whole St. Louis area. This is one of the centers in the world of Christian science, right here, where we are. And that's just all the different kinds of places of worship. Never mind people who believe all sorts of other things, or who think they don't believe anything at all. We're living in a context of extraordinary religious diversity. That's descriptive pluralism. We may use the term pluralism in a second sense as well, and that is relativistic pluralism. And again, you'll find this in addiction. If you look up in Webster or any other dictionary, you'll find that first definition, a society with this great diversity, you'll find a second definition. That is that there is not one view of reality, which makes full sense of the world, but there are all sorts of competing and different views, which people have of the world in which we live. So the second definition will be something like that. That there is no one truth. That there are all these various ways of seeing the world. Now, that's relativistic pluralism, and when you're talking with somebody, you need to make sure that you understand how you're using the term. Because if you're using it in descriptive sense, that first sense, then there's nothing wrong with that. That is just simply the truth about where we live. And we need to recognize that. If you're using a second sense, if somebody's using that sense, you need to understand that. So otherwise, you're just going to go past each other. It would be a perfect illustration of the postmodern dilemma that we use words in different ways. There's a third sense of the term as well. And that is what we might call legislative pluralism. That is where a society and its laws and its lawmakers decide that it will uphold pluralism. That is, people will be free to have their different religious views. And all will be protected by the law, so that the society decides that the government will not favor one church or one religion over another. Now, sometimes we use the word pluralism in that sense as well, that this is actually a good thing that we have a society. We want laws to protect this, to protect religious diversity. Francis Schaeff used to say, in this statement, may surprise some of you. I may disagree with you, but I will die for your right to disagree with me. You think about that one. Now, just on this issue of pluralism, sometimes Christians get hot under the collar about it in an inappropriate way. We think that what we really need is the state to kind of work on our side as Christians. And uphold Christianity, legislate prayer in the schools. I'm probably treading on all sorts of toes by talking about this issue. But let me tread on them firmly. Christians do not need the state to try to require people to be Christian. You can't legislate worship. Well, you can, but you shouldn't want to as a Christian. You can't require people to pray. I can tell you, growing up in a country, England, where we had school assemblies every day, with required prayer and required religious instruction, because there was a state church. It was an enemy of the gospel. Most of the time, because most of the people praying those prayers didn't believe them. It had actually had the effect of inoculating people against Christianity. Some of you may not like what I'm saying, but just listen, please. It wasn't helpful. And the religious instruction up from the Bible was by people who didn't believe it most of the time. And we all hated those classes. It had the effect of making us feel that Christianity is completely irrelevant because the people who taught it didn't believe it. That's one problem with trying to have the state legislate your religion. Another problem is this. If we ask for this, are we saying that in a state like Utah, what we want is legislated Mormon prayer, because the majority of the people are Mormons? Well, let me put it another way. How do you pray for the missionaries from your church who are in a country like Saudi Arabia or Iran? Let me tell you how you pray, because in those societies Islam is legislated by the state. It is against the law to preach the gospel of Christ, and it is against the law to convert, and there are severe penalties if you do. It would be the same in a Hindu kingdom like Nepal. It is against the law for a Napoli to preach the gospel of Christ, and it's against the law for a Napoli to convert to Christ. Now, what are we praying for? Because I have very good friends who work in both of these contexts. What we pray for is the beginnings of legislated pluralism. That's what you're praying for. You're praying not that, or the Muslim Imams, we put to death, they're not allowed to speak, and the mosques close down. You're praying simply that Christians will be allowed to proclaim the gospel, and that the people in Saudi Arabia, or Iran, or Nepal, will have the freedom to convert to Christianity, because you know that freedom, in that sense, the state not interfering with religious belief, is the friend of the gospel. The Holy Spirit does not need the force of the state to uphold the gospel. He simply needs the possibility of Christians being able to live and proclaim the truth without fear of persecution, and people being able to convert without fear of persecution, and Christ people will become Christians. That's the reality. That's what we pray for in every setting where Christianity is persecuted. Now, of course, we recognize this creates problems before the fall of the Iron Curtain. In the former Soviet Union, Christians were persecuted all over the place, and we all prayed, you all prayed. I'm sure many times, for the end of Communism, so that the church might be free to preach the gospel without hindrance from the state. Now, that's happened. One of the consequences, of course, is that now Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses and every New Age cult also is able to proclaim their ideas, all over the former Soviet Union, and they're growing rapidly there, as well as the church. But Christians kind of at both ways. You can't want to have freedom for me, but not for anybody else. You see, historically, it's no accident that the church is much stronger here than it is in any Western European country where we had the state backing up our religion. You don't need it. The gospel flourishes much better in a context of freedom. We don't need to burn books. We don't need to stop people listening to false teachers. Let me tell you a wonderful story. Something that might be quite new to you. When William Kerry is the founder of the Modern Mishmi movement in the 1790s, not that long ago, just over 200 years ago, because the Protestant churches didn't really get to well the challenge of the Great Commission to go out into all the world and preach the gospel. You might think that's very clear to us. Well, we do struggle with not seeing things clearly, with prejudice and knowledge that doesn't always come easily to us. It wasn't until the 1790s that the Protestant church really began to get its act together and that started with William Kerry, going from England to India to start to preach the gospel there. William Kerry is a fascinating man, and it's worth your reading a lot about. Among other things, he translated the Bible into Bengali, the language of the people, but he also used a passionately committed Calvinist. He also translated the Hindu holy books from Sanskrit into the language of the people. Because he wasn't afraid of them reading them. He just simply wanted them to have the opportunity to look at God's word and to compare for themselves its truth and its claims with what their own religions taught. He wasn't afraid of them seeing more clearly than they had ever seen what Hinduism taught. We don't have to be afraid. You will never proclaim the gospel faithfully to anybody by requiring, but they don't watch things, they don't listen to things, they don't read things, something else. So when you come back to your question, our education can never be about communicating propaganda. That's what the Marxist did. And sometimes Christians talk because if that's what we want to do, we'll just give people absolutely programmed education. We won't allow them to ever think about anything else. It's not the way God treats us. He challenges us with the truth and we have to challenge people with the truth. And not be afraid of them being exposed to other ideas. It doesn't help us. We don't need the enforcement in any way. That's just a little aside. But to come back to our main point here, how pluralism reinforces this. I meant pluralism in both senses, both the first two senses challenges us. In the first sense, the fact that we live in a descriptively pluralistic society. It's much easier for people to say, I'm a Christian, if everybody around me is a Christian. But if I've got neighbors, let's say my next door neighbors are Hindus, or Muslims, or my college roommate, and they're really decent people, it's challenging. So you have to think it, no, it ought not to be challenging. But it's sometimes challenging to us because we haven't thought through what we believe and we just assume that being a Christian is the only way you can be a decent person. Some Christians really think like that. When I was in seminary, I had one of my fellow students say to me, well, non-Christians don't love each other. Have you ever met any? Have you ever met any? If you think such a thing, if you try to put yourself in a little cocoon, you might have such views. But if you really rub shoulders with people and get to know them, who are unbelievers, you find lots of really decent people out there. In all sorts of ways, not saying anybody's perfectly good, none of us are. Nobody is, that's not the point, but there's lots of really decent people who aren't Christians. So living in a pluralistic society can challenge us. Now, in the second sense, living in a pluralistic society in a relativistic society, which says there is no truth, which explains reality, that's very challenging to us because that's the way we breathe all around us. So that really affects us in all sorts of practical ways. The second here, point B, was, this is being American. Everybody has the right to their own views. Well, of course I'm free to think what I want. Of course I'm free to believe what I want. This is just part of our American democracy. Now, in one sense, of course, that's true. We live in a society which has a history of upholding people's freedom to think and believe what they want, and that's a good thing. But it depends on how far we take that. If we turn that freedom into saying, therefore, people are free to think what they want and they're right when they think what they want. Then you've got another problem, and that's why the first half of what Schaefer said is important. I will disagree with you, and I'll sit down and try to persuade you, though I will die for your right to disagree with me, but I will disagree with you. In other words, the Christian has to hold on to this conviction of truth rather than just saying, well, everybody has a right to their own views, and that means everybody will just leave them in their own views. The Christian can never be content with that, but it's very challenging to us not to stay there, and that's one of the reasons why Christians just like to be with other Christians. It's much more challenging to actually get to know somebody who thinks something quite different and have to deal with it. It's more comfortable just to stay with my fellow believers. That's why you're required to write this paper that you're going to write, all of you, to get out of your comfort zone and really get engaged with somebody who doesn't agree with you, because that's in the end what all outreach and evangelism is about, getting really engaged with people who don't agree with you. Who said it was going to be easy? The Scripture certainly doesn't. Yes. That's a very good question. Is this the first time that there has been this problem, problems with truth, with skepticism, and with plurality, or pluralism, or religious diversity? The answer to the question is yes and no. Let's start off with no, this isn't the first time. If you look at the period in which the apostles went out into the Greco-Roman world across the Roman Empire to proclaim the gospel, they certainly were speaking in a religiously pluralist context. The Roman Empire in the first century was very religiously diverse, and there were a lot of parallels actually to the context in which we are. The mystery religions, for example, and they're going to talk more about them later when we get to the early church, the mystery religions are very similar to new age religions. People didn't believe they were objectively true, they were myths, which they were religiously pursuing to provide them with some comfort and hope, and brotherhood, and these kinds of things. A social group where they could enjoy themselves with other people who shared the same convictions. But there's a huge religious diversity because the Roman Empire is enormous. It's one of the biggest empires the world has ever seen. And across that Roman Empire people worshipped all sorts of different gods, had many, many different religious perspectives. And the Romans basically tolerated them all, and accept that they required everybody, eventually, to offer incense to Caesar. First they regarded Caesar as a high priest of the state religion, you'll read about this when you read Michael Green's book. And then they started regarding Caesar as a god and required everybody to acknowledge him as a god and offer incense to him. Well, for many other people that didn't matter. They didn't particularly believe their religions anyway, all of them, some of them did, like the people in Ephesus, they certainly believed in Artemis. That's why they have that riot. But many people didn't. More thoughtful people didn't. But they didn't mind anyway, just offering incense to Caesar. This was just something which held the state together. Made a huge challenge for the Christians, who were not relativistic in any sense. And had to say, no, I will not offer incense to Caesar. I'm quite prepared to honor him as the emperor, but I will not worship him as a god, and I will not say that he is Lord. And that's why they were killed. And had a hard time. Now, among the Greeks and the Romans, there are some who were genuinely skeptical, like the postmodernist, that is that no knowledge is possible, ultimately. But they are a tiny minority. So there are some similarities, yes, in the sense of those are religious pluralism in the New Testament period and in the centuries afterwards. But there's also a radical difference because while there were a few people, and you can trace that in Greek philosophy, who really believed we can know nothing, the main currents of Greek philosophy weren't like that at all. Now Plato, who's the greatest of the Greek philosophers, is quite clear that knowledge is possible and especially moral knowledge. And in fact, he regards that as the greatest sin and the greatest blasphemy to deny that we can know what is morally good and that we're required to live it. It's the very heart of everything he teaches. And so you would find very few people actually in terms of the population who were skeptical and who were relativist. Now in our culture, it's very different. It's not just one or two philosophers. We live in a culture which is skeptical and relativistic, and that's the difference. So yes, there are some similarities. This isn't the first pluralistic culture, though it's certainly more diverse than anyone has ever been. But what is different is that relativistic pluralism is far stronger than it was in the Roman Empire because there's a much deep escepticism underlying it. Now we'll pick up from here next time. We need to stop there.