<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Give Give Monthly

Christ: Systematic Summary of Christology, II

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

Let's do our quiz, first of all. We continue the doctrine of the person of Christ tonight, and we're actually going to get to some of the systematic categories, pre-existence, incarnation, and virgin birth. But first of all, the quiz. As you know, we try to weave together the readings and the lectures. I need you to do the readings to get especially historical and theological information that on the basis of some Bible study in class, we might reach conclusions. So I thank you for your perseverance, true or false, according to my graph. You all know who Alistair and my graph is by this time. Everybody, I'm taking no shaking of heads to me, yes. He is a theologian who teaches primarily at Oxford University in Great Britain. And it's just a prology in terms of his ability in a short time. He is an international reputation and is deserved for both academic and popular books. Some of the popular books, such as this one, he is really remarkable. We should pray for him. In the British scene, he is very conservative and is standing for Christ. It's wonderful to see true or false, according to my graph, 18 questions. Number one, there's sufficient historical evidence for Jesus Christ's existence as a first century Jew who lived in Palestine. True, of course, page 18. It would be a radical, radical criticism that would deny that Jesus was a historical figure. I don't even know if anybody holding that. There probably are some outlandish types who do, but that is indeed outlandish, to say the least. Two, the Christian faith is to be identified with an interpretation of certain events. It is irrelevant whether those events actually occurred in history or not. False, thankfully, page 23. Now, our faith depends upon more than the historicity of those events. One, we have to personally trust Christ to be saved. Somebody could believe that Jesus lived and died and rose again, and even that he is divine and he's able to say, and not really personally rest in him for salvation, understand. So our faith depends upon more than those historical events, but not on less. We can't deny the history of those events, and the graph does not deny them either. He affirms them. Number two is false, page 23. Number three, Christianity is primarily concerned about an intellectual system of doctrines and only secondarily about a person. False page 34. It's the other way around, as long as we don't deemphasize the teachings because we know the person based upon the information, the teachings that we have from him. Nevertheless, he is right. He is primarily about a person and our knowing and loving and serving that person. We have accurate information about him, and we do have a doctrine of Christ, which is our topic right now in the course. But the doctrine is not an end in itself. The Bible is not an end in itself. It is God's truth to lead us to know and love and serve God. So yes, the person is more important than the doctrines, although I guess they're basically inseparable. Yes. When I say Judaism is the other way around, it certainly isn't concerned about the person of Christ. Well, Judaism is a mixed thing, and you have liberal Judaism, which is largely ethnic and cultural, and even as some liberal Protestants and Catholics substitutes culture for genuine spirituality. You have Orthodox Jews that are looking for Messiah, and I haven't read things like this week on or whatever, but when I dabbled a little bit in that their picture of Messiah is remarkably like Jesus, but so there's a whole span, and we need to distinguish between the true Judaism of the remnant or the faithful people of God in the Old Testament, and the true Judaism that Jesus found, it was a minority Judaism from the religion largely of the Pharisees and others, so and then of course in rejecting Jesus and coming down to us in our own time, Judaism does not know the Lord. We do acknowledge that there was such a thing as Hebrew Christians, and we also acknowledge that there are different styles of worship for them. There are some that are distinctively Jewish Christian and others have not gone that way, but within Judaism per se, today they need to know the Lord. It would not be loving to say that the Judaism's Jews are fine, they don't need to know Christ, that wouldn't be loving at all, and that would be unloving, although it's going to get us in trouble because it's not politically correct. We have to teach the truth in love no matter where that lands us. For early Christians worshiped Christ as God, it is true, page 37. Their worship preceded their doctrinal formulation, that's a wonderful thing, that their instincts went ahead of their full understanding anyway. Number five, we are almost totally dependent upon the New Testament, and particularly the first three gospels for our knowledge about Jesus. According to McGrath, true page 41, now you know by now that I really appreciate him, right? Very much, okay? He is to be criticized. He does not believe in an erity, in his broad British spectrum he is very much on the right. He's conservative, I rejoice in that. On the other hand he's not our model for the doctrine of Scripture, he just isn't. I suspect he downplays the gospel of John, and is making some concessions to a liberal criticism of the New Testament. And if that's the case, I still receive him and hold him highly for his work, but I lament that. And I would use the gospel of John for historical information about Jesus, even as I would use the first three gospels, different perspectives, but it is still God's truth and the accounts in the gospel of John are not invented. McGrath is careful, he doesn't attack it, but he doesn't use it as he should at the same time. So I fault him within my overall great appreciation for his work. I would be foolish to not use his books because of that, okay? On the other hand I would be less than careful, and not a very good guide for you if I didn't fault him where he needs to be faulted. Six, early Christians faithfully transmitted the substance and meaning of Jesus teaching and actions. Although some slight inaccuracies may have arisen, true according to McGrath, 44 and 45, his answer makes me nervous and opens the door to urgency, which is the opposite of inerrancy. I know he holds to urgency because a former student of mine is, as a matter of fact, just finishing up his PhD under McGrath at Oxford, and again greatly appreciates him. But they differ on this particular point, and in fact, my student whose name is John, he's a professor in his own right now, and he's about to eclipse his former teacher, and he's really a gifted guy. Anyway, John told me that McGrath had made comment after a couple of years back, the Evangelical Theological Society had Tom Odin and Alistair McGrath as their keynote speakers, and afterward McGrath said he was really impressed that the ETS, which has as its doctrinal statement inerrancy, and now they added the trinity, but that's the only thing it has, the only two things it has inerrancy and the trinity, that it would have two people come and speak to it who couldn't sign its own doctrinal statement. Now I know they believe in trinity, so he was talking about inerrancy. The irony of the situation is, Tom Odin, who for all those years at Drew, was on the extreme left of things, has come progressively to the right to the point where he now has signed the doctrinal statement of the ETS, and he is a member. Anyway, McGrath handles the Bible pretty well, okay, it's not that he's always criticizing it or something like that, but there are just little glimpses here and there of the fact that he doesn't hold to the inerrancy of the Bible, and here is one of those little glimpses, the trails, if you will, number six is true, 44 and 45. We have no inaccuracies in the Bible, oh, we need to be careful. We have accurate reports of what Jesus said and did, but not accurate by modern standards, the Bible is not a scientific book in that way, but he means more than that, and I would fall to him again. Seven, critics of traditional Christianity should not appeal to Boltman in support of their views about Jesus being a moral example or a religious teacher, true page 51. Eight, the tradition concerning the empty tomb should be accepted as historical fact, true 65 through 67. All this is to be rejoiced with nine, so eight was true 65 to 67, nine, there are no examples of New Testament writers taking Old Testament words originally referring to God himself and applying them to Jesus, false 70 and 71. I was instructed on this regard, this point, I suppose I had forgotten it, but in Romans 10, for example, we have the Old Testament word, everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved, I'm thinking of Romans 10, 13, from Joel chapter two, and specifically it is applied to calling Jesus as Lord in the preceding and in the following context, there's no doubt about it. That is a high Christology, that's a very high view of Christ. We'll see some more of that a little later on tonight. That's a good feature to observe. Ten, Pattonburg approves of churches using the principle of analogy for historical research and as an index to reality, false page 75. He approves of it for the former for historical research, but not as an index to reality because of course it rules out miracles before the fact. 11, the first Christians regarding Jesus as both the source and object of their religious experience, true page 82, once again remarkable affirmations. He's the source of their religious experience, he is the object of it, they serve and worship and love, the Lord means the Lord Jesus. 12, Jesus was not prepared to accept the title Messiah in the course of his ministry, true according to the graph page 85, I have some minor disagreements in my own notes, as you know if you have read carefully, it seems again, he is dependent upon New Testament scholars and that's not bad, he can't be an Old Testament scholar and a New Testament scholar and a church historian and a system act theologian and he can't be everything, so we have to depend upon each other. And he's a theologian largely and a historical theologian who uses the Bible well and reads what biblical scholars say, okay, but at times he is somewhat dependent upon liberal biblical scholarship and this is one of those times. 12 is true page 85, 13, there was a time when Jesus was not the son of God, false page 92, that is an ancient heresy that is still propounded today, unfortunately, 14 since Jesus acts as God in so many important contexts in the New Testament, we should conclude that he is God, true page 96, 15, Jesus must be God and man if he is to redeem man, true page 99, we're going to think about the connection between the person and the work of Christ and if my past experience teaches me anything, you are probably better at making connections between the fact that Jesus is God to be able to save us, then you are at the necessity of his becoming a real flesh and blood human being to be able to save us, both are important and we will work toward integrating our understanding of Jesus person and his saving work. 16, we should reject the counsel of Calcedon statements, false 101 following, false 101 and following, Calcedon was the epitome of the early churches, the liberations and state and confessions concerning the person of Christ, and to reject Calcedonian Christology, history, reject Orthodox Christology, 17 Christ provides the most reliable knowledge of God, true page 110, he is the great prophet in that sense, 18 Emmanuel means God is on our side and present with us, likewise true page 116, so the last two are true pages 110 and 116 respectively, comments or questions, yes sir, a student asks a question on number two, number two is not dealing with various different statements in the Bible itself, okay it's not that it's not a biblical phenomenon, it's not something going on in the Bible, it is rather number two is written to oppose modern reinterpretations of that which the Bible patently presents as history along the lines of well I don't know how detailed to get, a manual Kant changed thinking by his work in philosophy whereby to make a long story short he said that scientific reasoning will not enable us to get to God, we can't think of God that way rather we know God through morality but not through reason that has caused a great divide and as a result of great much historical development since Kant's time in the 18th century some would say whether Jesus rose from the dead or not is unimportant, okay, if the Christ is born in you today, it's if the Christ event has existential significance for your own self actualization, stuff like that, that is gobbledygook, okay, it is not enough that the events happened, it's not enough to confess that the events happen but to think that they're not, it's not important whether they happened or not is so far from the Bible's intention that we have to dismiss it as wishful thinking and so forth so that's what he's talking about, now he is plain that he is not happy if somebody just assents to Christian orthodoxy, it's not enough just to say Jesus died and rose again, one has to personally trust Christ as Lord and Savior but saying that, emphasizing the importance of Christian experience does not minimize the necessity of the events having happened that undergird that experience, the quote first Corinthians 15 if Christ has not been raised from the dead we are fools our faith is vain those who have died in Christ have perished and so forth so the Bible itself holds in high regard those historical events you're certainly right John everything in the scriptures is not equally plain but it's not talking about that it's talking about a frontal attack on Christian orthodoxy in terms of denying its historicity and trying to hold that the things can be religiously true whether they happened or not no the Bible knows of no such dichotomy it's a modern dichotomy in philosophy whereby our feet are cut out from under us in our faith and we just can't let that happen other comments or questions give me a number correct over 18 as in 16 over 18 don't persecute yourselves these are not designed so you get hundreds on them okay if your neighbor does your neighbor is exceptional do your best and make progress and learn if you are reading and learning then I'm a happy camper you say you have it I'm failing these quizzes I hope you're not failing the quizzes the total number of points and how you're doing is the most important thing not your performance on any one of these particular picky I mean tricky I mean a very fair and straightforward quizzes any other questions or comments okay John you're certainly right and the graph has brought it out well that Jesus was reticent to accept certain titles he didn't arrive on the scene at the beginning of his public ministry and announce I'm the Messiah for one thing he had to be walked prudent and it was the father's will for him to have a three and a half year public ministry and not to get crucified in the first two months so you know yes he was careful and that's why the qualification on that one pass them in please and we need to turn to our notes and make some tracks page 88 page 88 thank you for remembering please don't cross the magic line there that that's right there is very good thank you a systematic summary of Christology you have done some background reading things are starting to be as appear as clear as mud I mean I'm starting to clear up in your mind here you have read my notes which summarize many biblical passages teaching about Christ last time we went over those historical errors those heresies concerning a person of Christ we now move to a systematic summary of Christology I'm going to interspersed this with Bible study okay but the but we have arrived at our grid okay I've got to work with these categories because this is not the Bible study class this is theology class we work with the Bible primarily but we need these categories so a systematic summary of Christology here's the overview the pre-existence of Christ to page 89 the incarnation three more accurately entitled the virginal conception of our Lord we'll talk about that the deity of Christ for on to page 90 the humanity of Christ 5 91 the unity of the person of Christ and then 92 the two states so we got to work cut out for us let's begin with pre-existence bottom of 88 by pre-existence we mean that the son of God existed before the incarnation now the father and the son and the holy spirit all existed for all eternity but we don't we only use pre-existence of the son is not proper to use it of the father or the spirit it's proper to use eternity and eternal of all three the father son and holy spirit are eternal they all possess the attribute of eternity fine but we only say the son of the son that he pre-existed because he is the only one of the godhead who underwent a change in his existence that is he is the only one to become a human being so it is very much from the perspective of the incarnation that we look back and talk about pre-existence understand so it's assuming incarnation to talk like that we're not with the perspective we we're taking when we talk about pre-existence is not the trinity before the creation of the world from all eternity no it's the life of Jesus and then admitting immediately that his birth in Bethlehem was not his beginning it was the beginning of his humanity he was not always a man he began to be he became there we go a human being at a point in time he was always God with the father and the holy spirit in heaven he took on his condition changed his status changed if you will because he who was always God now became a human being of course remaining God God cannot cease to be God and henceforth he is the God man but from the perspective of his earthly life looking backwards we can say of him alone that he pre-existed or we could use the noun form the Bible affirms the pre-existence of Christ in John 1 we saw last time that he the eternal word was with the father in heaven and the holy spirit the Bible doesn't always fully systematize before the worlds were made in the beginning was the word the word was with God he was God he was in the beginning with God in John 8.58 I won't turn to this one but to the John 12 passage in John 8.58 Jesus identified himself with the I am I am now not certain whether it's the I am of Exodus 3 or of the I am's of the latter chapters of Isaiah it's immaterial because both of those places speak of it's a divine title I am I want to go to John 12 in John 12 41 we learned that Isaiah saw Jesus when he saw the Lord high and lifted up as recorded in Isaiah 6 John 12 37 is a very sad verse Jesus has done six miracles he calls them signs the sixth was the climactic one he raised Lazarus from the dead in chapter 11 surely now their prejudices will the prejudices of the Jewish leaders will be broken down and they will believe surely now they will be fair in their estimation of the Son of God wrong they won't in chapter 12 with John they put out a death warrant for Lazarus they're not about to believe in Jesus no matter what even after Jesus had done John 12 37 all these miraculous signs in their presence they still would not believe in him this was to fulfill the word of Isaiah the prophet Lord who has believed our message and to whom has the arm of the Lord been revealed where is that from in Isaiah so John 12 was at 38 John 12 38 quotes from Isaiah what did you tell me Isaiah 53 okay John 12 38 quotes from Isaiah 53 let's keep going for this reason they could not believe this teaches inability to believe because as Isaiah says elsewhere he has blinded their eyes and dead in their hearts so they can neither see what their eyes nor understand what their hearts nor turn and I would heal them Isaiah 12 I mean John 12 sorry 40 now this quotes from where Isaiah 6 okay if you think Peterson is setting you up for one of his old tricky patterns you're exactly right let's see if you don't think it's here Isaiah said this verse 41 because he saw Jesus glory and he spoke concerning him Isaiah saw Jesus glory Isaiah spoke okay both of these are in verse 41 where did Isaiah Isaiah see Jesus glory Isaiah 6 he just quoted from Isaiah 6 he's thus taking us by the hand and pointing us to the place where he saw where Isaiah saw Jesus glory where did Isaiah speak concerning him well this is my own interpretation my suggestion is we have a chiasm here one of those patterns we thought about before and that we are we are John intends for us to figure it out and that conclude that Isaiah saw Jesus glory in chapter 6 when he saw the Lord high and lifted up and he spoke about him in Isaiah 53 so the reference to Isaiah 53 in John 12 38 would be A the reference the quotation from Isaiah 6 in John 12 40 would be B Isaiah seeing Jesus glory would be B prime reference to Isaiah 6 and if my analysis is right this is a pattern John uses sometimes we saw a chiasm in chapter 1 I don't have time to show you one in chapter 6 but there's there there's one there as well if you're really interested in this the great two volume commentary in the anchor Bible series by Raymond Brown he has a long introduction in the first volume to some of the features of John style one is chiasm this inverted parallelism and he gives a number of them I had not seen this one in print I found it myself but the main thing is I think it's really there but for our purposes here is what I'm concerned about and that is right here regardless of the rest of the pattern I want to know when Isaiah saw Jesus glory for our purposes that is the whole point right now and I would submit to you it is in Isaiah 6 I'm sure that I'm not positive of the last the last member of the chiasm that he intends for us to say to conclude Isaiah 53 is where where Isaiah speaks of Jesus I think so but I can't prove it but I'm pretty I'm sure of this Isaiah said this because he saw literally his glory and I think says Jesus glory and the right to interpret the his as Jesus and he spoke about him in Isaiah 6 we read in the year that King Uzziah died I saw the Lord seated on a throne it's the word for Lord and master Adonai high and exalted and the train of his robe filled the temple above him were seraphs apparently angels each with six wings with two wings they covered their faces with two wings they covered their feet and with two they were flying and they were calling to one another holy holy holy is Yahweh or Jehovah the name that that special name for God is used is the Lord Almighty the whole earth is full of his glory you know the rest of the story here is my contention at this point this combination of John 1241 referring back to Isaiah 6 shows that proves the pre-existence of the son of God okay remember I said last time how it's very common for us to make mistakes and to talk about well when president Carter grew up well he wasn't president Carter we use the later designation of the famous person earlier even if it's an anachronistic thing okay John does it in chapter 12 I'm not criticizing the scriptures here when he says his glory he's referring to Jesus technically Jesus is the name given the son of God at his birth it's his human name it means the Savior the Lord saves but the biblical writers can't help themselves and neither can you and I they see continuity in the son of God who became Jesus who became a human being my point is this the son of God did not begin to exist at Bethlehem he pre-existed and there are other proofs of this as well since I'll be turning to some of these other passages I won't go there now but for now John 1 all things were made by him he certainly existed before Bethlehem if he was the father's agent in creation as a matter of fact Colossians 1 he made all things in heaven and earth and Hebrews 1 teaches the same thing by him the worlds were made yes sir did the son of God exist before creation of course and the student asking the question of firms that as well was there equality between the father son and Holy Spirit in all eternity from yes from eternity passed if you will yes why did the son of God become a human being and not the father of the Holy Spirit it is fitting for him who is the image of the invisible God who is the true image in whose image human beings were made in the first place is fitting for him to become a human being I like to stay away from speculation so it was fitting for the son to become a human being he did not have to become a human being nothing was lacking in him sometimes we too glibly say oh he became a human being so we could have fellowship with him well that's true but then he could have fellowship with us it's true but our fellowship is so impoverished compared to the fellowship he shared with the father and always buried so it wasn't because he needed us I don't know how to answer the speculation as to whether could the Holy Spirit have become a man could the father have become a human being the bible doesn't know anything like that oh another one you asked was was he always the son of God maybe the implication is as some have taught are we to limit that title to his becoming a human being or to his earthly existence no it goes before then John 17 for example in John 17 oh maybe about verse 24 Jesus said father you loved me before the creation of the world I don't believe he's speaking incorrectly there are imprecisely the relationship of father, son and spirit is an eternal relation I can't answer all those things that we're beginning to think about there but we affirm the eternity of the three persons and for the standpoint of his incarnation we affirm the pre-existence of the second person and number two page 89 we affirm his incarnation I think we take this for granted as is true of many of the great the great fundamental truths the guarantees of the Christian faith when we talk about the incarnation we are saying nothing less than this that the eternal almighty God became a human being in Jesus of Nazareth we are saying that God became a man I encourage my students around Christmas time to go ask with some mother's permission of course to hold the newest born baby you could find okay it's a tremendous experience as you know to hold a little one in your arms and it is wonderful I think to see how adults both men and women how they act around babies okay and the things we do to babies we like to rub their soft skin don't we we love when they grab our fingers that little reflex action where they have a tight grip on things and we make noises it's fitting to make noises to a baby that we wouldn't make anywhere else probably all right but of all the things we do think of how abnormal it would be to worship that baby so go with permission again get a hold of somebody's baby around Christmas I mean just think about it think about the shepherd's coming and worshipping a baby it is so far into our instincts and later the wise men did the same but here's the amazing thing those shepherds and those magi were directed by God and they were correct in worshiping a baby you say it blows my mind the God baby yes the Bible teaches nothing less than that John one for example the true light was coming into the world the one who had illumined men and women who are in darkness had given them the light of God has no mere prophet ever did because here was a prophet who could turn the lights on inside of his ears to switch the metaphor in John 5 the son gives life to whomever he wants to give it well that's only half the story there's also real human responsibility but there's divine sovereignty and since the sun is God and man he's sovereign he gives life to whom he wants to give it a more amazing thing to be said of a human being the point is he's not only a human being and the the point of continuity didn't say that right that which provides continuity in the life of the son of God is his divine nature of course because his human nature began to be in Mary's womb it didn't exist before he always was God the son so now God the son took on not just the body he became a human being the point of continuity is thus his divine nature he was not incomplete he was a true person before became a man he took on true humanity he say oh now he's one plus one he makes two right no it is one plus one in a sense he who is God becomes a real human being nothing is lacking in his humanity he's not a man with you know the mind missing and the logos fills that slot as we said last time that doesn't work and this is one of the mysteries of the Christian faith how he could be God and man and yet be one person with two natures but we are saying nothing less than that Almighty God became a human being John 114 says so well the word a divine title the word who was with God who was God became flesh became a flesh and blood human being yes yes am I saying he was the word at the same time he was the son yes at the same time he was the light and the second person of the Trinity these are different designations of him okay yes they're different ways and we do grow I can appreciate Henry's question in a way we grow up to talk intelligently about these things and we ought to be careful in trying to figure out too much what the Trinity was doing before the creation of the world less we deserve Augustine's smart comment for the person who was not asking questions from good motivation but in mockery and he wanted to know what God was doing before creation Augustine said for pairing a hell for people who ask these kind of questions is what isn't so we don't want to probe in the mysteries where we can't probe but we do want since the Bible talks about certain things happening before creation and God existing then we want to humbly with out speculating make some basic affirmations God the Holy Trinity has always existed there's no beginning to him father son and Holy spirit existed from all eternity and since God is three and one there's fellowship there's communion there's sharing there's love we know it John 17 again father Jesus said you loved me before the creation of the world I'll tell you what we need to take a little break let's come back at 10 after and then proceed to doing some Bible study going to one of these good passages and studying together