<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.plyr.io/3.7.8/plyr.css" />
Give Give Monthly

Historical Overview of Worship 1

December 13, 2010
0:000:00

I'd like to start this session 8 with an explanation of some of the assignments, particularly the HEM paper, the worship service paper, and the online final exam. So the HEM paper, which we've talked a little bit about, has two options. Option 1 is a 2-3 page paper written about a contemporary HEM that both the words and the music have been written since 1980, and you need to make sure you know that the words weren't written before 1980, because there are a lot of songs that are old HEM rewrites or re-tuning of HEMs is what some people call them, where take words that are written a long time ago and write a new tune to them, and it seems like a new HEM. Okay, for instance, before the throne of God above, you all know that tune. The tune was written in, I don't know, 99 or something like that. The words were written in 1859, but sometimes that information is not always attached to the copy that you have of the HEM, or you know it's a new song because of the tune, and you may not be able to, I'll be giving you some online resource places to go and walk and find, you know, to search some of these things. There's CyberHemmelt.com, or org, can't remember which right now, that you can look at some of the old HEMs and put them in it, they'll actually organize, you can put in a theme and it'll give you some HEMs over theme, or a scripture passage will give you some HEMs, it's pretty cool. But all the tunes on there are the old ones with a little MIDI thing going, that, that, that, that, you know, sort of thing, it's not the most exciting to listen to, but you can get an idea what it sounds like. Then I will give you some criteria for discerning the appropriateness and so on of contemporary HEMs for public worship, and it's to be something that you would like to sing. You think it's worthy of singing in a corporate public worship service, okay, so as I said before it's not something you want to pick one you hate and blast it and say why you can't use it, this is supposed to be a positive assignment, this is one I love, and even if I'm in a traditional only church, I might suggest they consider trying it, and it's something like before the throne of God above, it's a good one for that because it has a real HEM feel to it and it's structured that way. Option two is to write a hymn, lyrics only, or lyrics and music, if you're writing lyrics only, tell me to whatever degree you can in words, what it might sound like, in terms of soft and loud, sad or joyful, kind of lamenting or rejoicing, reflective, building throughout the song, or it would sound a lot like kind of Irish Celtic feel to it, or bluegrass feel to it, I mean you could use genres of music that in some ways, anything you think might communicate to me with you, what it sounds like as you hear a tune that actually doesn't exist, okay, because there's not one yet for it. And for this class, taking this access residency week, your HEM papers do send in online by Thursday August 10th, and it's 10% of your grade. The worship service paper, and we'll talk more about this, I'll give you some samples of these, at least one, as well, and it's, I'm not real concerned about, I say five to six pages, it could be more than that, it depends on how you, whether you attach copies, photocopied out of a hymnal and put it on the back of the hymns that you use, or some people just, you know, put the hymn text right in the service, the paper itself, and how you format things, but here's what I basically want, I want you to plan a worship service, that would be for a church you envision yourself being in, either already, or maybe sometime down the road. So you're writing worship service for you, for a church of yours, existing, or imaginary. Tell me a little bit about that church. There's a new church plant in inner city, downtown Philadelphia, where this is suburban church, trying to reach untouched youth, and through them, their families, or this is a church in wherever, Seattle, Washington, trying to reach untouched people, which is most of Seattle, Washington. So you could, I want that, then, everything that is said in the worship service, I want in the body of the paper. So, for instance, if you say, we welcome you this morning to Yada Yada Presbyterian Church. We're glad you're here, and this morning, the focus of our services on the power of the gospel to change people's lives, and it's our prayer that your life will be changed by the gospel this morning. If that's the way you open your worship service, I want you to write all of that out and say, maybe use italics. The italics are the words you say that aren't in the bulletin,

that I want all the elements of the worship, and the hymns can be joyful, joyful, we adore, great as I faithfulness, and it's attached at the end out of a copy out of the hymn, or the words in court. If you're sure I know the hymn, then you don't have to give in to music. If you're not sure if I know the hymn, it'd be nice for me to see music if possible. And on the hymn, assignment, I want to copy the music. I'll sit down, piano, sort of play whether you write it yourself, or hand right out notes, or if you want to come and sing it to me with just guitar chords and words, I'll take that too. If you have any questions just ask me. Those of you on the videotaping, if you want to fly here from England and sing it to me, I won't cover your expenses, but you're welcome to do that. An MP3 would probably be better. One of the major parts of the assignment is the footnotes. Because in the footnotes you are explaining to me the professor, the reader of the paper, even things you're not explaining to the congregation about your rationales to why you chose to put this hymn here, or this prayer here, or the sermon this early or this late in the service. And we'll be talking about a lot of those things, but it's sort of on this. Tell me how this is serving the gospel-centered purposes of this worship service by doing this element with this specific expression at this place in the service. So in some ways you're graded as much on your footnotes. As you are in things else, if you say why, I'm just going to use the 19 whatever prayer book of whatever denomination, and I'm going to give you a bunch of stuff. I'm going to use something out of one of these worship source books or whatever. Well if you're going to use something that's a higher liturgy, I'm fine with that. I'll be looking for even more explanation as to why not necessarily more, but adequate explanation as to why you think this liturgy serves your gospel purposes for this service. So just because you say, well, it was good enough for King Edward, so why can't it be good enough for Mark Downing? Well, I want you to tell me why you think it's good enough for the purposes of this class. And it also, the service needs to include the celebration of the Lord's Supper. I want to see how you put that together as well. There'll be a lot more we'll talk about in a class. The key thing is what kind of church is it? Give me the worship service with the hymns, words, and the prayer words. Now if you do a long pastoral prayer, you say, well, we'll pray for the sick, we'll pray for missionaries, we'll pray for, you know, things of that. So you don't have to write out every word of like a long pastoral prayer, but sort of this is what we would be covering in this prayer. But like a prayer of invocation, I want you to write one out or select one from a worship liturgy.

So kind of church, the worship service, the words that aren't in the bulletin, what we sometimes call the rubrics. If you're going to say, please be seated, then I want you to write to me in italics or whatever, please be seated. And then if we're going to say, I think it's important for people to sit during this because I'm sort of exaggerating, but you're getting my point. Let's stand up for

for prayer, for intercessory prayer. We're standing before God and crying out to Him and let's all raise our hands together. If that's what you're telling people, then write that that's what you're seeing to people. And then the footnote, note, say, I think it's an appropriate expression of bodily posture and worship and we're crying out to God to stand before Him and raise our hands and ask Him as we intercede for others. And then the Lord's open. The question's on it. The rationale, given for these decisions, will they come from this course? I mean, when I just say them, because if you come up with some reason that what does that matter? You know, it's kind of subjective. I just tell you why. I think, I've alluded to this and we're going to go into a whole session on it. Gospel centered worship, which basically says in its simplest form, we're coming into the presence of a God who is way more holy than we dare imagine. And we are a sinful people blind to much of the depth of our sin and unwilling to even acknowledge how much we need God. God in His grace, graciously provides His Son, so the gracious provision of Christ. He has provided means for our growth in grace, some of which should be happening right here in this worship service. We hear the sermon. We receive instruction regarding how we're to live as those sinful people in the presence of a God who have been provided for and forgiven in Christ. And then we're sent out to live for His glory in all we do. There's an entrance into worship, understanding who God is, who we are, what He's done for us in Christ, and we come together not just to glorify Him but to be strengthened in our faith and walk with Him that we might go out and live for Him. So there's a sending out that then goes into this larger thing that we talked about into all of life and back into gospel centered corporate worship in that regard. So to say, now do you always have to have a prayer of confession at this point in a service, or could you maybe acknowledge in a more general prayer of invocation that we stand in need of you and come before you centers and thank you for your provision? But if you're preaching on Psalm 51, you may want to have a corporate prayer of confession after the sermon, or before you come to the Lord's table. So there are there are gospel purposes in particular services that may alter what you do where and what you select to use in a given week or you may decide to sing the Lord's prayer in the service that you give to me. And you're saying you might say the rationale for singing the Lord's prayer this week is we normally say it and it becomes it has a tendency to become sort of wrote if we just keep singing to sing it sort of brings it in a different realm and we think about the words and here's why I decided we should sing it this week. Where you may have the choir sing a song before you before the call to worship that's going to be a new song you're teaching the congregation that I have look I'm having a choir for a sort of a pre-worship song sing or the worship team to sing through a song it's going to be new this day but so that when people come to that part in the service that have a little bit of familiarity with it. So you're sort of giving me sort of practical rationale as well as biblical gospel centered rationale in that way and we'll spend a whole we'll spend a lot of time in the course after the history side doing that sort of thing okay let's see oh the sermon part of the worship service if you give me more than a half a page of a sermon outline I'll start deducting points the purpose of the assignment is not just for you to cut and paste a three-page outline from a advanced hom certainly I hear it the seminarian put it in here to impress me with your homiletics okay I want to be impressed with your ability to structure a worship service but I want to see what you're preaching on or what's being preached on it may not be the preacher okay how you may be the worship leader or elder or musician or something but you're you don't necessarily have to be the one doing everything so you may be putting words in the mouth of a preacher or an elder or a deacon you may have you may have the deacon pray before the receiving of the offering and you say I think it's important to utilize people in the congregation to leave the congregation a prayer and the deacons who have this responsibility or it's a good thing for a deacon to pray at this point and that put the words in his mouth that he prays the sermon I just want I mean I would love to just have you know scripture title follow condition focus proposition of the sermon three-point outline that's it conclusion you know some and if you don't understand what all the FC have sent all those sorts of things aren't basically a half-page outline of what you're going to see in the sermon so that then you may say um the reason I've chosen uh this song at this point in the service on on let's say holy holy holy is not only to remind us of God's holy presence we're coming into but um I'm preaching on seraphim and cheraphim cherubim whatever falling down before him and that's in this hymn and so I want to I want to have the congregation be singing a praying some things that are going to be showing up in the sermon or flowing out of it at the other end not not sure I've ever heard a sermon on the seraphim and cherubim falling down before him but anyway I heard I heard a little doshal this morning on lions roosters and letting goats came with his army so this I just want to know enough about the sermon that helps make sense to the rest of the service okay and you can use an outline of the sermon you've reached someone clearly but choose that carefully because this time it's about the rest of the worship service and you might want to think through what you want to do with the worship service a little bit before you pick even a passage how you want to go with it okay does that make sense okay and after this real quick in our tradition the sermon usually is that which all of the stuff yeah normally there are there are basically three three sort of general structures of worship service you have the it's kind of a higher liturgy is um um gods it's the dialogical God speaks we respond God speaks we respond sort of working through in a more serial sort of way with a sermon and then the you know the Lord's table it looks like a saw horse in my little thing um and that so that's sort of a liturgical that's more uh God speaks we respond God speaks we respond sort of thing this content driven is sort of a content driven usually says here's the sermon and the color of worship anticipates it and this hymn sort of is is serving it in this prayer it's like all these things are building toward it and then some things come out of the other end of it okay and then there's what's this this is typical sort of Bible church Presbyterianism although there's some of this in Presbyterianism too the dialogical niche I think you can do a dialogical content driven okay but you also have what some call a flowing this is dialogical this content driven and this is sort of flowing praise where you've got it's mostly music with some prayer and maybe some scripture enters first but the sense of I'm coming into God's presence and reaching this climactic moment usually through effective use of song and then kind of winding back down the lead into the sermon okay and here's matter circles this is sort of the this is where you have the outbreak of speaking in tongues and that sort of thing in some of the extreme expressions of it is kind of at this holy of holy's point okay and you know you can see probably all been in churches even PCA churches that are this is a little higher liturgical this is this is maybe a little less formal but still very well structured to plan and and this feels more informal a little usually often more contemporary music and that sort of thing that fits into this but I think there's room to do gospel centered worship as we'll be discussing it in any of these now minus some of the Pentecostal side of this okay or maybe minus a certain view of the sacraments in this okay but in terms of the general outline of the service I think you can adopt any of these are some hybrid of them to accomplish gospel centered worship because in some churches like Chesterfield where I go we don't say creeds but we sing in Christ alone which is like a creed express us what we believe about the person who worked of Christ and our union with him okay I lead worship once a month there and I I ask Ryan the worship director has said the next time I leave can we do in Christ alone because I want to make a point about expressing our professing our faith and even though we may not I just basically start asking the church has always expressed its faith in statements of what we believe early on the church's Jesus is Lord some people got put to death for saying Jesus is Lord rather than Caesar's Lord but that was a profession of faith that they stood on some churches use the apostles creed that I see and creed in our church we do many of our elements through song prayers of confession or often songs creeds what we believe are the content of what we sing and so I then said let us profess what we believe by singing in Christ alone okay and what that do or those who are sort of maybe because of background or baggage or whatever saying we don't want to be in a church it does creeds reminds us of filling a blank that was you know a press ever whatever saying oh I guess we sort of do do something like a creed I'm glad we do it through songs and those are saying we need a decrease we need a decrease we need a decrease um are saying oh I guess we do do creeds we do song now we're Chesterfield gets a place where we say the apostles creed potentially but what are the things probably likely to happen before that would be to use a scripture passage creed take Colossians 1 15 to 20 I believe that Jesus Christ is the image of the invisible God the first born overall creation I mean how could you be against that even if you had baggage bearings of creeds it would just sort of roguely center whatever so I think there's there's room and I just sort of introduce what I'm going with some of this stuff later on that what helps you think about the worship service the final it's always my favorite part of the class probably because you know then it's all over and you're all done and I get to grade your stuff and I think the deadline for this access residency class for the worship service papers August 24 and then for the online oral final Paul you get to take yours a little bit later if you want because you're not starting into the September classes the way the rest of these guys are there's this also August 24 so your worship service paper and your oral your online final take home case study final is also the 24th but yours is September 8 the worship service papers 25% of the grade the online take home final is 25% degree what I will do for the final exam is I will give you seven or eight case studies that are kind of a composite of my own experiences and some other people in friends of mine okay in terms of real-life issues and churches that relate to worship issues all of which have some relational pastoral dynamic connected to it that complicated

and you'll be asked to respond as though you're the ministry leadership person in charge of what the dynamic is asking you to do and so I want you to engage the relational pastoral issues as you respond that shows me two things one you understand gospel center biblical worship dynamics that relate to the to the city to the case study and two you have a pastor's heart for the church the whole church as well as the individuals that may be complicating and making things difficult or maybe you know the youth group would love to see more of the songs like they sing a youth group as part of the sounding worship service and you're the youth pastor how the sick pastor why can't we sing more of these songs in the worship service and then I let you answer how are you going to respond to that that shows kind of a love for them and a recognition of the leadership of the pastor the elders and you know what are the contextual dynamics and how long have you been there and what kind of credibility you have or not have yet or you know all the sorts of things are you're going to split the church by the way you respond to them or you're going to keep unity and bring gradual change or you know there's just there's a lot of things out there and worship issues are hot issues they always have been in the church hasn't always been music style like it is right now in many places but think about the controversy and the history of the church over the sacraments the church has always been fighting over worship related issues how is Christ present on what's what actually happens at a baptism service okay and there we go the second part of every you'll get to pick four of the seven or eight so you can look at one you know you can eliminate the one you least one answer pick the one you most want to answer the second half of what I want is not you're going to enter into the case study and pastorally as a worship knowledgeable worship person respond the second half I'm going to ask you to just list one two three four five whatever biblical and theological principles that you drew upon when you answered that question not paragraph form just list half sentences couples scripture passages but for instance the thing I taught on Romans 15 about unity and praise before you're trying to do is keep unity in the church as you're addressing worship things you might say Romans 15 the importance of keeping a body together in one heart and mind is very important as I've addressed this and let's see it seems like I'm forgetting one thing on that you have three hours to take the exam once you log on to take it um and how far in advancing in the case studies well you'll you'll you won't get to see them till you log on but you'll be able to take it I mean I can have it on there as soon after the course is over as you want you can take it well before then I could like but once you decide I'm going to take it now oh here's the other thing thank you maybe think of that you're allowed a one-page of notes and your bottle and if you want a handbook you can have it but you won't need it on the one page of notes which can't be any smaller than nine point you can fill the white space which with as much nine point text as you want eight and a half by level I mean the legalist in the class has always asked well what about this and what about this what fun can it would be whatever fun can't be over nine point though um and you know that's basically what it makes you do is kind of go over everything from the class and pick what you think is going to be most helpful to you as you go be a pastor or minister leader dealing with the congregation and that's mainly what I want you to do and then be able to express it in real life situations that are at least that are drawn from real life along the way there may be one or two of the situations have already talked about that will reappear out of my you know ministering contacts there's one I've already told you about that'll be on there I won't tell you which one but I should see now you have to pay attention to the rest of the class too yeah okay any questions on that I guess I would get to this uh pre-reformation historical overview of worship now I think that the reading assignments and so on may have different dynamics I'm not sure how it works in that when you listen to it on audio or video or whatever so and you've already done those anyway right what most of them so okay pre-reformation we sort of pick up with this early church legacy of the synagogue and the temple what influences the way the early church worships got well their elements of synagogue worship as we've talked about which are basically made up of reading of scripture uh expounding a scripture sort of like preaching or devotionals or you know exhortations from scripture um prayers and songs singing of the songs

those are the those are the key elements of the synagogue worship and if you go to synagogue today and in a Jewish context obviously you'll get that they'll be the reading of the word we some comments about the word they'll be prayers they'll be singing it will be devoid of Christ so as we said earlier the thing that is distinctive about Christian worship that it is based on the sort of the structure and the elements of the synagogue service which were there because of things that are in the Old Testament about the way God communicates his word as people and invites him to come before the prayer of the temple and songs in the Psalter and so on the thing that is distinctive then is that Christ is central to all of it it's about him as we now focus these elements around him so then you have the perfect sacrifice of Christ reflected in the celebration of the Lord's Supper and early church worship then and it's sort of simplest articulation I have here under C the content was Christ the structure was word and sacrament with prayer and praise I mean is that what Christian worship is word and sacrament prayer and praise I mean in its simplest formulation and the context was the fellowship of house churches you know the end of the book of Romans Paul says greet the church that meets in the house of okay and then they're just a whole lot of sometimes wonder if you know people rode their donkeys or whatever they rode passed on house church to go to another house church because they likes the style of preaching of the guy at this house church over here more than this one here or they love the music leader over here you know boy can he or she's saying but boy how they they can't keep a pitch over here and music's important to me so I won't go to the closest house church to me I'll go to the next closest house church to me that has more kisses on my personal preferences now we sometimes are so glorified the early church to think that they're beyond such disputes well if you ever read first Corinthians there are all kinds of disputes in the church accord that Paul's having to dress and many of them relate to worship practices okay so churches always been fighting over worship practices essentially at least on the pages of scripture we see okay uh the end of Roman church um greet Priscilla and Aquila Roman 163 I fellow workers in Christ Jesus they risk their lives for me not only I but all the churches the Gentiles are grateful to them greet also the church that meets at their house

I think that the portion of the body Christ that meets at Priscilla and Aquila's was got a separate greeting at the end of Romans okay oh that was that was a context but he writes the letter of the rope to the Romans if you look at the very beginning at the other end

verse 7 to all in Rome who are loved by God and called to be saints he's writing to the church in Rome which happens to be made up of all these house churches so you have local expressions of the church in Rome that meet in particular people's homes now you know what's my most fundamental identity as a Christian well I belong to Christ and I belong to the people who belong to Christ and part of his church now when I think of church do I think first of just a feel price between church where I attend my family some of my family at least or do I think of the church of the Lord Jesus Christ that's way beyond even the PCA when I think of the church of the Lord Jesus Christ in St. Louis, Missouri let's put it there all are writing the letter of the church in St. Louis would you be writing just a new city or just a clerk he was it's sort of a more like he's writing a letter that the St. Louisian would ever letter it would be to all the St. Louis who are loved by God and called to be saints that are aren't identifiable in any one particular house church alone or local church alone so I'm part of the church of the Lord Jesus Christ of St. Louis, Missouri which is bigger than the PCA which is certainly bigger than the particular church I go up to and so there's these these identity things I think that I think there's a place for expression of corporate public worship at times you know when all the house churches ran out some town hall in Rome and come together because Paul's coming to town or somebody else coming to town that Billy Graham's coming to Rome for a century now sorry a Paulist is coming get so I do well he can go and preach from house or some maybe they have a sort of a Sunday evening service where they all join together and worship together there's there should be a place for the expression of the oneness of the church I believe in ways that are beyond just our our ordinary local Lord's Day house church equivalent kind of expression and again we don't have a lot of information what that looks like but I think it certainly means that we we reach out to other people who share a common faith with us even though they may not be reformed in Presbyterian

and seek to put on display the oneness of the body of Christ in a way that according to Jesus and in John's gospel said that by this all men will know that you belong to me right love you have for each other and what better way to express love to each other than to gather worship together partly by this all men will know that the father sent the son by the love you have for him how do you make that unity visible so I think one of the ways that was their Presbyterian tries to do that is they have three services a year that rotate around to I think mainly back and forth between Kirk and Twinox in terms of having big enough space for people to gather around and they have a Presbyterian wide worship services it's around the sanctity of human life Sunday and Reformation closest to Reformation Day Sunday and I think they have one I'm not even as a Presbyterian it's why I'm struggling here and maybe they have a I remember in the other ones but they have three and different people preach sometimes guest preachers somebody from sometimes for the Presbyterian different they have a combined choir at the Reformation Day one people from different churches so that I think so there's there was a thing a few weeks ago down at the ball the new ball field that the Lou Baroque and his wife former San Luis Carna Baseball player and his wife who I think is an ordained pastor okay actually called I will believe in Christians across San Luis to come together for a joint worship service in the new stadium okay on Pentecost Sunday I think it was okay well should PCA people go be a part of that what happened I think they should I don't think that we're denying our distinctive by joining with others who believe that the Bible's word of God and Jesus Christ is fully gotten fully man and the only Savior of centers and so on and so forth okay it tells St. Louis that Christians can transcend their local expressions and join together in a common faith around Christ I think those are good things promise I mean I could find fault with certain things if you press me you know was all of the theology about promise keepers gatherings for men in the history of promise keepers and every speaker always write down a lot and everything I believe no did I go and take men for my church yes why there's a place for a larger expression on the body of Christ then just the little church of 250 that I had in Richmond, Indiana that was a tremendous encouragement to the men of the church that I talk about 25 over several years and also God used to help spawn a Saturday morning men's gathering once a month well we pray for each other worship together have breakfast together of course breaking bread just like it says in Acts two might be the word supper breaking bread but we'll do well okay so we've really gone down a rabbit trail on that one but I think it's important the context was a fellowship of house churches with the recognition that the church was bigger than just their house church I guess that's a major point I'm trying to make it what was this the status of music and worship in the early church fathers well about 150 AD we have writing up one of the early church fathers that I named Justin called his first apology and apology here doesn't mean oh I'm so sorry it means here's where I stand let me tell you why every time in our household we use the word apologetics just in conversation my youngest son Eric always says I'm sorry it's sort of fun trying to keep you guys awake late after day or at least give myself away here's what we find in Justin's first apology about the the format of a worship service around 150 AD their scripture readings and sermons or lessons there are intercessory prayers followed by a summary prayer probably praying for specific things in general there's the kiss of peace as one of the distinguishable it was sort of a formal element in the worship service greet one another with a holy kiss or as the today's English version translated that came out as a college handshakes all around that's our like the kiss of peace better for it anyway I'm getting sort of punchy here like what does the kiss of peace mean it means we're we're reconciled to one another we're greeting one another we we love each other we're delighted being each other's present it's not an erotic kiss it's a kiss a friendship and fellowship okay and different cultures would express that in different ways and you know different people within I mean this is a whole issue sometimes I won't go there right now we'll come back to another time offerings which included the bread and the white the actual bread and wine that was used for the Lord's Supper that day and this this continues to be a practice in in some churches I think the Eastern churches particularly do this meaning Eastern as compared to Roman the split in what was it 10 aren't you church history has 1057 like the Eastern Orthodox churches they had a eucharistic prayer which means the prayer related to the celebration of the Lord's Supper is setting apart the elements and thanking God I mean for what he had done in Christ and ex-temporaneous prayers it was sort of spontaneous prayers there was singing and there was weekly celebration of the Lord's Supper these were the things that what Justin Justin's comment on these being like this was he was viewing this as a sort of reordering of the apostolic tradition and not the creation of something new so there's sense in which being fairly close to the apostolic tradition of what worship look like in these early house churches and so on what Justin was viewing was that we have liberty to sort of take these same elements ingredients and sort of put them together together in a way that serves well the churches of our day more in the realm of application than a change of elements or purpose for those elements there's a letter a fairly famous letter from a statesman

planning the younger to trade in the emperor sometime between 62 and 113 AD which is a pretty wide range but we just know it was during his reign his emperor and those are the dates of his being emperor where he described what Christians do when they get together as to other in turn songs to Christ as to a god that that was a thing that struck him about observing a Christian worship service they sang songs to this man named Jesus Christ as though he were god that to me that's pretty cool it tells me several things tells me they're singing more than songs it tells me that they're singing their theology the Christ is God and that it was as though he were real and present even you can almost you know sense in this there was a growing concern in the early church about the use of instruments partly because of their association with a group of pagan influences and there's nothing new under the sun and Augustin in particular was concerned because of the association of certain instruments with some of the most drunken orgy type gatherings of of pagan unbelieving people that I guess analogous in in my lifetime too kind of sex drugs and rock and roll okay rock and roll music is evil because of its association with drugs and sex ill illicit sex so there's sort of a pulling back from the use of instruments I think also if you go back a little ways some of the study that I did for my dissertation

the Christian churches didn't get all of the instruments of the temple it isn't like always starting to church you know we think 40% of the temple instruments should belong to the Christian churches and our negotiated settlement about the property of the temple and all that they weren't exactly there to do the negotiating in that way all right and so people who had instruments and were gifted at playing them weren't necessarily all flocking to the early Christian church that way some of the synagogues did acapella music partly because they were removed from the central worship place of Jerusalem where the kind of school of musicians were among the Levites so just because there weren't instruments used in some synagogue worship it doesn't necessarily mean that there's a biblical theological rationale against the use of them I may just mean they didn't have anybody who had them or was skilled at playing them but that's different than what then later became this association of them with the Greek pagan influences now an interesting dynamic happened in the whole issue of the of the Aryan controversy and heresy the Aryans were people who denied that Jesus was fully God he was first born it's sort of like the Jehovah's Witnesses today believe that he's kind of what the most exalted man but he's not God and so the Aryans used hymns to spread their heretical teachings and they were very they were they were it was pop music it's a music of the masses and the people would pick up on these great tunes that they love to sing that were filled with the words of false teaching of Aryans so like our teenage children my my generation was accused of you know we love the music but do you hear what's being said in the words well it doesn't matter what the words say we know we can say all the words to the great songs of the sixties of sex drugs and rock and roll but we say well it doesn't really matter it's not really impacting us it's really the music that we like our parents would say yeah but it's subtle and you know these these bad words and content are going to influence your life because you sort of subtly there you know so you can see some of those those aren't as well the Aryans were making use of that sort of connection between good music and words um and so a way of responding to that orthodox teachers like Ephraim Cyrus in this time wrote faithful texts to the Aryan tunes wow it's almost like putting let's see um it's like I heard a guy at a fellowship of Christian athletes conference one time singing to Michael to the Jackson five I'll be there I'll be there he changed words to he'll be there and it was all about Christ he'll be there and you're very corny but you know for a while you're walking around singing you know the Jackson five song with Christian words to it okay well this wasn't very successful um and so the council have laid to see a between three sixteen three eighty one prohibited the singing of non scriptural text here's how we'll make sure we won't be singing heresy we'll sing all my scripture wow that's true but is it is it necessarily engaging um by the use of the gift of music um biblical theological application to the lives of people of our day we we don't say we wouldn't necessarily say well this preacher preaches heresy therefore the only sermons we're going to have we're going to have are going to be the recorded words of Peter and James of Jesus in the violence our sermons will only be biblical words that were sermons and we wouldn't do that um so why would we necessarily do it with music but that's what they did okay the Roman mass and we'll wrap it up for today the Roman mass originally was simple dignified beautiful form uh that carrying much of gospel center worship uh in fact Luther wanted to return to the Roman mass in its earlier forms as a way of restoring biblical worship to the church of his day it had increasing focus on the doctrine of transubstantiation in terms of the understanding of the Lord's Supper

based on the teaching regarding that doctrine of the latter and council on twelve fifteen and then increasingly partly because you would have you know monks and clergy who would be cloistered in uh places monasteries um who some of them were became the musicians it's almost like the temple musicians uh in the Old Testament that certain monks would give to the music and so they they wrote and sang music uh in worship and the congregation because it was it was beautiful it was somewhat it wasn't very congregational friendly for the masses to be able to for particularly when it was in Latin and they didn't know Latin for example uh to sing along wasn't conducive to congregational singing um and so the congregation became more and more passive in the Roman mass rather than participatory and at the council constants in fourteen fifteen congregational singing was actually prohibited in the Roman mass and so the mass became more and more sort of elaborate austere distant um the clergy sort of doing worship with the congregation looking at almost as spectators rather than fellow worshipers now it's easy to be critical of that in that context but you know i've been in some churches and been guilty of myself sort of planning worship services that have a whole lot more to do with um what the upfront people are doing it saying terms of choirs and preachers and testimony givers and things like that um that doesn't engage and draw in and have a dialogue of worship um that the congregation's involved in or a great preacher's you know coming to do a bible weekend of worship service bible teaching sorts of things and you know it's very much about being ood and odd and wowed by this great effective orator public speaker um much more than it is about gab coming together in the presence of Christ to worship him again don't hear what i'm not saying um i'm not saying that a sermon is unimportant but a sermon should serve these gospel purposes and worship service in a way that has um humility that has that draws people in that gives people opportunity to respond to the preaching of the word one of the problems i have with a lot of our churches is well a great powerful christ centered 40 minute sermon and if you set your clock from the time the pastor says a man after his prayer at the end of the sermon to win the pastors at the door greeting people it's sometimes as less than 90 seconds we'll do one stands at a hymn uh well he walks to the back door and gives a benediction from back there and then he's greeting people there's nothing wrong with giving a 45 minute sermon and standing at the door greeting people but it's pretty hard to uh to digest the meat of such a sermon without some time to sing a all the stands of a song to respond or leading into the Lord's sufferer or having time for reflection and response it's almost like i can't quite take all this in and now i'm out the door and gone i think there's there's a i mean you guys know this just with uh with the study of these deep theological things in the courses that you take you don't have you know early on in the semester you've got some time off and to sort of process things a little bit you know no papers do no test to take midterms have to come and i'm excited about what i'm learning and i'm thinking it through and i'm going home and talking to my wife or talking to my friends in the city wall outside of the library uh just about these great things we're engaging what would this look like in ministry and so on so forth now then midterms here and you've got to start reading things you haven't been reading and you know you've got to start writing papers and you're in the library you're not talking to anybody and you're not processing the things you're learning um you know you just sort of wish you could have a little more time without the pressure of testing papers and readings to work these things into your life i think it's the same way with preaching and we need to think about that in our worship services maybe move the sermon a little bit early on the service or or extend the amount of time you're gathered for worship and have two or three songs and prayers in scripture readings and offering and Lord suffered more regularly after the sermon in a way that lets it become a part of who we are rather than just i got all the notes down close i'll open now off to lunch i think that's that's worth thinking about it um it's sort of like um it's almost like there are three movements in a worship service you can't sort of have the pre-sirmen at least in most of our circles the sermon and the post-sirmen

i think churches that have the Lord suffer every week have a built and they have it after the sermon which it doesn't always have to be i think normally it's best there if you have the Lord suffer every week you sort of have a built in processing reflecting time upon the sermon and the other elements of the service while other people being served you're thinking through the application of this Christ-centered sermon to the meaning of the Lord suffer and the things that God needs to be engaging me about in my own life and and Calvin who tried to get the Lord suffer weekly in Geneva Switzerland um couldn't that the elders didn't agree to it but he would structure several things as though they were preparing to have the Lord suffer as part of the coming out of the sermon time that way sorry i got the plant here it didn't run out of room okay on there okay that's just area okay so i think we need to think about you know a lot of our services are sort of like this

the way we the relative comparative time of the pre-sirmen's sermon are both sermon okay and i'm not i'm if you have to have this big of a sermon and that's just sort of who you are and how you believe God wants you to do gospel centered worship there and i would say lengthen your service and you know make it more like that okay i don't think they have to be like this but i think you need to give a little more attention to the before and after of this sermon uh that's sometimes we do and i think that's that's one of the weaknesses and here's my reason and i'll just end with this the reason is the preaching of the word is not the only means of grace present in a Sunday morning worship service or afternoon or evening. God's designed for corporate worship is to have a convergence of multiple means of grace, praying, preaching, reading of word, sacraments, singing

and i think that there's a there's a synergy that develops when there's the recognition of how those things interact and sort of impact together the body believers who gather in the name of Christ or worship God. It's not that i want to take anything away from it so i love to preach as much as the next God i love to preach now if i can okay but i think it's um it's not about how much and how long i want to preach. It's about what all of these means of grace together doing to glorify God and build up his church and to cook us to be a worshipping community on a king division. I'll close with that and we'll pick it up tomorrow.